Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to worry about the hold alcohol has on the UK?

293 replies

whyhere · 02/01/2024 08:48

Prompted by a thread about an alcohol-free wedding, and some of the comments therein ('boring.... wouldn't go.... take a hip-flask....'), it seems to me that the need for/expectation of alcohol has really taken a grip in this country. Can people really not enjoy anything without alcohol? Is it really impossible to create a soap scene without alcohol being involved (yes, EE, I'm looking at you!)?

Anyone doing dry January? (Full disclosure - come from a family of alcoholics and have been sober for around fifteen years.)

OP posts:
newoldfluff · 02/01/2024 09:20

CoatOfArms · 02/01/2024 09:17

But this is a fundamental misunderstanding. Of course people are physically capable of going to a wedding without alcohol. The point is that for millennia, the social convention has been to celebrate an occasion like this with a drink. That is why it seems so odd.

And? They can get over it and not drink.

Taciturn · 02/01/2024 09:19

Most alcoholic drinks are dry or bitter, whereas most non-alcoholic ones are sweet.

This is a real issue: most people don't know what to drink in a non-alcohol setting. Countries in Europe have a far wider variety of alcohol free beer now, but it is still not prevalent in the UK

isthismylifenow · 02/01/2024 09:18

I don't think you should target the whole country. I don't live in the UK and would find an alcohol free wedding, for a couple who do usually drink alcohol, quite strange.

Unless ...

It's for cultural or religious reasons. Then of course no alcohol would be available at all. Or, if a close member of the wedding party is a recovering alcoholic for example.

These two instances would not be stated on invites as cultural reasons we all just know there wouldn't be alcohol. Example 2, it would feel wrong to add it to an invite if someone is struggling.

Porageeater · 02/01/2024 09:18

Yes there is a terrible attitude towards alcohol in this country. It’s really apparent once you spend any time in other countries. I also agree with pp that you can be a problem drinker without being what we may describe as a full blown ‘alcoholic’. People normalise heavy and problematic drinking because ‘it’s ok I’m not an alcoholic’.

CoatOfArms · 02/01/2024 09:17

newoldfluff · 02/01/2024 09:15

It's ridiculous to not be able to go to a wedding without alcohol.

But this is a fundamental misunderstanding. Of course people are physically capable of going to a wedding without alcohol. The point is that for millennia, the social convention has been to celebrate an occasion like this with a drink. That is why it seems so odd.

Chilicabbage · 02/01/2024 09:16

Tl be fair to OP there, the moan was just about that it would change plans. Drinks - stay over, no drinks, can drive easily home.

Alcohol free events needn't be boring. I went to many since DH's side are muslims. Bar 1 all were nice and fun. And I am a drinker (who can put pints away better than many men)

Theyvegotatrex · 02/01/2024 09:16

Five months into being alcohol free as I don’t have a healthy relationship with it and I can assure you that the OP is correct. People don’t want to admit it but I can’t tell you how many times people have commented and said they couldn’t do it, not even for a week. The fact that people make such a huge deal of having month off says it all really. It’s actually bloody hard to stop.

Luckly I’m now free of alcohol and it no longer has any interest for me. Life is so much better. And I never drank gallons, I wasn’t drinking myself into a stupor. I’m talking, socially acceptable levels of consumption - half a bottle of wine on a Friday. A few classes of wine with lunch on Saturday and Sunday. And yes, it is harder to let your hair down in the same way initially but that soon changes. Life is better.

squashi · 02/01/2024 09:16

I think as a society our attitude to alcohol is hugely contradictory - it's celebrated (let the fun be-GIN etc) and condemned in equal measure. We encourage excess and then disparage those who fall victim to it.

With the alcohol free wedding thread, I think the issue was that the guests hadn't been told this was the case before they booked expensive hotels.

newoldfluff · 02/01/2024 09:15

It's ridiculous to not be able to go to a wedding without alcohol.

KingsleyBorder · 02/01/2024 09:13

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 02/01/2024 09:09

YANBU. I used to regularly drink too much and rarely do now, but certainly overdid it a bit over Christmas and am doing Dry January. I think the people saying that not everyone who drinks alcohol is an alcoholic are missing the point. You can tick many boxes of being at least a slightly problem drinker without being close to being an alcoholic.

It would be very naïve (or disingenuous) to suggest that people who drink alcohol are divided into those who are alcoholics and those who like a couple of drinks occasionally. The fact that so many people would be appalled by the idea of a dry wedding is probably not great. Let's face it, most of those people are appalled because weddings=getting a bit drunk, if not hammered.

But what is wrong with getting a bit drunk? It’s possible to feel pleasant effects from alcohol without behaving inappropriately.

OddBoots · 02/01/2024 09:13

You do know that the original 'water into wine' was because the wedding was running low, don't you? This is not a new or UK thing.

LuckyVoila · 02/01/2024 09:12

I also think it says something that many members of Gen X and Boomers would be utterly horrified at the idea of smoking the odd joint (which I also don't do), but think nothing of knocking back a bottle of wine at the weekend.

You don't have to be an alcoholic to be drinking too much. The effects of alcohol on the body are well documented, and not just large amounts.

ManateeFair · 02/01/2024 09:11

It hasn’t ‘taken a hold’. Alcohol has always been a huge part of our culture; it goes back thousands of years. This is nothing new.

My ex was an alcoholic and I have considerable experience of being around problem drinkers (not my family) so I’m not naive about this subject by any means. But the vast majority of people do not have a drink problem. They simply don’t. The fact that people are used to celebrating weddings with alcohol doesn’t indicate that alcohol has suddenly ‘taken a hold’ of the nation.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 02/01/2024 09:09

YANBU. I used to regularly drink too much and rarely do now, but certainly overdid it a bit over Christmas and am doing Dry January. I think the people saying that not everyone who drinks alcohol is an alcoholic are missing the point. You can tick many boxes of being at least a slightly problem drinker without being close to being an alcoholic.

It would be very naïve (or disingenuous) to suggest that people who drink alcohol are divided into those who are alcoholics and those who like a couple of drinks occasionally. The fact that so many people would be appalled by the idea of a dry wedding is probably not great. Let's face it, most of those people are appalled because weddings=getting a bit drunk, if not hammered.

KingsleyBorder · 02/01/2024 09:08

CantDealwithChristmas · 02/01/2024 09:03

I don't think alcohol has a 'hold' over the UK. I think it's an important part of the culture which goes all the way back to the Saxon and Viking cultures which invaded the UK and brought a big drinking culture with them. Maybe the earlier Celts also had a big alcohol culture too, we don't know much about that.

If you look at rates of alcohol-related deaths in say Russia, there's other cultures where it's more pernicious. Or, say, in the UAE where alcoholism is a big problem but it has to be 'hidden' becauase of religious-cultural reasons. Or the huge salarymen drinking culture in Japan. Or the pernicious problems of alcoholism in the oppressed Native American cultures.

Studies show that Boomers and Gen X and older millenials are the last of the big drinkers. Gen Z and Gen A are drinking less and less. The Economist reviewed a Cambridge study which suggested that social media is the cause of this - younger people don't want to appear drunk in pics and want to be conscious of their actions throughout the night as they know it'll be on social media. I don't know whether this is true or not!

So, I think it's more nuanced than your OP suggests but I don't think the UK is particularly terrible for alcoholism when seen in context of other cultures.

I also think most British people would expect to be able to drink at a wedding.

Great post. Agree with all you say.

On the evolving habits of younger generations, there are noticeably more 0% alcohol drinks on sale in supermarkets and venues these days too, with better taste.

CoatOfArms · 02/01/2024 09:07

I think though you are confusing two things. Yes there are some people who are problem drinkers, drink several times a week, cannot possibly imagine going a few days without a bottle of wine. There are undeniably people like this who are the sort of people who pour scorn on those who don't share their habit. But there are lots of other people who associate drinking with a "special occasion" - they could go weeks or months without having any alcohol at all, but want to have a couple of glasses of champagne or pints of beer at a wedding.

Having a dry wedding is very unusual unless it's for religious reasons because this is the sort of special event which most people want to mark with a glass of wine. This is not particular to the UK, you would find alcohol being drunk at weddings across Europe and further afield.

I do not drink very much at all, glass of wine on Christmas Day, time before that was October, but I would still think it odd that a wedding was dry. Not because people are unable to enjoy without booze, but because it's going against a very long standing social convention.

Silverbirchtwo · 02/01/2024 09:07

Lots of people at weddings are designated drivers and don't drink. Seems odd to pick on weddings for obsession with alcohol, Friday night out getting thrown out of pubs, teenage girls legless on the pavement, that is pretty horrible. A couple of drinks at a celebration not so much.

Maireas · 02/01/2024 09:07

LuckyVoila · 02/01/2024 09:01

I don't drink at all because I don't enjoy it - don't like either the taste or the effects - and you would not believe how much of an issue other people have with it.

IMO if you can't dance, chat to people and have fun at a wedding without booze then that's pretty sad and I feel sorry for you.

This

Maireas · 02/01/2024 09:06

ImCamembertTheBigCheese · 02/01/2024 09:01

A wedding is a celebration and for some it is the chance to celebrate and have a few glasses of wine / beer etc. Most people can sensibly enjoy alcohol without getting drunk.

A dry wedding sounds miserable to me.

Why would it be miserable? It's a celebration and a happy day. I've been to Muslim weddings which were far from miserable!

anothernamechangeagainsndagain · 02/01/2024 09:05

And I do think (which was the original post) that the organisers of a dry wedding should tell their guests so that they don't arrange hotel rooms or expensive taxis when they could drive! I personally drive to concerts and don't drink for the convenience, but I choose in full knowledge

CantDealwithChristmas · 02/01/2024 09:03

I don't think alcohol has a 'hold' over the UK. I think it's an important part of the culture which goes all the way back to the Saxon and Viking cultures which invaded the UK and brought a big drinking culture with them. Maybe the earlier Celts also had a big alcohol culture too, we don't know much about that.

If you look at rates of alcohol-related deaths in say Russia, there's other cultures where it's more pernicious. Or, say, in the UAE where alcoholism is a big problem but it has to be 'hidden' becauase of religious-cultural reasons. Or the huge salarymen drinking culture in Japan. Or the pernicious problems of alcoholism in the oppressed Native American cultures.

Studies show that Boomers and Gen X and older millenials are the last of the big drinkers. Gen Z and Gen A are drinking less and less. The Economist reviewed a Cambridge study which suggested that social media is the cause of this - younger people don't want to appear drunk in pics and want to be conscious of their actions throughout the night as they know it'll be on social media. I don't know whether this is true or not!

So, I think it's more nuanced than your OP suggests but I don't think the UK is particularly terrible for alcoholism when seen in context of other cultures.

I also think most British people would expect to be able to drink at a wedding.

anothernamechangeagainsndagain · 02/01/2024 09:03

It's not alcohol per se but if you are going on a night out you want to drink things you like the taste of, I personally don't like sweet things ruling out nearly all non alcoholic drinks - at home I drink herbal tea (can't have caffeine) or water but on a special occasion I like wine, beer or a g&t - I don't see what the issue is, I like them and have no issues with alcohol

Worldgonecrazy · 02/01/2024 09:02

I think alcohol in moderation is fine. However we seem to have lost sight of what ‘moderation’ means.

There was a lot of talk about saving the NHS during covid. One of the best things we could all do is cut back on alcohol. It would drastically reduce the numbers in A&E and reduce a number of other health conditions.

I used to enjoy alcohol at the level much of the country does. It’s only when I cut back and looked from the outside that I saw how ingrained heavy drinking is in U.K. culture. It was quite an eye opener.

A number of people also seem to be waking up to this, and I know a number of colleagues and friends have cut out alcohol completely.

Im quite shy and rely on alcohol for that social ‘oil’ mentioned by a pp, so it is difficult to stick to one small glass of wine but I have found some methods to manage.

LuckyVoila · 02/01/2024 09:01

I don't drink at all because I don't enjoy it - don't like either the taste or the effects - and you would not believe how much of an issue other people have with it.

IMO if you can't dance, chat to people and have fun at a wedding without booze then that's pretty sad and I feel sorry for you.

PriOn1 · 02/01/2024 09:01

I’ve been to an alcohol free wedding and it was fine, but then I grew up in a family who rarely drank alcohol. Some people are very reliant on it to have a good time, which is sad, in my opinion.

Every year at school, we had a ceilidh at Christmas where people seemed to have a great time. Then I progressed to university and every year, at the annual ball, there were people crying in the toilets, either because they were drunk, or because someone who’d been drinking had treated them badly.

Parties where there was lots of alcohol often ended with people so drunk they were ill. Parties with plenty of food and things to do always seemed more enjoyable and ended with less drama.

I guess it takes more effort to have a fun party where there’s no alcohol, but alcohol ruins many an occasion, especially for those with relatives who have an abusive relationship with alcohol. I guess, other than a hangover, those who abuse others when drunk don’t remember or care.

Unfortunately, it’s so much a part of the culture in the UK, including getting drunk, rather than just moderate drinking with food, that it’s not likely to change.

Swipe left for the next trending thread