Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Don't ever phone! Text instead or make an appointment!

131 replies

ValerieVomit · 02/01/2024 16:14

Happy new year Mumsnetters.

I've read a thread over the holidays and some of the posts talked about not phoning people because it's intrusive, you should text or message some other way but don't phone them, you don't know what they are doing, what you are interrupting etc. One poster said that you should make appointments for a phone call.

Fair enough things might have changed with social media and mobile phones over the last 20+ years.

Do you think it's rude to call someone if they are not expecting it? I called someone this morning, they were in the middle of taking down the christmas tree but we had a chat. Somebody else called me but I was shopping. I called them back when I had finished.

And the big question is .....

What makes it rude now if it wasn't rude before 1993 or so? Would you have just called someone then?!!!!

OP posts:
NaughtybutNice77 · 03/01/2024 01:57

I don't think it's rude to ring someone during sensible hours but if I had something to talk about that might take a while I'd text and ask 'can I give you a call later today about A?' If it was just a catch up it would depend on the person. I've a couple of friends who I could easily chat with for an hour but were quite comfortable saying "give me half hour (or whatever) and I'll call you back.
Obs I'd ensure the time of call was reasonable too. Friend A will take a call at 10pm as would l.My mum would think someone had died.
I think the real problem isn't that you've called at an inconvenient time, it's that the callee doesn't tell them then grumbles later. Why is it so hard to say lm in Tesco, or putting the children to bed?

Lotrehin · 03/01/2024 01:44

There was a fad a few years ago where everyone said they had anxiety about phone calls. Maybe some people still have a hangover of that.

Fionaville · 03/01/2024 01:39

I don't think it's rude, but I do think 'why didn't you just message?' It's the having to drop everything and listen that gets me. It does feel intrusive, like whatever I'm doing should take a back seat because they want to talk. If it can be written in a message, then don't call. I've never liked talking on the phone though, some people love it.
I make an exception for my parents or anybody over the age of 60. Everyone else should know the score by now.

NotAClueZ · 03/01/2024 01:31

What makes it rude now if it wasn't rude before 1993 or so? Would you have just called someone then?!!!!

I think its actually generational - so younger people expect a pre-call text but older people more relaxed.

But to answer your question, previously calling someone was a lottery - whether they were in or not by their landline. Many people didn't have answer phones - you just had to call and take the chance if they were in. There wasn't really a method by which you could pre-plan a call - unless you were doing it for business or meeting people face to face and agreeing. If the phone rang, it was a "rare" thing and people wanted to answer it.

Now because of mobiles people are availalbe 24/7. If you call a number you know the person is with the phone and will most liekly be in a position to answer it. The mystery of are they in or not has gone. They are always in because they are always with their phone. This means it will often be inconvenient to call in theory. plus its v. easy to text to pre-plan.

Personally I think its all bullshit and often just call because its quicker than all this texting to and fro and I figure if the person doesn't want to answer , they can just not answer.

UsingChangeofName · 03/01/2024 00:48

I think some people just can't see that it's the polite thing to do.

I'll fix that for you "the polite thing to do in my opinion."

As Chintzy says - if I need to have a longer chat about something, then I would ask "have you got 5mins?" or "is now a good time?" .
If someone called me and it wasn't a good time, then I simply wouldn't pick up. They could leave a message and either try again or I could call them back.

In my opinion there is nothing rude about making a phone call - either at work, or socially.

ChintzyGunslinger · 03/01/2024 00:12

I think some people just can't see that it's the polite thing to do.

The polite thing to do is ask, are you free to chat now? etc. It's not hard.

Evanna13 · 02/01/2024 23:52

It's ridiculous to say that there is so much loneliness in the world because people prefer some notice before a phone call or visit.
I think some people just can't see that it's the polite thing to do.
It's so much more beneficial to pick a time for a chat or a meeting that suits both parties.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 02/01/2024 23:52

I don’t like people calling me out of the blue. And if they do I think it’s an emergency so I tend to answer, but then it’s annoying (although obviously a relief) when it’s not and you’re stuck on the phone.

I don’t really like talking on the phone at all though. I find it very tying in a way that real life conversation is not, and I much prefer a WhatsApp or text.

SheerLucks · 02/01/2024 23:46

I must say I hesitate to just call someone now - even my sister I texted the other day to ask if she was up for a phone chat later.

How times have changed - I remember in the early 90s I was in the living room with my flat mate, and a guy who was keen on me called the landline. I didn't want to pick up but me and my mate sat there frozen while the phone rang, thinking it must seem so rude to him that we were probably there but just not answering!

I wouldn't give it a second thought now - in fact I sometimes don't even answer the doorbell now if I'm not expecting someone!

ChintzyGunslinger · 02/01/2024 23:45

What makes it rude now if it wasn't rude before 1993 or so? Would you have just called someone then?!!!!

Back in the day, we had answerphones, machines that you left a message on to say you'd called and why, or call me back. People could screen their calls and choose to pick up and talk or not. People just called people! It was quite common to spend an hour chatting on the phone.

Now, people despite having similar options on their mobiles are too precious to ever consider speaking on the phone. I am surprised they don't disintegrate when they hit the air outside their front doors.

Wooloohooloo · 02/01/2024 23:45

I do however

Mumof2teens79 · 02/01/2024 23:42

If you're busy just don't answer
Drives me mad at work...instant messages "are you free for a quick call"...and if you don't respond either way they message again, then email!
Firstly you can see my calendar if you choose, and the IM shows if I am in a meeting but secondly sending me an IM on my screen is far more disruptive to my current task and interrupts my thought processes than a simple ring tone

WhatFlavourIsIt · 02/01/2024 23:40

Ohh my friends must hate me. I always call without an appointment. If I'm driving, it's a great opportunity to call someone for a catch-up (hands free, obviously). If I'm near someone's house I call & ask if they fancy a short notice visit. They don't hate me because we're friends and like to talk & see each other and if it's not convenient we just use our words & say so.

Wooloohooloo · 02/01/2024 23:36

Depends what people are like. I don't like social phone calls- my friends aren't callers and I couldn't be in a relationship with a man who was a caller. Some people like them but I do not.

SummerSazz · 02/01/2024 23:19

I phone friends randomly all the time as they do me. Usually on a dog walk or when driving. If they can't answer or I can't answer we just press the auto reply of 'I'll call you later' or 'i can't talk right now'.

I also just call people at work (as they do me) - in professional services and like people dropping round. I'm actually an introvert but like human connection and prefer to chat than have a long WhatsApp/text conversation

Evanna13 · 02/01/2024 23:17

biscuitnut · 02/01/2024 22:47

All I can say is I really hope the obviously very busy and self important people who find others rude for ringing them and having the temerity to kick on their door don’t find themselves lonely or have to reach out for help one day. You might find nobody gives a shit. If you were relatives or friends of mine I wouldn’t make the effort. And we wonder why teens are suffering from mental health issues??? No wonder if this is what they are being taught. It makes for sad reading. You want to hope that you don’t pass this attitude onto your kids, it would be ironic if you find yourself having to make an appointment with them one day. Perhaps they will ignore your call because their time is precious.

I don't think people are self important because they would like a text before a call/ visit. I think it's respectful to do this and better to set up a time which suits both parties so that you can give your full attention to the chat. Surely this benefits everyone.

I think the self important one is someone who calls or visits unexpectedly and expects the other person to give up whatever they are doing to chat to them there and then.

Dancerprancer19 · 02/01/2024 23:11

biscuitnut · 02/01/2024 22:47

All I can say is I really hope the obviously very busy and self important people who find others rude for ringing them and having the temerity to kick on their door don’t find themselves lonely or have to reach out for help one day. You might find nobody gives a shit. If you were relatives or friends of mine I wouldn’t make the effort. And we wonder why teens are suffering from mental health issues??? No wonder if this is what they are being taught. It makes for sad reading. You want to hope that you don’t pass this attitude onto your kids, it would be ironic if you find yourself having to make an appointment with them one day. Perhaps they will ignore your call because their time is precious.

I think that's the thing, I wouldn't expect to turn up to my kids' houses without checking or to have a chat without texting to agree a time. So those things wouldn't upset or offend me.

Dancerprancer19 · 02/01/2024 23:09

I don't like receiving unexpected calls or unexpected visitors to the house. Maybe it's a generational thing. Perhaps as well it relates to the 'always on' nature of modern life, so the need for 'boundaries' is more of a thing than in the past when you wouldn't take work home and your clients wouldn't be able to contact you on Christmas Day.

Evanna13 · 02/01/2024 23:09

I would usually text but if I wanted/needed to speak to someone I would usually message a few hours prior to a call to make sure it suits them and tell them what I need to chat about or if it is just a catch up etc...

If its my hubby or someone I speak to all the time I would call without checking. However I know his routine so generally would know when is a good or bad time to call him.

If someone called me unexpectedly I would think it was bad news.
I hate unexpected phone calls especially if its something that could be sent in a message.

I don't like talking on the phone, I would much prefer to meet up in person or even on video call where I can see the person and their expressions etc...

I would never turn up to someone's house unannounced. I think that is so rude and disrespectful.

The noise of the phone and the doorbell spike my anxiety...

OldTinHat · 02/01/2024 23:05

^^ obviously lighthearted!

OldTinHat · 02/01/2024 23:03

My friends will text and ask if it's okay to call. My family just phone.

I prefer my friends asking (as I do them), so you can make sure you're able to pay full attention to the call and not having to be distracted by needing a wee/are halfway through emptying the bin/just put on a coat of nail varnish/midway through cleaning out your critters enclosure/eating cold Chinese takeaway/trying to find a clean pair of knickers and then panic putting the washing machine on/hiding from an unknown ringing the doorbell/avoiding crows.

My family just phone. I either ignore if I'm involved in any of the above or answer and then cut a call short if any of the above suddenly becomes more pressing!

biscuitnut · 02/01/2024 22:47

All I can say is I really hope the obviously very busy and self important people who find others rude for ringing them and having the temerity to kick on their door don’t find themselves lonely or have to reach out for help one day. You might find nobody gives a shit. If you were relatives or friends of mine I wouldn’t make the effort. And we wonder why teens are suffering from mental health issues??? No wonder if this is what they are being taught. It makes for sad reading. You want to hope that you don’t pass this attitude onto your kids, it would be ironic if you find yourself having to make an appointment with them one day. Perhaps they will ignore your call because their time is precious.

MereDintofPandiculation · 02/01/2024 22:40

also don’t understand the “in my day there were no phones..” line. My dad used that excuse when he used to just ‘drop in’ and disturb me all the time. Phones exist now so use them. What is the relevance of not having one 50 years ago? The relevance is that "manners" that you learn as you are growing up you internalise as part of the way the world works. Manners you learn in your 40s or 50s are learned experience, they don't feel "right" in the way things do that you learned very young, rather in the same way that you learn that in this country that you are visiting you behave in a certain way that doesn't feel natural because they have different cultural norms of politeness.

So while I accept that someone of your generation thinks I should phone first, and so I do that, as a way of being polite to you, I don't have the internal feeling of it being rude not to, and I certainly don't take offence when someone turns up at my door without phoning first.

I accept that you do things differently, and I try to fit in with that, without calling you rude. You perceive that I do things differently and call me rude, and I find that quite offensive.

Eastie77Returns · 02/01/2024 22:24

I become quite anxious if my mobile rings. I’m aware that sounds a bit bonkers but most of my friends and family only WhatsApp so I would only expect a call if there was something seriously wrong, eg someone has died.

Calling on people unannounced is the height of rudeness imo. I do not answer the door to unexpected ‘guests’ and have no qualms about leaving them outsider. There is no excuse for just turning up on someone’s doorstep without warning.

I also don’t understand the “in my day there were no phones..” line. My dad used that excuse when he used to just ‘drop in’ and disturb me all the time. Phones exist now so use them. What is the relevance of not having one 50 years ago?

Anahenzaris · 02/01/2024 22:20

I’m all seriousness - why don’t you put your phone on dnd when Bub is sleeping? Isn’t that easier than trying to schedule everything (including Bub)?