Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

PIL gave their Christmas presents from us away

433 replies

olympicsrock · 01/01/2024 13:46

PIL came to stay before Christmas. It was hard going. They are very ‘particular ‘ people. DH had a big fall out with BIL 10 years ago . We see them at family occasions only and do send gifts to BIL’s child. PIL have pushed for a reconciliation hard over the years. We get on fine with DH’s sister who has adult children but we agreed years ago not to exchange adult presents . ( kids under 18 only) .

During visit PIL gave our kids presents and the children gave them a small present back each . We agreed not to exchange adult presents then so that we all had something to open on Christmas Day.
I put BIL’s child’s gift in a bag with a label - (it was pretty full )and asked them to deliver it.
On the day that they left DH put the gifts for PIL , he says he said here are your presents ( expensive and thoughtful presents) on our kitchen table next to Christmas cards for the siblings that they would deliver . No labels on the gifts but FIL always gets a bottle and MIL loves reading ( rectangular parcel)

FIL must have put the wrapped bottle in the child’s gift bag and MIL decided that because the pile of books for her was next to a card for DH‘s sister then the gift must be for SIL .

None of them have told lazy BIL that the bottle he received ‘from DH’ was not meant for him. Awkward as he did not send birthday or Christmas gifts to our kids . They did however finally tell the lovely sister so MIL did get her gift. I am relieved because I do not want the expectation of having to buy and post and exchange gifts with adult extended family.

Today I told MIL that DH was upset about the mistake because he put time into choosing MIL’s gift. She initially said that they did nothing wrong as it was ‘obvious’ that the gifts were for the siblings and we should have labelled them.
I said that if in doubt they should have checked with us. She replied that I wasn’t there when they left and they had no doubt . I said you could have phoned and didn’t you think it was odd for you to have no gifts from us and why we were sending gifts to family who we never exchanged gifts with.

She eventually apologised in a very self righteous way for doing harm and I said no harm done but a mistake that could easily have been prevented .

She also was stroppy about them receiving a generous gift of wine from a wine merchant from
my mother that did not contain the sender details. For background my mother gives them a gift of wine every year and I was easily able to confirm that yes the gift was from the usual sender. Aaaghhh!

AIBU that they want to pretend that the gift was from DH to BIL and that they didn’t check! Accept that gift labels would have helped and have said this to DH but to be honest they would only have had a few gifts so not hard to remember.

And would I be unreasonable to suggest that DM doesn’t bother them with a gift from wine merchants next year!

OP posts:
BluesingInto2024 · 03/01/2024 09:48

I couldn't even understand from your post which gifts were given to whom and meant for whom. So yes, they should always be labelled.

I'm not sure what you are upset about as I didn't get your op but are you upset because they intentionally or carelessly regifted your presents? In my family we all do a lot of regifting. Mil does it super openly. I think she hardly every buys anything but gives away the many presents she gets. It's not mean. When she gets something she thinks me, dh or kids like she will give it to us. I used to find it odd but now totally buy into it in an effort to reduce waste.

Or are you upset because pil pretended that you gave presents to bil and sil that you aren't on good terms with to improve the relationship? A bit cheeky but to be honest I always buy something for dh or others from my parents. In this case they would want him to have something from them though but they sometimes forget and are grateful if I do it.

Either way I don't think your pil did anything terribly wrong. It sounds like it was an easy and understandable mistake to make.

Sartre · 03/01/2024 09:38

An honest mistake by the sound of things, the presents should have been clearly labelled.

ButWhatAboutTheBees · 03/01/2024 09:34

GauntJudy · 02/01/2024 22:53

Not sure why you are getting such a hard time OP, it's extremely common to let people guess which is their present based on the shape of the wrapped gift and the historic gifts that they have received.

Your bil is BU for accepting an unlabeled bottle shaped gift from his father, unless that is his allocated father gift shape of course.

This is the best response here

FarmGirl78 · 03/01/2024 08:53

olympicsrock · 01/01/2024 15:43

Because they don’t ever talk about anything… no conflict just pretend everything is ok.

I think their "no conflict" stance is much better all round than your bee in bonnet getting worked up and having to resolve everything panic. You chose to leave presents and the giving of them to DH, and he dealt with it as he saw fit. Stop making a mountain out of a molehill and just let it be. Laugh about it with him.

You keep going on about this backstory, and more having happened. So what? History doesn't mean you have to get worked up about every event since. Lots of families have these little spats, disagreement and goings on, but you come across as the insufferable DIL stoking things up. It's a very rare day I side with PILs on here. Poor them. Poor DH.

CleaningAngel · 03/01/2024 08:14

Iam lost who's present was who's just reading this post.
Silly not to label them on the pretence they are easy identifiable due to shape of them!!!

DinkyDonkey2018 · 03/01/2024 08:12

You're getting a hard time here. If I'm reading into this properly, you've had a pretty awful time of it with your BIL and have been NC about 10 years, which MIL isn't accepting and has been pushing for you all to build fences. This is the bit I suspect has got your back up as it seems like she found an opportunity to hand over the gifts to BIL to give him the impression that you and DH are ready to "make up" and she can play happy families again.

I know someone very much like your MIL who would pull something like this, and to be honest, I'm not surprised you're annoyed. The worst thing is that it's hard to prove she actually did it on purpose, so you kind of have to sweep it under the rug. Of course, it could have been a genuine mistake, but you know your MIL better than any of us.

It sounds like you've just reached the end of your tether with her. I'd let DH handle it in the future and make sure the presents are labelled!

Janieforever · 03/01/2024 07:33

Sounds like you’re really hard work op. Not just on this thread but in real life. There was a mix up. Normally people would apologise for not labelling, speak to the recipients, and not blame the recipipients for not asking or checking with ghe supplier. On what planet is that a normal way to behave.

Marchitectmummy · 03/01/2024 07:28

Feels like the gifts aren't the issue here, as of course presents handed over should have beeb labelled or in a distinguishable bag or something very clear- that's obvious.

However your comments appear full on anger, clearly there are issues, resentment, distaste between you and ils.

telestrations · 03/01/2024 07:21

If it's your DHs job to sort his families presents why concerning yourself with the whole matter and expectations, let alone taking it upon yourself to scold his mother

Nanaof1 · 03/01/2024 05:30

olympicsrock · 01/01/2024 14:52

Not all sorted out. BIL still believes we gave him an expensive gift .

So, sort that out with BIL. If he keeps the scotch, then he is a CFer.

Your DH isn't too bright by not labelling gifts. No excuses, it was a dumb move and this shit-show was the consequence.

OldPerson · 02/01/2024 23:59

PIL obviously want their sons to make up. Since PIL get the same presents every year, they knew what they were. They were just hoping that their sons would start talking if BIL thought he got a nice present from his brother. But obviously, no one except PIL want a reconciliation.

CountessWindyBottom · 02/01/2024 23:49

These types of threads are exhausting 🤣 You’ve asked ‘AIBU’, which you clearly are, and then scrap like an angry puppy when told that you are. For goodness sake! Why even bother starting a thread?

Bournetilly · 02/01/2024 23:33

Your responses are rude so I can only imagine how your MIL feels.

They obviously haven’t given BIL the present purposefully because they gave SIL one too and asked for it back. They probably feel awkward asking BIL for it back given the history.

Just leave it now and make sure your DH labels them next year. People are assuming you wrapped / labelled them as you are making a post about.

Pointynoseowner · 02/01/2024 23:19

You are being incredibly unreasonable

HarrietTheFireStarter · 02/01/2024 23:03

This thread has given me a good chuckle. 😃

GauntJudy · 02/01/2024 22:53

Not sure why you are getting such a hard time OP, it's extremely common to let people guess which is their present based on the shape of the wrapped gift and the historic gifts that they have received.

Your bil is BU for accepting an unlabeled bottle shaped gift from his father, unless that is his allocated father gift shape of course.

Bella5C · 02/01/2024 22:46

This.

Aranoo · 02/01/2024 22:43

You are equally at fault for it going to the wrong person but YABu for being so annoyed about it as it is their gift to lose or have to retrieve

pineapplecrushed · 02/01/2024 22:43

seriously? You should have labelled them.

Noglitterallowed · 02/01/2024 22:37

*No one in your house did labels

*You expected someone else to do your donkey work and deliver them for you

*You’ve had ago at your mother in law for a genuine mistake

*You’ve kicked off like a stroppy teenager when people haven’t agreed even though you asked if you were being unreasonable

f**k me sideways this post is mental!

Also in future just bloody order off Amazon and pay for gift wrap with a label if it’s really that much of a chore to write a label for a “loved one” (using the term loosely as you clearly can’t stand them)

AngelinaSpin · 02/01/2024 22:32

… you have don’t think your FIL has given the (hated) BIL the whiskey intending for it to look like a peace offering from you & DH, do you? Just a thought?

Good Night Love GIF by Pudgy Penguins
Treesandsheepeverywhere · 02/01/2024 22:05

If DH sorts presents, why did you get involved.
You'd told him to label, he didnt, so his issue to sort out.
Talking to MIL about it was unnecessary as the only fix would be for presents to be labelled next time.
Back story or not, you do owe her an apology about the presents.

Maddy70 · 02/01/2024 21:27

You didn't label them You asked them to pass on presents for you. Yabu

Jack80 · 02/01/2024 21:23

I would just label all gifts so no confusion

Densol57 · 02/01/2024 21:16

How to tell us you hate your PIL without telling us you hate them ! 🤣😂

What a load of old nonsense over labelgate! 😳