Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

HLTA (qualified teacher) being used as cover

154 replies

LorlieS · 03/01/2024 10:50

Posted in Education but no traffic...

AIBU to feel miffed about this?

I'm a qualified teacher with 20 years' experience but stepped down from class teaching about five years ago as workload was ridiculous and I wasn't having any time with my own children. I'm now working as an HLTA, specialising in supporting children with EHCPs. Love it. Hard work for appalling pay but it's my "thing." I take responsibility of interventions (both 1:1 and group) and ensuring work on EHCP targets is undertaken. Feels great to have autonomy whilst (hopefully) making a difference and I really get to know the children I work with.

However, it's a huge primary I work in and I find I am being pulled away from my job more and more to cover classes for staff absences. Very rarely with a TA and full class of 30. High SEN needs in all classes.

I used to get paid my teacher rate for such cover but now with budgets being what they are I dont; I am just paid my normal HLTA rate.

School loathe to get supply in as expensive.

OP posts:
Motherofacertainage · 03/01/2024 14:31

Kim3456ss1 · 03/01/2024 14:28

@LorlieS So you are saying that the childs EHC plan is not followed correctly as 'sort of access something' is not what a child plan that is unique to them would say. But sure, of course your more interested in not earning more money by your higher skills being used as cover.

Let's not talk about vulnerable children with an EHCP being left without their legal provision, sounds about right!

Kids bring left without the support they are legally entitled to is not OPs fault, or even the school's in many cases. Your anger needs to be directed at those who are not funding education. You can't expect TAs - or teachers , doctors, nurses, dentists etc - to work for less than they could earn elsewhere just to paper over the cracks of systemic failure. Use your vote wisely when the time comes.....

Kim3456ss1 · 03/01/2024 14:28

@LorlieS So you are saying that the childs EHC plan is not followed correctly as 'sort of access something' is not what a child plan that is unique to them would say. But sure, of course your more interested in not earning more money by your higher skills being used as cover.

Let's not talk about vulnerable children with an EHCP being left without their legal provision, sounds about right!

Motherofacertainage · 03/01/2024 14:28

Bex5490 · 03/01/2024 14:24

@LorlieS

When I did supply teaching a few years ago the agency guaranteed me daily work and would still pay me if they couldn’t find it (which was incredibly rare). The work would be varied though - some longer stints of teaching like 2 week blocks, some 1:1, some nursery cover but all primary school age. This was in London though…

If you’re in a big city I’m sure an agency will do this for you as they value experienced teachers.

And as an SLT member who now often sorts out the cover of classes when teachers are absent, I can honestly say that while budget is a factor, a large reason for using HLTAs is that they’re trusted and known to the children. I am always so reluctant to trust an unknown adult with our precious kids especially the younger ones and classes with high SEN needs for whom the unfamiliarity can be really unsettling.

Whilst I totally get this and is better in the short term for the kids, in the long term how are we going to retain good teachers and TAs if something doesn't give?

Bex5490 · 03/01/2024 14:24

@LorlieS

When I did supply teaching a few years ago the agency guaranteed me daily work and would still pay me if they couldn’t find it (which was incredibly rare). The work would be varied though - some longer stints of teaching like 2 week blocks, some 1:1, some nursery cover but all primary school age. This was in London though…

If you’re in a big city I’m sure an agency will do this for you as they value experienced teachers.

And as an SLT member who now often sorts out the cover of classes when teachers are absent, I can honestly say that while budget is a factor, a large reason for using HLTAs is that they’re trusted and known to the children. I am always so reluctant to trust an unknown adult with our precious kids especially the younger ones and classes with high SEN needs for whom the unfamiliarity can be really unsettling.

Redlocks28 · 03/01/2024 14:18

LorlieS · 03/01/2024 14:10

Thanks all. I've seen a mat cover teaching job advertised - two days a week. I imagine they'll be after a newly qualified, but worth a look?

That sounds interesting-good luck.

ECTs aren’t quite so popular with schools now as they require a really heavy mentoring load and lots of release time. That doesn’t mean the job will pay you much above M1 though, sadly.

StripeyDeckchair · 03/01/2024 14:14

1 or 2 lessons - OK as HTLA
Full days, repeatedly - should be paid at teacher rate

School have set a precedent for this, which makes it harder to withdraw.
Talk to your union rep and make a formal issue of it as early as possible this term.

Alternatively you could leave and do agency work as it suits you - probably 3 days/week would equal your HLTA salary and you'd just deliver cover provided.

LorlieS · 03/01/2024 14:10

Thanks all. I've seen a mat cover teaching job advertised - two days a week. I imagine they'll be after a newly qualified, but worth a look?

OP posts:
BringMeTea · 03/01/2024 14:07

@LorlieS I do supply but only want to do TA supply. Sometimes they ask me to do cover supervisor role for the TA pay but I just say no. I appreciate you are working in the school full time so it's different. I fundamentally disagree with TAs delivering lessons so won't go along with it. I am VERY lucky that I don't need full time hours so can take or leave what the agency offer.
If I were you I would certainly be stating my case and leaving if they don't pay you teacher rate. Plus, it's not what you enjoy! Flowers

Redlocks28 · 03/01/2024 13:55

Motherofacertainage · 03/01/2024 13:53

Sadly in some cases, noone. The government has cut school funding to the bone and these are the consequences.

Agree.

The LEA aren’t meeting their legal obligation of finalising EHCPs within 20 weeks either. Everything is falling apart.

Motherofacertainage · 03/01/2024 13:53

DyslexicPoster · 03/01/2024 13:11

Who forfills the kids legally bound ehcps while your teaching too?

Sadly in some cases, noone. The government has cut school funding to the bone and these are the consequences.

LyricalGangsta · 03/01/2024 13:44

The school office

LyricalGangsta · 03/01/2024 13:43

Work in the office

LorlieS · 03/01/2024 13:43

@LyricalGangsta What do you do now?

OP posts:
LyricalGangsta · 03/01/2024 13:42

I was just a regular TA and often covered class.
I gave it up.

Caterpillargirl23 · 03/01/2024 13:39

@LorlieS
They support in lessons with a teacher, plus they have a few small timetabled classes-low ability year 7s generally.
One of our HTLAs is a qualified teacher, the others started as TAs in the school.
It's better pay than the cover supervisors but not as good as the teacher's pay.
We have one in Maths, English and Science.

Rioja81 · 03/01/2024 13:34

I am a qualified teacher who used to work as a TA/HLTA. When just carrying out TA duties in the mornings I was paid one rate (minimum wage), then HLTA rate (11.40 something) in the afternoons during which time I covered PPA.

I wasn't doing a teacher's full job, hence not getting a teacher's full wage.

Redlocks28 · 03/01/2024 13:33

Have just asked a friend and they don’t have any HLTAs in her secondary-it’s just CS for cover and some TAs who support 1:1 or run interventions.

LorlieS · 03/01/2024 13:29

@Caterpillargirl23 I'm not comfortable with teaching in secondary, having taught in primary all of my working life. What do your HLTAs do if they don't cover?

OP posts:
Caterpillargirl23 · 03/01/2024 13:27

In my secondary school the HLTA do not cover teacher absences, the cover supervisors and supply teachers do that job.
Would you consider swapping to secondary?

LorlieS · 03/01/2024 13:26

@BringMeTea But is there a difference now between the roles of HLTA and TA?

OP posts:
BringMeTea · 03/01/2024 13:21

I refuse to do HLTA teacher cover for TA rates. I am a qualified teacher. I would state that you want teacher rates for teaching. Leave if they refuse.

Coolhwip · 03/01/2024 13:20

LorlieS · 03/01/2024 13:17

@Coolhwip I have only met one male TA in my entire 20 year career.

Not surprising.

Coolhwip · 03/01/2024 13:19

Of course they then offered the MALE teachers rate for taking that class and he was on a HIGHER BAND than me. I contacted my union and they were useless (money well spent).

Bastards.

TheCorrupter · 03/01/2024 13:18

This is not an uncommon problem. I was in the same position op.

The problem is that the hlta job description and responsibilities are wooly. It doesn't specify how much time you should teach or what constitutes planning and assessment alongside the teacher rather than for. I remember this from my last role. I was used for two terms as class teacher I'm the sats. Had to do all the assessments, collaborators with other schools twilight's etc on an hlta rate.
When they went for a third term (September so I'd be likely stuck as class's teacher for a year) I said they'd need to pay me my band. They refused so I said no, just regular PPA over then.

Of course they then offered the MALE teachers rate for taking that class and he was on a HIGHER BAND than me. I contacted my union and they were useless (money well spent).

So sympathy but I think realistically you can only keep repeating what you willing do and quibbling about what your role is, but since the law is wooly and unions don't back you, what can you do?

Redlocks28 · 03/01/2024 13:17

if they paid HLTAs teacher pay for covering, all teachers would decide to become HLTAs because it's less responsibility. I might even be tempted to go back into education if they did that!

Absolutely! Delivering lessons is probably about 30-40% of the job and the nicest part of it at that! I’d be full time HLTA on a teacher wage if I could just teach and mark! Even with planning!