Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dh gets annoyed when Dd asks him to play

115 replies

Newyearnewmerubbish · 01/01/2024 11:23

Dd, 5 literally has to beg him, he gets grumpy and says ‘I’m sitting down’ then looks me up and down. He eventually gives in and storms around, makes me so sad for Dd.
Yesterday, she had friends over then I did baking with her and arranged and tidied and cooked from a small party. The day before, I took her food shopping and took her to the playground ( he asked if he needed to come)
Now he’s looking at me as if I should be playing with her as though I should be doing it, hate the way he begrudges it so much. He’s the same about bedtimes (we alternate Dds) and will ask in front of her if he has to do tonight’s or will I stop etc
He says he’s off work and should be relaxing, is it so hard to play with your child, everything is always no or I’m sitting down now.

OP posts:
SgtJuneAckland · 01/01/2024 12:13

DS is very good at self directed play and doesn't need us, he's happy to get on, but we've spent this morning building a huge Lego kit (police station, jail, vehicles etc) and playing cops and robbers. A balance is needed, I don't think children ought to dictate all of the adults' time but absolutely playing with your children is important. Your DC is getting the message that she's an irritant/inconvenience to her father and that's not ok

Notmetoo · 01/01/2024 12:10

Kendodd · 01/01/2024 11:43

Can she not play by herself?
With regard playing with her, I think we have this middle class Western idea that parents must play with their children and its harmful to their development if we don't. I heard some child development boffin on R4 once saying playing with children is completely unnecessary and so adults should only do it if they really do enjoy it themselves (and most don't). He also said that when adults engage in the sort of imaginative play children of this age want, they enviably take over and start directing play, even when they think child is leading. And that this sort of play is a child's opportunity to play at being an adult, make decisions etc. Their job is to copy what we the adults do, not for us to copy what they do, that's how they best experience and learn from play. Apparently throughout human history and across every culture, parents have never played with their children, it's just a very recent, middle class Western idea. Although I expect in the past children had lots of other children around all the time to play with so the above assessment might not be 100% appropriate to children living today.

Anyway, maybe cut some slack for both of you with regard needing to play with her. The other stuff though, bedtimes, stories, pushing her on a swing at the park, he needs to get his lazy ass into gear. If he doesn't enjoy it, tough.

Doesn't that depend on what the type of play is?
Maybe she got some games at Christmas that you can't play with alone? Maybe she wants to do things that need adult input like cooking, reading instructions etc
I am in my 60s from a working class background and I remember my parents playing card games, pencil and paper games, board games and outside games with me.

Also I think some studies show the opposite of what you site. I've that children who have active , engaged parents who enjoy spending time with them do much better.

blackfluffycat · 01/01/2024 12:10

@AndThatWasNY Oh yes I've done Lego, baking, crafts, games I just can't pretend to be someone else!!

tiredmama23 · 01/01/2024 12:10

And if my 2.5 year old wants me to get down on the floor with her and do Bluey jigsaws or build a Lego tower for the 100th time that day, and I always totally thrilled and loving life to be on the floor again doing yet another tower / jigsaw? No, course not (sometimes yes but not every single time obviously)! Do I engage with my child regardless though, and feign as much enthusiasm about the 100th Lego tower of the day as I can because I know it's important to her emotional wellbeing? Yes, I do.

That's parenting though isn't it. Doing shit we aren't always thrilled about because it's in the best interests of our children's wellbeing.

Deathbyathousandcats · 01/01/2024 12:08

Why do some people even have kids? He’s a shit dad.

tiredmama23 · 01/01/2024 12:06

@WonderLife

We cross posted very similar thoughts there! You're on my wavelength with this it seems.

WonderLife · 01/01/2024 12:06

AndThatWasNY · 01/01/2024 12:01

That's sad. It doesn't have to be role play (that is the pits- I would rather gouge my eyes out than pretend to be a character, as this seemed to entail being told I was wrong in whatever I did).
But playing with Lego, cars, some board games, cards etc etc is all part of being a parent. Boring but bonding. Giving value to them.

Totally agree, it doesn't really matter what kind of positive attention you given your child so long as you do give them some. I hate role play too and almost never do it but you can involve children in whatever you enjoy more - whether that's stories, card games, drawing - or in things you need to do. My 6 year old helped me put together some flatpack furniture yesterday. They can help you cook dinner. I fondly remember going through the car wash with my dad.

It's being rejected and told you are an annoyance and boring that is so damaging.

tiredmama23 · 01/01/2024 12:05

@AndThatWasNY

Exactly. It's any type of positive attention from her father - that's what she's really asking for. My 2.5 year old often follows me when I'm doing something as mundane as cleaning windows for example, and says "mummy I help you". She's not genuinely wanting to help me clean, obviously. She's asking for my attention and time because I'm important to her. So I give her a dry cloth and let her "pretend" to clean windows with me, and praise her etc saying she's done a great job etc. Something as simple as that and her face lights up. It's the interaction this little girl is craving, it doesn't matter what the "game" is. Toys don't even need to be involved.

tokesqueen · 01/01/2024 12:05

Dare I ask, did he want a boy?

Mrgwl29 · 01/01/2024 12:05

I don't think he's wrong to not want to play - it's boring for adults. I don't enjoy playing with my kids and try to connect in different ways.

It the huffing is more of a problem. He needs to regulate his response better and think of ways to connect with her that aren't play. Reading, baking, trips out - could even be just to run errands or a walk round the park.

I think you both need to discuss this - he needs to get out of the grump but I think don't guilt him for not wanting to play. It's so common to see women posting on here full of guilt for not playing and the thread is full of reassurance its fine not to, so why would it be different for fathers?

AndThatWasNY · 01/01/2024 12:01

blackfluffycat · 01/01/2024 11:29

Not helpful my parents never played either me and me and dh don't play either our kids. Do you mean role play etc?

That's sad. It doesn't have to be role play (that is the pits- I would rather gouge my eyes out than pretend to be a character, as this seemed to entail being told I was wrong in whatever I did).
But playing with Lego, cars, some board games, cards etc etc is all part of being a parent. Boring but bonding. Giving value to them.

tiredmama23 · 01/01/2024 11:59

Dd, 5 literally has to beg him, he gets grumpy and says ‘I’m sitting down’ then looks me up and down. He eventually gives in and storms around, makes me so sad for Dd.

The message the little girl is getting here is, I'm an inconvenience / unimportant to my Dad, and it makes him annoyed when I ask for some of his attention, so it's wrong to do that.

That's not a healthy message for a 5 year old little girl to be getting about her relationship to one of her parents. I feel so sad for her 🙁 Thank goodness she has the OP as a mum to mitigate the effects of that.

tiredmama23 · 01/01/2024 11:56

TheShellBeach · 01/01/2024 11:40

You're heading for a divorce and it sounds like he won't even want contact with your DD after a few months.

Sadly, I agree with this forecast.

blackfluffycat · 01/01/2024 11:55

@WonderLife

If he doesn't like role play he could offer to do lego, board games, crafts, read a story with her instead?
Sounds like he just doesn't want to do anything with her if he is moaning about putting her to bed in front of her

😥 DH never did any of these with ours. Neither did my parents. I'm realising this isn't normal.

tiredmama23 · 01/01/2024 11:55

Kendodd · 01/01/2024 11:43

Can she not play by herself?
With regard playing with her, I think we have this middle class Western idea that parents must play with their children and its harmful to their development if we don't. I heard some child development boffin on R4 once saying playing with children is completely unnecessary and so adults should only do it if they really do enjoy it themselves (and most don't). He also said that when adults engage in the sort of imaginative play children of this age want, they enviably take over and start directing play, even when they think child is leading. And that this sort of play is a child's opportunity to play at being an adult, make decisions etc. Their job is to copy what we the adults do, not for us to copy what they do, that's how they best experience and learn from play. Apparently throughout human history and across every culture, parents have never played with their children, it's just a very recent, middle class Western idea. Although I expect in the past children had lots of other children around all the time to play with so the above assessment might not be 100% appropriate to children living today.

Anyway, maybe cut some slack for both of you with regard needing to play with her. The other stuff though, bedtimes, stories, pushing her on a swing at the park, he needs to get his lazy ass into gear. If he doesn't enjoy it, tough.

Sorry but I disagree that this applies to this situation.

No, we don't need to be actively playing with our children 24/7, but this little girl is asking her father for some of his time and being rejected. In OP's words, she has to "literally beg" her Dad for some attention. That's potentially emotionally damaging to a little girl, to feel that level of rejection from one of her parents.

Saschka · 01/01/2024 11:51

Kendodd · 01/01/2024 11:43

Can she not play by herself?
With regard playing with her, I think we have this middle class Western idea that parents must play with their children and its harmful to their development if we don't. I heard some child development boffin on R4 once saying playing with children is completely unnecessary and so adults should only do it if they really do enjoy it themselves (and most don't). He also said that when adults engage in the sort of imaginative play children of this age want, they enviably take over and start directing play, even when they think child is leading. And that this sort of play is a child's opportunity to play at being an adult, make decisions etc. Their job is to copy what we the adults do, not for us to copy what they do, that's how they best experience and learn from play. Apparently throughout human history and across every culture, parents have never played with their children, it's just a very recent, middle class Western idea. Although I expect in the past children had lots of other children around all the time to play with so the above assessment might not be 100% appropriate to children living today.

Anyway, maybe cut some slack for both of you with regard needing to play with her. The other stuff though, bedtimes, stories, pushing her on a swing at the park, he needs to get his lazy ass into gear. If he doesn't enjoy it, tough.

Totally depends on what kind of playing though doesn’t it?

Mine has wanted to: play connect 4, play football, have a freestyle competition with his monster jam trucks, and measure him doing a long jump challenge onto our sofa. None of which he could have done alone, and none of which we directed him to do. I agree if we had more children he could have played with them instead, but we don’t.

rwalker · 01/01/2024 11:50

I massively struggle with things like this playing games and thing like that and found it hard work as someone else pointed out I can never remember my parents doing that with me

fast forward 3 years when kids were older bike swimming outside stuff there weren’t enough days in week to do things worked out fine as wife detest things like this

I think different people engage more with different stages

MiIIieee · 01/01/2024 11:50

Hes an awful Dad

WonderLife · 01/01/2024 11:44

blackfluffycat · 01/01/2024 11:29

Not helpful my parents never played either me and me and dh don't play either our kids. Do you mean role play etc?

If he doesn't like role play he could offer to do lego, board games, crafts, read a story with her instead?
Sounds like he just doesn't want to do anything with her if he is moaning about putting her to bed in front of her.

It must make your DD feel really shit about herself @Newyearnewmerubbish

Precipice · 01/01/2024 11:44

said he just wants to relax and how can I be sat there on my phone doing nothing

So why does he think he gets to relax, but you don't? He's literally saying 'I just want to relax; how can you be sat there relaxing?!" This is blatant.

Kendodd · 01/01/2024 11:43

Can she not play by herself?
With regard playing with her, I think we have this middle class Western idea that parents must play with their children and its harmful to their development if we don't. I heard some child development boffin on R4 once saying playing with children is completely unnecessary and so adults should only do it if they really do enjoy it themselves (and most don't). He also said that when adults engage in the sort of imaginative play children of this age want, they enviably take over and start directing play, even when they think child is leading. And that this sort of play is a child's opportunity to play at being an adult, make decisions etc. Their job is to copy what we the adults do, not for us to copy what they do, that's how they best experience and learn from play. Apparently throughout human history and across every culture, parents have never played with their children, it's just a very recent, middle class Western idea. Although I expect in the past children had lots of other children around all the time to play with so the above assessment might not be 100% appropriate to children living today.

Anyway, maybe cut some slack for both of you with regard needing to play with her. The other stuff though, bedtimes, stories, pushing her on a swing at the park, he needs to get his lazy ass into gear. If he doesn't enjoy it, tough.

TheShellBeach · 01/01/2024 11:40

You're heading for a divorce and it sounds like he won't even want contact with your DD after a few months.

DelurkingAJ · 01/01/2024 11:39

YANBU on the face of it but I can see that if your DD cannot and won’t ever entertain herself then it can get a bit much. I have been known to refuse to play a game with DS2 (7) because I’ve already played two this morning and I’d like 15 minutes to drink coffee in peace. I don’t think that’s awful, or unusual. When DSs were tiny of course it was a bit different…but there comes a point when DC’s wants shouldn’t always override adult reasonable wants.

BrightGreenMoonBuggy · 01/01/2024 11:36

You definitely aren’t BU. He’s making it really clear that he doesn’t want to play with her - it’s not even a private thought which he hides. I think it’s fine and fairly human for him to feel this way (eg think ‘oh god - please leave me alone - I really don’t want to play make believe when I’m knackered!) but it’s not ok to keep making that clear to a young child. As you’ve already started to notice / worry, it’s going to make her feel rejected. So he needs to be told to grit his teeth and at least make an effort to spend some time doing it, even if he would rather sit and watch tv.

Some people just shouldn’t really have had children because they treat them as a hassle that interrupts their free time. If he continues to make her feel like this, then he’s one of those people.

Newyearnewmerubbish · 01/01/2024 11:35

I’ve just had a go at him and said he shouldn’t be huffing and puffing as though it’s a chore for him in front of Dd. He got upset/annoyed and said he just wants to relax and how can I be sat there on my phone doing nothing, I then listed examples of things I’ve done all holidays-all the planning, all tidying, food shopping, cooking, baking with Dd, taking her out etc

OP posts: