Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to go to medical school at 37?

432 replies

MilanHilton · 03/01/2024 08:02

I’m 37, married with two nursery aged children. Husband and I both earn £45k each so we live comfortably but not well off.

My medical care when I was pregnant was atrocious and the NHS was negligent (they admitted it). Which really got me thinking… I want to be a doctor that LISTENS to women so that what happened to me won’t happen to another lady.

I know I’m old, and coming from a non science background I’ll have to do 6 years in medical school and then extra training to be an OBGYN. Looking at the junior doctor pay bands it is going to take me years to get back to my current salary. Not to mention needing to do shift work and the stress of it all.

Financially it will be a tight decade and by the time I finish uni, the kids will be towards the end of primary so hopefully life will be easier. I’ll be mid 40s when I finish medical school so will still have another 20 years of working still.

AIBU for considering putting my young family through a decade of financial and emotional stress with the hope that I’ll earn more in the future? Is it worth the stress?

AINBU - go be a doctor! You’ll save lives (sometimes)
AIBU - that’s too much work and financial turmoil, even if you become a doctor you’re not going to address the chronic lack of resource in NHS

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
SparklingLime · 03/01/2024 10:04

I was referring to the many med students who don't complete due to the overwhelming pressure causing MH issues, sexual/racist harassment, illness, insoluble problems at home such as childcare or bereavement, @CeciledeVolangesdeNouveau. Just because you describe yourself as oversensitive, it doesn't erase all those other barriers.

LaMarschallin · 03/01/2024 10:04

MilanHilton

rochethenut I’ve clearly offended you in some way as your responses are terribly rude

Tbf, I thought rtn's responses sounded much more irritated than rude.
Your OP combined a very unrealistic view of medical training (both pre- and post-graduate) and the even more unrealistic view that you (with your "empathy" mentioned in another post) were going to stop the experience you had happening to another lady.

notmorezoom at 09:18 (quoted a few posts above so I won't quote the whole thing again) put it more tactfully perhaps.

But if your skin is thin enough to find those posts rude, it's probably too thin to cope with some of the things patients will say/do to you as well (and some will be unpleasant - they're part of the general population) and are quite capable of telling you what to do with your empathy, I'm afraid.

Sandy8765 · 03/01/2024 10:03

Do it..i changed career at 40 did 5 years training, people will be jealous and say dont do it but yes do it

FormerlyPathologicallyHappy · 03/01/2024 10:02

It’s the patients who make HCP what we are.

When we meet a nice dr do you what we say? “They’ll change”

Spacecowboys · 03/01/2024 09:58

There isn’t a single dr or health care professional who doesn’t want to listen to patients! This comment alone makes me think you really don’t appreciate the demands of working in the nhs.

jamsandwich1 · 03/01/2024 09:57

Fully agree. Do you think you’ll be the only one to ever have empathy? Do you think you’d be the first doctor to ever have given birth?
I don’t mean to sound rude but you sound incredibly naive.

Turmerictolly · 03/01/2024 09:55

Sadly, you are unlikely to get on the Medicine course. Medicine places are hugely over subscribed. If you are really passionate about this then I would always say try but be realistic.

EarringsandLipstick · 03/01/2024 09:54

MilanHilton · 03/01/2024 09:38

@rochethenut I’ve clearly offended you in some way as your responses are terribly rude

I didn’t realise you have to do years of research in something before posting on mumsnet. I thought I could benefit from getting some real life experience from people who has gone down this path. I just wanted to float an idea on something I know I don’t know much about before, especially how it impacts on people with a young family. So yes, I have now read the responses and confirmed my thoughts that it is a very tough career with long and stressful training with not brilliant pay at the start.

With respect, did you really not know this already?

auntyElle · 03/01/2024 09:50

I think I will stick with my current career and consider whether there are volunteering opportunities where I can advocate for patients.

Please inform yourself about the realities of working for the NHS before doing that. Follow some JDs on Twitter. Have a look at PA issues.

Start with this?

www.theguardian.com/society/2023/dec/28/two-in-three-uk-doctors-suffer-moral-distress-due-to-overstretched-nhs-study-finds

LemonLight · 03/01/2024 09:48

Its a very noble profession, but I wouldn't do it with kids unless I were already rich and money wasn't an issue. If I won't the lottery then for sure, but I do think medical professions are very glamorised by the media when in reality the training and then the lifestyle is extremely tough and the working environment is lacking in resources and support.

rochethenut · 03/01/2024 09:48

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

rochethenut · 03/01/2024 09:47

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

MrsPatrickDempsey · 03/01/2024 09:46

notmorezoom · 03/01/2024 09:18

*No I don’t see myself as a sole saviour of the NHS but I just thought with my own experience, I can bring in a lot more empathy than some others

@MilanHilton I'm sure you didn't mean it that way, but do you not realise how immensely patronising that is to all of us who work in the NHS, who all have our own experiences of being patients? Empathy takes time. If you are in the position that I once was, with 45 minutes to discharge 12 patients from the post-natal ward, including finding all the notes and writing in them, how empathetic do you think you would be?

I completely agree with this and feel that your comment is a bit ill informed.
I was a midwife for 18 years - ran a delivery suite for many of them.
On a 13 hr night (with no sleep the previous day as I was looking after my young children) I was in charge of the whole unit but ended up delivering three babies within two hours of each other as there were no other midwives available. The rose tinted view of this privileged job was constantly challenged by demands out of my control. I did my absolute best to be compassionate but when you are running between 3 women at 5am ......

Sartre · 03/01/2024 09:43

I wouldn’t do it personally.

My DH did his PhD when our youngest DC were babies and it was the toughest 3 years of our marriage. He was working FT alongside it so slotted the hours into all evenings and weekends, even worked on it when we went on holiday. I did my PhD before they were born so I understood why he wanted to do one too and felt he had the right to do it but honestly, having such small children and him never really being present put so much pressure on our marriage. I even instigated a trial separation at one point because I couldn’t cope with him, he was unbearable to be around.

That was a 3 year PhD, you’re talking about a 6+ years medical degree which is much more taxing. Your kids will suffer, as will your marriage because you’ll barely be around. If you didn’t have young children I’d say go for it but they need you around and the hours med students and indeed junior doctors put in are not family friendly at all.

MilanHilton · 03/01/2024 09:38

@rochethenut I’ve clearly offended you in some way as your responses are terribly rude

I didn’t realise you have to do years of research in something before posting on mumsnet. I thought I could benefit from getting some real life experience from people who has gone down this path. I just wanted to float an idea on something I know I don’t know much about before, especially how it impacts on people with a young family. So yes, I have now read the responses and confirmed my thoughts that it is a very tough career with long and stressful training with not brilliant pay at the start.

OP posts:
Southwest12 · 03/01/2024 09:33

The moving with the military is very different to rotational training as a junior doctor. With the military you know in advance when you will be moving, with rotational training you'll know what deanery you are in but some are massive with hours between hospitals, you may not get told what hospital you are at until 6 weeks before. That maybe 2 hours drive away, tough, they won't care that you have children. Someone I know just about lived in his car for 6 months as the hospital he was at was so far away and traffic was awful (NW).

I know a lot of Surgical trainees and consultants and most trainees have taken time out to do a PhD, competition for specialist training is such that just having a medical degree isn't enough to get into the ST years.

I tried for the extended medical degree many years ago and at interview they made a big thing about how old I was... I'm glad now that I didn't get in.

rochethenut · 03/01/2024 09:28

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

LaMarschallin · 03/01/2024 09:26

My local uni offers a foundation year for those with no medical background so not impossible.

X-posred.
Fair enough - that's one thing off my list.
But - as a PP said - there's no guarantee you get your first choice.

Hallesmellie · 03/01/2024 09:21

Don’t do it. Your children are only young once - you will miss the best part of their childhood in a cloud of hard work and stress for little reward. Do you even have the grades and experience to get in to a medical degree? Your age is likely to count against you too.

LaMarschallin · 03/01/2024 09:21

I expect the training as a medical student is different from how it was for my contemporaries, but then (80s) there were two pre-clinical years which had lectures from 9-5, but at least you got normal university holidays.
Then there were three clinical years, where you spent time on the wards learning general medicine and surgery as well as specialties; you were still having lectures. You were also expected to shadow the SHO/registrar of the team you were with during overnight on calls and still do your normal studying the next day. You were also sent away to various placements (friends from London spent time in, for example, Stoke, Bedfordshire, Tewkesbury...) which were residential, so even if it had been practical to return each night, you couldn't.
And you went down to 4 weeks holiday a year which you had to apply for. However, teaching still went on at those times (there were not set times when everything shut down) so you had to catch up when you got back.

I'm sure things have changed, but I imagine it's still pretty grueling.
And I know people are saying they know people who've trained at a later age and who have no science background, but universities/teaching hospitals taking those students will be in the minority.
There's no guarantee that there would be such a placement at a university near your family home. So you could end up travelling hours a day or living away from home Mon-Fri.

CeciledeVolangesdeNouveau · 03/01/2024 09:18

SparklingLime · 03/01/2024 09:10

Perhaps be aware that you are heavily implying that those who don't successfully complete med or vet school are oversensitive and not strong. Could not be further from the truth.

I certainly was. It was the ones who could skateboard around on a dead horse’s liver that made it. Nobody else did. I got my first sitting about pointing out the anatomy because I’d revised in advance. Doctors have to dissect dead people.

notmorezoom · 03/01/2024 09:18

*No I don’t see myself as a sole saviour of the NHS but I just thought with my own experience, I can bring in a lot more empathy than some others

@MilanHilton I'm sure you didn't mean it that way, but do you not realise how immensely patronising that is to all of us who work in the NHS, who all have our own experiences of being patients? Empathy takes time. If you are in the position that I once was, with 45 minutes to discharge 12 patients from the post-natal ward, including finding all the notes and writing in them, how empathetic do you think you would be?

AgeingDoc · 03/01/2024 09:17

Even if you started next year- and realistically that's fairly unlikely - you'd be looking at becoming a consultant at about the age that most who are able to do so are starting to think about retiring. It's not impossible but would be extremely difficult and not something I would encourage anyone in your position to attempt to be honest. Medical school is the easy bit of medical training. Working and doing professional exams whilst juggling family commitments is a whole different ball game and is draining in your 20s/early 30s. You'd be into your mid 40s by the time you got there, assuming you worked full time and everything went according to plan. And to be honest, it's not that great when you finish training - I'd say the last decade of my career was the most stressful by miles.
And the problems of the NHS aren't due to a lack of staff who want to be able to "really listen" I'm afraid. * *

Catunderling · 03/01/2024 09:16

Have you any other interest in being a doctor or studying medicine other than an your own experience? Not to diminish that, it's just a heck of a slog and there could be other ways of addressing this interest. What do you do now, for instance? Maybe you could look at midwifery? Very hard work but wider access and quicker training. Something to do with quality or advocacy maybe?

I started at 34 (no kids) and am just coming up to my final year of grad entry (3rd year passed). Work broadly fine except a couple of serious health issues. I do feel as though I'm only just starting though yet have been through a bit of a war of attrition compared to the 21 year olds. This could be the health stuff though to be fair as in the normal run of things I'd be going full steam at 37.

You'd need to consider the length of the application process though plus you're not guaranteed to get in your local uni and it would be a lot of work just to decide not to relocate the kids. Also I'm not sure how much assistance if any you'd be given with logistics and placements if you have a specific pathway in mind.

I wouldn't personally consider Medicine without getting on the GEM due to funding but I don't know your circumstances. It's competitive but doable if you make a strong case for yourself. Bear in mind the entry exams. GAMSAT or UKCAT. I think GAMSAT has more coverage if you don't have science degree and is not an easy exam. That's if you have a degree. Perhaps you can just get funding as a first time undergrad.

Perhaps decide what universities are realistic for you and speak to medical admissions then go from there.

I suppose m saying there may be ways but it would be a hell of a lot and you'd feel quite different from the other students.

supercalifragilistic123 · 03/01/2024 09:11

I work in theatres and have met some fantastic junior obs/gynae drs. They have either left the speciality, moved to another country (usually oz) or gone to work in a major city. The fear of litigation is very real and they feel they need to be in a well supported environment. Not one has stayed past the end of their training in the 7 years I've been in my DGH hospital.
Instead we have locums or overseas recruitment.