Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

She won't let me in her house

438 replies

Xmasdread22 · 02/01/2024 22:15

I have a friend I met through work. We've been friends 5 years. She doesn't let any friends in her house. We've been on nights out and to meals together but she won't let anyone in her house. I dropped her home the other day and I was desperate for the toilet and she wouldn't let me in to use it. Has anyone else had this before?

OP posts:
Fairyliz · 03/01/2024 16:31

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 03/01/2024 14:29

Not allowing random folk into your house isn't unreasonable behaviour.

But it isn’t a random person who has knocked on the door and asked to use the toilet, it’s a friend.
She’s happy enough to accept a lift from the op but won’t let her use the toilet.

Goldenbear · 03/01/2024 16:30

Bleechy · 03/01/2024 14:04

Everyone just judges your friend saying its probably because she has a dirty house
It could simply be the same as me I have issues inviting people into my house and its spotlessly clean and tidy
I would always meet hem on neutral ground as my home is my sanctuary .
She shouldn't have to justify her actions its her choice.You claim to be her friend so try acting like one and appreciate people are different

Why doesn't she be a friend and let the OP use her loo. For goodness sake a request to use a loo is not akin to a dinner party suggestion in your 'sanctuary'. It is probably any think but a sanctuary and this is the reason!

StockpotSoup · 03/01/2024 16:20

Have you possibly mentioned on more than one occasion that you have never been in her home? Could it be that she did not really think that you were not that desperate for the loo and therefore only wanted a snoop?

I’m wondering this too. Maybe I’m doing the OP a disservice, but the thread seems to be mainly about how she and her friends are never invited in, why isn’t anyone allowed… even the thread title is “She won't let me in her house” rather than “She wouldn’t let me use the loo”. Maybe the friend twigged it was a good excuse for a look around.

RampantIvy · 03/01/2024 16:19

I must know some very strange people because this behaviour has happened many times, by different people.

Sadly, I think you do.

It sounds like you know some rather unpleasant people @GotBeatenUp.
I hope your user name isn't indicative of your life experiences Flowers

No-one I know would do the things in my house that have happened to you - we only have close friends and family visit us.

In response to other posters - no-one rummages about in our house, no-one smokes, no-one passes judgmental comments, no-one steals and no-one oversteps boundaries.

Some of the emotive language used on this thread - safe space, sanctuary, boundaries indicates that either these posters have had some unpleasant experiences from visitors or there is something else going on.

margotrose · 03/01/2024 16:18

Couchant · 03/01/2024 15:46

What you’re describing isn’t ‘introversion’.

How isn't it?

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 03/01/2024 16:18

biscuitnut · 03/01/2024 15:35

@GotBeatenUp yes it is rubbish. Here in the real world people don’t accept the hospitality of someone giving them a lift, letting them pay for petrol, then don't let them go for a wee, unless there is something wrong with them or in the home, it’s odd behaviour. It’s not op’s problem- it’s hers.

There's many versions of 'the real world' though.

betterangels · 03/01/2024 16:17

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 03/01/2024 16:10

Actually, not wanting folk in your space can definitely be a part of introversion, especially if you've already socialised that day.

Absolutely, it can. If I've been out socially for hours, and people suggest we go around my flat for however long? No. I need time on my own to decompress, no matter how close friends they are. Luckily, most of the people in my life understand and accept that.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 03/01/2024 16:10

Couchant · 03/01/2024 15:46

What you’re describing isn’t ‘introversion’.

Actually, not wanting folk in your space can definitely be a part of introversion, especially if you've already socialised that day.

GotBeatenUp · 03/01/2024 15:50

@biscuitnut , I have boundaries and try to look after my mental health.
Letting someone into my house when previous visitors have been unbelievably rude means I would have said no. It's not rubbish behaviour, but I can do without someone inviting themselves in if it means risking someone rummaging through my bathroom cupboard or having a quick look round and then passing comments.

I don't have anything unusual or shameful in my bathroom cupboard. but to rummage through it so that things fall out is weird behaviour. It's just things like toothbrushes, floss, q-tips, san-pro etc.

Couchant · 03/01/2024 15:46

PupInAPram · 03/01/2024 15:45

Some people are introvert and happy. But please, just judge away...

What you’re describing isn’t ‘introversion’.

PupInAPram · 03/01/2024 15:45

everyredsock · 03/01/2024 05:17

My ex sister in law was like this. Her then DH was very sociable and loved having people around but she hated it. Now they're divorced he hosts loads of parties and has a happy life while she can be miserable on her own not letting anyone into her house.

Some people are introvert and happy. But please, just judge away...

Aspiringhermit · 03/01/2024 15:43

My home is clean and pretty tidy but I don't really like people coming in. Maybe your friend has someone staying with her that she doesn't want anyone to know about. Have you possibly mentioned on more than one occasion that you have never been in her home? Could it be that she did not really think that you were not that desperate for the loo and therefore only wanted a snoop? If it's a problem for you then don't offer her a lift home in future or make sure you go to the loo before you set off for home.

biscuitnut · 03/01/2024 15:35

@GotBeatenUp yes it is rubbish. Here in the real world people don’t accept the hospitality of someone giving them a lift, letting them pay for petrol, then don't let them go for a wee, unless there is something wrong with them or in the home, it’s odd behaviour. It’s not op’s problem- it’s hers.

Somepeoplearesnippy · 03/01/2024 15:31

@biscuitnut's comment has reminded me of something. She said what if she needed a paramedic - would she refuse to let them in?

I think she might. I posted upthread about my mum not letting people in her house and have just remembered that when she was in her late 60s she fell off a step stool and broke her wrist. Rather than calling an ambulance she took 2 buses to the nearest A&E. Looking back I think maybe that was the first warning of her impending eccentricity.

housethatbuiltme · 03/01/2024 15:28

Lots of reasons, I dont let anyone in outside of those that need to be in like the gas man or workmen fixing problems etc... There lots of reasons for this but the top two are:

  1. on more than one occasion I have had so called friends steal from me and/or not follow basic house rules (like smoking in bedrooms etc... when we do not allow smoking and no cracking the window is not enough)

&

  1. boundary overstepping, we had some family members that thought nothing of letting themselves in and going through our personal stuff... we are private people. I have medications and stuff that are not public knowledge or anyone elses business, I should not have to lock up my belonging in MY house. These people seemed insistent that 'family' are entitled to do these things.

Frankly most people have proved they could not be trusted unfortunately so we have not had anyone in our house in 12 years and all these issues magically stopped and we are much happier in our secure and PRIVATE space. If I want to hang out I will go out in public to meet friends or they can have me to THEIR house if they are comfortable with that.

GotBeatenUp · 03/01/2024 15:25

@biscuitnut , you would not be invited in to mine. 'All this rubbish...' indeed.

biscuitnut · 03/01/2024 15:22

I am sorry but if I had given someone a lift and they couldn’t even let me use their loo I would assume something was very wrong with them mentally or in their house. Definitely not your issue op. It’s downright odd not to allow someone to use your loo in normal circumstances whatever mumsnetters say. All this rubbish about I wouldn’t let someone in the house because it’s my sanctuary etc etc. what happens if you need a paramedic, do you meet them on neutral ground? Whatever the reason I would drop it because there is something going on with her and you can’t fix it. Most likely hoarding.

RosesAndHellebores · 03/01/2024 15:20

MIL is similar. The house is clean and tidy whilst being the house that time forgot. I have known her for 35 years. In 35 years, she has never invited a visitor in (except dh, the sils and the dc). After FILs funeral she refused to let her brothers and sisters go back to the house.

She's just quaint, a bit unsociable and hates the thought of offering anyone a drink or something to eat.

GotBeatenUp · 03/01/2024 15:20

RampantIvy · 02/01/2024 22:31

Everyone sticking up for the colleague - don't you think it is rather mean to not let a work colleague use the loo when they needed to?

You have no idea what it is like when someone wants to invite themself in.
I won't and it freaks me out when people turn up unannounced.

I have issues with people in my house because they cross boundaries and behave in an unacceptable way.

Examples are rummaging, opening closed doors and passing remarks.

People might seem normal, nip upstairs for a wee, then you hear stuff tumbling out of the bathroom cupboard because 'I wondered what you kept in there'.

I must know some very strange people because this behaviour has happened many times, by different people.

CombatLingerie · 03/01/2024 15:12

@Toottooot your posts never disappoint 😂always give me a laugh!

MCOut · 03/01/2024 15:10

LittleMissSunshiner · 03/01/2024 11:16

If I have someone I consider a friend, we have got to know one another over the years, we hang out and share personal information and confidences, they have been in my home etc and are always welcome, I would be very disturbed if that person would not allow me in their home and had never explained why.

My friend I mentioned way up thread (had never been in her home but gave me her key and asked me to do something in an emergency - found squalor, filth, stench, infestations, floor to ceiling, hoarding for 20+ years) should have told me about the state of her home IMO as it was dangerous and badly infested in a way that could have affected me and my life and my home. Also she had her son and cats living in there. I can't believe she herself was living in there - it was like one of those extreme hoarding USA progs.

Obviously I have total empathy and there's been many times in my life that my flat has been so messy or unkempt that I'd be mortified if anyone needed to come in (but, personally I would let someone in to use the loo as I feel it's a medical need).

It's a massive part of someone's life when they're living like that and clearly they're in denial or something but for me it would be a game changer and put the friendship in a whole different light. Especially as this one in my example was quite bitchy and grandiose and snarky. When she said 'never come to my home unexpectedly' I assumed she was being snobbish and lording it over me like she did sometimes.

Instead she was actually profoundly mentally ill and I would have been kind enough to try and support or help her. It ended our friendship as I refused to go back into the house (due to infestations and other hazards) and she bizarrely and incorrectly assumed I'd lost her door keys so we argued and drifted apart after that, never seen her since.

I think it’s this kind of self absorption that posters are trying to warn the OP against tbh. It is a well documented feature of a lot of MH disorders that people do not have the self-awareness to realise that there is a problem. In others, they don’t confide in loved ones because of extreme shame. For example, in OCD and hoarding, the compulsions are a response to not being able to cope with discomfort. It is not reasonable to expect somebody who does not recognise the problem, or who may need to be medicated before they relearn how to deal with uncomfortable feelings, to open themselves up to you so you don’t get offended.

It had nothing to do with you, was not a reflection of you and was not a reflection of your relationship. It was her disorder. No one owes you their every shame and vulnerability. The only way in which you could’ve helped her was to encourage her to seek professional medical help.

Goodlard · 03/01/2024 15:02

ATVL96 · 03/01/2024 14:44

What to mess up their car by sitting in it? Behave.

I do not owe them anything because they gave me a lift, that isn't how friendships work, im afraid. You dont give to recieve... If you knew they don't let people into their house, what right do you have to get angry over them delicing your use of their toilet? What right do you have to feel entitled to them allowing you to do so?

If you're that stuck on someone saying no because they have boundaries, go and find like minded people to be your friends.

Edited

How can they mess up your house by using the toilet, behave!

No you don't give to receive, sone people are just all take. We've all got "friends" like that, they end up walking a lot.

pontipinemum · 03/01/2024 15:01

It could be as some suggested hording/ dirty

In the house I grew up in through where my stepdad would have hit the roof if I brought anyone in, I got in huge trouble once when a friend phoned the landline. I only ever once had a friend stay over and that was when he was away for a few days. Our house was spotless (to his exact specifications 😐)

Could be she just didn't want to let you in, which I would find mean I can't imagine doing that now in my own house. I let the post woman use my loo!

alltoomuchrightnow · 03/01/2024 14:54

My friend actually got rejected by the council as 'beyond help' , also she refused to pay anything towards it... and sadly yes I do believe she's beyond help....she makes the tv hoarding programmes seem normal. I live at other end of country so only see her once a year when I stay nearby (and she's quite a new friend anyway) I asked her to ask around for volunteers as some people DO volunteer for this kind of thing.. no one should live like this...but she said she's too ashamed, and the neighbours would know.. (I'm sure they know anyway as can tell by the back garden which she stores food in!)
If it IS this with your friend, it may be an impossible path but let's hope not

AInightingale · 03/01/2024 14:51

If she is your friend, why don't you just ask her and say that you find her attitude surprising? She may need help. Councils run schemes - not just for tenants - where they help people fix things, declutter etc. She might be ashamed of her bathroom and need a plumber in. Taps might be broken etc. People get into a downward spiral with this stuff - end up living with broken lights, no heating etc for years, as they fear being judged if the house is a tip.

Swipe left for the next trending thread