Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

She won't let me in her house

438 replies

Xmasdread22 · 02/01/2024 22:15

I have a friend I met through work. We've been friends 5 years. She doesn't let any friends in her house. We've been on nights out and to meals together but she won't let anyone in her house. I dropped her home the other day and I was desperate for the toilet and she wouldn't let me in to use it. Has anyone else had this before?

OP posts:
2pence · 06/01/2024 10:07

It's all conjecture because we don't know the OP or their work colleague.

As with all things, it's also likely far more nuanced than what's on the surface.

They're work colleagues. Is one more senior than the other? What is the office dynamic like? My house could be pristine and Country Living feature worthy but I'm not opening myself up to questions, criticisms and judgments in a toxic workplace. Work is a place where you need to keep boundaries and a professional structure to keep your job. You don't behave like you do with family or friends who are privy to your more controversial opinions and beliefs.

TattleTalesTattling · 06/01/2024 09:40

wannabetraveler · 05/01/2024 22:45

But not inaccurate. A casual skim through MN - it's full of people who won't open their doors, affirmatively choose not to have cordial relationships with neighbors and for whom extraversion is akin to a moral failing.

..it's still none of your concern, or the OP's.

You have no right passing judgement on people who are simply minding their own business.

FYI the dictionary definition of an introvert is "a shy, reticent person."

An example of that is "I'm an introvert and don't like public speaking"

It's not all about how you 'recharge' but also includes what you're comfortable with socially.

It's fucking rude to call reserved people misanthropic. Do you realise what sort of people you're lumping us in with? Antinatalists, for a start.

I don't hate people. I love my family and my small handful of friends.

StockpotSoup · 05/01/2024 23:15

Almost as if more introverted people were more comfortable communicating anonymously…

wannabetraveler · 05/01/2024 22:45

StockpotSoup · 05/01/2024 22:11

Lots of people on MN consider themselves introverts but I would describe them as anxious/paranoid misanthropes.

Would you? Because that would be needlessly bitchy.

But not inaccurate. A casual skim through MN - it's full of people who won't open their doors, affirmatively choose not to have cordial relationships with neighbors and for whom extraversion is akin to a moral failing.

StockpotSoup · 05/01/2024 22:11

Lots of people on MN consider themselves introverts but I would describe them as anxious/paranoid misanthropes.

Would you? Because that would be needlessly bitchy.

wannabetraveler · 05/01/2024 20:10

BlackFriYay · 05/01/2024 13:51

Uh, well of course introverts are socially withdrawn. That is the point. They don't like socialising very much and that is perfectly ok and is their perogative, so long as that's what makes them happy.

It might be hard for you to understand but some people are perfectly comfortable in their own company and being left to their own devices.

I find lots of socialising draining, truth be told, and would much rather lose myself in a good book or spend an afternoon doing something of my choosing at my own pace.

Some people don't like the idea of being alone and lonely, some people prefer it that way. I'm neurodiverse as are many other introverts.

I do what socialising I need to do to ensure my DC don't miss out, such as going to parties they're invited to or taking up the suggestions of play dates, but I do it out of love for them and never because I actually want to go.

Don't be so condescending about introverted people.

Introversion is nothing to do with levels of sociability; rather it's a term describing how you are energized - do you recharge alone, or are you buoyed up by being around people.

Lots of people (including me) and sociable introverts.

Lots of people on MN consider themselves introverts but I would describe them as anxious/paranoid misanthropes.

Big difference.

BlackFriYay · 05/01/2024 14:35

It hasn't got anything to do with anybody else though has it?

If somebody wants to spend time alone that is their right.

Similarly, people are allowed to not want to invite people into their house.

There's no need for all the brooding and faux offence. The OP knows that her friend doesn't have anybody in so shouldn't be so surprised that she wasn't invited in herself.

It's really entitled to get pissed off because you're not given access to somebody else's home, no pun intended.

RampantIvy · 05/01/2024 14:19

@BlackFriYay to be fair a lot of people are confused about what introversion really means. All true introverts I know dislike being with lots of people all of the time, but they do enjoy seeing people - just not too many and not too often. They just need more alone time than extroverts.

So, I agree with @Couchant

BlackFriYay · 05/01/2024 13:51

Couchant · 05/01/2024 10:54

And yet surprisingly common in Mn, where people who believe themselves to be ‘introverts’ but are in fact socially withdrawn, anxious or isolated, participate in disproportionately high numbers, and appear to undergo agonies at. The idea of an unexpected visit, however brief, a postman ringing the doorbell while trying to deliver a package, or a tradesman using the loo.

Uh, well of course introverts are socially withdrawn. That is the point. They don't like socialising very much and that is perfectly ok and is their perogative, so long as that's what makes them happy.

It might be hard for you to understand but some people are perfectly comfortable in their own company and being left to their own devices.

I find lots of socialising draining, truth be told, and would much rather lose myself in a good book or spend an afternoon doing something of my choosing at my own pace.

Some people don't like the idea of being alone and lonely, some people prefer it that way. I'm neurodiverse as are many other introverts.

I do what socialising I need to do to ensure my DC don't miss out, such as going to parties they're invited to or taking up the suggestions of play dates, but I do it out of love for them and never because I actually want to go.

Don't be so condescending about introverted people.

phoenixrosehere · 05/01/2024 12:14

SerenChocolateMuncher · 05/01/2024 10:55

If the lift was conditional on using the loo, she shouldn't have offered.

The friend has made it plain for the five years if their friendship that she will not allow OP into her home. It was reasonable for the friend to assume that the offer of a lift was not conditional on letting her use the loo and she did nothing wrong in accepting the offer.

It is an unusual for friends not to invite each other into their homes, I agree, but this woman clearly has very strong feelings about it and those feelings should be respected.

OP is very unreasonable to try and force her way into her friend's home by offering a lift with unagreed conditions (you let me me into your home, or I'll report you on Mumsnet).

I don't believe OP needed the loo. She knew in advance she could not use her friend's loo and could have (and probably did) gone before they left the venue. Instead, she deliberately caused her friend discomfort and distress in an attempt to satisfy her curiosity.

Agree.

As weird as it may be, OP KNEW this about their friend. If it was such a problem for OP, why remain friends for that long? There is give and take in a relationship but I doubt this friend was a taker due to the length of time OP has been friends with them and OP continuously offering lifts.

If OP was allowed in, they would quite likely tell others they had, whatever state it was in considering she had talked to others about this friend’s home boundary and could put this friend in an awkward position with other friends who would expect to be allowed in too.

Regardless of mental health issues, the home being a safe space/sanctuary/castle with drawbridge and portcullis with boiling pitch at the ready or the house being full of hoarded stuff, just denying someone the use of the loo when they are desperate is just plain mean spirited

I have allowed people to use my loo, but I do it out of politeness not because I want to due to the several guests/visitors who make me question what their own bathrooms are like due to the way they have left mine. I also highly doubt OP was as desperate as they claimed since again, they could have easily gone before they left knowing about this friend’s issue and they conveniently left out the distances they are driving nor mentioned if they have any medical issues where they can’t hold it or when they need to go, they need to go. If that were the case, then OP would likely not be offering this friend a lift to begin with even more so if this friend was completely out of the way from their journey home.

Lucky2shoes · 05/01/2024 10:56

I'm the same because I'm ashamed of my tatty rental

SerenChocolateMuncher · 05/01/2024 10:55

RampantIvy · 05/01/2024 10:31

I agree.

Regardless of mental health issues, the home being a safe space/sanctuary/castle with drawbridge and portcullis with boiling pitch at the ready or the house being full of hoarded stuff, just denying someone the use of the loo when they are desperate is just plain mean spirited.

I also think that most visitors do not want to snoop round people's houses, and it's worrying that so many people think this.

If the lift was conditional on using the loo, she shouldn't have offered.

The friend has made it plain for the five years if their friendship that she will not allow OP into her home. It was reasonable for the friend to assume that the offer of a lift was not conditional on letting her use the loo and she did nothing wrong in accepting the offer.

It is an unusual for friends not to invite each other into their homes, I agree, but this woman clearly has very strong feelings about it and those feelings should be respected.

OP is very unreasonable to try and force her way into her friend's home by offering a lift with unagreed conditions (you let me me into your home, or I'll report you on Mumsnet).

I don't believe OP needed the loo. She knew in advance she could not use her friend's loo and could have (and probably did) gone before they left the venue. Instead, she deliberately caused her friend discomfort and distress in an attempt to satisfy her curiosity.

Couchant · 05/01/2024 10:54

Macaroni46 · 05/01/2024 10:04

@Loveablockheel meanwhile in the real world, not letting someone use your toilet is just plain weird. Never come across it!

And yet surprisingly common in Mn, where people who believe themselves to be ‘introverts’ but are in fact socially withdrawn, anxious or isolated, participate in disproportionately high numbers, and appear to undergo agonies at. The idea of an unexpected visit, however brief, a postman ringing the doorbell while trying to deliver a package, or a tradesman using the loo.

RampantIvy · 05/01/2024 10:31

Macaroni46 · 05/01/2024 10:04

@Loveablockheel meanwhile in the real world, not letting someone use your toilet is just plain weird. Never come across it!

I agree.

Regardless of mental health issues, the home being a safe space/sanctuary/castle with drawbridge and portcullis with boiling pitch at the ready or the house being full of hoarded stuff, just denying someone the use of the loo when they are desperate is just plain mean spirited.

I also think that most visitors do not want to snoop round people's houses, and it's worrying that so many people think this.

Macaroni46 · 05/01/2024 10:04

@Loveablockheel meanwhile in the real world, not letting someone use your toilet is just plain weird. Never come across it!

Loveablockheel · 05/01/2024 09:41

Macaroni46 · 05/01/2024 08:58

No it's not. It's give and take. The 'friend' is taking without giving. Wouldn't work for me. Denying someone the loo? Nah. I'd be dialling back on that friendship.

If the lift was offered on the basis that the OP would need to enter her house and use her bathroom then I expect the friend would have made alternative travel arrangements. If the lift offer was transactional the OP should have made that clear to her friend at the outset. The OP knows full well her friend does not let anyone into her house so she shouldn’t be surprised at her refusal.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 05/01/2024 09:16

Macaroni46 · 05/01/2024 08:58

No it's not. It's give and take. The 'friend' is taking without giving. Wouldn't work for me. Denying someone the loo? Nah. I'd be dialling back on that friendship.

The friend can’t even bring themselves to let tradespeople in and lives instead with broken appliances.

The OP chose to give a lift knowing that.

Couchant · 05/01/2024 09:07

Macaroni46 · 05/01/2024 08:58

No it's not. It's give and take. The 'friend' is taking without giving. Wouldn't work for me. Denying someone the loo? Nah. I'd be dialling back on that friendship.

If she won’t even let in a tradesman to fix broken appliances, then I imagine the OP wasn’t surprised, as it’s clearly rather more a MH/hoarding issue than ‘my loo isn’t pristine’ or ‘I didn’t tidy up’.

Macaroni46 · 05/01/2024 08:58

Loveablockheel · 04/01/2024 21:29

Fair enough. But then OP's 'friend' shouldn't accept a lift. After all, that's getting inside someone else's private space, albeit their car.

But the OP is happy to open up her car, her private space, the friend is not happy to invite someone into her home so it’s completely different.

No it's not. It's give and take. The 'friend' is taking without giving. Wouldn't work for me. Denying someone the loo? Nah. I'd be dialling back on that friendship.

Loveablockheel · 04/01/2024 21:29

Fair enough. But then OP's 'friend' shouldn't accept a lift. After all, that's getting inside someone else's private space, albeit their car.

But the OP is happy to open up her car, her private space, the friend is not happy to invite someone into her home so it’s completely different.

Macaroni46 · 04/01/2024 19:00

bemusedmoose · 04/01/2024 09:21

As someone with ADHD who struggles to keep on top of things and a long term illness which meant I got really behind and could never catch up... I did this. I was utterly ashamed of not being able to have a nice place and never let anyone in. Mental health could be an issue as having depression really makes you not able to keep things up, both diagnosed and undiagnosed ADHD people struggle with keep a tidy house, hoarding is also a mental health issue. She may also just see it as her safe place and keep the world locked out, autistic people or people that have been through serious trauma tend to want to keep their house as an only them space to feel safe.

No one has to let you in and the idea we have to is frankly weird and rather intrusive. But then I'm neuro divergent and value my space as my own so don't really get the whole having to have people over because I have to and people dropping in is the absolute worst. In my old house the landlord wouldn't fix the leaks so running water meant running a tap for a few minutes and filling buckets to have next to the loo to flush, turning the mains back off then mopping up all the leaks. Someone desperate for a wee would have been my nightmare because I wouldn't want them to be busting but also couldn't have them see the house or not working loo!

It's not rude - she has struggles and is fully aware of them. Don't push her boundaries.

Fair enough. But then OP's 'friend' shouldn't accept a lift. After all, that's getting inside someone else's private space, albeit their car.

Aspiringhermit · 04/01/2024 14:46

As the OP last posted two days ago, I doubt there will be any more updates from her.
Some people like to welcome people into their home and others do not.
The OP states that she has known the person for 5 years, but gives no other details of why she is concerned for the individual ie lack of personal hygiene or reluctant to talk about who she might live with. I'm in the camp of let the poor woman be and if it means no longer being willing to give her a lift then so be it.

blackpanth · 04/01/2024 14:46

Hoarder

RampantIvy · 04/01/2024 14:37

I still don't get why so many posters are worried about people snooping around. There seems to be a lot of paranoia on this thread, with a couple of genuine exceptions.

EmmaGrundyForPM · 04/01/2024 13:36

This is now in the Daily Fail today so it's obviously a slow news day there