Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to go to medical school at 37?

432 replies

MilanHilton · 03/01/2024 08:02

I’m 37, married with two nursery aged children. Husband and I both earn £45k each so we live comfortably but not well off.

My medical care when I was pregnant was atrocious and the NHS was negligent (they admitted it). Which really got me thinking… I want to be a doctor that LISTENS to women so that what happened to me won’t happen to another lady.

I know I’m old, and coming from a non science background I’ll have to do 6 years in medical school and then extra training to be an OBGYN. Looking at the junior doctor pay bands it is going to take me years to get back to my current salary. Not to mention needing to do shift work and the stress of it all.

Financially it will be a tight decade and by the time I finish uni, the kids will be towards the end of primary so hopefully life will be easier. I’ll be mid 40s when I finish medical school so will still have another 20 years of working still.

AIBU for considering putting my young family through a decade of financial and emotional stress with the hope that I’ll earn more in the future? Is it worth the stress?

AINBU - go be a doctor! You’ll save lives (sometimes)
AIBU - that’s too much work and financial turmoil, even if you become a doctor you’re not going to address the chronic lack of resource in NHS

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Famousperson2023 · 04/01/2024 06:49

DOI NHS dr of 23 years.
please don’t. You’ll destroy your children’s childhood and probably your marriage.
I do mentor an allied HP of 39 and we occasionally discuss him applying to medical school. He has thought about it a lot, is an exceptional clinician and would be brilliant, but for all the reasons already mentioned on this thread he has said he can’t put his family through it.
im late 40s. At 55 consultants can opt out of providing on call services. For the first time a couple of weeks ago I mentally calculated how many years I had to go. I struggle to make safe decisions about patients beyond 10pm….by my age youll only be a few years out of med school with the worst years ahead of you. And I rarely help patients (I can’t think of the last life I saved). I mostly see people with lifestyle related health problems for which they intend to make zero lifestyle changes but would like me to use some fairy dust to make them better, all with a smile…..and don’t forget ……’my taxes pay your salary’.
if you really want to work in the NHS go down the physicians associate role (a role I don’t support), but a 2 year course will start you on a £45k/yr job rising to £80k within a few years. 9-5, mon-fri and the consultant you work under has all the responsibility. But I’d strongly advise not working in the nhs in any capacity.

withthischoice · 04/01/2024 06:34

CanaryCanary · 04/01/2024 06:29

@HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou yes of course I would. My point (which a lot of others have made!) is that there are other careers which would fulfill the same goals without such a massive commitment at the beginning.
Although got to be honest, I wouldn’t personally have hired a male lactation consultant.

you should have ignored @CanaryCanary

It didn’t justify a response.

CanaryCanary · 04/01/2024 06:29

HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou · 03/01/2024 21:28

Would you suggest that to a man considering a medical career?

@HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou yes of course I would. My point (which a lot of others have made!) is that there are other careers which would fulfill the same goals without such a massive commitment at the beginning.
Although got to be honest, I wouldn’t personally have hired a male lactation consultant.

Vettrianofan · 04/01/2024 06:28

tamade · 04/01/2024 00:43

Some food for thought from a practicing doctor - a series of 5 blog articles "what's wrong with the NHS"

https://drmalcolmkendrick.org/author/drmalcolmkendrick/

Thank you for posting. I will enjoy listening to this tonight once I get peace and quiet. Just finished listening to a Veblen podcast last night.

ToeSucker · 04/01/2024 00:25

jamsandwich1 · 03/01/2024 19:25

What degree is he doing now @Scirocco ?

My guess is dentistry to do maxillofacial surgery or oral medicine.

Hollydays · 04/01/2024 00:02

Have you ever worked within the NHS? It’s great to have goals and ambitions as to how you would do the role differently but with no experience I would be concerned that you aren’t aware of the constraints of the role? This is informed by my experience of retraining as a social worker at 46 (to make a difference) and realising that most/all issues ar as a result of a lack of resources.

MuckyPlucky · 03/01/2024 23:34

Meadowlands · 03/01/2024 22:34

Good for you wanting to help, the NHS needs people like you.

That’s right. Because there’s currently v few of us in the NHS who are caring & “want to listen and make a difference”.

The shameful underfunding by the Tories, the horrendous conditions, woeful backlogs & huge waiting lists aren’t the problem at all. All that’s needed is some entirely unqualified, optimistic, personally-traumatised patients to step-in, to show us where we’ve been going wrong. 🙄

Nigglenaggle · 03/01/2024 22:49

Yanbu to want to go and try to help.

Yabvu to think that you as a newly qualified doctor under circumstances of overwork and chronic underfunding will be able to do better than the people who treated you. The whole system is broken and you are deluded and very unfair to think that anyone working there did not start off wanting to be the person being the person who listens to women and does everything right.

They were short with you because they had to get you safely out of the way before the 10 women waiting behind you died or lost their babies. You were not their only problem that day. If you want to change things campaign for proper funding.

Meadowlands · 03/01/2024 22:34

Good for you wanting to help, the NHS needs people like you.

Manthide · 03/01/2024 22:29

NCJD · 03/01/2024 20:38

I’m so sorry your care was substandard.

I graduated from medical school at 28. I’m now 35 with 2 DC. I’m floundering at middle grade, years off being a consultant because it’s so hard to progress whilst maintaining anything approaching a family life especially (?exclusively) due to being an older female. During speciality training you have to move around enormous geographical areas which is both exhausting and awful for seeing your DC. For complete example, in O&G training in South Thames you could be in Guildford in year 1, central London in year 2, Dover in year 3, Brighton in year 4 and Chichester in year 5. In any hospital speciality you have to do a vast amount of work outside the horrendous hours if you want to progress. Night shifts in your 30s are horrible. I can’t even imagine how dreadful they will be in my 40s.

I do enjoy my job but I really wish I hadn’t gone back to medical school if I’m honest. I literally have no life outside of work and my DC because I don’t have the time or the brain space.

My dd1 wouldn't recommend it either! She's a ST5 OBGYN registrar and her latest move in October means she has a 90 minute commute each way. She has to stay in hospital accommodation when she is doing nights and sometimes long days. She is currently pregnant and wondering how her and her dh (also a doctor) will manage.

Mirabai · 03/01/2024 21:50

Have you considered physician’s associate OP? I don’t approve of the role as I don’t think they have enough training - 2 years - but the pay is comparable to doctors and the terms can be better.

HelloWorldItsNiceToMeetYou · 03/01/2024 21:28

CanaryCanary · 03/01/2024 08:06

Would you consider midwifery or nursing instead? Or something like a lactation consultant/doula? There’s lots of roles involving working with childbearing women without putting your family through all that.

Would you suggest that to a man considering a medical career?

jamsandwich1 · 03/01/2024 20:49

@Scirocco thats ok. I was just wondering because the only additional degree (PhD aside) I could think of was dentistry for omfs.

NCJD · 03/01/2024 20:38

I’m so sorry your care was substandard.

I graduated from medical school at 28. I’m now 35 with 2 DC. I’m floundering at middle grade, years off being a consultant because it’s so hard to progress whilst maintaining anything approaching a family life especially (?exclusively) due to being an older female. During speciality training you have to move around enormous geographical areas which is both exhausting and awful for seeing your DC. For complete example, in O&G training in South Thames you could be in Guildford in year 1, central London in year 2, Dover in year 3, Brighton in year 4 and Chichester in year 5. In any hospital speciality you have to do a vast amount of work outside the horrendous hours if you want to progress. Night shifts in your 30s are horrible. I can’t even imagine how dreadful they will be in my 40s.

I do enjoy my job but I really wish I hadn’t gone back to medical school if I’m honest. I literally have no life outside of work and my DC because I don’t have the time or the brain space.

Angelsrose · 03/01/2024 20:38

The NHS is a really tough place to work and not one I would recommend. If you plan to move to Canada, Australia or New Zealand immediately after qualifying, medicine may well be a rewarding and worthwhile pursuit. Staying in the UK will lead to unnecessary and untold misery. You may earn more than you do currently (after 10 years hard graft as a postgraduate) but especially with OBGYN you will work twice as many hours and will be lucky to see your family. OBGYN is a high risk, high stakes and high litigation speciality.

withthischoice · 03/01/2024 20:07

Scirocco · 03/01/2024 19:58

Funded by us, no additional funding for this one.

good grief!

All the best

Scirocco · 03/01/2024 19:59

jamsandwich1 · 03/01/2024 19:25

What degree is he doing now @Scirocco ?

I'd prefer not to say as it's potentially quite outing for him, but it's directly relevant to his career plan.

Scirocco · 03/01/2024 19:58

withthischoice · 03/01/2024 19:36

out of interest - is the degree funded?

Funded by us, no additional funding for this one.

withthischoice · 03/01/2024 19:36

Scirocco · 03/01/2024 18:45

No, he is one now. Working part time as a doctor, studying degree number 3 which is also work related.

out of interest - is the degree funded?

jamsandwich1 · 03/01/2024 19:25

What degree is he doing now @Scirocco ?

Scirocco · 03/01/2024 18:45

No, he is one now. Working part time as a doctor, studying degree number 3 which is also work related.

withthischoice · 03/01/2024 18:26

is your DH still in training to become a doctor @Scirocco ?

Scirocco · 03/01/2024 17:30

withthischoice · 03/01/2024 17:15

I have had students and trainees in similar situations to the OP,. and your dh too? that must have been tough

I think it depends on how you view it. We love our jobs and our family, and those are our main interests so that's where we put our energy. There have been sacrifices along the way of course. A job opportunity came up recently that I would have really enjoyed but I didn't apply because it wouldn't fit with our current schedule. I'm thinking of staying where I am, career-wise, for a few more years, then once DH is doing his new thing (hopefully!) and DC's settled in school (again, hopefully!) I might look for another opportunity. It's kind of like career leapfrog! If DC doesn't cope with school, we can both drop our hours and split home ed 50:50 instead.

CantGetInToday · 03/01/2024 17:28

One of my biggest achievements is that my kids are at university and not following me into Medicine.

I am in my fifties, have been a full time NHS consultant since I was 30 and have seen it all change behind recognition.

I am sure you could do it. But the toll it would take would be great.

Interestingly, the best F1 I have ever worked with was a 40-year-old mother of twins, one of whom had severe disabilities. It is the only time in my life, I have been moved to tears in admiration of what someone has achieved. She was incredible.

However, things in the NHS have become much worse. I have seen less camaraderie and more rudeness. Clinicians are often irritable with patients which is my bugbear. The service we give is simply not as good. We do not have a time for proper joined-up thinking and of course the NHS cannot be viewed in isolation and it is affected by inadequate social care and poverty.

I don’t like crushing dreams but it is good to be realistic. Well done for asking other people’s opinions before taking the next step.