Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to go to medical school at 37?

432 replies

MilanHilton · 03/01/2024 08:02

I’m 37, married with two nursery aged children. Husband and I both earn £45k each so we live comfortably but not well off.

My medical care when I was pregnant was atrocious and the NHS was negligent (they admitted it). Which really got me thinking… I want to be a doctor that LISTENS to women so that what happened to me won’t happen to another lady.

I know I’m old, and coming from a non science background I’ll have to do 6 years in medical school and then extra training to be an OBGYN. Looking at the junior doctor pay bands it is going to take me years to get back to my current salary. Not to mention needing to do shift work and the stress of it all.

Financially it will be a tight decade and by the time I finish uni, the kids will be towards the end of primary so hopefully life will be easier. I’ll be mid 40s when I finish medical school so will still have another 20 years of working still.

AIBU for considering putting my young family through a decade of financial and emotional stress with the hope that I’ll earn more in the future? Is it worth the stress?

AINBU - go be a doctor! You’ll save lives (sometimes)
AIBU - that’s too much work and financial turmoil, even if you become a doctor you’re not going to address the chronic lack of resource in NHS

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
PieAndLattes · 03/01/2024 13:00

Would you be able to meet the entrance requirements? Medicine is very, very, competitive. You’ll be asked for 3 A* grades (or equivalent) in science subjects at A level. I don’t know what your first degree is in, but would it be possible to go into medical law or something like that?

HermioneHerman · 03/01/2024 12:57

Have you heard of the nationwide Maternity Partnerships, OP? https://nationalmaternityvoices.org.uk/

They are wonderful advocacy and campaigning organisations that work with NHS Trusts to influence maternity policy and improve care and outcomes etc. Volunteering with your local one might be a great place to start and they do have jobs from time to time too.

National Maternity Voices – Networking Maternity Voices Partnerships in England

https://nationalmaternityvoices.org.uk

Viviennemary · 03/01/2024 12:54

It will be a very hard struggle. Even harder with no science background. No I don't think it would wise in your circumstances.

therealcookiemonster · 03/01/2024 12:53

@MilanHilton have read all your posts now. can't believe they missed a PE!!!!!!! I hope you put in a complaint. being short of time to not 100% be able to empathise is one thing but what you describe is down right negligence

I think volunteering is a great idea. given your experience, maybe look into volunteering for PALS?

Coachvikki · 03/01/2024 12:51

I retrained into Psychology at 38. I am 4 years in and I still have 2 years of my doctorate left. It is hard, really hard and I don't have children. That said, if it is something you really want you should do it.

My advice would be to seek out some people who have done their training late and truely understand what you are setting yourself up for. Then do it

housethatbuiltme · 03/01/2024 12:49

I studied a medical field and the first day of my course they said 'Congratulations on attending university. By the time you graduate your jobs will mostly be done by a robot and you'll be retraining as an medical engineer to fix that robot. You should have just gone straight into engineering'.

I have no idea how true that is as my degree has never actually been used for its intended purpose. NHS hours are way to long, work far too hard and the pay way to low to justify it being an option in my life right now.

My DS was 3 and very easy child when I started, it was stressful but now I have 2 more much more difficult children it would be impossible.

You also tend to need more studies to get into specialist areas, like my best friend had to study and intern for an extra 2 years after her degree to qualify and get licensed in her field.

If you have lots of free time to fill, don't mind working yourself to death and are willing to do it for not much money then go for it but I wouldn't recommend it. If I could go back I would probably have picked something else.

Gunnersforthecup · 03/01/2024 12:47

Another option would be to do a degree in a health related field. If you have an arts degree, say, would you be able to do some qualititative research looking at people's experience of healthcare?

If you are passionate about the subject, you could dive deep into just that topic (without all the preclinical study and in call etc).

Often in medical research departments, there can be very senior non medics who are really highly thought of. They might end up doing very similar work to medics in research, and have equal or greater status, but didn't need to have done the medical degree, the on call etc.

HermioneHerman · 03/01/2024 12:45

@User4363463 , re mature students being outsiders, that's not the case at my med school at all but I think our cohorts are unusually diverse. I'm on a 5 year course, as without a science background GEM and the science -based entrance exam would have been tough for me. So I am studying alongside a lot of 18 year olds too, but also over 50 previous graduates of very varied ages and backgrounds. I've not experienced any ostracism/age discrimination at all, although I'm sure I will at some point. And of course this is very specific to where I'm studying and no idea where OP is based. Long story short though, medicine is in some regards/areas, embracing diversity and moving away from the very traditional academic/school leaver model as extreme resilience is needed these days.

Carpediemmakeitcount · 03/01/2024 12:43

User4363463 · 03/01/2024 12:30

Another thing to be aware of is that your 10 years of studying and training are going to suck because you'll always be the outsider. The other students are all young, single, childfree and one of the key factors of getting through gruelling medical school is having emotional support from friends. Think 20 year-olds pulling all nighters then blowing off steam in wild parties and holidays. Realistically, you won't be able to join nor feel inclined to do so. Would your kids and husband be enough emotional support for the entire journey, without understanding how difficult it is? Or would they resent you for taking so much time away from family responsibilities?

Medical students are fairly cliquey, with many coming from privileged backgrounds as well. From experience, the second & third generation doctors (whose parents all know each other) tend to stick together immediately. The first gen medical students find friends amongst each other or eventually join the main inner circle. The mature students are usually just forgotten or even worse ostracised. It's not direct bullying but just falling through the gaps. There was a mature student in DH's year with a child and none of the other students warmed to her because she kept requesting specific rotas or last min changes due to childcare or child-related issues. In retrospect, this makes perfect sense if you have kids but there's no way a bunch of students in their mid 20s could relate to that.

My daughter is studying to become a chiropractor she has told me that there are men and women in their 30's on the course. One of them recently got married and they have children. What you have posted is not a turn off it's about maturity and how life is. The 30 year olds are not going to go out partying they will go home to their families. Mature students are not interested in cliques there main goal is to make there family life better.

Gunnersforthecup · 03/01/2024 12:40

You are not too old, in that there are training hospitals that would accept someone of 37 or 38.

As a doctor, who trained as a mature student (I was 22 when I started) it was remarkably hard work. I was in love with the idea of medicine and that was what sustained me. It was all very intense.

However, I think I would have found all the on calls increasingly difficult as I got older. I think O & G is a tough speciality for a woman especially with young children (though your young children would be in secondary school maybe by the time you started training). Also, the NHS is becoming increasingly difficult as a workplace and the pay and support arrangements are being eroded; patients are more demanding, and more dissatisfied (often but not always with good cause).

If you have enough energy and passion, then it might be wonderful. But you would need to make sacrifices, especially perhaps in terms of time with your children while they are young, when you aren't too busy or tired to focus on their needs.

BeaRF75 · 03/01/2024 12:37

OP, you do know how physically knackered you'll feel?
There'll be a lot more (expensive) studying to qualify for obs& gynae.
The defence fees are humongous.
Medicine is NOT family friendly - which is why so many marriages break up, or doctors choose not to have kids.
In your first few years as a junior doc, you could be sent to work anywhere in the country.
Otherwise, go for it 🤣 (I wouldn't!).

SylvieLaufeydottir · 03/01/2024 12:35

zendeveloper · 03/01/2024 12:26

I know someone who started at 45 or thereabouts, no science background after GCSE / O-levels, a single parent to two very young children, and they are graduating this year - I believe on track for a first. So definitely doable. But probably easier as their children live full time with another parent, and there has been no big pressure to contribute financially as the other parent is earning ok money. I think they ended with a 50K+ debt anyway.

That's certainly an accomplishment, but it's only finishing uni, which is the easy part. There are many, many more years of relentless work and study, harder than uni, for the route the OP wants.

thinktwice36 · 03/01/2024 12:35

Please do this for you and all the people you can help, I think it’s brilliant.

an alternative would be to look at a physician associate qualification? It might be a more easily worked compromise?

User4363463 · 03/01/2024 12:30

Another thing to be aware of is that your 10 years of studying and training are going to suck because you'll always be the outsider. The other students are all young, single, childfree and one of the key factors of getting through gruelling medical school is having emotional support from friends. Think 20 year-olds pulling all nighters then blowing off steam in wild parties and holidays. Realistically, you won't be able to join nor feel inclined to do so. Would your kids and husband be enough emotional support for the entire journey, without understanding how difficult it is? Or would they resent you for taking so much time away from family responsibilities?

Medical students are fairly cliquey, with many coming from privileged backgrounds as well. From experience, the second & third generation doctors (whose parents all know each other) tend to stick together immediately. The first gen medical students find friends amongst each other or eventually join the main inner circle. The mature students are usually just forgotten or even worse ostracised. It's not direct bullying but just falling through the gaps. There was a mature student in DH's year with a child and none of the other students warmed to her because she kept requesting specific rotas or last min changes due to childcare or child-related issues. In retrospect, this makes perfect sense if you have kids but there's no way a bunch of students in their mid 20s could relate to that.

zendeveloper · 03/01/2024 12:26

I know someone who started at 45 or thereabouts, no science background after GCSE / O-levels, a single parent to two very young children, and they are graduating this year - I believe on track for a first. So definitely doable. But probably easier as their children live full time with another parent, and there has been no big pressure to contribute financially as the other parent is earning ok money. I think they ended with a 50K+ debt anyway.

Usernamen · 03/01/2024 12:19

This is the timeline to OBGYN consultant:

Foundation course due to non-scientific background: 1 year
Medical school: 5 years
Foundation training: 2 years
Getting to consultant: another 10-15 years?

Assuming you apply now to start next academic year at the age of 38, you’re looking at late-50s before you’re a consultant.

I am normally very encouraging of career changes, but this doesn’t seem like a very practical idea, OP, sorry.

ChrisPackhamsYellowFleece · 03/01/2024 12:19

@MilanHilton You sound like a smart, ambitious person with lots of drive. Rather than qualifying as a doctor, which is not really a practical route for you, how about looking at healthcare policy/ patient rights campaign groups and seeing how you could progress your career there. There are charities like Birthrights which look into patient experiences like yours. Perhaps that would be a more feasible way of making a difference.

CormorantStrikesBack · 03/01/2024 12:15

It’s so true about not having the time. I can remember as a student midwife being told by the antenatal clinic sister not to make eye contact with women in appointments as it will encourage talking and your appts will take too long and clinic overruns. I can remember being horrified by this advice.

ive never worked as a qualified midwife in clinic so not sure if this is still a thing but I suppose realistically what do you do when the clinics are over filled? You spend time and are emphatic with people, morning clinic overruns by an hour and you get no lunch break (was a frequent occurrence) and then straight into afternoon clinic which also overruns and you’re an hour late getting home. I remember coming out a room once as a second year student to find all the qualified midwives had gone home!

It’s ok as a student on a 4 week placement but if that was your working life 5 days a week and you worked non stop from 8:30 to 6pm with no break how fucked would your mental health be? So I can see why even if we ignore the extreme advice about no eye contact there isn’t the time for decent care without giving yourself a breakdown.

scoobysnaxx · 03/01/2024 12:15

rochethenut · 03/01/2024 08:28

No OP

This is not remotely sensible or indeed realistic

This.

Shocked you're even considering it! Especially with 2 very young kids and a non medical non science background.

I think becoming a doula would be a good thing. Right alongside women throughout their pregnancy and during childbirth. Helping them through it but advocating for them and advising them.

Seems a good fit.

Midwinter91 · 03/01/2024 12:13

I started googling med school after binge watching Greys anatomy. The fantasy passes after a week or so.

You need to enjoy your family whilst the children are young not spend all your time along with your nose in a laptop.

FreshWinterMorning · 03/01/2024 12:12

Morechocmorechoc · 03/01/2024 08:10

Between the fact you'll have no money so you'll struggle with the kids, the fact you'll have to do shift work forever more, again missing Christmases, birthdays etc, kids plays, all sorts, at this point is it worth it? You'll likely end up with years of struggle for your while family and a terrible job at the end of it.

Yeah this. ^ The fact I would not be qualified til I was in my mid 40s, and I would be living on the bones of my arse for 6-7 years, and even then would not be guaranteed a job that would pay any more than stacking shelves in B & M means I would not do it. Sorry @MilanHilton I just wouldn't.

I think some people romanticize the idea of being a doctor, like 'I wanna help people and save lives and make the NHS better etc...' But in reality, you will just be another overworked underpaid NHS staff member who will rarely see your family, or get any thanks from anyone. You being a doctor is not going to make the NHS better.

It's a no from me. (Sorry.) Blush

HermioneHerman · 03/01/2024 12:09

A few things to add having now read the full post.

  1. 4 year graduate medical programmes do come with tuition fee loans except for the first ~£3.5 but are ultra ultra competitive as a result

  2. I'm most definitely at a medical school, signposts everywhere plus same at all tjis I visited when applying - completely normal terminology.

  3. I'm only in my first year, but I definitely do get to see my kids and am certainly not completely absent from their lives. I'm currently in 3 days a week and not for full days usually. I do do a lot of work by myself at home, in evenings and weekends around them. I choose to prioritise that but it is very tiring. In future clinical years, I'll be in more but kids will be older plus my medical school are supportive of parents (I don't think all med schools are but mine is known for a diverse cohort) and will place me as locally to home as possible. I'm not the oldest on my course, not do I have the most kids!

  4. For Foundation years, even though the allocation process has changed, parents and others with mitigating circumstances can get pre-allocated locally. What this means for me is that I'll have certainty and won't be a really long way from home but any ambitions on my part are completely irrelevant to be honest. I won't be able to choose my preferred rotations and I won't be able to be picky about specialties. It will be a case of I get what I get and do what I can do, which is available locally and not ultra-competitive or oversubscribed. I'm ok with that but if I was aiming for a specific career like OBS, I'd be disappointed.

  5. Whoever mentioned that maintenance loans are means-tested on household income is incorrect, they very much are and reduce amount a lot even at fairly low level, with dependants and only one income coming in and paying for everything. I've needed significant savings to do this.

AgeingDoc · 03/01/2024 12:08

Clearly I’m just a lazy patronising person. You guys are right, I’m too thinned skin for this.
I wouldn't have said anything like that, not until your last post anyway. I would have said you sound idealistic and a bit naive/not very well informed but that would apply to lots of people - there seem to be posts along the same lines pretty regularly here. Lots of people have somewhat rose tinted views about working in healthcare, and other professions of course. One of my best friends is a vet and the reality of her life is very different to what most people expect. There's nothing wrong with not knowing stuff and asking for information. It's laudable that you want to help other people and it would be wonderful if you could make a difference. I've experienced very poor treatment in the NHS both for myself and other members of my family so I do understand why you might feel as you do, but sadly, your dream is probably not realistic.
And really nobody has said anything terribly rude or unreasonable to you on this thread. If you were to pursue medicine I'm afraid you will face a massive amount of negativity and rudeness throughout your career. I started at medical school in the 80s and have just retired and honestly I have had far worse things said and done to me more or less every working day of my life in that time than pretty much any of the comments on this thread. The reality is that you do need to be extremely resillient to put up with being on the frontline of the NHS, or probably any public service, in any capacity. If you are interested in any healthcare role at all, the best thing to do would be to get some work experience even as a volunteer and get some idea what it's really like, because you do seem to have reacted quite negatively to some fairly mild criticism on here.

reesewithoutaspoon · 03/01/2024 12:04

Having left the NHS after 37 years I would say no, it's not realistic. It's laudable that you want to do something to change what was a horrible experience for you. but this isn't the way.
Even if you did get to be an OBGYN consultant, how much impact do you think you could have within a broken system? You can't spend ages with each patient, gently describing what their treatment is, patiently explaining what is going on. Unfortunately, compassion takes time and you won't have it. You will have a list of patients to see and not enough hours to do it, the stress of that alone is huge,, the moral injury of not giving your patients the care you trained to give, and the trauma you see daily. All of these will wear away at you.
Compassion fatigue is real, you mentally cannot deliver empathetic, compassionate care 100% of the time, not in this system and not if you want to preserve your own mental health

123bumblebee · 03/01/2024 12:03

Gosh no! Stick with the salary you are on now. I’m entering my 7th year after qualifying and don’t earn as much as you (admittedly I work PT but that is because my PT hours equate to most people’s FT hours plus studying on top!). That’s with £100 a month of professional fees on top (no reduction for PT hours), an hour commute each way to my training placement (fuel £££) and increased childcare fees because of long hours and I have put my little girl into an extra 1/2 day per week so I can study for my exams/work on my training portfolio that is quite rigorous to complete each year.

Sorry I haven’t read the full thread- ironically am at home studying for upcoming exam but I have seen you have had some unfair comments. I’d be happy to speak to you if you want a bit more of an idea of what postgraduate training looks like- medical school is the “easy’ part! PM me if I can help.