Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask that fireworks are no longer available except for organised gatherings

163 replies

HurryUpSpringDays · 02/01/2024 11:36

After another NY being woken by neighbours' fireworks, AIBU?
They are dangerous (every year someone is injured on Nov 5) and very anti social.

If they aren't banned for personal use, they could be made noiseless only.

I know people will think I'm a party pooper and come along with 'It's only one night of the year' (it's not actually as some neighbours let them off on birthdays and other personal anniversaries.)

People just don't seem to appreciate that not everyone is up at midnight, some people are ill and don't want to be woken up, (in my own family there is someone on treatment for Stage 4 cancer, others with Covid) some people have pets and babies who're disturbed, etc.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
CatamaranViper · 03/01/2024 10:55

enchantedsquirrelwood · 03/01/2024 08:54

I see no reason for dogs to be upset by a human activity that doesn't need to happen.

Not just dogs, cats don't like them either. And I suspect the impact on wildlife is significant, too.

People WANT fireworks, they don't NEED them. Well I want doesn't get. People need to consider whether their wants have a disproportionately bad impact on the people around them. It's quite easy to be considerate. Occasionally you can't help it, eg if you need your trees cutting down, there will be noise from the tools. But you don't have to be deliberately annoying (see also being noisy or eating smelly foods on trains).

Dogs are upset by human activities all the time!

Being forced the breed then having their pups removed from them. Sure it doesn't have the same 'quaking and pissing everywhere' result that a firework can have, but it can cause them to feel upset.

Some dogs can be upset when put in a crate while owners go out/go to bed. People train their dogs to be okay with it but the first few times often upset them.

I'm sure there are many more examples where we upset dogs to fit them into our lives, why single out fireworks?.

BlackLambAndGreyFalcon · 03/01/2024 10:44

I agree they should be banned for personal use. I'm not bothered by the noise, but my DD was hit in the face by a firework a few years ago. Very fortunately she did not require medical treatment, but it could have been a different story. I only attend organised fireworks displays now.

Goodlard · 03/01/2024 10:42

Youcannotbeseriousreally · 02/01/2024 11:44

I honestly don’t understand how people are happy to literally burn money.

75 seconds of fireworks was £85 at Costco! mad that people will buy them tbh.

According to one MN on another post, their neighbours were letting fireworks off continuously for 2 hours!

She couldn't understand that I wouldn't believe that, but based on this it would've cost £8160 .....

Just didn't ring true to me 🤷‍♀️

Alcyoneus · 03/01/2024 10:42

The people moaning about fireworks are largely the same people who hide behind the same sofa anytime someone knocks on the door and start a thread on MN asking if they are unreasonable to not open a door. Get help.

Goodlard · 03/01/2024 10:39

I tell you if banning them was based on people complaining on MN, then they'd be banned.

But as the moaning on MN is going to make no difference, I'd stop wasting your energy!

Willyoujustbequiet · 03/01/2024 10:34

I love fireworks.

I'd support an organised display only if that's what people want but I never hear them. Not a sausage on NYE or Bonfire night this year. It wouldn't bother my dog anyway.

Theunamedcat · 03/01/2024 10:23

I think the huge ones can be banned for personal use the people across the road set them off I found them in my front garden the following morning they also landed on my and my neighbours car I live on a main road (so wide) have a bay for parking (makes the road wider) PLUS I have a decent size front garden footpath etc he set them off at the end of his garden so they travelled a fair distance embedded themselves in my front lawn that could have hit someone and injured them

TrashedSofa · 03/01/2024 10:12

LenaLamont · 03/01/2024 09:35

Where are these “organised events”?

The city council used to put on yearly displays that attracted 75,000 people. Because of government budget cuts to local authorities these have been cancelled.

That means more private bonfires and fireworks as the safe, professional and organised one isn’t available.

It's a good point. If people don't have access to a public event where they can watch a firework exhibition on a date where fireworks are common, some of them are going to run their own. The most efficient way to reduce the amount of fireworks outside organised events might well be to campaign for more publicly funded official displays. Calls for bans aren't doing anything.

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 03/01/2024 10:09

The last organised display in our town (population 14k and growing fast) was
about 3 years ago. Sports clubs who used to do them say they can longer afford the insurance and other event costs.

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 03/01/2024 10:08

SpecialCharacters · 02/01/2024 22:37

As someone who has twice been attacked by youths with fireworks, definitely up for them to be sold to licensed displays only.

I suspect the kind of people who attacked you will easily find a way to get fireworks.

As usual with bans, they tend to affect the law abiding more than the actual target.

Saucery · 03/01/2024 10:04

LenaLamont · 03/01/2024 09:35

Where are these “organised events”?

The city council used to put on yearly displays that attracted 75,000 people. Because of government budget cuts to local authorities these have been cancelled.

That means more private bonfires and fireworks as the safe, professional and organised one isn’t available.

The council don’t put them on in my area, haven’t done for over 40 years. In fact the last one I went to as a child my parents took us home early as the fire safety was shit and they could see an accident happening (it did the following year, a rocket was set off wrongly and shot into the crowd, burning a couple of spectators).
It tends to be businesses - rugby club, football club, conservative / RBL clubs etc. They helpfully spread them out for 10 days or so across actual Bonfire Night, so they can each make money. Hmm

Tartantatooes · 03/01/2024 09:57

I think fire works in peoples garden are slowly dying out anyway . I've noticed them declining on bonfire night and nye in my area.

LenaLamont · 03/01/2024 09:35

Where are these “organised events”?

The city council used to put on yearly displays that attracted 75,000 people. Because of government budget cuts to local authorities these have been cancelled.

That means more private bonfires and fireworks as the safe, professional and organised one isn’t available.

Grammarnut · 03/01/2024 09:32

Lorac23 · 02/01/2024 17:41

I like a proper organised display as much as anyone but this year near us they went on for a whole hour, just a taste of what is currently going on in Ukraine and the Middle East. Quite apart from the sheer tone deafness of it all, and the effects on animals and those with PTSD just as a couple of examples, I don't actually understand why people don't just take a few hundred quid out at the cash point and set fire to it. Bizarrely (or maybe not), the more run down the area I've lived in, the bigger the bangs seem to have to be....

There's no excuse for the noise, in a world where we now have noiseless fireworks and clever drone show options. Frankly though it will take some minister or celeb being injured before anything is even likely to be debated.

The poor have few pleasures. They cannot go skiing, they are unlikely to go on treks to the Andes. Fireworks bring great pleasure. You remark on a display going on for an hour. If I have paid to go to a firework show I want it to go on for an hour. I have bought several tickets and spent money on soup and hotdogs, so ten minutes of noiseless stuff is going to piss me off to the point I want my money back and won't go next year. Not unreasonable as a reaction.
There is a puritanical streak in the British that doesn't like pleasure for its own sake. Fireworks are pure pleasure for many people and for some one of the few pleasures they can afford, so stopping them is mean-spirited. In winter we need light in the darkness. Why do we celebrate Christmas in December in the northern hemisphere? Jesus called the Christ was most likely born in August (which may be referenced by the mention of the census of Augustus, which never happened). We celebrate in the dark months when light is needed. We send fireworks into the sky to encourage the sun to return, just as we light bonfires, little suns on earth. Magic has its place. Technocratic solutions, silent fireworks and bans on private displays, have no relationship to nor understanding of humanity and its needs.

Grammarnut · 03/01/2024 09:21

enchantedsquirrelwood · 03/01/2024 08:54

I see no reason for dogs to be upset by a human activity that doesn't need to happen.

Not just dogs, cats don't like them either. And I suspect the impact on wildlife is significant, too.

People WANT fireworks, they don't NEED them. Well I want doesn't get. People need to consider whether their wants have a disproportionately bad impact on the people around them. It's quite easy to be considerate. Occasionally you can't help it, eg if you need your trees cutting down, there will be noise from the tools. But you don't have to be deliberately annoying (see also being noisy or eating smelly foods on trains).

Want and need are sometimes the same thing. I don't need an inside lavatory, and the Victorians considered it insanitary to have WCs inside the house. However, I do want an inside lavatory when I need a pee in the middle of the night (the Victorians used a po) and for the safety of women the nearer the lavatory is to the inhabitants of a house the better. As to fireworks, well maybe we do not need them in the sense that we need an accessible lavatory, but we do both want and need light in the darkness of winter and that is mostly when we have fireworks. Festivals of light need lights, lights on Christmas trees, bonfires in the darkness, fireworks to light up the sky, to remind us that winter ends, spring and hope always return. In that sense we definitely need fireworks.

Grammarnut · 03/01/2024 09:17

enchantedsquirrelwood · 03/01/2024 08:50

They have a useful purpose - as do cars.

Fireworks don't.

As for complaining on here and not doing anything about it, I have asked why my local council can't ban garden bonfires when other councils do via bylaws and haven't had a reply.

I didn't say you should campaign, nor did I complain you did not. Fireworks do serve a useful purpose. Or do you think that anything that is just for fun and pleasure is useless?

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 03/01/2024 09:10

People WANT fireworks, they don't NEED them. Well I want doesn't get.

'I want' does get though, particularly when the majority either want something or aren't fussed either way, or when the opinion of those whom it does bother (e.g. animals) isn't as important.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 03/01/2024 08:54

ReindeerShelter · 02/01/2024 21:10

It’s a dog. It doesn’t have empathy. Pet owners need to stop ascribing human emotions to their animals 🙄

I see no reason for dogs to be upset by a human activity that doesn't need to happen.

Not just dogs, cats don't like them either. And I suspect the impact on wildlife is significant, too.

People WANT fireworks, they don't NEED them. Well I want doesn't get. People need to consider whether their wants have a disproportionately bad impact on the people around them. It's quite easy to be considerate. Occasionally you can't help it, eg if you need your trees cutting down, there will be noise from the tools. But you don't have to be deliberately annoying (see also being noisy or eating smelly foods on trains).

enchantedsquirrelwood · 03/01/2024 08:50

Grammarnut · 02/01/2024 15:53

Kitchen knives are dangerous - and vegetable chopping knives (the big ones) are the ones most often used in domestic murders. Shall we ban kitchen knives because they are dangerous?

They have a useful purpose - as do cars.

Fireworks don't.

As for complaining on here and not doing anything about it, I have asked why my local council can't ban garden bonfires when other councils do via bylaws and haven't had a reply.

Grammarnut · 03/01/2024 08:47

Not aimed at you, Xeno, but to Reindeer person who said dogs are just dogs, no empathy etc.

XenoBitch · 02/01/2024 23:29

Grammarnut · 02/01/2024 22:25

Dogs, as sentient and intelligent beings, do have empathy for those things that matter to them. It is outrageous to suggest that because they do not speak they have no real feelings. Much research has shown that animals are not instinctive but act upon information received and thinking about that information. Crows, for example, are great problem solvers and also able to pass what they have learned to other members of their group. They also have long memories, which means you should not upset your local crow.

Yep, there is a thread in AIBU right now about someone who has upset the local crows.

Another vote here for fireworks being for registered displays only, and not available to the general public. They are explosives, and some cunts do use them to frighten/hurt people.

AlizeeEasy · 02/01/2024 22:40

Grammarnut · 02/01/2024 22:18

But we cannot have rules and laws that eliminate every possible harm. Another one will just turn up. Impossible.

Agreed, but every ‘fun’ activity needs to be weighed up with the risk/reward analysis. It’s not about eliminating harm, but minimising it. Alcohol is fun, but there are still limits in place for when you are allowed to do it (eg no drink driving, or underage drinking). I’m not saying we should have a complete ban on fireworks, but giving anyone who wants an explosive in their garden is a recipe for disaster.

SpecialCharacters · 02/01/2024 22:37

As someone who has twice been attacked by youths with fireworks, definitely up for them to be sold to licensed displays only.

Legendairy · 02/01/2024 22:28

Grammarnut · 02/01/2024 22:25

Dogs, as sentient and intelligent beings, do have empathy for those things that matter to them. It is outrageous to suggest that because they do not speak they have no real feelings. Much research has shown that animals are not instinctive but act upon information received and thinking about that information. Crows, for example, are great problem solvers and also able to pass what they have learned to other members of their group. They also have long memories, which means you should not upset your local crow.

Yes I totally agree, it wasn't me that said it. They may not have feelings in the same way/thought process as humans but they clearly have very strong feelings. They definitely know when things aren't right, one of my dogs had a serious operation and my other dog (very large breed but only a pup) just knew to be gentle with him. They know an awful lot and whilst perhaps not full on empathy they certainly have more feelings and are more caring than the poster I was replying to.

Grammarnut · 02/01/2024 22:25

Legendairy · 02/01/2024 21:20

I wasn't really being serious, it was a comment relating to your lack of, my dog mostly only cares if I feed him. If I am ill he never leaves my side though so maybe he does have a little bit.

Dogs, as sentient and intelligent beings, do have empathy for those things that matter to them. It is outrageous to suggest that because they do not speak they have no real feelings. Much research has shown that animals are not instinctive but act upon information received and thinking about that information. Crows, for example, are great problem solvers and also able to pass what they have learned to other members of their group. They also have long memories, which means you should not upset your local crow.