Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is not a 4 year old's fault? (Shoe size)

83 replies

ShoePalaver · 02/01/2024 16:54

Went to the shoe shop a few weeks ago with my husband and children aged 2 and 4. They each had their feet measured, had grown by half a size since last time, selected a pair of shoes each from ones brought to us by the assistant, the fit was checked by the shop assistant, we paid for the shoes and went on our way.

Now my older child is saying her shoes are too small, I've checked the receipt and the shoes and they are 7.5 instead of 8.5 that we were told in the shop, so a whole size smaller. That is pretty annoying as what's the point of having the shop check the fit - it's a farce clearly, although obviously mistakes can be made. We probably should have checked the size ourselves although assumed the fact they the assistant said they fitted meant they were the right size! Won't bother having shoes fitted again that's for sure.

Anyway coming to my aibu now. I told my husband about this saying I would return to shop and complain, and the first thing he did was go and tell off my 4 year for not saying that the shoes were too small when we were in the shop. I intervened saying it's hardly her fault, it could be our fault or the shop's but not a 4 year old's. He responded saying well she's got to learn somehow and stomped off to the shed and is now in a mood with me for interfering in his parenting. Wondering if I am going mad now.

Yabu - 4 year old child should say if shoes don't fit even though shop lady says they are fine

Yanbu - shop and parents take responsibility for checking correct size of shoes for 4 year-old child

OP posts:
Cmonluv · 02/01/2024 20:40

ShoePalaver · 02/01/2024 19:59

I know and I try never to leave them with him. On this occasion he was walking his mum to the bus stop so thought they'd be ok as she is fairly sensible. The whole situation is a mess. We just had an argument yesterday about him shouting at the 2 year old over minor things (talking too loudly in the car, not using knife and fork). Now this. Aargh.

No way would I stay with someone who treated my kids like this

fairymary87 · 02/01/2024 20:04

Erm the kid probably tried the right ones in the shop and the cashed out the wrong size! It happens! Your husband is thick

Chichimcgee · 02/01/2024 20:01

2 year old gets shouted at for not using a knife and fork and not knowing road safety.

genuinely, why are you with him?

ShoePalaver · 02/01/2024 19:59

Mischance · 02/01/2024 19:12

Frankly I would be more worried about the road incident. If he really is that incapable of grasping what a 2 year old can and can't do/understand then he it is not safe to leave the children in his care.

I know and I try never to leave them with him. On this occasion he was walking his mum to the bus stop so thought they'd be ok as she is fairly sensible. The whole situation is a mess. We just had an argument yesterday about him shouting at the 2 year old over minor things (talking too loudly in the car, not using knife and fork). Now this. Aargh.

OP posts:
IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads · 02/01/2024 19:59

Did they measure on one manufacturers gauge, but sell you another manufacturers shoes? There always used to be a discrepancy between Clark's and Start Rite, and some of the European brands.,

If it was Clark's, did they give you a slip of paper rug the measured size on?

Gowlett · 02/01/2024 19:37

My DH sometimes says that DS “has to learn” or “do as he’s told” etc… When he clearly doesn’t understand how toddlers work.

MrsSkylerWhite · 02/01/2024 19:22

Your husband is an idiot. Petulant, too.

MCOut · 02/01/2024 19:20

How can a four-year-old be expected to take responsibility for this? How can a two-year-old be taught road safety? Next thing you know he’ll be expecting them to raise themselves. Idiot man.

Chichimcgee · 02/01/2024 19:16

He can’t be trusted to parent his toddler and lashes out at a 4 year old for something that don’t her fault. You need to have a word because he doesn’t have a clue

RedRobyn2021 · 02/01/2024 19:15

Your husband is being a total dick

Mischance · 02/01/2024 19:12

Frankly I would be more worried about the road incident. If he really is that incapable of grasping what a 2 year old can and can't do/understand then he it is not safe to leave the children in his care.

Hankunamatata · 02/01/2024 19:08

Weird since they were fitted. Shop assistant always showed me how many fingers gap were on the toe, often asking dc to flex toe up. Tbh I gave up during lockdown. We now own a foot measurer and I fit them myself as found m&s school shoes last longer than clarks.

I would take them back if you have receipt and show they clearly don't fit your dc.

AvengedQuince · 02/01/2024 18:58

7.5 would be an unusually small size for a four year old. Could that work in your favor, that the size seems wrong for a child that age?

The fitter did a very bad job if the child measured 8.5 and they didn't notice that a shoe was a full size too small.

ShoePalaver · 02/01/2024 18:43

Nov902 · 02/01/2024 17:37

Are you sure the shoes she tried on in the shop were even the same shoes? As in was there a mix up somewhere cos a whole size wrong is a really bad error! Definitely go back to the shop.
Your husband is being unreasonable she’s 4. I have a 4 year old and they don’t give you clear answers to sometimes basic questions! Absolutely not her fault.

Yes, they kept them on until we got home.

OP posts:
NoTouch · 02/01/2024 18:31

Clarks were never great at fitting when ds(19) was young and I always double checked how much toe, heel, width room there was in the shoe and questioned if it didn't feel right.

At point of sale they usually check the size on the box, size of both shoes, and check with you verbally before initialling the inside of the box to prove they checked/asked. Did they do this?

Several weeks later if she has been wearing them outdoors it is going to be your word against theirs if the shoes, box (if you still have it) and receipt are aligned. I wouldn't try for a refund, but would take more responsibility to ensure you check they are the right shoes for her in the future while in the shop and then check again as soon as you are home before wearing out.

Ds is older now but Independent shops used to be much better, and better quality longer lasting shoes - start right, geox etc. The staff rarely used/didn't depend on measure guides as they had different brands/styles which all fitted differently, but would happily explain to you and show you how they were fitting/checking them.

AvengedQuince · 02/01/2024 18:25

I always measured feet myself and checked the charts. I had a fussy child so I couldn't rely on them being fitted. I needed to size up on anything that wasn't foot shaped as he couldn't tolerate his toes being squashed by a narrow toe box.

Onceuponaheartache · 02/01/2024 18:14

Firstly if it wad Clarks they are notoriously shite around my area for not measuring or fitting correctly.

Secondly is your husband always such an abusive arsehole??

HamstersAreMyLife · 02/01/2024 18:14

4yo can't tell this, it's unusual they didn't sense check the size with you at the till, I've had an issue before where the box from the back ended up being the wrong size but it was picked up at the till when they double check what's in the box

GrandHighPoohbah · 02/01/2024 18:12

Tell him my 14 year old still can't tell if a shoe is a good fit 😂. Your DH is being ridiculous, of course a four year old can't judge shoe sizes.

Snowwhite83 · 02/01/2024 18:10

Your husband sounds like a horrid man. Why is everything yours and the children's fault. Why can't he teach your two year old about road safety? She is 2! Is he not responsible for her safety while she is so young? What a prize knob! Stop entertaining his delusions.

Zippedydoodahday · 02/01/2024 18:03

I've given up on physical shoe shops. I use Happy Little Soles instead. You can buy a special measurer from them for a few pounds, and they give amazing advice on which shoes might suit your child over the phone. Free returns too. Much less stressful for me and my kid as I order a few different sizes and styles based on their advice, we can try them out in the comfort of our home and then just send back what we don't want.

Cmonluv · 02/01/2024 18:03

ShoePalaver · 02/01/2024 17:36

Er what? The point of having shoes fitted by a trained shop assistant is surely to avoid relying on a child to know ? Not sure what your point is

I'm an arse! I totally misunderstood and thought you meant why bother getting them measured if a child can't tell. Sorry

lastchristmas80 · 02/01/2024 17:58

ShoePalaver · 02/01/2024 16:54

Went to the shoe shop a few weeks ago with my husband and children aged 2 and 4. They each had their feet measured, had grown by half a size since last time, selected a pair of shoes each from ones brought to us by the assistant, the fit was checked by the shop assistant, we paid for the shoes and went on our way.

Now my older child is saying her shoes are too small, I've checked the receipt and the shoes and they are 7.5 instead of 8.5 that we were told in the shop, so a whole size smaller. That is pretty annoying as what's the point of having the shop check the fit - it's a farce clearly, although obviously mistakes can be made. We probably should have checked the size ourselves although assumed the fact they the assistant said they fitted meant they were the right size! Won't bother having shoes fitted again that's for sure.

Anyway coming to my aibu now. I told my husband about this saying I would return to shop and complain, and the first thing he did was go and tell off my 4 year for not saying that the shoes were too small when we were in the shop. I intervened saying it's hardly her fault, it could be our fault or the shop's but not a 4 year old's. He responded saying well she's got to learn somehow and stomped off to the shed and is now in a mood with me for interfering in his parenting. Wondering if I am going mad now.

Yabu - 4 year old child should say if shoes don't fit even though shop lady says they are fine

Yanbu - shop and parents take responsibility for checking correct size of shoes for 4 year-old child

I always order Startrite. You can download a paper fitting guide (you draw around foot to get an accurate fitting). Once you’ve done it the first time, you just order half size up each time? I get so fed up of going into store and the style/size I need being out of stock. I’d take them back and see if they will do anything for you. Probably not, but at least make your voice heard!

CecilyP · 02/01/2024 17:56

It’s pretty bad that neither of you noticed for a few weeks. Don’t they make you take the box these days. It would have had the size on it. If it is wrong Clark’s may do an exchange.

You cannot blame a child for an adult’s negligence whether it is shoes or road safety.

BiffandChip1 · 02/01/2024 17:50

Delassalle · 02/01/2024 17:02

The little girl is surrounded by adults in a shop and her mind will be on dollies not on whether the ankle bit rubs or she's worried about her instep being too high! 🙄 I imagine her thoughts were in getting back home to play with her dollies.

I am guessing the assistant measured correctly but brought out the incorrect box size which wasn't checked at the point of sale.

Your husband is just plain nasty to tell the child off.

Buy the kid some steel toe caps and if daddy is vile to her again she can boot him up the jacksy which he thoroughly deserves.

Is he always so nasty to your children?

Yes because she's a girl, her mind must be on her dollies 🤯🤦🏼‍♀️

YANBU but not sure they will refund etc think it's on you to have checked