Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think she shouldn’t have done this?

57 replies

Wwydtomorrow · 02/01/2024 02:17

I had my baby nearly six months ago and couldn’t breastfeed her. I contacted a lactation specialist with the aim of helping me, but she wasn’t very helpful and spent most of the session pushing other services (in particular cranial osteopathy) at us. It got a bit embarrassing in the end as her follow up messages were just ‘have you done this’ and I ended up having to say I just couldn’t afford to keep spending money, which was true.

I was obviously quite vulnerable at the time as the baby was only six days old but when I look back AIBU to feel a bit annoyed?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
DrinkFeckArseBrick · 02/01/2024 11:20

Maybe not what you want to hear but we had massive breastfeeding issues and it wasn't just one thing that helped.

The breastfeeding support service near me is actually quite decent (or used to be, probably not so much now, but they used to send people to your house) and they helped me with positioning and technique. They said the baby had a tongue tie which they couldn't fix. So we went to a tt practitioner, who agreed it was severe and cut it, but by that time the baby was a couple months old and although they fed a lot better on one side, they still had massive issues on the other side. The tt practitioner strongly advised cranial osteopathy and I was very sceptical but decided to give it a go...I don't know why it was called cranial because it was whole body. For some reason, my baby could bend one way and not the other way. It was really obvious when they pointed it out (the osteopath likened her to a banana) and I felt so awful I hadn't noticed. Even looking at baby pictures the baby is always bending one way. So they did some exercises to stretch the muscles, gave me some more to do at home, and after a few weeks the baby was fine, I think I had 4 appointments.

My point is, yes it's shit, and there should be more support available, and it shouldn't be so expensive, but sometimes different experts are needed. All of those specialisms require years of training and you aren't going to get anyone trained in everything. So she might have just been pushing you to spend money needlessly. Or she might have been trying to help signpost you appropriately.

MouseMama · 02/01/2024 11:06

I would have thought she could have supported you better. I had great problems bf my first child due to tongue tie, weak suck, dairy allergy etc. The lactation consultant was an amazing support, sat with me at home for at least half a day and afterwards was at the other end of the phone when needed. Genuinely it would have been impossible for me to bf without her invaluable expertise. So yes I think you were unlucky not to have a good experience.

But prior to the lactation consultant, I tried the birth doula I had paid a fortune for who also offered bf support and she didn’t seem to know any more than me as a first time mum. One of those things where word of mouth referrals are everything as it’s hard to distinguish a true expert from a mum with a side hustle until they’re on the job.

The only caveat to that though is that perhaps you struggled with bf because baby had a stiff neck or jaw and really did need separate support on that. Even so I would have thought a good LC may have been able to support you with those problems.

wellyesisupposeso · 02/01/2024 10:49

Some very harsh and strange responses around here.

Yes, Op, you were vulnerable and she shouldn't have done it.

I had help with breastfeeding from midwives and they were great. They also recommended breastfeeding support groups which sounded good although I never managed to attend for various reasons. They were free.

Did you pay this woman? Is she still in business? I would drop her an email and lay out how she made you feel. Will get it off your chest and may make her think twice when dealing with vulnerable post partum women.

Quitelikeit · 02/01/2024 10:46

So your baby is 6 months and you’ve been expressing the whole time?!

She suggested CO and you decided not to pursue it. You are misdirecting your anger - you said you engaged a number of professionals yet none of their advice worked.

This was nobodies fault. You paid for her knowledge and ideas and she gave you them. Not sure she should state in her bio that she might recommend other paid interventions.

Couchant · 02/01/2024 10:41

Oh, and despite doing literally everything to try to get my milk supply to come in, DS was FF. I was sad about it for years.

Couchant · 02/01/2024 10:40

DS was born by CS the week before the Easter long weekend and my milk never came in. I had BF advice from La Leche League, my midwife, HV, NCT peer supporter and HP, but nothing worked, so I found the one lactation consultant in London who was prepared to come to the flat over the Easter weekend, panicked by having a baby I couldn’t feed. I think it was also something like £175, and this was 2012. She said exactly the same thing everyone else did, and then, as a parting shot, pointed to a patch of dry skin on one breast and said it looked potentially cancerous and I ‘should get it checked out, because a tumour could be impacting on my milk’.

My GP pointed out a matching patch on the other breast and suggested, rightly, that trim on my new nursing bra was irritating me.

I still remember that lactation consultant with fury. She was a quack.

Pelham678 · 02/01/2024 10:35

AlwaysWearSPF · 02/01/2024 02:52

Firstly these comments are not helpful at all to you.

I'm so sorry that this has happened to you and I sympathise with you and I know exactly what you mean with the lack of support.

My situation is somewhat similar to yours.

I had my DS in August last year he is approaching five months.

At first breastfeeding was painful and he looked extremely uncomfortable when feeding, arching his back etc.

I saw a breastfeeding support worker who was absolutely useless she just kept saying you're doing well and I don't see the issue you are facing.

Then I went to a breastfeeding work shop and saw a breastfeeding specialist who then told me my DS had a posterior tongue tie.

NHS waiting times was eights weeks, we were so desperate as breastfeeding was becoming unbearable for both of us. We paid privately to have his tongue snipped. The midwife who came to perform the snip explained to us that she rates the tongues performance after a few checks, 0 to 10 zero being the lowest she rated my DS at a two. She said that the skin was so thick the likelihood of it growling back was very high.

After the snip breastfeeding became less painful for me but my DS was still having issues. He would sound and look as though he was in pain when feeding and wouldn't relax always flipping his head back, latching on and off, crying, arching his back I mean it was awful for us both.

So we paid privately to see and osteopath, she said my sons jaw was stiff and that he had acid reflux. He had six sessions which to be honest I don't think it helped very much at all.

Back and forth to the GP and HV eventually my DS was prescribed baby Gaviscon. In time my DS had then what the HV called food avoidance, he had basically linked pain with breastfeeding and was shallow latching. This then affected my milk flow.

Now four month later after all of those challenges plus a very bad chest infection my milk flow is so low that I'm only expressing 2oz - not that long ago I was expressing 8oz.

The guilt from my failure has made me feel so sad about this. I'm still trying after three weeks to get my milk back up but we are taking about a lot of expressing, like every hours. Plus now my DS has got so used to the bottles that he doesn't suck hard enough to send the signals to my brain. A sad situation but I'm learning to just not expect anything and I still do breastfeed him for comfort even though he's now on the bottles.

Please don't think it's a failure. You sound like an amazing mum who's doing the best she can for her baby. Breastfeeding is not the be-all and end-all. (I breastfed but tbh it's a tiny part of parenting).

Try and be kind to yourself. That's just as important to your baby longterm! Flowers

Beautiful3 · 02/01/2024 10:27

Perhaps she suggested it, thinking it may help. Sometimes when the main things don't work, it suggests it's a different problem. It may have worked for you. I went through the standard route of a medical issue for a very young child, for a few years. Nothing was helping at all, until someone recommended something else. At the time I thought they were selling me something, while I was desperate. I tried it and it actually helped. I spent a fortune.

NWQM · 02/01/2024 10:13

I agree.

I would add though that if you feel you do don't get the right clinical services or incorrect advice it is reasonable to consider doing something now you feel able. Depends if you feel it stepped over a line that you need to help protect overs from or was 'just' disappointing. Say just as that isn't right. Are you able to offer a review at least in their website or SM? Firstly though have you fed back to them?

Wwydtomorrow · 02/01/2024 10:08

Interesting you’ve made it my fault, @ManateeFair

OP posts:
ManateeFair · 02/01/2024 10:05

It sounds like she was an alternative therapist rather than a medical/nursing expert, and I think if you engage an alternative therapist you can only expect them to push alternative therapies on you.

I think you made a mistake when you chose to engage her, and that you need to let it go.

CurlewKate · 02/01/2024 10:03

Yea-I think pushing other paid services- particularly unproven and potentially dangerous ones like cranial osteopathy is very wrong. Your baby was 6 days old- there was plenty she could have suggested and helped you with.

Sadly, there's nothing you can do about it now. It wasn't your fault, it was hers. I hope your baby is well and thriving, and you can put it down to experience and look forward, not back.

Wwydtomorrow · 02/01/2024 09:59

I have been expressing milk for her but my breast pump just keeps breaking. It’s happened again and she’s 6 months in two weeks. I just really don’t know if I want to get it fixed or just ask for a refund (if you’re planning on expressing don’t buy an Elvie hands free.) Just ruminating on how much easier actually breastfeeding is!

OP posts:
Evanesy · 02/01/2024 09:01

quisensoucie · 02/01/2024 06:44

Lactation specialist are like mediums. Pointless rip-off merchants, preying on the vulnerable
What do you think midwives and HVs are for? You know, those people with qualifications recognised by professional regulators...
Such people are Emperor's new clothes; you are on a band-wagon of daftness

That wasn’t my experience at all. With my first, the so called feeding specialist told me to use formula when DS couldn’t latch just an hour after being born. The midwives were then too busy to help me and the HV never actually visited. The lactation consultant I used was amazing and so supportive, and without her, I wouldn’t have managed to BF for two years.

With my second, no one even spoke to me about feeding after I said I want to BF. Luckily everything I learnt from the consultant I used helped.

Post natal care end support can be really bad.

AlwaysWearSPF · 02/01/2024 08:37

quisensoucie · 02/01/2024 06:44

Lactation specialist are like mediums. Pointless rip-off merchants, preying on the vulnerable
What do you think midwives and HVs are for? You know, those people with qualifications recognised by professional regulators...
Such people are Emperor's new clothes; you are on a band-wagon of daftness

I don't know where you live in the uk or how long it has been since you had a baby or mother, so excuse me. I had my DS in August I also have a daughter who is 19 big age difference between my eldest and youngest. I live in London and my experience the second time round using the NHS was remarkably different to when I had my daughter. This time round I saw more than eight different midwives during my pregnancy. They are stretched and overworked, it almost felt like to me when I reached out that the advice they give is limited, after that they send you to the HV or GP.

My HV only regurgitated what the midwives told me, she did get a breastfeeding support worker who came to my home but wasn't very helpful at all, lovely lady but again just regurgitated the same advice.
Once you get to that point where you've tried out all that has been advised and you're still facing issues thats then when you have to get the £££ out.

I spent a lot of money fishing through all that could be, might be, try this and try that. Also the NBA told me anyone can call themselves a lactation consultant, she said to look out for those who were qualified and gave me a website of a few.

hedgehoglurker · 02/01/2024 08:26

I'd had a difficult birth with my first baby who couldn't latch. After about 2 or 3 weeks, we had a double appointment with a therapist. One session of cranial osteopathy for the baby followed by a neck and back treatment for myself whilst the baby had an amazingly relaxed sleep. It fixed whatever the problem was and I breastfed for 9 months.

It wasn't pushed by a breastfeeding consultant, but from my experience I can understand why they might consider it helpful.

I hope you are able to find peace with this issue.

Wwydtomorrow · 02/01/2024 08:17

We did have various people from the infant feeding team come out, but it was all futile unfortunately. I daresay that whatever we did wouldn’t have worked but having pressure put on me to spend a lot of money to make it work - I don’t know.

@WandaWonder i am addressing you because I think your reply tipped from blunt /abrupt to really quite spiteful - I think the fact I had enough about me to find, contact and arrange specialist support indicates I was thinking. What I wasn’t in the position to do was be particularly assertive and say ‘OK, but for now what I need support with is …’ I just sort of tried to swerve round the subject.

OP posts:
itsgettingweird · 02/01/2024 08:01

I actually get the 6 month mark. It's because everyone pushes the first 6 months are the important stage to BF.

I BF ds but my milk dried up suddenly (then discovered I had viral hepatitis so probably linked) and I had to switch to solely formula from 7 weeks.

At 6 months when he started weaning the guilt set in.

I also understand why when you spent £175 on a lactation consult you'd expect value for that not recommendations to spend more on other treatments.

The good news for you though is my ds is now 19yo and an athlete representing Britain. It doesn't seem to have harmed him!

oblada · 02/01/2024 07:34

Lactation consultants are often a lot better qualified than midwives and HV when it comes to breastfeeding. There are various qualifications that are recognised that I would expect any lactation consultant to have.
In this case it looks like she felt that signposting you for help re cranio osteopathy was the right way forward to improve the breastfeeding issue. I imagine she will have looked at the other possibilities (positioning and attachment etc) first. I don't see anything in your post OP to suggest she was not a professional or didn't do her job to appropriate standards. I appreciate you're annoyed she didn't fix the problem but in fairness you didn't follow her guidance. And you're annoyed you had to pay for her services and that is probably a fair point but not something that should be held against her surely, it's down to government funding/NHS. She provides a service that is clearly currently needed.

Thankyouthankyoujellybean · 02/01/2024 07:21

Ooh, some nasty replies! OP I suggest you ditch the thread.

My tuppence worth though... I found sacro-cranial therapy very useful for DS1, so I don't think she was pushing something unnecessary for the sake of her mate's finances. However when you said you couldn't afford it should have either tried to get you a discounted rate (I've never heard of a therapist with only one rate) or piped down!

I'm sorry this has upset you. I found that there was a lot I couldn't process at the time and it came out months or years later.

Mumsfishnets · 02/01/2024 07:14

I think it's normal to come out of those hazy first weeks and then months and with a less tired, more levelled head on think 'why did I think that was okay?'.

It's difficult to know the full facts without being an expert. I was like this over my birth.

I am surprised that the NHS (assuming you're uk based) didn't push a load of free support your way? I had lactation experts visit my home when new born wasn't gaining weight. There always seemed to be someone in my house brandishing a knitted booby at me!

Fraaahnces · 02/01/2024 07:10

I have to say that my 2nd lactation consultant was amazing. She listened and asked clinical questions about breast growth during pregnancy, etc. pointed out that my boobs hadn’t swollen up after a week and were the wrong shape for someone who had just given birth to twins. I had no feeling I’d let down, etc… she came back with an ultrasound and showed me that I had virtually no milk ducts. Explained everything. With my first baby I was repeatedly told that EVERYONE can breastfeed and I tried and tried and beat myself up when I had to swap for formula as my baby wasn’t thriving. I let go of Al the guilt from that time and tbh, with twins, was quite relieved.

JANEY205 · 02/01/2024 06:52

I’ve never found lactation consultants helpful (and tried a few when my first was born). The final straw for us was being advised to pump and tube feed my baby so he didn’t ’get used to the bottle.’
We were just desperate for him to eat at that point and having a tongue tie released did nothing. Also got advised to see a baby chiropractor. About to have my 3rd baby and will be bottle feeding from the jump and I feel so much relief knowing I don’t have to deal with all the BFing pressure and crap that comes along with it! It’s something women put enormous pressure on themselves over when the support to do it is also so greatly lacking and I wish there was better education that sometimes fed is best, doesn’t matter if you BF or not and pushing BFing at all costs is hurtful to mums and babies.

quisensoucie · 02/01/2024 06:44

Lactation specialist are like mediums. Pointless rip-off merchants, preying on the vulnerable
What do you think midwives and HVs are for? You know, those people with qualifications recognised by professional regulators...
Such people are Emperor's new clothes; you are on a band-wagon of daftness

Evanesy · 02/01/2024 06:40

Did she explain what the issue was with breastfeeding?

Sometimes, breastfeeding just isn’t possible and paying someone for help isn’t going to change that, so I wonder if her suggestion of other services was because of that.

Either way, I mean this kindly but what is the point of dwelling on it? Breastfeeding is often romanticised but ultimately, it is just a way to feed your child. Unfortunately it didn’t work out for you, but what matters is your child is healthy and fed.

Swipe left for the next trending thread