Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Knowing what you know now, would you have still made the same decision about having children?

382 replies

Drsparks · 01/01/2024 15:20

I'm not necessarily asking if you regret it but if you had all the facts, and knew exactly how it would pan out would you have still made the same choice?

Eg
I would of had kids earlier/later.
Or
I chose not to have them because I wanted a childfree life but having lived it, I would have chosen to have kids because it wasn't all it was cracked up to be.
Or
I love my kids 100% but in hindsight I'd of probably been happier with a childfree life
or
Yes it is 109% the right choice

OP posts:
KimberleyClark · 01/01/2024 16:52

I wanted them but couldn’t have them due to fertility issues. If I had my time again I’d be childfree by choice.

HamBone · 01/01/2024 16:51

brownbutterfrangipanetart · 01/01/2024 16:48

That’s good to know! Everyone says the baby stage doesn’t last long but it seems to last forever! One child families are common where I live too :)

@brownbutterfrangipanetart When they’re small it can drag but once they’re older it seems SO long ago. I’m now the smallest person in the family, my teens tower over me. 🤣

Toastcrumbsinsofa · 01/01/2024 16:49

I’m 100% sure it was the right choice for me. I always wanted children and it was (mostly!) a pleasure bringing them up. DH and I are empty nesters now so I’m probably looking back with rose tinted glasses Smile

brownbutterfrangipanetart · 01/01/2024 16:48

Beezknees · 01/01/2024 16:39

I stuck at one because I knew I couldn't do pregnancy, birth and baby stage again. I never once regretted it.

That’s good to know! Everyone says the baby stage doesn’t last long but it seems to last forever! One child families are common where I live too :)

Ohtobetwentytwo · 01/01/2024 16:45

Completely the right choice to have kids.

Completely the right choice to decide not to have the 2 I'd planned and to stop at 1 child because I'm a better mum for it.

shamshir · 01/01/2024 16:44

Yes, I am 100% certain I'd have kids again if given the choice- they are flipping amazing and I love spending time with them.

My only regrets are my career choices- I would have gone for something very different knowing what I know now.

ZforZebra · 01/01/2024 16:43

I would have them again. I find having DC simplifies life - before I had them I often lacked direction, was too impulsive and rarely considered the full impact of my decisions. With DC your options and priorities are streamlined and pared down, which may sound like hell to many but has been really good for me. I’ve achieved my best professionally because I have them as a motivator. I’ve been more inclined to really work through conflict/disagreements with my DH because now there’s more at stake - our relationship is stronger as a result. I’m also much wealthier and more financially secure because now I actively save/invest to ensure I am not a burden to DC in my old age and can hopefully help them get on the property ladder or make major purchases when older - before I would burn through my paycheck on useless crap like clothes and takeout. I’m more interested in and active around things like climate change, politics and other issues because now I have my kids future to consider while before I was apathetic or completely disengaged. Having something bigger than myself to focus on has been good because I was quite self-centered and self-absorbed.

It helps that my DC are very easy, laid-back and make me laugh everyday (and I have a ton of support from family on both sides, nannies etc.). Parenthood has so far been much easier for me than many experiences I read on MN. It’s also made me closer to my parents because I can relate to them better and understand the decisions and sacrifices they made for us. Overall I’m glad I did have DC and wouldn’t change it, but can fully appreciate it isn’t the case for everyone who has kids. My answer is largely based on my circumstances - I can imagine many scenarios where I could regret having DC.

EmpressaurusOfTheSevenOceans · 01/01/2024 16:41

50, in peri & like several PPs, I know for sure that going child free was absolutely the right choice for me.

Cats are a whole other matter.

Mumof2NDers · 01/01/2024 16:40

Magatha · 01/01/2024 16:25

Up to when DC were around 11 years old, I'd have said yes it was the right choice to have DC.

But I now have a troubled teen (17 years). I've shared some details with people at work and have been astounded by the number of people worrying about their teenagers and young adult DC. In the past month I have spoken to people about (and these are all different people) -

DC admitted to hospital with anorexia
DC at risk of anorexica, parent has left work to look after them before they get to hospital admission stage
DC refusing to go to school
DC only going to college 50% of the time
DC addicted to weed and doesn't want to do anything else but smoke
DC transitioned a few years ago but now regrets it
DC depressed and refusing to engage with anything - no school, no work

It's such a difficult time for teenagers and mental health. The emotional strain is enormous- I know I'll be worrying about them forever more.

I know some people have the veiw that it's bad parenting. But every single person I've spoken to has raised other DC (older or younger) without these kinds of issues and I think it's societal pressure, friendships and limited mental health support that ends up with some DC struggling while others are OK. It's kind of by grace of God (in my view) if you've had teens grow up with just normal teen issues.

So if I hadn't met my DC but knew how emotionally difficult it would be to worry and worry about the, I'll say I would choose differently.

Hang on in there. It does get easier.
my oldest DS now 23 is the reason I suffered from anxiety and insomnia. He was a bit of a twat if I’m honest. He was always home well past curfew. I never knew where he was. He wouldn’t answer his phone. If I rang a few times he’d switch his phone off. When he was grounded he’d wait til I was in bed then climb out the window. I hid all his shoes (desperate measures) he took his dads.He was arrested for vandalism at 14. He took my car and wrote it off at 18!!
Thats all behind him now. He’s kind, thoughtful and loving. I’m proud to be his mum.
DS2 is 16 and is very different. He always lets me know where he is. If he’s going to be a bit late he’ll let me know. If he wants to stay out late he rings and asks. He’s just applied to join the army! 😭

fruitypancake · 01/01/2024 16:40

Love them very much and wouldn't Be without them but huge amounts of stress

daliesque · 01/01/2024 16:40

I think I thought I'd be trading children for more freedom, holidays and flexibility. When in reality I live a similar life to people with children, caring for older parents, pets and rarely going abroad.

Yeah, I'm afraid that is the reality for those of us without children. The fantasy childfree life of luxury is just that, fantasy. Most of us lead very ordinary lives because we too have to work and pay bills. The difference is that we don't have to deal with all of life's usual shit and children as well....for me, that's the advantage to not having them. I like a quiet life, a quiet house, silence and the company of my dogs and my partner only, or time on my own. I find children loud and annoying and the older j get, the less I enjoy their company.

No regrets here.

grimcas · 01/01/2024 16:39

I'm about to turn 40, very happy to be childfree and if I could go back in time I'd stay childfree.

SingsongSu · 01/01/2024 16:39

I have one of each and absolutely made the right decision. They are adults now and I have one DGC. All of my happiest moments include them and my favourite years were when I was a SAHM when they were young. That being said it’s lovely to have time with DH now, just the two of us. We definitely have the best of both worlds. Also my sister had no children by choice and she is a sad, jealous and selfish woman who is never content even though she and her DH enjoy freedom, good health and they are wealthy. I do have a close friend who has no DCs by choice and she is a wonderful person so I know not everyone is like my sister!

Beezknees · 01/01/2024 16:39

brownbutterfrangipanetart · 01/01/2024 16:32

If I knew, I would have gone child free as I didn’t realise the levels of sacrifice involved - currently in the baby stage and thinking of sticking at 1!

I stuck at one because I knew I couldn't do pregnancy, birth and baby stage again. I never once regretted it.

Wholovesabitofcheese · 01/01/2024 16:39

100% I am glad I had my dc's. I always known I wanted to have children. I had them later in life. Late thirties, youngest dc at 40. Best decision I made.

My DSIL. Never wanted children. She knew from when she was young. She has a great life. Everyone is different. I couldn't imagine not having children and my DSIL couldn't imagine having children.

MummyJ36 · 01/01/2024 16:38

Yes I’m very glad I had them when I did. I probably would have waited longer to have DC1 to give my career a bit more advancement (although I was 30 so hardly young!) but as DH is a bit older we thought better crack on with it. I feel very lucky it all worked out how it did. I’m very glad in lots of ways I wasn’t older as I think I would have become a lot more set in my ways and found the transition from “freedom” to motherhood a lot harder!

tilsmumsy · 01/01/2024 16:38

I have 3, don't regret it but knowing what I know now, I'd have started later. I wasn't particularly young (29 when I had the first) but I'd assumed getting pregnant could take a while and then I fell pregnant first month of trying. I was very very fortunate in falling pregnant with dc 2 and 3 very quickly too, so in retrospect I'd have waited until my early 30s partly to have more time just me and dh (we met and married at age 27 so didn't have a lot of time before embarking on kids) Also it would have given me more time to get promoted in my career before taking mat leave. And this was back in the early 1990s when mortgage rates went through the roof so it was financially extremely stressful with mortgage and nursery fees.

Having said all that, there's probably no 'right' time and I'm aware many people have posted here that they wish they had started earlier, so looking back I feel grateful I had my 3

Beezknees · 01/01/2024 16:38

Yes, I'd have done exactly the same. I was young when I had DS, but I genuinely can't imagine life any other way.

JadeVS72 · 01/01/2024 16:37

In an ideal world I would have conceived when I started TTC rather than taking 10 months, and I would have been well enough to have another one (or 2) but I am glad I had my only child (8) when I did (at 28) rather than waiting to be more financially stable/further on in career etc. and I chose the right dad too 🙂

clarepetal · 01/01/2024 16:37

Yes. It's bloody hard, but yes.

aSwarmOfMidgies · 01/01/2024 16:36

No I wouldn't have had children

I didn't realise how little would be done to counteract climate change and am scared about the horror we are Leaving them

TokyoSushi · 01/01/2024 16:36

I would have had them slightly younger and of if I was guaranteed to have another similar to the two that I have, I probably should have gone ahead and had that third that I contemplated.

Waitingfordoggo · 01/01/2024 16:36

I have DC. I often feel guilty about bringing them into existence because the world is such a shitshow and I don’t think I realised that when I was in my twenties which was when I had them. I worry immensely about their futures because of climate change, politics, war, AI… This is probably more about my mental health than anything else though. And that’s another layer: I wish I could have been a mum with good mental
health as my DC deserved that. I have done my best and overall I think I’ve done a decent job under the circumstances but I would have liked to have been a brilliant mum and I don’t think I have been. Rather I’ve been ‘good enough’.

If I had my time again, I’d like to think I’d make a wise choice and not bring children into a very troubled world, but I suspect I’d have them anyway because the hormonal drive was so strong for me. I desperately wanted to be a mother and can’t imagine being happy in life if I hadn’t.

And if I did make the same choice again to have DC, I’d also have two of them again, and have them at the same age (I was 28 when I had DC1 and 30 with DC2). I have friends of my age, mid-40s, with very young children and don’t envy them. Am very relieved I’m not dealing with sleepless nights and all that noise while also dealing with perimenopause.

So very mixed feelings overall!

MegaMeg2710 · 01/01/2024 16:35

I’d have had just one instead of being kind of persuaded to have another. I would’ve stuck to my guns and had her later in my life and I would’ve maybe thought about solo parenting or even coparenting with my mum instead 🫠

That said I love my mad son.

CreationNat1on · 01/01/2024 16:34

No, I wouldn't change becoming a mum at 29 and again at 30. Having a well adjusted 14 and 15 year old is very rewarding. I m separated but overall their dad is a great Co parent....... He is easily influenced on a social and attitudanal level via the lads, including lad step father, so his behaviour slips around me but overall he is a great dad.

If I ld met someone else, they might be more problematic.

So currently I would say no regrets, but navigating teenage risks is daunting.

Surround them by as many healthy role models as possible is my ongoing tactic, sport, sport, sport. Sensible sports.

If I hadn't had kids, I think I ld either be a bored high achieving professional, locked into a boring sensible image...... Or else gone off the rails myself on drink..... Who knows?