Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

HLTA (qualified teacher) being used as cover

154 replies

LorlieS · 03/01/2024 10:50

Posted in Education but no traffic...

AIBU to feel miffed about this?

I'm a qualified teacher with 20 years' experience but stepped down from class teaching about five years ago as workload was ridiculous and I wasn't having any time with my own children. I'm now working as an HLTA, specialising in supporting children with EHCPs. Love it. Hard work for appalling pay but it's my "thing." I take responsibility of interventions (both 1:1 and group) and ensuring work on EHCP targets is undertaken. Feels great to have autonomy whilst (hopefully) making a difference and I really get to know the children I work with.

However, it's a huge primary I work in and I find I am being pulled away from my job more and more to cover classes for staff absences. Very rarely with a TA and full class of 30. High SEN needs in all classes.

I used to get paid my teacher rate for such cover but now with budgets being what they are I dont; I am just paid my normal HLTA rate.

School loathe to get supply in as expensive.

OP posts:
Kim3456ss1 · 03/01/2024 16:15

@DyslexicPoster That is bloody awful that they actually say this to your face. I mean SEND parents know it happens but to not care and tell you to your face they are unlawfully using your child's funding for the roof!!

Yes it does and then some schools wonder why parents dislike them and do not want to work with them. They are actively admitting to putting your child at an even bigger disadvantage.

In my experience this is what schools want for parents/carers to not gain an EHCP or cease having one as it leaves the LA open to judical reviews if provision is not legally provided. If the child does not have a EHCP in place it is a lot easier to not provide provide child needs.

Redlocks28 · 03/01/2024 16:08

The senco even told me it goes towards the roof etc.

That’s bizarre-I’d ask for a breakdown of what they are spending it on as a provision map and submit that with the next AR.

It’s one thing to spend the money on a TA, but then that Ta to be off sick (eg one we currently employed as a 1:1 who said she was pregnant a week after starting and got signed off shortly after and hasn’t been back since October, but is still obviously being paid) but another to spend the money elsewhere.

LorlieS · 03/01/2024 16:05

@P3bbl34875 I can't afford for my salary to drop any lower.

OP posts:
DyslexicPoster · 03/01/2024 16:04

Motherofacertainage · 03/01/2024 13:53

Sadly in some cases, noone. The government has cut school funding to the bone and these are the consequences.

I know that's the reality. In fact I'd bet my car that my daughters 14k of ehcp funding only has 1k spent on her a year. The senco even told me it goes towards the roof etc. Then they tell me they can't cope with her. I'm pretty close to telling them it's not in my power to fix. I had to appeal twice to get her ehcp up to standard, just to get funding they don't spend on her. You can see why or how this builds bad feelings towards the school. I'm tempted to say she doesn't need it as then they need to get proactive.

At some point the whole shit show will collapse. With the new white paper it will be very very soon. School are trying to expel my dd. If they do she will be disregistered asap to cut off the funding stream.

P3bbl34875 · 03/01/2024 16:03

I think you’re in the wrong role. HLTAs are used for cover in our school and TAs for EHCP and IEPs. I’m an ex teacher and chose to be a TA not a HLTA. Interestingly there are a few of us ex teacher TAs and a couple of non ex teachers in the HLTA roles.

Luxell934 · 03/01/2024 15:54

This is normal is my school too. Plus level 3 LSAs can cover a class. They can get round it because you aren’t technically “teaching”, only supervising a pre planned lesson that’s been planned by the “teacher”. Yeah right 🙈🤣

Kim3456ss1 · 03/01/2024 15:48

@LorlieS I am glad you have voiced your concerns both for the child who is having their EHCP funding unlawfully used but also for yourself being used in this way.

Redlocks28 · 03/01/2024 15:42

In my experience, pupils with 1:1s lose them if that member of staff is absent, as otherwise it’s taking away another 1:1 from another child in a different class. They might double up, depending on how the needs are spread out. Many schools can’t afford insurance for support staff so if they are off, you are obviously still paying them, but can’t afford to pay someone else to do the same job.

Enigma52 · 03/01/2024 15:37

Kim3456ss1 · 03/01/2024 12:15

What happens to the children with EHC plans when you are removed from assisting them 1 to 1 them to teach classes?

I was wondering this too?
Do the children just not receive the additional support then?

Honestly, it's a nightmare.

My school uses HLTA for general cover, for maternity cover and whatever else they can find for them to do.

TA's get used for cover also. We are meant to " deliver " the " planned " work and it's not fair.

Not sure what the answer is, except get a new job ?

cardibach · 03/01/2024 15:36

Surely with the way schools are you would be pretty much guaranteed work as a supply teacher?
Sadly, @Bbq1 , that’s not the case. I’m a supply teacher (as a way to supplement my pension which I took early) and up until this school year that was true. This year work is very thin on the ground because schools are doing what the OP says - using anyone and everyone with a pulse who won’t cost them more. It’s frustrating, but it isn’t actually the schools’ fault - they just do t have the funding.

LorlieS · 03/01/2024 15:32

@Kim3456ss1 I have but ultimately it is their choice how to use me. And as supply cover is simply the most cost effective. I was taken on as 1:1 SEN support as I have a wealth of experience in their field (especially with SEMH) but this is not how the school can afford to use me now.

OP posts:
LorlieS · 03/01/2024 15:30

@LWTW Totally agree. There have been a few parents question it re me teaching their kids frequently (good on them!) to which they are reassuranced I am a qualified teacher with 20 years' experience.
I'm just not paid as such.

OP posts:
LWTW · 03/01/2024 15:25

Sorry, this is not particularly helpful! But I'm reading this thread and feeling thankful that I live in Scotland. While our education system is also far from perfect, we have retained the GTCS and all classes in schools must be covered by a registered teacher. There is no equivalent of a HLTA. As a parent, and a teacher, I find it quite difficult to imagine allowing unqualified staff to regularly and routinely cover classes and deliver lessons and take full responsibility for the children in the classroom.

Kim3456ss1 · 03/01/2024 15:12

@LorlieS I did not say I expect you to do anything about it. However myself personally I would not accept a vulnerable child's EHCP funding being used this way and would happily tell the HT my concerns.

Redlocks28 · 03/01/2024 15:10

savoycabbage · 03/01/2024 15:01

Also, there aren't enough.

Many schools are in a deficit budget and have been told they cannot spend money on supply. I am interested to see where the strict rules that HLTAs can’t be used for cover that@Cherrysoup is talking about is written? That’s the primary role of HLTAs in all schools I’ve worked in. Just working with 4 pupils would be done by a TA.

Kim3456ss1 · 03/01/2024 15:09

I fully understand there is a major issue with recruiting especially HLTA.

The bigger concern for me is the school have no right to redirect resources from funding from an EHCP to cover a class so they do not have to pay cover. Its not about best use of provision for 30 children compared to one child losing their 1 to 1 for the day/week. It is unlawful to use funding from EHCP this way its quite simple. And yes I know it happens all the time and yes parents of SEND children know it happens all the time hence the LA will be in breach of the CAFA section 42 for the schools doing this.

Maybe SLT should start not having cover for 30 children, as they can not afford to cover the class then maybe all parents would see how poorly funded education is and things might start to change.

However this wont happen and its easier for a school to take from the most vulnerable to give to the many, same old.

BreatheAndFocus · 03/01/2024 15:04

LorlieS · 03/01/2024 11:54

@Hmindr68 Union have advised that yes, HLTAs can be used to cover classes. They can ask me to do this on HLTA psy even though I'm a qualified teacher.

Yep. I’m in a very similar position (qualified, experienced teacher now working as support staff). I get asked to cover classes too. I don’t get supply teacher rate but I do get a slightly higher TA pay rate for those hours. I was a bit 🤔 at first but now I don’t mind and I enjoy it - basically teaching but with no (or little) planning.

You’re employed as a HLTA not a teacher. The fact you’re a qualified teacher doesn’t matter. You’re being asked to do the role as a HLTA. Less pay but less responsibility; you ‘keep your hand in’ at teaching; the children benefit from your experience; if you choose to go into supply later, you’ll have lots of cover experience to refer to.

If your issue is that it’s taking you away from your preferred role, then maybe talk about limiting the amount of cover you do and sharing it between other TAs?

savoycabbage · 03/01/2024 15:01

Redlocks28 · 03/01/2024 14:39

The union should also have told you that covering for known absences should be done by supply teachers, not ‘in house’. That is quite a strict rule

In which legislation in England is it stated that cover must be done by supply teachers?

Also, there aren't enough.

LorlieS · 03/01/2024 14:55

@Kim3456ss1 AnD what do you expect me to do about that?

OP posts:
Motherofacertainage · 03/01/2024 14:52

I can't obviously speak for all schools but I know of several where it's a case of simply not being able to recruit sufficient TAs/HTLAs plus issues with staffing or classroom teachers. No school LT, I should hope, is willfully holding back support for individual children but rather directing their human resources where they can give the best provision for the most children so for example having no effective classroom teacher for 30 is worse than one child missing their 1:1 support. It's not right but headteachers are doing the best they can with limited resources.

Kim3456ss1 · 03/01/2024 14:41

@Motherofacertainage It is the school fault in part. Funding given to schools for a child's EHCP is legally not allowed to be used for anything other than the child's and to provide provision within the plan.

If funding for the plan is not adequate then it is the job of the school headteacher and senco to challenge the LA to fully fund the EHCPS by law if need be.

@LorlieS But you know the school you work for are breaking the law by using another childs funding from an EHCP to provide cover for teaching but in your original post you only mention your disatifaction of pay, not what distress or damage this causes to the vulnerable child. Its only a secondary issue isn't it.

Yes you should be pay more if being used in this way I totally agree of course you should but tbh the childs funding being used unlawfully is a bigger issue to me, not your wages.

nutbrownhare15 · 03/01/2024 14:39

I would say you would not be unreasonable to request that, given your qualifications and experience, that you are paid at teacher rate. If they say no (sounds like they already have) I would suggest that you request that teacher cover is distributed equally between all the HLTAs at your school. They can't have it both ways. If they say no, are they implying that supporting children with EHCPs is less important than other teaching related activities at the school? Maybe something to chat to you union about.

Redlocks28 · 03/01/2024 14:39

The union should also have told you that covering for known absences should be done by supply teachers, not ‘in house’. That is quite a strict rule

In which legislation in England is it stated that cover must be done by supply teachers?

Cherrysoup · 03/01/2024 14:33

Are you covering or being expected to teach? The union should also have told you that covering for known absences should be done by supply teachers, not ‘in house’. That is quite a strict rule, which I’ve had to remind management about this year in my school. Our HTLAs only take small groups of 4 who are withdrawn from some mainstream lessons, never whole classes.

LorlieS · 03/01/2024 14:32

@Kim3456ss1 I LOVE working with my EHCP kids. It's my absolute passion. But I am now asked to provide teacher cover instead.

OP posts: