Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

PIL gave their Christmas presents from us away

433 replies

olympicsrock · 01/01/2024 13:46

PIL came to stay before Christmas. It was hard going. They are very ‘particular ‘ people. DH had a big fall out with BIL 10 years ago . We see them at family occasions only and do send gifts to BIL’s child. PIL have pushed for a reconciliation hard over the years. We get on fine with DH’s sister who has adult children but we agreed years ago not to exchange adult presents . ( kids under 18 only) .

During visit PIL gave our kids presents and the children gave them a small present back each . We agreed not to exchange adult presents then so that we all had something to open on Christmas Day.
I put BIL’s child’s gift in a bag with a label - (it was pretty full )and asked them to deliver it.
On the day that they left DH put the gifts for PIL , he says he said here are your presents ( expensive and thoughtful presents) on our kitchen table next to Christmas cards for the siblings that they would deliver . No labels on the gifts but FIL always gets a bottle and MIL loves reading ( rectangular parcel)

FIL must have put the wrapped bottle in the child’s gift bag and MIL decided that because the pile of books for her was next to a card for DH‘s sister then the gift must be for SIL .

None of them have told lazy BIL that the bottle he received ‘from DH’ was not meant for him. Awkward as he did not send birthday or Christmas gifts to our kids . They did however finally tell the lovely sister so MIL did get her gift. I am relieved because I do not want the expectation of having to buy and post and exchange gifts with adult extended family.

Today I told MIL that DH was upset about the mistake because he put time into choosing MIL’s gift. She initially said that they did nothing wrong as it was ‘obvious’ that the gifts were for the siblings and we should have labelled them.
I said that if in doubt they should have checked with us. She replied that I wasn’t there when they left and they had no doubt . I said you could have phoned and didn’t you think it was odd for you to have no gifts from us and why we were sending gifts to family who we never exchanged gifts with.

She eventually apologised in a very self righteous way for doing harm and I said no harm done but a mistake that could easily have been prevented .

She also was stroppy about them receiving a generous gift of wine from a wine merchant from
my mother that did not contain the sender details. For background my mother gives them a gift of wine every year and I was easily able to confirm that yes the gift was from the usual sender. Aaaghhh!

AIBU that they want to pretend that the gift was from DH to BIL and that they didn’t check! Accept that gift labels would have helped and have said this to DH but to be honest they would only have had a few gifts so not hard to remember.

And would I be unreasonable to suggest that DM doesn’t bother them with a gift from wine merchants next year!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Nanaof1 · 08/01/2024 04:37

The BIL speaks! LOL!

Love how people who have nothing to add to the conversation just make uneducated, unintelligent comments and actually think they are being witty.
You succeeded doing that quite well!

Good Job GIF by MOODMAN
PomPomtheGreat · 07/01/2024 03:04

I sympathise with the issues you've been caused by your brother-in-law. I have a friend who lost their business and almost their house in very similar circumstances. She really struggles to be polite when she has to meet him. And she has similar pressure and expectations from elderly parents to play nice. It can't be easy.

Maybe think of the whole thing as some excruciatingly awful Christmas farce put on by the local community theatre. I see it as being set in a rambling old vicarage where everyone is snowed in and has to spend Christmas together against their wishes.

Presents are being left on tables, under the tree, in people's bedrooms ... The wrong people are all finding them and making assumptions about who has given them and why. The vicar's wife accidentally ends up with the lingerie meant for the person with whom the local squire is having an affair, and she decides to start flirting with him because she's fed up with her husband's sermons.

The parlourmaid accidentally delivers the stolen jewels, which were wrapped up in Christmas paper by the Butler to deceive the local police when they came to investigate, to the vicar, who finds himself in a moral dilemma. You can fill in the details for yourself!

Hopefully, you can come to think of this entire event as a similar farce that isn't worth thinking about any further.

Avoidingsleep · 07/01/2024 02:30

This was hard to read, it was like your brain vomited it onto the screen. From what I can gather…

You didn’t label them, and then made a big deal that a mistake was made. It could have been easily fixed with a couple of phone calls (all be it a slightly awkward one to your BIL), and you all could have giggled about it.

“She eventually apologised in a very self righteous way for doing harm and I said no harm done but a mistake that could easily have been prevented.” You could have prevented it, I assume what you saw as ‘self righteous’ was her feeling a mix of defensiveness and gobsmacked at your overreaction.

Also, it sounds more like she was confused and wanted to ensure she thanked the correct person for the gift of wine. Are you always slightly hostile towards your in-laws (you refer to your BIL as lazy and say he doesn’t buy presents for your kids. Does he expect you to buy for his child? Have you discussed it? Can he afford to?). If so that might be why she wasn’t sure whether to trust you.

Goodlard · 06/01/2024 18:32

Nanaof1 · 04/01/2024 21:27

On just one page, here are things posted about:
Gifts should have been labeled. How were PIL to know if the gifts were for them?
I agree, gifts should have been labeled, but some things are common sense, especially when followed by,
You/DH get the same bottle of scotch and a book every year for PIL. That's not thoughtful
Hhmmmm...so they get the same thing every year but lo and behold, THIS year they can't figure out who the recipients were supposed to be, when they were the same size as all the previous years? Sure, I understand that and will address it as soon as I sell my ocean front property with a perfect view of the Brooklyn Bridge here in Phoenix, AZ
Not getting a present for BIL's DC is just mean. An innocent child. Those "lovely people", BIL (and his wife who seems to have no mind of her own), do not reciprocate, according to PP. So, why should they continue being mugs and having THEIR DC let down because the BIL is obviously an extremely self-centered, nasty, piece of human excrement?

OP--PLEASE tell your DM to not bother sending PIL a gift next year, since they don't seem to appreciate it. I would also stop buying PIL a gift and just stick a gift certificate in their Christmas card. Just make sure it is properly labelled and sealed. Hopefully, someday, your BIL will get his just desserts for doing all that to your DH, you and your business. Your DH was wrong to not label the gifts but who knows, if MIL/FIL are so set on trying to get everyone to kiss and make-up, they might have just removed the tags and still played dumb. I think LC should be the rule for this year. The truth is, you can pick your friends, you can pick your flowers, you can pick your nose, but, you can't pick your family. All you can do is forge strong friendships that can be like family and keep some/most/all family at arm's length.

Edited

This response is as non sensical as the OP, are you connected?

LonelynSad · 06/01/2024 18:30

I've read the OP 4 times and I still don't get it

Nanaof1 · 04/01/2024 21:27

On just one page, here are things posted about:
Gifts should have been labeled. How were PIL to know if the gifts were for them?
I agree, gifts should have been labeled, but some things are common sense, especially when followed by,
You/DH get the same bottle of scotch and a book every year for PIL. That's not thoughtful
Hhmmmm...so they get the same thing every year but lo and behold, THIS year they can't figure out who the recipients were supposed to be, when they were the same size as all the previous years? Sure, I understand that and will address it as soon as I sell my ocean front property with a perfect view of the Brooklyn Bridge here in Phoenix, AZ
Not getting a present for BIL's DC is just mean. An innocent child. Those "lovely people", BIL (and his wife who seems to have no mind of her own), do not reciprocate, according to PP. So, why should they continue being mugs and having THEIR DC let down because the BIL is obviously an extremely self-centered, nasty, piece of human excrement?

OP--PLEASE tell your DM to not bother sending PIL a gift next year, since they don't seem to appreciate it. I would also stop buying PIL a gift and just stick a gift certificate in their Christmas card. Just make sure it is properly labelled and sealed. Hopefully, someday, your BIL will get his just desserts for doing all that to your DH, you and your business. Your DH was wrong to not label the gifts but who knows, if MIL/FIL are so set on trying to get everyone to kiss and make-up, they might have just removed the tags and still played dumb. I think LC should be the rule for this year. The truth is, you can pick your friends, you can pick your flowers, you can pick your nose, but, you can't pick your family. All you can do is forge strong friendships that can be like family and keep some/most/all family at arm's length.

MoonWoman69 · 04/01/2024 18:04

Bored now, let's move on and have a lovely 2024... OP has buggered off anyway, doesn't like being in the wrong clearly!

Noodlesmumm · 04/01/2024 14:45

Most bizarre thread ever

ButWhatAboutTheBees · 04/01/2024 14:28

Except there's no issue with SIL and she also got a present intended for MIL

So they can't be "forcing" a reconciliation there

And labelling WOULD have taken the excuse away

And OP shouldn't have been rude to MIL and made her apologise

Regardless of the past issues with BIL, OP is acting badly.

AuntMarch · 04/01/2024 14:23

I've only read the first page but given your snotty reply about it being your DHs responsibility why are you getting involved or making a thread about it?

AliceOlive · 04/01/2024 12:03

It is really confusing. And it sounds like they just consolidated the bottle in with the nieces gift to carry it out.

reflecting2023 · 04/01/2024 11:55

Also your OP is a bit confusing with detail about the children's presents etc not needed

reflecting2023 · 04/01/2024 11:53

Definitely should have labelled your presents easily confused otherwise especially if not delivering them yourselves

Luxell934 · 04/01/2024 11:49

AliceOlive · 04/01/2024 11:30

You also can’t get away from the fact that they well know their sons are not speaking.
I am a veteran in dealing with family members not speaking. You most especially don’t “forget” two sons are at odds.

He was lazy in not labeling the gifts, but he handed the gifts for his parents directly to them and the gift for the niece was being delivered.

I accept he gave them plausible deniability by failing to label their gifts but also because of their manipulative history, think they were trying to broker a truce by giving expensive whisky to the shit bird.

Edited

He was lazy in not labeling the gifts, but he handed the gifts for his parents directly to them and the gift for the niece was being delivered.

No as stated by the OP the gifts were left on the table, FIL put his gift into the gift bag which contained the nieces present ( I assume to be able to carry it) and the MIL present was next to a card for the SIL which is why they assumed the gift was for her.

AliceOlive · 04/01/2024 11:30

Luxell934 · 04/01/2024 11:18

Yes but you can’t get away from the fact the the present was NOT clearly labelled. Perhaps the PIL did it on purpose, maybe not. Either way it could have even avoided by a simple label.

I wonder why the husband made sure the nieces present was labelled but not his own parents?

You also can’t get away from the fact that they well know their sons are not speaking.
I am a veteran in dealing with family members not speaking. You most especially don’t “forget” two sons are at odds.

He was lazy in not labeling the gifts, but he handed the gifts for his parents directly to them and the gift for the niece was being delivered.

I accept he gave them plausible deniability by failing to label their gifts but also because of their manipulative history, think they were trying to broker a truce by giving expensive whisky to the shit bird.

Luxell934 · 04/01/2024 11:18

AliceOlive · 04/01/2024 10:53

Nah, it’s a classic case of a poorly worded and overly detailed OP.

It should have said: “We have been no contact with my husband’s brother since he stole from us and caused us to lose our business and nearly our home. DH’s parents hound us constantly to forgive and forget, yet he’s never made an effort to repay us or apologize. This year PIL handed an expensive gift clearly intended for my FIL to BIL and told him it was from us.”

Yes but you can’t get away from the fact the the present was NOT clearly labelled. Perhaps the PIL did it on purpose, maybe not. Either way it could have even avoided by a simple label.

I wonder why the husband made sure the nieces present was labelled but not his own parents?

DeeLusional · 04/01/2024 10:59

Treesandsheepeverywhere · 04/01/2024 08:56

A lot of people find Christmas exhausting, a lot have prickly relationships, a lot are neurodiverse, it doesn't excuse your rudeness.

You said it was your husband's thing to buy the presents yet now, to punish the in-laws, you're happy to 'punish the innocent child'.

Interesting when the majority say one thing yet you cling on to the two that don't.

Being snarky to pp who've called you out is an insight of how you treat those around you.

You posted for other opinions yet you're stuck on being right, or more importantly to you, the in-laws being wrong.
Narcissistic much!

Why post if you thought you were right all along?
A bit of humility will serve you well OP.

I thought OP meant a break from MN.

AliceOlive · 04/01/2024 10:53

Nah, it’s a classic case of a poorly worded and overly detailed OP.

It should have said: “We have been no contact with my husband’s brother since he stole from us and caused us to lose our business and nearly our home. DH’s parents hound us constantly to forgive and forget, yet he’s never made an effort to repay us or apologize. This year PIL handed an expensive gift clearly intended for my FIL to BIL and told him it was from us.”

AliceOlive · 04/01/2024 10:49

Buying the same bottle of whiskey every year is not thoughtful. No matter how well received it was, it scores zero in terms of thought

Matter of opinion and only relevant in the sense that ILs surely knew the present was not for BIL.

If they’d given it to anyone else I would understand.

Peaceandquietandacuppa · 04/01/2024 10:46

Muchof · 01/01/2024 14:53

It was very clear that you were just looking for a reason to have a go at MIL.

The "you" should have labelled the presents was intended for the collective you as in you and / or your husband. It was "your" (as in you two) fault.

Buying the same bottle of whiskey every year is not thoughtful. No matter how well received it was, it scores zero in terms of thought and a book every year much the same.

So you want to point out to mumsnetters that a man is responsible for sorting gifts for his family, I agree and I think the majority will. But yet in your rambling story, it was MIL (not FIL) than got the blame and you (not her son) that had to lay into her.

This!! The OP is wilfully obtuse on this fact (the “you plural” meaning her and DH. But is upset that she thinks PIL are wilfully obtuse….

Classic posting in AIBU thinking she is right and then not accepting the outcome!

purplehair1 · 04/01/2024 10:45

I am so confused by this post - at the beginning you say you don’t exchange presents between adults? Anyway, label your presents! A sharpie will do!

Goodlard · 04/01/2024 10:43

olympicsrock · 04/01/2024 08:45

@AliceOlive @DinkyDonkey2018
I’m glad at least a couple of people get the massive frustration I feel having been pushed and pushed by PIL to reconcile over the years. It just feels like manipulation. And this was on top of a dreadful 4 day visit from them.
I / we only asked them to deliver ONE present (labelled and in a gift bag) for BIL’s daughter so that a child who is innocent didn’t miss out. It wasn’t reciprocated by the way!

What I’ve taken from this is that I will not bother buying gifts for the little girl in future , yes I do resent it and will certainly not ask PIL to deliver ANYTHING .

I’m neurodiverse and find christmas exhausting. And Mumsnet didn’t feel hugely kind in this instance. If someone’s post is not clear perhaps consider that they are really stressed. Has made me think about taking a break ( which would probably do me good anyway) . 😀

Good idea to not ask other people to deliver for you, do it yourself and take responsibility for it?

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 04/01/2024 10:18

For your DH to label really I mean - using “you” as a plural for you both

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 04/01/2024 10:17

Yes it could easily have been avoided- by you labelling the gifts!

It was by no means obvious the gifts were for PIL and it shouldn’t be on them to phone you. They made a mistake but it was on you to label the gifts.

All that pressing for an apology - when it was your fault! Quite embarrassed for you.

AliceOlive · 04/01/2024 10:17

socks1107 · 04/01/2024 10:12

They weren't labelled, that's your fault not theirs.
My mum did similar this year, sent a bottle bag unlabelled that my dad said was from my sister to me. I bought a gift voucher in a panic and sent to her email confused as we don't exchange Xmas gifts.
The bag was for my daughter from my mum! So my sister was then confused as to why I'd bought her a gift but we've all laughed about it and she enjoyed her voucher which she deserved anyway

Yeah, it’s her DH’s fault for not labeling and for using his parents as winged present delivery monkeys. But they had to know the present wasn’t for DH’s arch enemy.