Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this isn't sexual assault...

724 replies

harerunner · 02/01/2024 17:21

I saw a story on the BBC about Jenni Hermoso testifying in a sexual assault case about her kiss with Luis Rubiales. Not having seen the kiss, I decided to look at a video of it, a link of which I've put below.

Firstly, i need to say I think sexual assault is extremely serious, and it's appalling how low the conviction rate is for sexual crimes. Men get away with far too much, and it's sickening.

However, in all honesty, i wouldn't class the kiss here as sexual assault. This is a lengthy full body embrace followed by a very brief peck of a kiss.

If something like this is classed as sexual assault, then it surely makes it impossible to initiate anything physical at all without explicit verbal consent.

Surely there's much more to this... i reckon she hated the guy before this incident and this was a way to get him back for other shitty and belittling treatment from him over the years.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
23
MargotBamborough · 03/01/2024 14:45

Surely there's much more to this... i reckon she hated the guy before this incident and this was a way to get him back for other shitty and belittling treatment from him over the years.

If she hated the guy, why would she consent to him kissing her like that?

JustanotherMNSlapperTwat · 03/01/2024 14:43

TrixieFatell · 03/01/2024 14:31

The lengths some posters are going to, to try and prove a point that a man forcibly kissing a woman isn't sexual assault. Did she want the kiss, she says not. Did he force her to kiss him by grabbing her head. Yes. What that has to do with a consensual sexual relationship is completely grabbing at straws.

It's almost like some posters have an agenda to make sure men can do what the fuck they want to women...

TrixieFatell · 03/01/2024 14:31

The lengths some posters are going to, to try and prove a point that a man forcibly kissing a woman isn't sexual assault. Did she want the kiss, she says not. Did he force her to kiss him by grabbing her head. Yes. What that has to do with a consensual sexual relationship is completely grabbing at straws.

JustanotherMNSlapperTwat · 03/01/2024 14:17

Pickledonionout · 03/01/2024 13:46

@JustanotherMNSlapperTwat because most in the real world wouldn’t consider that sexual assault.

sexual harassment? Sure
assault? No

The Spanish law has changed so that sexual harassment comes under the term sexual assault now

So therefore under Spanish law it is correct to call sexual harassment sexual assault

CalishataFolkart · 03/01/2024 14:08

Pickledonionout · 03/01/2024 13:46

@JustanotherMNSlapperTwat because most in the real world wouldn’t consider that sexual assault.

sexual harassment? Sure
assault? No

What matters here is what the Spanish law considers it.

Pickledonionout · 03/01/2024 13:46

@JustanotherMNSlapperTwat because most in the real world wouldn’t consider that sexual assault.

sexual harassment? Sure
assault? No

JustanotherMNSlapperTwat · 03/01/2024 13:43

Pickledonionout · 03/01/2024 13:41

@JustanotherMNSlapperTwat if he had been hugging me beforehand and then kissed me I’d be annoyed, go to HR and he’d likely be fired

arrested and charged with assault? No

Why not? Because you wouldn't choose to go to the police, or because you think the police wouldn't arrest him?

IncompleteSenten · 03/01/2024 13:42

JustanotherMNSlapperTwat · 03/01/2024 13:40

And if your CEO celebrates some good news for the company and decided to do so by grabbing your head and forcing you to kiss him that's okay then?

Woo-hoo we got that ten billion pound contract, let's celebrate. Come here. Mwaaah.

There's no way that doesn't end with a call to acas.

Pickledonionout · 03/01/2024 13:41

@JustanotherMNSlapperTwat if he had been hugging me beforehand and then kissed me I’d be annoyed, go to HR and he’d likely be fired

arrested and charged with assault? No

IncompleteSenten · 03/01/2024 13:40

harerunner · 03/01/2024 13:02

Just to follow up, asking "permission" (or more often "shall I get a condom") has always occurred before actual sex, but rarely, if ever in the intervening build up.

I think consent is a complex and nuanced - yet vitally important - subject. Some posters are determined to frame it as a simple and easy, but in reality it isn't nearly as super straightforward as they presume... We're not doing women any favours by pretending it is - much as I wish it was!

I don't think it really matters what is and is not considered consent in a personal romantic encounter when this incident was neither.

This man was unprofessional, his actions were inappropriate and his grabbing of her and kissing her was assault. The fact he kissed her instead of punching her made it a sexual rather than physical assault.

Those facts do not change because of how a couple on a date might behave or communicate consent.

JustanotherMNSlapperTwat · 03/01/2024 13:40

Pickledonionout · 03/01/2024 13:34

@CalishataFolkart he was still celebrating the new, for his country.

And if your CEO celebrates some good news for the company and decided to do so by grabbing your head and forcing you to kiss him that's okay then?

Pickledonionout · 03/01/2024 13:34

@CalishataFolkart he was still celebrating the new, for his country.

CalishataFolkart · 03/01/2024 13:32

Pickledonionout · 03/01/2024 13:30

YANBU I can see where you’re coming from

I’ve seen many male football celebrations where players kiss each other or their manager does, usually on the head but still.

this man is a sexist oaf, but I’m not sure whether the label of sexual assault is accurate in terms of the context

He’s not another player or her manager.

Pickledonionout · 03/01/2024 13:30

YANBU I can see where you’re coming from

I’ve seen many male football celebrations where players kiss each other or their manager does, usually on the head but still.

this man is a sexist oaf, but I’m not sure whether the label of sexual assault is accurate in terms of the context

pickledandpuzzled · 03/01/2024 13:25

@harerunner you’re not doing women any favours pretending it’s this hard, either.

CurlewKate · 03/01/2024 13:22

@harerunner- these people do not know each other. They aren't in a social situation. The man is in a position of power. He takes a woman by the head and kisses her on the mouth in public. Surely you can see that is completely unlike any sort of shall we/ shan't we potentially sexual encounter?

CalishataFolkart · 03/01/2024 13:18

harerunner · 03/01/2024 12:56

@CalishataFolkart

Assume you and a new partner are kissing. Every time they put their hand somewhere new on your body they say something like, “Do you like that?” “Does that feel good?” “Is this ok? ”That’s all. If that level of communication isn’t “practical” then those people should not be having sex because the chances of a misunderstanding are too high.

Firstly, asking the question after you've touched is surely too late when it comes to consent. Based on what you're saying if Rubiales said "was that ok?" after the kiss that would have been ok?!?

Secondly, yes, verbal communication is clearly important when it comes to sexual activity, but no, asking "is that ok?" or "does that feel good?" after each and every new move - quite apart from it arguably being too late in terms of consent - isn't really much better than constantly asking "can I do this? Can I touch there?".... and also is something that I've never experienced in all the dozens of "encounters" i've had over the years.

Being honest, do all you sexual encounters involve such a continuous running commentary after each change? I very much doubt it!

Can we agree that grabbing an employee’s head and kissing them is not the same as a sexual encounter with an intimate partner?

People are comparing the two and coming to the disingenuous conclusion that because he didn’t explicitly ask for consent means that them not explicitly asking for consent = they have committed sexual assault.

You’re right, there is nuance. So it is ok to touch a partner somewhere new, find out if they like it and move your hand if they don’t. Because they have already consented to being touched by you in general. What you are discovering is the nuance of how far that consent goes.

What you call a “running commentary” other people might call dirty talk 🤷🏻 Each to their own.

harerunner · 03/01/2024 13:02

Just to follow up, asking "permission" (or more often "shall I get a condom") has always occurred before actual sex, but rarely, if ever in the intervening build up.

I think consent is a complex and nuanced - yet vitally important - subject. Some posters are determined to frame it as a simple and easy, but in reality it isn't nearly as super straightforward as they presume... We're not doing women any favours by pretending it is - much as I wish it was!

OP posts:
harerunner · 03/01/2024 12:56

@CalishataFolkart

Assume you and a new partner are kissing. Every time they put their hand somewhere new on your body they say something like, “Do you like that?” “Does that feel good?” “Is this ok? ”That’s all. If that level of communication isn’t “practical” then those people should not be having sex because the chances of a misunderstanding are too high.

Firstly, asking the question after you've touched is surely too late when it comes to consent. Based on what you're saying if Rubiales said "was that ok?" after the kiss that would have been ok?!?

Secondly, yes, verbal communication is clearly important when it comes to sexual activity, but no, asking "is that ok?" or "does that feel good?" after each and every new move - quite apart from it arguably being too late in terms of consent - isn't really much better than constantly asking "can I do this? Can I touch there?".... and also is something that I've never experienced in all the dozens of "encounters" i've had over the years.

Being honest, do all you sexual encounters involve such a continuous running commentary after each change? I very much doubt it!

OP posts:
whatsitcalledwhen · 03/01/2024 12:54

Oh @artifan you have been so let down. What you experienced was a clear cut, unequivocal sexual assault.

A stranger followed you, groped you and penetrated you. That is absolutely sexual assault.

I cannot imagine what a therapist or survivors charity were doing telling you otherwise but they were wrong. Just like your dad.

I'm so sorry Flowers

NeighbourhoodWatchPotholeDivision · 03/01/2024 12:47

I'm sorry for how your father and therapist treated you.

They were wrong.

What happened to you is classified as Assault by Penetration, and it is clearly described as an offence in the Sexual Offences Act 2003

Sexual Offences Act 2003

An Act to make new provision about sexual offences, their prevention and the protection of children from harm from other sexual acts, and for connected purposes.

https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2003/42/part/1/crossheading/assault

CalishataFolkart · 03/01/2024 12:36

harerunner · 03/01/2024 08:02

This idea that every "escalation" in physical touch requires explicit verbal consent just isn't the practical or realistic. If not doing so counts as sexual assault then 99% of the entire population, men and women, are sexual abusers!

The principles of consent require some common sense and an appreciation of how normal physical interactions occur... It's not helped by dogmatic posts insisting that explicit verbal consent is required for every physical interaction for it not be considered sexual assault!

That said, in this case, I think it's the fact he was holding her head before he kissed her that means he clearly crossed a line. If it was a peck(which is all it was) in an otherwise close physical and consensual embrace, then I don't that could be deemed sexual assault.

Why do people have the idea that “explicit verbal consent” means “Can I do xyz?”

Assume you and a new partner are kissing. Every time they put their hand somewhere new on your body they say something like, “Do you like that?” “Does that feel good?” “Is this ok?”

That’s all. If that level of communication isn’t “practical” then those people should not be having sex because the chances of a misunderstanding are too high.

Lottapianos · 03/01/2024 12:36

@artifan , your post is extremely sad and disturbing. I'm so sorry that your father responded like that and minimised everything you had to say. I can imagine how very confusing and shaming that felt for you. What you experienced was sexual assault and it was not in any way your fault. You have nothing to blame yourself for

DuncinToffee · 03/01/2024 12:36

I think its difficult to judge as we weren't there

I watched it live as did millions of people world wide, we even had a thread on it here on MN.

JustanotherMNSlapperTwat · 03/01/2024 12:29

artifan · 03/01/2024 11:58

I think its difficult to judge as we weren't there. It does sound like she went through something unpleasant and at the least she is owed an apology.

Having said that, it can be quite easy to conflate something innocuously meant into something horrible. I'm a bit ashamed of this but when I was 15, I went through one of these unpleasant kind of grey area incidents, basically stranger followed me, groped me and tried to put his fingers inside me. stupidly I froze up, I felt embarassed to tell anyone, it was in a public place, my parents were around but not next to me, we were in a crowd and they weren't aware and I felt ashamed of them knowing, so I said nothing. I think I would have been blamed by them, my father was quite shouty about things. I just disppeared into my own head somewhere out of my body. I used to do this a lot if I was shouted at at home or my parents were fighting or something.

Some time after this there was a discussion in my family. I had been going through a tough time, teenage angst, self harm, getting into fights, tearful a lot, unable to concentrate at school, eating too much. My father and I had a discussion about the risk of rape and being careful at parties, drinks being spiked etc, and I blurted out about what happened a year before. I had decided I had been "sexually assaulted" and that I knew what it was like to have "abuse trauma" (my father had done some work as a church minister with sexual abuse survivors, I think I just wanted his approval somehow). So I mentioned what happened and quite rightly, my father pointed out that I was NOT sexually assaulted and that most girls get touched like that, its part of life. He was offended that I was appropriating the terms sexual assault. he did get quite angry with me and told me I was toxic making sexual assault all about me, just trying to ruin his evening with my disclosure. I would like to say that I realised the error of my ways and that I was being offensive, but the idea that I had experienced some sort of abuse never left me. there had been some inappropriate tickling and touching over my clothes from a relative when I was small, nothing damaging, and an incident with some boys at primary school, and again I think I believed I had been violated. The idea that maybe this is common for girls and I was making a fuss did cross my mind, but I didn't feel any real guilt over how my labelling these experiences could affect real victims.

In my late 20s I went to a sexual assault survivors counsellor, (my psychiatrist had suggested it was seeing her for what was later diagnosed as a personality disorder, but she was concerned I had been through some sort of trauma, as personality disorders can be linked to that and she referred me to an incest and rape survivors organisation. it took them 15 minutes of an interview for them to tell me firmly that no I had not been sexually assaulted, and didn't need their services.

I feel dead ashamed of myself now for casting myself as a victim, in my defence I was young and I never reported these incidents to anyone, but I can see how easy it can be for our minds to cast some low level incidents into something more sinister. I think there is more to this story about the spanish footballers though, we only know what the media tells us. If the accuser was genuinely violated, then it is not for us to cast aspersions.

Sending Flowers to all those who have had genuine serious assaults, for what its worth I don't think even unwanted kisses should happen but I agree with @Westernesse that there is definitely a spectrum and I think sometimes its best to move on and not give the lower level stuff headspace. After reading the Sarah Evered case I would report indecent exposure though, as that can lead to bigger things.

I am so sorry you have been let down by both your father and a therapist and led to believe that you were in any way to blame either for what happened or for calling it what it is - sexual assault

It is never okay for someone to follow you, grope you or try to take that further. This should never be a part of life and you are quite within your rights to call it what it is and to make as much fuss as you like.