Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

PIL gave their Christmas presents from us away

433 replies

olympicsrock · 01/01/2024 13:46

PIL came to stay before Christmas. It was hard going. They are very ‘particular ‘ people. DH had a big fall out with BIL 10 years ago . We see them at family occasions only and do send gifts to BIL’s child. PIL have pushed for a reconciliation hard over the years. We get on fine with DH’s sister who has adult children but we agreed years ago not to exchange adult presents . ( kids under 18 only) .

During visit PIL gave our kids presents and the children gave them a small present back each . We agreed not to exchange adult presents then so that we all had something to open on Christmas Day.
I put BIL’s child’s gift in a bag with a label - (it was pretty full )and asked them to deliver it.
On the day that they left DH put the gifts for PIL , he says he said here are your presents ( expensive and thoughtful presents) on our kitchen table next to Christmas cards for the siblings that they would deliver . No labels on the gifts but FIL always gets a bottle and MIL loves reading ( rectangular parcel)

FIL must have put the wrapped bottle in the child’s gift bag and MIL decided that because the pile of books for her was next to a card for DH‘s sister then the gift must be for SIL .

None of them have told lazy BIL that the bottle he received ‘from DH’ was not meant for him. Awkward as he did not send birthday or Christmas gifts to our kids . They did however finally tell the lovely sister so MIL did get her gift. I am relieved because I do not want the expectation of having to buy and post and exchange gifts with adult extended family.

Today I told MIL that DH was upset about the mistake because he put time into choosing MIL’s gift. She initially said that they did nothing wrong as it was ‘obvious’ that the gifts were for the siblings and we should have labelled them.
I said that if in doubt they should have checked with us. She replied that I wasn’t there when they left and they had no doubt . I said you could have phoned and didn’t you think it was odd for you to have no gifts from us and why we were sending gifts to family who we never exchanged gifts with.

She eventually apologised in a very self righteous way for doing harm and I said no harm done but a mistake that could easily have been prevented .

She also was stroppy about them receiving a generous gift of wine from a wine merchant from
my mother that did not contain the sender details. For background my mother gives them a gift of wine every year and I was easily able to confirm that yes the gift was from the usual sender. Aaaghhh!

AIBU that they want to pretend that the gift was from DH to BIL and that they didn’t check! Accept that gift labels would have helped and have said this to DH but to be honest they would only have had a few gifts so not hard to remember.

And would I be unreasonable to suggest that DM doesn’t bother them with a gift from wine merchants next year!

OP posts:
amicissimma · 01/01/2024 15:05

"Don’t assume that Mumsnetters being women will think that a man is responsible for sorting gifts for his own family."

Well either your DH is responsible for sorting gifts for his own family (my preferred approach, though willing to help if he asks) in which case there is no need for you to get involved or comment to your ILs or anything.

Or

The gifts come from the pair of you, in which case the lack of labelling is equally down to you, it's resonable for you to involve yourself in trying to sort out the muddle you caused between you.

Either way, it is completely unreasonable of you to berate your MIL.

And you absolutely do owe her an apology, however you try to spin things.

Aquamarine1029 · 01/01/2024 15:03

olympicsrock · 01/01/2024 15:02

Bye!

Off you flounce.

JANEY205 · 01/01/2024 15:03

WTF should PIL have checked? You already out the mental load on them to give the gifts out when you could have just posted the gift for your niece…
Then there would have been no confusion. Why bother why Christmas cards if you don’t even like BIL? And your MIl asking who sent her wine isn’t rude at all!! We got some gifts at Christmas not labeled and it was confusing as hell.

olympicsrock · 01/01/2024 15:02

Bye!

OP posts:
Crochetablanket · 01/01/2024 15:02

Your fault and your DH for not labelling gifts. You were very rude to your MIL too.

You sound a bit of a nightmare tbh

Plus why are you both still holding some sort of grudge after 10 years ?
Just maybe ILs just want all their kids to get along? (- maybe the misplaced wine will reconcile you’d dh with his brother ?)

Copperoliverbear · 01/01/2024 15:02

Presents should be labelled

Muchof · 01/01/2024 15:01

olympicsrock · 01/01/2024 14:59

I owe MIL no apology at all. Without the whole backstory you guys can’t really know . But that’s another long story and I ‘d be accused of gobbledygook so won’t bother.

Yes fault on both sides , DH should have labelled the gifts but equally PIL could have checked .

Will check out of this thread now. It’s just annoying me more than I already am.

Well you do.

olympicsrock · 01/01/2024 15:01

Where did I say he got bought the same whiskey every year?? I said a bottle… It varies…

OP posts:
Sugarfree23 · 01/01/2024 15:01

Sorry Op between you and DH you dropped the ball. One of you should have labelled the gifts. It's why tags and sticky labels were invented.

The innocent people are PIL.
You & DH played a game of Chinese whispers and the information got confused.

Aquamarine1029 · 01/01/2024 15:01

Yes fault on both sides , DH should have labelled the gifts but equally PIL could have checked

No, they shouldn't have had to check. FFS.

Christmaslights21 · 01/01/2024 15:01

OP “am I unreasonable?”
Literally everyone “yes”
OP “no I’m not!” flounce
hahaha bye

BungleandGeorge · 01/01/2024 15:01

Since you like the SIL it would be perfectly acceptable for one of you to speak to her and say there Was a mix up. You hope they enjoy the whisky but would like to continue with the no gifts for adults so please don’t reciprocate. Presumably they already know this since she was asked to give the books back and did so!

pushbaum · 01/01/2024 15:00

olympicsrock · 01/01/2024 14:51

Shouldn’t have bothered with the backstory…
PIL trying to micromanage their children getting on is part of the issue.
Trying not to drip feed

That's a nasty attitude - your parents must be upset that their children have fallen out, them 'micromanaging' is probably because they'd love a more harmonious family. This whole scenario was your husband's fault and you have been really rude and demanding of your MIL, drawing her into a mess of your husband's making. He should take responsibility, you should stay out of it, end of story. You said his family's gifts are his responsibility, so by that logic you should not have bothered your MIL at all with this.

Dillane · 01/01/2024 15:00

‘doing harm’ ? Sheesh 🙄

musiquo · 01/01/2024 15:00

So is it that you think your parents in law engineered the mix up to make your estranged brother in law believe he got a gift from his brother, in the hope of encouraging a reconciliation? And also that this might get you sucked back in to adult gift giving? But you didn't give him a gift and you won't next year, so you're stressing over nothing.

jannier · 01/01/2024 14:59

Apologize

olympicsrock · 01/01/2024 14:59

I owe MIL no apology at all. Without the whole backstory you guys can’t really know . But that’s another long story and I ‘d be accused of gobbledygook so won’t bother.

Yes fault on both sides , DH should have labelled the gifts but equally PIL could have checked .

Will check out of this thread now. It’s just annoying me more than I already am.

OP posts:
AppropriateAdult · 01/01/2024 14:58

Why hasn't your husband just told his brother he was given the gift by mistake? Surely he'll be relieved to hear it, seeing as he hasn't given you a gift in return.

BungleandGeorge · 01/01/2024 14:57

If an unlabelled gift is next to a card with a name on it, it’s not unreasonable to presume they’re together OP.
the unreasonableness on your part is laying into the MIL when your husband failed to make things clear. And to suggest you tell your mum to stop sending them gifts which seems to be vindictiveness, why would you get involved there?

Aquamarine1029 · 01/01/2024 14:57

If it wasn't "your" fault, why didn't you have your husband call his mother to deal with this self-imposed nonsense?

You just wanted to have a go at your MIL me thinks.

autienotnaughty · 01/01/2024 14:56

You dh should have labelled or written on the parcels or he could have explained who's gift was who's. He's entirely at fault and owes his parents an apology for confusing things. If it was nothing to do with you, you shouldn't have spoke to mil about it. And forcing your mil to apologise (regardless of how irritating she is) was really unfair. I presume she did it to placate you because this wasn't her fault.

DuchessPotato · 01/01/2024 14:56

Imagine going to the point of telling your MIL that she has made a (genuine) mistake and then making her accept accountability! Wrongly! And then describing her as self righteous.

No words here.

Delassalle · 01/01/2024 14:56

Your fault completely for not putting a label or gift tag on each wrapped item.

You've created a drama by causing the confusion at a time when lots of gifts are exchanged!

Hankunamatata · 01/01/2024 14:55

Your dh should txt his sister and say there was a gift mix up and her dh got fil bottle of whiskey by mistake as he didn't label the gifts. Job done

CurlyhairedAssassin · 01/01/2024 14:55

You sound hard work and more "particular" than you say your PIL are.