Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to worry about the hold alcohol has on the UK?

293 replies

whyhere · 02/01/2024 08:48

Prompted by a thread about an alcohol-free wedding, and some of the comments therein ('boring.... wouldn't go.... take a hip-flask....'), it seems to me that the need for/expectation of alcohol has really taken a grip in this country. Can people really not enjoy anything without alcohol? Is it really impossible to create a soap scene without alcohol being involved (yes, EE, I'm looking at you!)?

Anyone doing dry January? (Full disclosure - come from a family of alcoholics and have been sober for around fifteen years.)

OP posts:
KarenNotAKaren · 03/01/2024 20:50

My dad died of alcoholism.

But I still can’t be doing with this pious shit of crying “ALCOHOLIC” because someone enjoys more than a thimble full of wine now and again.

And also YAWN to the incessant whining of “drunk people are soooo boring”. Do you know who’s boring? People who judgementally bang on like they’re so superior because they don’t need XYZ to have fun.

MarsandVenus · 03/01/2024 20:43

The normalisation of binge drinking is worrying and I often have to remind myself to cut back a bit. As someone said, the TV soaps don’t help. The other evening on Corrie, Sarah Jane was practically swimming in white wine with the no of times she reached for the bottle!

Nesbi · 03/01/2024 20:38

AnnieSnap · 03/01/2024 20:14

Not at all. Both alcohol and cocaine are addictive. Alcohol is more damaging to the body though 😳

“Potentially” addictive. Huge numbers of people around the world enjoy alcoholic beverages in all their varied forms with no ill effects ( at least no ill effects that don’t pale in comparison to all the other potentially harmful things we are exposed
to just by living and enjoying our brief time on earth).

In fact the same could be said about cocaine, the majority of users have no addiction issues. Some people unfortunately are do prone to addictive or self destructive behaviours which definitely can lead to addiction.

Itsdifferentnow · 03/01/2024 20:37

PinkyFlamingo · 02/01/2024 08:51

No I can't say a wedding without alcohol would have a great atmosphere really. Most people who drink alcohol aren't alcoholics

I think PinkyFlamingo has innocently spoken for most people who drink alcohol, whether regularly or just for special occasions. People think you need a drink, a toast of alcohol, a tipple, to warm things up.

However, I can honestly say it is not so! Not having alcohol does not make for a lack of a great atmosphere! Far from it! It is not the alcohol that warms the people up, but the people themselves, the company, the reason they are together.

I have enjoyed so many alcohol free Parties I can tell you they have been the best in my life!

Before the 1880s, the Founder of the Salvation Army, William Booth, was way ahead of the Medical world in realising that those who became addicted to alcohol could not learn to drink in moderation and their only hope of survival was to stop using alcohol. At the time, before penicillin or any health service or welfare state, there was terrible poverty, overcrowding, lack of work and people turned to gin and other alcohol to stop their pain both physical and mental. The Salvationists were among the first to try and help them. One day William Booth declared that he and the 'Officers', that is those full-time workers of the Salvation Army, would cease to drink alcohol so they could truly come alongside those whose health had been broken by it and who constitutionally could only recover by stopping drinking. When the ordinary Soldiers heard of this they said they too wanted to join in and stop drinking alcohol. Thus since the 1880s all Salvation Army Members take an oath not to drink alcohol.

It was through my choice to do this that I learned just how prejudiced people were. I have been met with rudeness and hostility and accused of being judgemental and many people have tried to spike my drink over the years, just because I have said no alcohol for me thank you. Little do they understand how it is the Salvationists choice to demonstrate that life without alcohol can be as wonderful, enjoyable, celebrational and victorious as you want it to be and we have been doing it to help those people, many of whom hit such rock bottom they ended up in prison, because alcohol ruled them. Our wish was that we could be beside them, that they might be lifted up with us helping them to build a good and happy alcohol free life. For 150 years, so many thousands of people have passed through the Salvation Army, being helped one way or another and many of them, like those poor desperate people in the 1880s. have had their lives saved from the misery of a life dragged down by the addiction to alcohol.

Today, even though we have Social Services, Benefits, Antibiotics and few people are starving, there remains a terrible problem with alcohol. You only have yo see a town centre on a Thursday, Friday, Saturday night. If you watch the real-life Police programs you will see how they have to deal with drunkenness all the time. Or go to A & E at night. That is a tip of the ice berg. In homes, after work, people drink now more than ever in the past. It is a very serious problem.

I entirely agree, whyhere, the thread about an alcohol-free wedding does indicate the alcohol culture in which we live, with many comments that give rise for concern.

If you want to see a really happy celebration without alcohol, go to a Salvation Army Wedding!

MouseMinge · 03/01/2024 20:35

I'm not at all convinced that you need alcohol to enjoy a wedding or a party or anything really. We convince ourselves that it gets the wheels rolling but I was reading a piece today from a young woman who's been sober for two years. She wasn't an alcoholic but felt that she was too reliant on alcohol and, of course, it's expensive. She had to go on some new drugs that reacted with alcohol which also helped. Stopped drinking. She said that at first she had social anxiety but she learned to lean into it and gradually got over it. She says she now has just as much if not more fun than when she drank. She did karaoke at her last birthday party stone cold sober.

I think we have a problematic relationship with alcohol in this country. I know I used to and I know how much happier I am now that I rarely drink and then only have at most a couple before stopping. Each to their own I think it's sad to imagine that you can't have fun at an event without alcohol.

AnnieSnap · 03/01/2024 20:14

IGotItFromAgnes · 02/01/2024 11:11

Does coke taste nice and go well with food?

I’m not a big drinker, wouldn’t be upset if told I could never drink alcohol again tbh, but equating it with cocaine is a bit silly.

Not at all. Both alcohol and cocaine are addictive. Alcohol is more damaging to the body though 😳

burgerandoats · 03/01/2024 20:10

I feel alcohol can make something more fun. But I wouldn't feel bored at an event without one

StaunchMomma · 03/01/2024 19:52

I hardly ever drink, only had a couple of Bucks Fizzes over Xmas, maybe one G&T a month.

I absolutely wouldn't have a big bash without alcohol served, though. It feels controlling and less understandable than eg a vegan only wedding, which would be guaranteed to get people's backs up.

Adults don't like being told what they can and can't do. It's certainly not a 'whole UK' issue.

As far as the thread you're referring to, that's not even about the alcohol - it's about the fact that people have paid out for hotel rooms so they can have a drink, as even 1 is not allowed in Scotland if driving. I would argue most people would expect to have at least 1 drink as wine is usually served for the toast!

Ottersmith · 03/01/2024 19:50

Yes I was surprised as well. I expected people to tell the person she was being unreasonable and she could have decided to drive originally but they were acting like it was all ruined and a complete waste of time. Maybe it speaks more to how boring weddings are.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 03/01/2024 19:48

Gen A would all be far to young to drink!

I think there is an over emphasis on drinking in this country.

I like to have a drink but can take or leave it as appropriate. I never feel the need to do Dry Jan and the like as I can go for a few weeks without drinking without deliberately trying not to drink. I’ve been to an alcohol free (Muslim) wedding and it was fine - really nice in fact. Drove back which was very convenient! (I realise I could do that anyway - edit - by choosing not to drink I mean)

sunshinemode · 03/01/2024 19:44

Some of the best weddings I have been to have been in Morocco. No alcohol at all, fantastic food, entertainment, lively music and everyone up dancing.

I think that there is a real lack of places to socialise here in uk if you don’t want to go to the pub.

1dayatatime · 03/01/2024 19:37

The revenue raised from smoking is £10 billion per year and falling about 3% a year (as more people quit). The cost to economy of smoking is between £14 and £17 billion and fairly stable. (Incl NHS cost, care home costs, unemployment due to smoking related illness, lost earnings due to smoking related illnesses etc)

The revenue raised from alcohol is £12 billion and rising slowly. However the cost to the economy of alcohol is £27 billion and rising (NHS costs, much greater losses in productivity etc).

In short although both alcohol and tobacco need to be taxed more, the problem with tobacco is that more people are quitting so despite increasing tobacco taxes the number of smokers paying is getting smaller meaning overall tobacco tax revenues are falling.

Whereas with alcohol the number of people drinking is fairly stable so an increase in alcohol taxation would create more revenue.

That said such is the hold alcohol has on UK society no Government is ever going to get elected promising to significantly increase alcohol taxation despite its cost to the NHS and the economy.

DeeCeeCherry · 03/01/2024 19:36

I'm a social drinker. I wouldnt mind an alcohol-free wedding though. I don't need a drink to have fun.

Event organisers trying to put on a dance event in a venue are always 'let go' in favour of a drinking crowd eventually. Its part of the reason why so many nights/venues close down or rebrand. They dont want people who'll have 1 or 2 drinks then stick to soft or water and still enjoy themselves. They want gluttons whose main focus is sitting down eating loads, and then chuck loads of alcohol down their throats whilst staggering around drunkenly. Drinking is embedded in British culture, its actively encouraged

MadWifeInTheAttic · 03/01/2024 19:35

AHG123 · 03/01/2024 19:25

People who glamourise alcohol or say it’s just a bit of fun haven’t lived with an alcoholic or watched one die.

I've done both of those things.

And I still find alcohol fun, a great social lubricant, and really delicious with a good meal, because I can drink a glass of merit without shitting myself or beating my kids. Most people can.

MadWifeInTheAttic · 03/01/2024 19:33

TAAT? You completely missed the point of the thread and you are mischaracterising the OP of it.

Dentistlakes · 03/01/2024 19:26

I do think this country has a problem with alcohol, but not so much in younger age groups. The 40+ age bracket tends to drink too much, too regularly, using alcohol as a means to wind down and relax. It makes people fat and leads to difficulty sleeping as well as a host of other medic problems. Alcohol does your body no favours and most people could dramatically improve their mental and physical health by stopping.

AHG123 · 03/01/2024 19:25

People who glamourise alcohol or say it’s just a bit of fun haven’t lived with an alcoholic or watched one die.

celticprincess · 03/01/2024 19:20

Bippitybobbityboing · 02/01/2024 23:19

I agree totally with this, don't drink alcohol, can't drink more than one glass of fizzy stuff, don't like alcohol free versions of things.
I quite often end up on tap water!!

At a recent wedding I caved and asked the barman for a nice cup of tea in the middle of the disco 😆

I got one and promptly started a trend!

You sound like me!! I hate it when they turn off the tea/coffee machine at a certain time in the evening. One pub near us doesn’t even serve hot drinks - I needed to kill time whilst one child was at a class in a village and this was the only place nearby to go to. They had no still juice, only fizzy. They served food though which usually means you can get a brew, but no!

Fionaville · 03/01/2024 19:19

I don't know anybody who drinking is an issue for. We all drink moderately and socially. I probably buy 12 bottles of wine a year and drink out/eat out socially about one a month and rarely get tipsy.
I'd find going to an alcohol free wedding a bit dull. Not because I want to get drunk, but I do enjoy the atmosphere the later in gets and people let their hair down more. Some of best weddings I have been to have been good because of the evening do, when there are lots of slightly sloshed people living it up on the dance floor. People just enjoy the feeling of being tipsy at certain functions like weddings. I don't see the harm in it.

AnnieSnap · 03/01/2024 19:19

SparkleyMud · 02/01/2024 08:59

I think what's more worrying is how an increasing number of adults are addicted to their phone and don't recognise it as that.

I am addicted to my phone

Seriously? That’s more worrying to you? This despite the costs of alcohol including street violence (including often serious injury and even murder), domestic violence, including child abuse (including often serious injury and even murder), serious health problems (often including terminal conditions) to name a few!

StrawBeretMoose · 03/01/2024 19:14

I wouldn’t mind an alcohol-free wedding though I’ve never been to one. I do like to drink, or at least I used to but I find it less appealing as I get older.

I do think alcohol has got a grip n the country, I remember trying to buy a birthday card for a friend in recovery from alcohol issues and there are so many ‘humorous’ cards about getting shit-faced. The rest seem to have flowers or butterflies!

There are a few people in my circle with alcohol issues. I think they would decline an invitation to an alcohol-free wedding or just bring booze with them as so many are suggesting on the other thread.

AnnieSnap · 03/01/2024 19:14

iloveeverykindofcat · 02/01/2024 08:55

Alcohol itself isn't the problem. The problem is the normalization of binge drinking.

It depends how you define a problem. Any alcohol is toxic. It’s a poison, that’s why it’s causes drunkenness and eventually sleepiness, followed by unconsciousness. That is the brain trying to protect itself. Alcohol is far more dangerous, both to the individual and to society than cannabis, Ecstasy or Cocaine. Any amount of alcohol increases the risk of breast cancer and other health issues. I do agree though that the biggest problem is the culture that celebrates and normalises heavy drinking.

People don’t really need alcohol to relax and let their hair down, they just believe they do. Studies in social psychology have shown that the placebo effect applies to alcohol. People who believe that have had it will party as well as those who really have, including feeling tipsy.

CantFindMyMarbles · 03/01/2024 19:12

I always laugh when people imply they need alcohol to enjoy themselves. I find it quite sad to be honest. I’ve noticed lots of young people aren’t drinking anywhere near as much as they used to and take a much healthier approach tk things. I do think the amount of harm done by alcohol is concerning - A&E demands, police etc….absolutely depressing.

80skid · 03/01/2024 19:06

I love drinking (not an alcoholic, just enjoy it) but recently have friends who have had unhealthy relationships with alcohol who have stopped entirely. I'd never realised how tough it can be to be teetotal - the constant questioning why, how so many social events are based around alcohol and how alcohol is such a part of life (my boss gave me a bottle of wine for Christmas, as is the usual gesture in my job). if you opt entirely out of boozy meals, nights out, BBQs, even raffles with boozy prizes, it can be very isolating.
Personally, I'm never going to be a non drinker, but im more than happy to not drink. I'm probably going to do dry January (I did November and most of December too) but not as a big thing and if I choose to have a drink, I won't be gutted. I'm just moving away from drinking every weekend (I don't drink during the week anyway). Alcohol is indeed a very large part of our society and although I enjoy it very much, I think overall reducing this will only ever be a good thing.

CoffeeMama1 · 03/01/2024 18:58

You're not wrong. The obsession that an event is only worth it or fun with alcohol is so toxic. People forget it's a drug, and there's more alcohol related deaths than any other drug. This goes for all events, from small things like a dinner party, right through to a wedding or massive party, if you feel the need to drink alcohol to enjoy it then I would seriously recommend therapy, because that is the legitimate meaning of a coping mechanism. (This obviously doesn't apply to people who are happy with or without alcohol, and those who legitimately just have one drink because they like it).