Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

She won't let me in her house

438 replies

Xmasdread22 · 02/01/2024 22:15

I have a friend I met through work. We've been friends 5 years. She doesn't let any friends in her house. We've been on nights out and to meals together but she won't let anyone in her house. I dropped her home the other day and I was desperate for the toilet and she wouldn't let me in to use it. Has anyone else had this before?

OP posts:
IDontHateRainbows · 03/01/2024 18:31

My house is an absolute tip and I wouldn't be happy with someone seeing it without prior warning, but if someone needed the loo I'd preface it with 'please excuse the house it's in a bit of a state' or something.

I supposed the social shame of not letting a colleague or friend use the loo when in need would trump the shame of them seeing my v cluttered and messy house

Unlike the OPs friend, I would allow people in my house with prior warning although my default is to agree to meet people on neutral territory such as a cafe or park

myfaceismyown · 03/01/2024 18:25

Domme with a scantily clad "pet" cleaner licking her floors???

AllyArty · 03/01/2024 18:12

She’s either a clean freak and doesn’t want anyone else sitting on her toilet seat or shes a hoarder or the house is dirty and untidy.

Cas112 · 03/01/2024 18:09

Why should you be let in her house?

phoenixrosehere · 03/01/2024 18:05

GotBeatenUp · 03/01/2024 16:51

@Rampant Ivy , the name does reflect real life, but isn't particularly relevant to the thread.

The rummaging is weird because I noticed some people doing it, then when I had someone else round, I said please don't rummage in cupboards. Cue 'What's in there?' (Cupboard under stairs). 'Leave the door alone,please', then I almost got shoved out of the way and the visitor opened the door. A rather full cupboard with ironing board, vacuum cleaner etc in. and shelves that weren't IG worthy

Apparently, I'd more or less demanded that they looked in it.

People in my car, more than one has just rummaged through the glove compartment. Fuck me, there's tissues, lipsalve, spare specs, some sanitiser, window scraper and a cloth in there.

With comments about the house, only one has been rude, and she's an 'I tell it as it is' sort of person (downright rude). I suggested she leave if she thought my decor was that bad.

Some things I'd class as pushing boundaries but not crossing them. Some might be things I don't like, but might be normal (switching the telly on and sprawling in front of it, leaving keys or mug on an antique object not the cheap & cheerful coaster on the coffee table because they didn't want to damage the coaster, not flushing the loo etc) .

I get it.

I’ve had bad experiences with people coming into my home, rent money stolen, expensive laptop and desktop computer broken, unnecessary comments made (a few crumbs here and there when the place is overall tidy with a SEN child and a clumsy 6 yo, how long I’ve been in my own shower when everyone has had theirs and there are two other loos) and family ignoring my instructions when I’ve made them quite clear because they see it as “helping” when really it makes more work for me and all I rather them do is leave things where I’ve said and let me take care of them, and people ignoring when I say keep their shoes on when they’ve asked (why ask then?!).

The older I get the less patience I have and find it way easier to just meet people somewhere.

Reading some of the comments by other posters, it reminds me why I rather wait and take public transport than accept an offer of a ride.

Misspepperpotts · 03/01/2024 18:05

Her home her choice for her reasons. Though as a UC sufferer I understand just how utterly dreadful it feels to need the loo urgently.

RocketIceLollie · 03/01/2024 17:59

Odd behaviour. To be more than happy to accept a lift but yet a firm no back to using her loo with no explanation. Is she socially awkward, or was this quite a surprising blunt no?

CleverLilViper · 03/01/2024 17:49

It also sounds like the issue isn't that the friend didn't let her in to use the loo-or the OP would have titled the thread "She wouldn't let me use her loo!" The issue is that the friend won't let OP or any friends in to her house.

It's just on this particular occasion, OP "needed the toilet."

CleverLilViper · 03/01/2024 17:46

Goldenbear · 03/01/2024 17:09

It is just a loo, that's all we are discussing allowing someone to use a loo after they have dropped you home. It is miniscule, nothing, not a big deal. Some perspective is needed. Self help culture just promotes help yourself IMO, help yourself to other people's good will but do nothing for others in return. How about if the OP was in pain with needing the loo, seems really mean spirited to let someone unnecessarily sit in that discomfort at best, pain at worst, especially after happily accepting a lift, presumably to save your legs from walking or your money from public transport fare. I think if you are intent on living an isolated life ans in pursuing that you cannot offer anything to others in the process of preserving that isolation, you need to probably find your own way home.

There's nothing said of wanting to live an isolated life.

OP's friend clearly goes to work and socialises. So, she clearly doesn't want to be isolated. However, is she truly not allowed to have any boundaries at all just because someone offered her a lift? For all we know-the friend does other favours for OP in return or has helped massively at work with OP.

Regardless, OP is willingly allowing this friend into her car and giving her lifts. That is her choice. Equally, her friend is free to decide who can and can't enter her home and it is her choice. She doesn't need to stipulate a reason and whilst it may seem, on the surface, mean, it is her right to do so.

From what it sounds like, OP was well-aware that this boundary exists and shouldn't have had any hopes of it being dropped. If it's an issue for OP and she feels it's "rude/mean/whatever word you want to use" she can make the choice to not offer lifts in future. That is her right.

However, someone doesn't get to break someone else's defined boundary just because they did something nice for them. That's not how life works. There could be a multitude of reasons why this boundary exists, and OP can either ask directly about it and be prepared to be told to mind her business, be told the answer, etc, or she can mind her own business and decide how to proceed with the friendship going forward if this is such a big deal for her.

Would I leave someone in pain/discomfort needing the loo? No, of course not but I'm not OP's friend and don't have her specific boundaries.

thing47 · 03/01/2024 17:42

So to summarise, this is a 5-year friendship which has entailed nights out together, dinners out together and the friend is only too happy to accept a lift home. But OP isn't permitted to have a quick pee after said lift home? Bonkers. I have no interest in 'rummaging' in someone else's house, but when I need the loo, I need the loo.

If the friend doesn't understand that someone kindly giving them a lift home might need to use the toilet before making the return journey, then they should not accept the lift in the first place.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 03/01/2024 17:37

Fairyliz · 03/01/2024 16:31

But it isn’t a random person who has knocked on the door and asked to use the toilet, it’s a friend.
She’s happy enough to accept a lift from the op but won’t let her use the toilet.

By random I mean anyone who doesn't live there.

Goodlard · 03/01/2024 17:31

@Loveablockheel I wasn't replying to the OP, I was responding to a previous PP.

RampantIvy · 03/01/2024 17:29

It's a pretty high boundary to not let someone you have known and worked with for five years and who has given you a lift home to not allow them to use the loo though (and mean spirited).

Clearly there is something more going on.

Loveablockheel · 03/01/2024 17:17

Goodlard · 03/01/2024 14:40

Not even for someone who had given you a lift in their space, for you to mess up there car, nosey at there stuff to use the toilet?

But the difference is the OP is happy to invite someone into her car, the friend is not happy to invite someone into her home and the OP knows this, If the OP started a thread saying she doesn’t want to give lifts or car share despite passing the friends house on the way I bet the responses would be far more supportive, your car your rules I would imagine.

GotBeatenUp · 03/01/2024 17:16

@biscuitnut , it's not strange to some of us. The friend probably had her reasons.

biscuitnut · 03/01/2024 17:11

CleverLilViper · 03/01/2024 17:05

I do find it interesting how someone having and implementing firm boundaries over their own home has led to insinuations that this person has clear MH problems, is a definite hoarder/scruff, etc.

Those things are possible and I mentioned them in my post as possibilities, because sure, maybe. It's equally possible she just doesn't want people in her home under any circumstances. It is her home.

If OP dislikes the boundary that has been set-and would prefer to say that she doesn't want to do lifts for this person anymore-that is absolutely fine, but the woman can have a boundary without it being because she's some eccentric hoarder living under mountains of junk that is threatening to burst out of her home the second she opens the front door.

Maybe she's had people rummaging around in her home in the past and really didn't appreciate it (who would?) and fears it happening again? Maybe she's been stolen from in the past. Maybe something happened the last time that someone entered her home that means she can't... who knows?

Or maybe she just doesn't want to? Isn't MN all about the "No is a complete sentence" and having firm boundaries? Or are people not allowed that when it comes to posters wanting access to their homes?

Seriously the woman wanted a wee? I feel so sorry for someone that can go out with a person, accept a lift off her (close proximity) but can’t allow that same someone to use their toilet? Of course it’s strange.

ginasevern · 03/01/2024 17:10

I won't let anyone in my house unless it's for essential maintenance or (god forbid) a medical emergency. My adult son is a schizophrenic and whilst he is not violent, it can take days to settle him if a stranger came in - yes, even just to quickly use the loo. Part of his condition also makes him a hoarder and I am so ashamed of the place that I could not countenance anyone visiting, even briefly.

Unfortunately people have little comprehension of what it is like to live with a schizophrenic or a hoarder unless they have direct experience. It is all very well to say that you wouldn't judge or talk to other friends/colleagues about it but most people almost certainly would. I probably would if this wasn't my life.

Goldenbear · 03/01/2024 17:09

It is just a loo, that's all we are discussing allowing someone to use a loo after they have dropped you home. It is miniscule, nothing, not a big deal. Some perspective is needed. Self help culture just promotes help yourself IMO, help yourself to other people's good will but do nothing for others in return. How about if the OP was in pain with needing the loo, seems really mean spirited to let someone unnecessarily sit in that discomfort at best, pain at worst, especially after happily accepting a lift, presumably to save your legs from walking or your money from public transport fare. I think if you are intent on living an isolated life ans in pursuing that you cannot offer anything to others in the process of preserving that isolation, you need to probably find your own way home.

CleverLilViper · 03/01/2024 17:05

I do find it interesting how someone having and implementing firm boundaries over their own home has led to insinuations that this person has clear MH problems, is a definite hoarder/scruff, etc.

Those things are possible and I mentioned them in my post as possibilities, because sure, maybe. It's equally possible she just doesn't want people in her home under any circumstances. It is her home.

If OP dislikes the boundary that has been set-and would prefer to say that she doesn't want to do lifts for this person anymore-that is absolutely fine, but the woman can have a boundary without it being because she's some eccentric hoarder living under mountains of junk that is threatening to burst out of her home the second she opens the front door.

Maybe she's had people rummaging around in her home in the past and really didn't appreciate it (who would?) and fears it happening again? Maybe she's been stolen from in the past. Maybe something happened the last time that someone entered her home that means she can't... who knows?

Or maybe she just doesn't want to? Isn't MN all about the "No is a complete sentence" and having firm boundaries? Or are people not allowed that when it comes to posters wanting access to their homes?

GotBeatenUp · 03/01/2024 16:51

@Rampant Ivy , the name does reflect real life, but isn't particularly relevant to the thread.

The rummaging is weird because I noticed some people doing it, then when I had someone else round, I said please don't rummage in cupboards. Cue 'What's in there?' (Cupboard under stairs). 'Leave the door alone,please', then I almost got shoved out of the way and the visitor opened the door. A rather full cupboard with ironing board, vacuum cleaner etc in. and shelves that weren't IG worthy

Apparently, I'd more or less demanded that they looked in it.

People in my car, more than one has just rummaged through the glove compartment. Fuck me, there's tissues, lipsalve, spare specs, some sanitiser, window scraper and a cloth in there.

With comments about the house, only one has been rude, and she's an 'I tell it as it is' sort of person (downright rude). I suggested she leave if she thought my decor was that bad.

Some things I'd class as pushing boundaries but not crossing them. Some might be things I don't like, but might be normal (switching the telly on and sprawling in front of it, leaving keys or mug on an antique object not the cheap & cheerful coaster on the coffee table because they didn't want to damage the coaster, not flushing the loo etc) .

ToWhitToWhoo · 03/01/2024 16:47

I suppose I have a mild version of this, because I have NO problem with people entering my home, even unannounced, and would always offer them a tea/coffee, biscuits. and of course give them access to my loo(!), BUT it makes me very anxious if people expect me to whip up a meal at short notice, and especially if they come and watch me/ 'keep me company' in the kitchen. It's not their seeing my home that bothers me, but their observing my awkwardness and inefficiency at manual and 'hosting' skills - I have some co-ordination disabilities, and such situations make me feel as though I'm failing an exam. Maybe your friend has some more severe version of such performance anxiety.

However. I would feel annoyed at a friend not letting me use their LOO. 'When I've got to go, I've got to go!' Though I've come across a few posts on MN where people have appeared quite paranoid about visitors using their loo.

CleverLilViper · 03/01/2024 16:47

There could be tons of reasons, and I wonder, as PP's have suggested, she refused to let you "use her loo" because she suspected you would use it as an opportunity to snoop in a space she has clearly defined as "off-limits."

Is it odd? Yes, perhaps.

I'm heavily introverted, and I really don't like people in my space unless I'm given warning and I know them well enough. My home is my space, my sanctuary. I'd let someone use the toilet, of course, but perhaps not if I suspected it was a ruse to have a snoop.

She may have also feared that once she let you in, she'd have difficulty getting you back out. Would she be obligated to provide refreshments, that kind of thing? I know it's not likely a simple dash to the toilet would lead to that-but if you're an anxious person, trying to preserve your boundaries, those little leaps can be leapt to.

That's what I struggle with when people are in my space unless I know them well. I don't know what is expected of me as "host." She may be a hoarder, have OCD, be highly introverted and keen to preserve her space, she may have anxiety around people being in her home unexpectedly. She may simply have a partner who works shifts and is sleeping or who wouldn't appreciate unexpected visitors. Who knows?

She may well have just not cleaned the toilet that day and be ashamed of it, or have a lack of loo roll.

verdantverdure · 03/01/2024 16:36

MCOut · 02/01/2024 22:25

There could be lots of reasons. Hoarder, unpleasant partner, previous bad experiences with guests, ashamed of how it looks, she could live with someone who is unwell. I don’t think you need to overthink it to be honest, whatever the reason it’s not a reflection of you. Just respect her choice.

That's a good point.

A five year old boundary needs to be respected.

The reason doesn't matter really does it?

verdantverdure · 03/01/2024 16:33

Xmasdread22 · 02/01/2024 22:15

I have a friend I met through work. We've been friends 5 years. She doesn't let any friends in her house. We've been on nights out and to meals together but she won't let anyone in her house. I dropped her home the other day and I was desperate for the toilet and she wouldn't let me in to use it. Has anyone else had this before?

Does she live alone or is there a man in there who would be angry if she let someone in?

Goldenbear · 03/01/2024 16:32

Anything but not 'any think but'.