Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is not a 4 year old's fault? (Shoe size)

83 replies

ShoePalaver · 02/01/2024 16:54

Went to the shoe shop a few weeks ago with my husband and children aged 2 and 4. They each had their feet measured, had grown by half a size since last time, selected a pair of shoes each from ones brought to us by the assistant, the fit was checked by the shop assistant, we paid for the shoes and went on our way.

Now my older child is saying her shoes are too small, I've checked the receipt and the shoes and they are 7.5 instead of 8.5 that we were told in the shop, so a whole size smaller. That is pretty annoying as what's the point of having the shop check the fit - it's a farce clearly, although obviously mistakes can be made. We probably should have checked the size ourselves although assumed the fact they the assistant said they fitted meant they were the right size! Won't bother having shoes fitted again that's for sure.

Anyway coming to my aibu now. I told my husband about this saying I would return to shop and complain, and the first thing he did was go and tell off my 4 year for not saying that the shoes were too small when we were in the shop. I intervened saying it's hardly her fault, it could be our fault or the shop's but not a 4 year old's. He responded saying well she's got to learn somehow and stomped off to the shed and is now in a mood with me for interfering in his parenting. Wondering if I am going mad now.

Yabu - 4 year old child should say if shoes don't fit even though shop lady says they are fine

Yanbu - shop and parents take responsibility for checking correct size of shoes for 4 year-old child

OP posts:
Zippedydoodahday · 02/01/2024 17:49

Is he normally this unpleasant to you and the children?

It's one thing to have a gentle word and say you know it's tricky but please do say in future if she notices they feel tight (whilst acknowledging it is the adults' ultimate responsibility) vs telling her off.

FictionalCharacter · 02/01/2024 17:43

Marblessolveeverything · 02/01/2024 17:04

So he wants the four year old to act above their age while he acts like a sulking toddler?

🎯
She’s 4. 4! A four year old can’t be expected to be responsible for anything.

Him stomping off to the shed is laughable. Any chance you could lock him in there for the night?

Lougle · 02/01/2024 17:42

There is only 1cm difference between sizes, so I can see why she didn't notice. Clarks has changed their policy over the years. When I was a child, it used to be that if you grew within 3 months, they'd replace them. I got free shoes for about 2 years under that scheme because I kept having growth spurts.

Then in COVID, they did a 6 month guarantee thing, but revoked it when stores were forced to close.

Now I don't think they do any guarantee.

Escaperoom · 02/01/2024 17:38

The Clarks shop locally to my DD closed. So now we just get the DGC to stand on piece of paper, draw carefully around feet. Measure length and width of foot.

Go online and look up sizes of various brands of children's shoes. Go to shop and try on said shoes in size indicated. Feel around the toe area yourself etc to check fit. Get child to walk up and down in shoes to check they don't slip up and down at the heel. Job done. You can also buy a children's shoe size guide similar to those used in Clarks from Amazon if you prefer.

(Yes OP your DH is an idiot).

Nov902 · 02/01/2024 17:37

Are you sure the shoes she tried on in the shop were even the same shoes? As in was there a mix up somewhere cos a whole size wrong is a really bad error! Definitely go back to the shop.
Your husband is being unreasonable she’s 4. I have a 4 year old and they don’t give you clear answers to sometimes basic questions! Absolutely not her fault.

DoorLockedAgain · 02/01/2024 17:37

Cmonluv · 02/01/2024 17:33

What?

Utter effing nonsense.

Your child couldn't tell they were tight in 2 mins in a shop, having been encouraged a made a big deal of but parents and shop assistant and eager to please.

Then when they became uncomfortable she DID tell you, and your husband shouted at you both for telling and not telling when he would have liked her to.

A 4 yr old child, a person who has been on the earth 4 years abd is definitely still learning and probably also figuring out when something does or doesn't fit her body, and what it even means for something to fit.

Your husband's an arsehole. I'd go through someone if they did that to my child.

She is clearly talking about the shop assistant not the child.

ShoePalaver · 02/01/2024 17:36

Cmonluv · 02/01/2024 17:33

What?

Utter effing nonsense.

Your child couldn't tell they were tight in 2 mins in a shop, having been encouraged a made a big deal of but parents and shop assistant and eager to please.

Then when they became uncomfortable she DID tell you, and your husband shouted at you both for telling and not telling when he would have liked her to.

A 4 yr old child, a person who has been on the earth 4 years abd is definitely still learning and probably also figuring out when something does or doesn't fit her body, and what it even means for something to fit.

Your husband's an arsehole. I'd go through someone if they did that to my child.

Er what? The point of having shoes fitted by a trained shop assistant is surely to avoid relying on a child to know ? Not sure what your point is

OP posts:
Cmonluv · 02/01/2024 17:34

ShoePalaver · 02/01/2024 17:06

This is what I thought to be honest. Not the first such incident. I think there must be something wrong with him as he always blames the children. A couple of weeks ago the 2 year old ran into the road when out with him (he doesn't take them out on his own that often) and he came back annoyed with me for not teaching the 2 year old road safety. I mean I do try to teach her but I think you just have to constantly watch them near roads and can't rely on a 2 year old 100% however well trained...

If he can't keep a 2 yr old safe near a road and thinks it's the child's fault straight up leave him. What's the point fo him exactly if he thinks a 2 yr old should just supervise themselves

Cmonluv · 02/01/2024 17:33

ShoePalaver · 02/01/2024 17:09

Well what's the point if they can't tell if a shoe is a whole size too small?

What?

Utter effing nonsense.

Your child couldn't tell they were tight in 2 mins in a shop, having been encouraged a made a big deal of but parents and shop assistant and eager to please.

Then when they became uncomfortable she DID tell you, and your husband shouted at you both for telling and not telling when he would have liked her to.

A 4 yr old child, a person who has been on the earth 4 years abd is definitely still learning and probably also figuring out when something does or doesn't fit her body, and what it even means for something to fit.

Your husband's an arsehole. I'd go through someone if they did that to my child.

ManateeFair · 02/01/2024 17:31

I don't have kids but I did work in a shoe shop for three years in my teens and a) it's pretty bad that they messed up so badly with the fit and b) of course a four-year-old isn't responsible for checking any of this. Because she's, you know, four. Children as young as that usually think that if they can physically cram their foot into a shoe, that means it 'fits' - especially if an adult is telling them it's fine. It was rotten of your husband to blame a four-year-old for this; she's too little.

MaryHinges · 02/01/2024 17:28

Oh and now he's a twat too lol 🤣

Coolhwip · 02/01/2024 17:27

ShoePalaver · 02/01/2024 17:06

This is what I thought to be honest. Not the first such incident. I think there must be something wrong with him as he always blames the children. A couple of weeks ago the 2 year old ran into the road when out with him (he doesn't take them out on his own that often) and he came back annoyed with me for not teaching the 2 year old road safety. I mean I do try to teach her but I think you just have to constantly watch them near roads and can't rely on a 2 year old 100% however well trained...

What a twat he is. Does he have any good points?

MaryHinges · 02/01/2024 17:25

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Thementalloadisreal · 02/01/2024 17:22

Children are very susceptible to being agreeable, just saying yes even if something’s not ok, to please adults.

The shop made the mistake, just take them back!

AuntySueDoesntGiveAShit · 02/01/2024 17:19

When you next buy kids shoes , draw around their feet on a piece of paper and take it with you, measure it up against the shoe.

AuntySueDoesntGiveAShit · 02/01/2024 17:17

Did you buy the actual shoes that she tried on or did they go and get a different pair from the back? Whatever they did, it's not the child's fault, the fitter should have been able to tell they were too small.

And your husband needs a very urgent lesson on how to keep his kids safe.

Mischance · 02/01/2024 17:17

The essence of good parenting is to make quite sure that you know what a child is capable of doing/understanding at different ages. So much grief is caused to both children and parents by these basic misunderstandings. Parents who have unreasonable expectations of their children are bad parents. Parents like this are miserable and angry because they are always frustrated.

You need to have a word in your OH's ear....

Parentofeanda · 02/01/2024 17:14

he obviously just has no idea what is a normal thing for certain age groups, even my 5 year old wouldn't know if a shoe is a good fit.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 02/01/2024 17:12

Your husband sounds awful amd unreasonable tbh. Either that or he's too dim to realise what a 4 year-old is and isn't capable of.

ShoePalaver · 02/01/2024 17:09

dinglyping · 02/01/2024 17:04

"Won't bother having shoes fitted again that's for sure."

This makes about as much sense as your husband. You're both over-reacting.

Well what's the point if they can't tell if a shoe is a whole size too small?

OP posts:
PumpkinPie2016 · 02/01/2024 17:08

He's being ridiculous! She's 4 - shoes can feel OK in a shop for a minute or two but then feel very different after.

She may also not recognise a part that is a bit tight/rubbing in a shop.

Just take them back and hopefully they will exchange - they did for my son at Clarks about 18 months ago- got the shoes home and they just didn't fit him right.

ShoePalaver · 02/01/2024 17:06

Ihaterhymingrabbit · 02/01/2024 16:56

Your husband is a dickhead. He’s taking the inconvenience out on a tiny child.

This is what I thought to be honest. Not the first such incident. I think there must be something wrong with him as he always blames the children. A couple of weeks ago the 2 year old ran into the road when out with him (he doesn't take them out on his own that often) and he came back annoyed with me for not teaching the 2 year old road safety. I mean I do try to teach her but I think you just have to constantly watch them near roads and can't rely on a 2 year old 100% however well trained...

OP posts:
dinglyping · 02/01/2024 17:04

"Won't bother having shoes fitted again that's for sure."

This makes about as much sense as your husband. You're both over-reacting.

Marblessolveeverything · 02/01/2024 17:04

So he wants the four year old to act above their age while he acts like a sulking toddler?

BeadedBubbles · 02/01/2024 17:03

As an adult shoes that feel okay in a shop often are uncomfortable once I start wearing them properly. So if I make that mistake from time to time not sure how a 4 year old is meant to know.

And if the fit was checked by an assistant that's terrible and down to them.