Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Knowing what you know now, would you have still made the same decision about having children?

382 replies

Drsparks · 01/01/2024 15:20

I'm not necessarily asking if you regret it but if you had all the facts, and knew exactly how it would pan out would you have still made the same choice?

Eg
I would of had kids earlier/later.
Or
I chose not to have them because I wanted a childfree life but having lived it, I would have chosen to have kids because it wasn't all it was cracked up to be.
Or
I love my kids 100% but in hindsight I'd of probably been happier with a childfree life
or
Yes it is 109% the right choice

OP posts:
Theunhappiestchild · 04/01/2024 13:17

3 teen/tween DC. Strong, long-term marriage to an excellent man, father, husband. Financially very comfortable. On paper life should be good. Hated the baby years but utterly loved the primary years. Without a doubt the happiest and most deeply fulfilled time of my life.

Yet somehow despite every advantage I have I have still managed to fuck up parenting somehow to the extent that all of the DC are struggling, one very seriously. That primal love I have for them makes watching them struggle is complete torture. Against the utterly bleak outlook in the UK and globally I cannot see a good life ahead for them.

So no, I wouldn't do it again. I'm sure I would have been desperately unhappy if I had have found myself unable to have children, but at least that would have been my own suffering. I'd take that a thousand times over the situation I'm in.

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 04/01/2024 13:11

41, child free and no regrets whatsoever. I did a few years ago when I was single wonder 'should I' but put that down to societal and others expectations. Deep down I knew I didn't want to.

I see friends with children, and the posts on here and now the thought fills me with terror.

BluJanuary · 04/01/2024 13:05

Don't regret having him and what age I was (31). The only thing I would do, is do things differently (get him to sleep on his own from an early age!), put him down more so he'd hopefully be less clingy.

Saying all this but he's only 2 now!

Malara · 04/01/2024 12:57

41, two kids (4 and 8).

I wouldn't change having kids but I would change who I had them with. I'm totally exhausted after Christmas, i did 95% of the work plus carrying the mental load of gifts, tree, Christmas cards (my mother passed away so it's the only way I keep in touch with get her family), meal planning, cooking, etc, etc.

Add to that researching about how to be a better parent, making sure the kids have the right clothes, and then the gaZILLION other things you have to think about as a parent.

My advice to anyone considering having children would be VERY CAREFUL about who you decide to have children with. Ending up with a man-child and/or someone not willing to go to therapy to sort out their emotional baggage and to watch them taking it out on your kids every day is a misery and grind I wouldn't wish on anyone.

Willyoujustbequiet · 04/01/2024 12:25

I would have started a bit earlier and done it alone.

Have told changed my opinion on the value of fathers. My own was wonderful but all I see around me are narcissistic deadbeat dads that cause nothing but pain to their children and abuse to their ex wives.

Sad but true

Bringbackspring · 04/01/2024 12:18

Childfree and no regrets. But I have a deep visceral feeling in my gut that rejects the very thought of having children, so for me it's been an easy decision. I have always felt like I'm very unusual because of this. I think every child deserves to feel truly wanted by their parents (e.g. I know that my Mum absolutely loves being a Mum, and you can feel a wantedness coming from her), so to have them when you aren't convinced you want them is not fair.

I do wonder who will give a crap about me and DH when we're elderly and need support. But that isn't in my mind a good reason to have children. There is no guarantee they'll help or look after you, and it also isn't fair to expect it of them.

I don't live a high-flying life, but that's more of a personality thing than lack of means. I'm naturally quite frugal and non-materialistic. I do think I've had a very interesting and varied life though because of the freedom I've had. We have a dog, which does put some restrictions on how easily we can do some things, but nowhere near as much as having a child. We are quite outdoorsy so just take the dog everywhere with us.

The main thing I love about being childfree is that I have always been financially independent. At no point since starting my career have I been dependent on another persons income to get by. I feel very empowered by that, especially as you see so many threads on MN where women are stuck in horrible relationships because to leave would be financially devastating. I know you can be financially independent and have children, but certainly when the kids are young I don't know any women personally who fall into that category. I think it takes a heck of a lot more effort to obtain that financial independence for women with children as their is so much compromise and juggling to do.

I do feel incredibly grateful to all the people who do have children. If no one had children, society would cease to function eventually. My nieces, nephews, friends children are the people who will run society when I am old. Without them we'd all be screwed.

Hotgoose · 04/01/2024 11:52

35 with one child, I wish I’d had her earlier tbh and then I might be able to have a second but with rising costs and getting older a second doesn’t seem a sensible option.

betterangels · 04/01/2024 11:41

KimberleyClark · 04/01/2024 11:36

Yes it’s the biggest gamble, and it’s gambling with someone else’s life too.

Exactly this.

betterangels · 04/01/2024 11:40

Notadramallama · 01/01/2024 15:29

46, childfree and have never regretted it for a single second.

Same. I regret things in life but not that.

KimberleyClark · 04/01/2024 11:36

EmpressaurusOfTheSevenOceans · 04/01/2024 11:25

Regardless, how one takes to parenting still cannot be decided on simply just knowing. Too many complex factors are involved in how “enjoyable” or not parenting can be.

If you’re pretty sure you’re not going to enjoy it though, as Chintzy feels & me too, you’d have to be a complete idiot to try anyway on the off-chance.

Yes it’s the biggest gamble, and it’s gambling with someone else’s life too.

Hubblebubble · 04/01/2024 11:33

@YetMoreNewBeginnings it's not your fault.

AlltheFs · 04/01/2024 11:31

I’d have possibly had more and earlier- I thought I didn’t want any, had DD late (41) and love it.

If I had my time over I’d have had 2 or 3 and started a few years earlier to enable that. But that said, I’m happy with one and I met DH late so it is what it is.

AbsoFrickingLuteley · 04/01/2024 11:27

Drsparks · 01/01/2024 15:32

I'm erring towards not having children atm, and am mid 30s so decision time is coming!
however I think the reality of my childfree life seems to be less than I expected

I think I thought I'd be trading children for more freedom, holidays and flexibility. When in reality I live a similar life to people with children, caring for older parents, pets and rarely going abroad.

Sounds like a no brainer to me then - have a child. If you're on the fence now it sounds like you'll regret it once you're too old.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 04/01/2024 11:27

I wouldn't have changed anything about the first five children I have.

I wouldn't change the fact I intended to terminate when I found out I was pregnant again despite having a coil.

I would change the fact the sonographer turned the screen after being asked not to (they were disciplined for it) and showed me the baby which lead to me feeling unable to terminate.

My youngest has a horrible life because of serious health problems. She's had multiple operations, numerous ICU stays and very likely won't live until adulthood. Her life has been one full of pain and illness.

The impact on my other children has been massive. I'm a shell of the person I used to be the majority of the time.

I've had stick on here before from people who say that it's awful that I say that and I obviously don't love DD. I do love her. That's exactly why I wish I'd had the strength to continue with the termination. What I've subjected her to (obviously I didn't know, but it's still my fault) is something I wouldn't wish on a worst enemy. It breaks my heart every day.

EmpressaurusOfTheSevenOceans · 04/01/2024 11:25

Regardless, how one takes to parenting still cannot be decided on simply just knowing. Too many complex factors are involved in how “enjoyable” or not parenting can be.

If you’re pretty sure you’re not going to enjoy it though, as Chintzy feels & me too, you’d have to be a complete idiot to try anyway on the off-chance.

theprincessthepea · 04/01/2024 11:17

@ChintzyGunslinger that makes sense. Regardless, how one takes to parenting still cannot be decided on simply just knowing. Too many complex factors are involved in how “enjoyable” or not parenting can be.

I understand. Also find it interesting that you’ve listed all the negative stuff. People really don’t talk about that (I was definitely underprepared for postpartum) unless one decides to scroll mumsnet and other parenting sites/social media accounts for hours.

KimberleyClark · 04/01/2024 11:03

I also have been called selfish for not wanting to have children.

I’ve always put it down to a warped expression of envy/jealousy that the person feels they cannot openly express.

I have always challenged it - selfish to whom? A not yet conceived offspring? My husband, who is equally as childfree as me? My parents, who live 250 miles away - or DH’s, who are 4,000 miles away? Both sets of parents live with or near their grandchild(ren) whose parents are other siblings.

I think it’s more personal than that - it’s that they see you as selfish for preferring to live your own life doing as you please rather than nurturing children. It’s a moral judgement.

Notateacheranymore · 04/01/2024 10:54

I also have been called selfish for not wanting to have children.

I’ve always put it down to a warped expression of envy/jealousy that the person feels they cannot openly express.

I have always challenged it - selfish to whom? A not yet conceived offspring? My husband, who is equally as childfree as me? My parents, who live 250 miles away - or DH’s, who are 4,000 miles away? Both sets of parents live with or near their grandchild(ren) whose parents are other siblings.

Don’t accept the bullshit from people dissatisfied with their lives to the extent that they will shit on yours. That includes those of you that have 1 child - “oh, are you having another?!” or 2 of the same “flavour” - “oh are you going to try for a girl/boy this time?” Or even 8 children - “gosh, that’s a big family! Don’t you think that is enough?!”

The last one I heard in a school staff room from one teacher to a new member of staff. All of the children were adopted from 2 families - 3 siblings from one and 5 from the other. All power to that person and their spouse!!!

Sapphire387 · 04/01/2024 09:23

I wouldn't undo the kids I have, but with hindsight, I should never have had kids with the father of my two older ones.

He turned out to be a chronic liar with £100k of debt (really!) and I was young and naive.

kerstina · 04/01/2024 09:19

Yes happy I had DS but wish I had tried for another one .

ChintzyGunslinger · 04/01/2024 08:50

No amount of babysitting or spending time with children can really prepare you for how you will take to parenting.

My comment was more about knowing - as I did by the powers of simple observation - that I absolutely did not enjoy the company of babies, toddlers, or children of any age really.

Obviously babysitting or visiting a supermarket heaving with screaming children cannot prepare you for factors beyond anyone's control that one may experience after giving birth, such as developing a fistula, or dreadful mastitis, or any other physical, mental, or emotional problem that might occur.

Teddleshon · 04/01/2024 08:48

I would have loved to have had them a few years earlier but absolutely no other regrets.

Imobsessedwithsuccesion · 04/01/2024 08:47

Yes 100%. I'm CF by choice, 45 and loving it.

Yes I have to work (I'm self employed) and have aging parents but other than that I have my freedom. I holiday a lot and don't have pets either so nothing restricting me.

theprincessthepea · 04/01/2024 07:39

@ChintzyGunslinger No amount of babysitting or spending time with children can really prepare you for how you will take to parenting. Also the baby years are short and it’s more about who you end up with (people often forget children become teens than adults - and also they have their own personalities and traits - I once met a woman with 3 children, she seemed to love them all except the middle one who she felt had a vendetta against her - very strange). I had the opposite experience - I am the last person in the world that would offer to babysit and I’m not that into children but surprisingly really enjoy raising my own but also I have to appreciate I’ve had an OK time with childcare and being able to fulfil my own “wants” simultaneously.

@UtterlyButterly2048 I agree people are so bitter. I think what is selfish is bringing kids into the world so that you can parade around with a mini me - that mindset has always baffled me.

HamBone · 04/01/2024 00:37

Whilst I’ve been called selfish for my choice (always by women) I always knew I would be a shit parent so I don’t think it’s selfish at all.

That's so bizarre, @UtterlyButterly2048 , why would choosing to be childfree be considered selfish by anyone?!