Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect my ASD daughter to love me?

190 replies

CryingCaroline · 02/01/2024 13:27

I’ve just had a heartbreaking conversation with my ASD daughter ( 12 years old ) where she said that she doesn’t feel she loves me, or anyone.

I feel terrible because I burst into tears and she just looked at me and said “ This is why I don’t tell you the truth and just say I love you back when you say it “

It feels physically painful for me to think my young daughter doesn’t love me and possibly never did - she certainly acted like she did when she was younger but as puberty hit she has become far colder and less emotional.

OP posts:
StrawberryJellyBelly · 06/01/2024 01:35

@CryingCaroline I hope you manage to get some sleep tonight and that the new day brings some peace for you and your DD.

CryingCaroline · 05/01/2024 20:22

Really struggling tonight
Ill reply tomorrow

OP posts:
greensleevez · 05/01/2024 16:57

OP, you can't 'expect' love, regardless of how much you do for your kids.

My relationship with my eldest daughter can be like this, but it's just how it is with teen/tweenagers. Give and take doesn't come into it where feelings are concerned. We are here for them and they are entitled to our unconditional love, no matter what. They don't have to 'earn' it.

All that said I understand how you feel and I often feel similar. I read about children saying how much they love their parents and it would be lovely to hear that from my children, but I love them regardless of how they feel.

Somebody shared this here once and it has comforted me when parenting my girls has felt tough.

"A really important but horrible developmental phase in teens is pushing you away.

They have to do it. It’s the start of independence and being separate to you. But so many of them are horrible about it because they simply don’t understand what’s happening.

You know when children are little and we get touched out? I think that’s the best comparison, where they fight and resist any warmth and closeness. Perversely it doesn’t mean they don’t need it.

Also, any hint they are children is likely to be met with rage because they are trying to go forwards and not back.

Everything you say will be wrong because in order to establish who she is, she has to establish who she isn’t. And she isn’t you - she’s smarter and more intelligent and knows more and you - well, you are so stupid and you know nothing and you’re creepy.

Take heart. She won’t have meant it in the sense that you think. She means all the above and she doesn’t know it herself."

CryingCaroline · 05/01/2024 16:49

I

OP posts:
CryingCaroline · 05/01/2024 10:38

Thank you

OP posts:
WhatNoRaisins · 05/01/2024 08:59

OP I'd argue that as well as a feeling love is doing right by a person. It sounds like she is testing you and that you need to have some boundaries. It won't do her any good in the long run if you keep giving into her behaviour and cancelling your plans to try and prove that you love her.

Taking the concept of love out of conversations sounds like a good idea. I'd say something simple like "I have made a commitment to go and see friend, it has nothing to do with my love for you" for example.

StrawberryJellyBelly · 05/01/2024 08:43

Caroline could you possibly say to your daughter
‘ I love you but I will no longer allow you to blackmail me emotionally and for the time being we’re taking the concept of love out of any conversation we have’.

She really does have you dancing to her tune and what’s going on goes way beyond us being our children’s guide through life.

CryingCaroline · 05/01/2024 08:06

Haveyouanyjam
Thanks for taking the time to write this long reply.
I agree with all you say as she currently does expect me to put everyone of her needs above mine, her dads and her sisters.
I almost do feel quite blackmailed at times as she will question that I love her if I make her do x,y,z

Today it is school refusal due to feeling lightheaded and how can I possibly expect her to go ( even though this is day 4 of a new term ) feeling like this when I say I love and care about her

It’s all exasperating trying to do the best by her all the time whilst balancing life

OP posts:
Haveyouanyjam · 05/01/2024 07:46

Honestly, you are clearly a good mum who loves her daughter. And to me is seems obvious that she does love you, rather than just not feeling connected to you, it’s just that her understanding and expression of love is different than hers.

I would agree that you need to have clear and consistent boundaries and that your DD needs to learn that is part of a loving and trusting relationship whether you feel some sort of deep emotional love or not. You are not there to meet all of her needs for her like she’s a baby, you’re there to meet some of her needs and support her to meet her own. She may need more support with this socially and emotionally than other children might.

Your daughter needs to learn that both love and parenting are not simply putting the child’s needs ahead of your own, that you are a whole person in your own right with needs and that in order to be a good parent and provide her with the care she needs, you also need to prioritise your own sometimes.

It is definitely being complicated by the fact she is becoming a teenager too. Your relationship will likely heal as she grows and you need to understand that you aren’t going to please her all the time and that’s okay. It sounds like your time is more important to her than your words or affection, and I agree that trying to find a shared interest would be good, but you can’t spend your life dropping things for her, as she can’t go through life expecting love to look like that as it isn’t healthy.

QwestSprout · 04/01/2024 22:51

Well there are things that frustrate me about her now and things looking back, but they aren't why I never felt love for her as a small child. My parents - one deceased - just happened to be people I was related to (unfortunately). I had a grandparent I would say I loved - or felt very fondly about at least - but I wouldn't say the same for any of the other blood relatives I used to have.
I think perhaps autistic people are more likely to question the narrative of 'loving one's family' because really there is no reason to, they are strangers one happens to live with or whatever.

CryingCaroline · 04/01/2024 19:08

Qwestsprout

Can I ask if there was anything she could have done to change this or do you genuinely just feel you don’t love her as you’re too different?
I ask because I can be different to family members and still love them but perhaps this is that bit harder with ASD?

OP posts:
QwestSprout · 04/01/2024 18:54

I'm autistic. I was about 5 when I told my mum I didn't love her, as I didn't and I still don't. Comments along the lines of 'of course she (the daughter) does she just doesn't know it' are a little naïve.

I am well aware of what love actually does feel like (at least romantic love) as I am very happily married. I just have no particular warm feelings towards my mother, we're too different.

CryingCaroline · 04/01/2024 18:42

Strawberryjelly
Honestly it really helps to have another insight so nothing taken as a criticism at all honestly. It’s really helpful for me to be able to get clear responses from people who don’t know me or DD so aren’t coming from my angle or hers in particular but just saying how it’s all coming across.

Jellycats4life

I actually hadn’t linked together her having to say she loves me as a demand avoidance type thing but of course it is as I’m asking her to say it back and if she’s not sure of the feeling anyway then it is just another demand
She’s so compliant in some ways, well at school and with extended family members but not with me or DH.
In fact, any question such as can I have your cup to put in the dishwater will get a horrible reply to, usually something about her having to do so much etc etc etc

Hillrunning

Gosh now you’ve said it like that I feel a little foolish!
She absolutely does think it’s a choice to have children and doesn’t understand why people do this so that does make even more sense to why she wouldn’t think it necessary to show appreciation for things that I would imagine her to.
Even if I compare in a way such as “ Auntie X works full time in London so her children don’t see her until 7pm “ when she is moaning that she wants entertaining as I’m quickly sending a work email at 3.30pm, she will reply “ Her choice to have them and if she wants to be a bad parent that’s on her “

OP posts:
itsmyp4rty · 04/01/2024 18:35

Mine tells me that I never need to tell him that I love him because I've told him once so he knows now and I never need to say it again!

I would say your dd has ideas of the meanings of a lot of things that may be really quite incorrect. Love for example - what does she think love means? It might be worth asking her. On the one hand mine would say he doesn't love me - but on the other hand he's said that if I died he'd kill himself (obviously I now feel obliged to live to well over 100). The same with being a parent. She probably has very rigid black and white ideas and if you're not inside those parameters then you're not fitting her idea of a good/loving parent. She probably sees your whole point of being as being a parent - just like young children can't imagine their teachers have a life outside teaching, they exist only to be teachers.

I think it might be worth discussing some of her ideas and see if you can get her thinking about some things that might not have occurred to her. I would talk to her a lot about emotions, relationships and parenting - you might be quite shocked by some of her ideas and some of the things she is completely oblivious to, things you would take for granted as being obvious.

Circularargument · 04/01/2024 18:01

CryingCaroline · 02/01/2024 13:46

Is this common with ASD?
I hate to sound so ignorant as my adult child has ADHD / ASD combined but she’s never had an issue with showing love or affection so it’s never been an issue before

I'd say it's common. If they're more or less happy with you that's enough. I can count on the fingers of 1 hand expressions of affection from DS2 (32). I'm used to it.

Hillrunning · 04/01/2024 17:29

I've scanned most of the responses and it doesn't yet look like anyone has made the connection between her comments to you about not having to be grateful because you are the parent and her view of not understanding why anyone would have children.

I absolutely felt the same as a teen (I'm autistic). I will try to explain my logic. There is no going back with children (mostly, voluntary relinquishment beingvery rare here) and so if you make the enormous decision to creat a whole other human, it is absolutely your duty to take care of them in every way they need. Given that it was the parents and not the child's choice to be alive, and they knew there was no 'giving them back' why would the parent the then be insisting of gratitude? Honesty, in my teens, it felt so manipulative when my parents wanted gratitude from me. In my view, they were simply carrying out the duty related to a decision that was entirely theirs. Then chose to have me, they could then chose to be good parents or bad parents but what did that have to do with me?

Now that I'm nearing 40, I still feel the same way about the ridiculousness of choosing to have children but do better understand why parents would be comforted by getting some acknowledgement of thier support as the child grows.

She is still young, she will still be working out a lot of her views of the world.

StrawberryJellyBelly · 04/01/2024 16:43

it pays your bills.

that should be ‘our bills’

Jellycats4life · 04/01/2024 16:32

I can definitely see a lot of demand avoidance in your daughter @CryingCaroline. You may have helped her get out of Spanish, but now there is a “demand” to spend that lesson in the library, hence the outburst. Even going back to your OP - having to say that she loves you is a demand.

StrawberryJellyBelly · 04/01/2024 16:29

Crying, nothing I said is a criticism of you and I’m sorry if it seems that way. And I certainly don’t think you’re trying to make things easier for yourself. My posts are just an alternative way to look at things in the hope that you may get some comfort from them as well as a different way to look at things.

Quite honestly I would say - yes today my work is a priority. Because it is. It pays your bills. What would happen if you did say it?

and I think it’s really important I make it very clear that my son requires 2-1 round the clock care and the example you’ve given of your DD isn’t something that would ever occur with my boy and that my replies have only ever concerned the ‘love’ aspect of things that you’ve mentioned.

I hope this makes it clear that I’m not judging you at all. You’re obviously a very loving mum.

CryingCaroline · 04/01/2024 16:22

Lushfloral
PDA has never been mentioned but she definitely does find it hard when asked to do anything she doesn’t want to do - her reactions are far more extreme than I expect and usually she will refuse anything she is not 100% comfortable with.

I told her she no longer has to do Spanish and that she can go to the library instead as I’ve arranged everything with her headmistress and that then led her to screaming at me for embarrassing her and that she is not going to the library - or school at all ever again.
This is after she knew I was having the meeting and said she didn’t care what she had to do instead of Spanish as long as it wasn’t Spanish!
It’s very hard but thank you for noticing the kindness I try and always give as I really do try to always be a good person

OP posts:
LushFloral · 04/01/2024 16:10

OP I can relate. Your replies are so kind, I hope you can be as kind to yourself as you would be to another poster, you have had a very tough time of it.

The anxiety in your DD that manifests in all of the criticism she gives, brings to mind PDA. I wonder if that might be something that it helps to look into? I find that even though it’s hard being screamed at and hit if I can understand a bit why it’s happening then that helps a bit. I really wish you well with this.

CryingCaroline · 04/01/2024 14:57

honesty (typo)

OP posts:
CryingCaroline · 04/01/2024 14:56

Strawberryjellybelly

I think the issue is that she never really appears to be happy.
Its not like she’s got this massive social circle and is having a great time at school and it’s just me she’s not interested in - that would be perfectly understandable at this age and much like my adult DD who went off to university without a look back and I didn’t crumble or anything as I could tell she’s content.

With younger DD I don’t think she knows what she likes until she doesn’t like it if that makes sense so she relies on me to provide entertainment, we try it, she usually dislikes it for varying reasons and then she holds me responsible for making her unhappy.

At times I haven’t tried to entertain her such as if I’m WFH over a weekend I’m then met with her saying things like “ Clearly work is my priority “ so I ask her what she would like to do as I can finish the work later and then she will retort “ if you haven’t thought of anything as the parent that’s your fault “

It’s honestly not me wishing things were easier for me in all this - it’s knowing how hard she finds everything and then not feeling she can see how hard I’m trying that’s causing me to feel down BUT you’re all right in saying that it is not her job to validate me and I am grateful for the honestly and will take it on board.

OP posts:
StrawberryJellyBelly · 04/01/2024 14:34

Life is hard enough for our children without us adding to their difficulties by asking them to take care of our needs when they can hardly take care of their own

sorry, just to make it clear I’m still referring to the ‘love’ aspect of things.

StrawberryJellyBelly · 04/01/2024 14:31

Op, I’m reading all of the replies and for me it can all be condensed into one sentence.

Life is hard enough for our children without us adding to their difficulties by asking them to take care of our needs when they can hardly take care of their own.

For me I’m just happy if we can get my son through a day that he’s enjoyed.

And what people say about mourning the child you thought you’d have - 32 years on I still can’t relate to that on a personal level. I do fleetingly wish things were different for my son but I can’t mourn a person that has never existed.