Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be selfish and not reveal my past?

109 replies

TinaTurner1980 · 01/01/2024 10:33

Name changed for obvious reasons…

Ive been married to DH for 15 years and have 2 DC. He comes from a really lovely family who I now proudly call my own and we really get on. It makes me so proud that I have given my children something I never truly felt growing up - love, safety and stability and I owe that to them.

I didn’t have the best of childhoods, my mum was a single parent and took drugs. She’s clean now but it meant that as a child my house was chaotic and unsafe. Things happened in my childhood that shaped me and by 20 I ended up partying all the time and eventually addicted to drugs myself.

It was a really rough time when I did things I wasn’t proud of but I came through, got clean, went back to uni and built a good career in a sector helping people like me. I met DH who knows all about my past, managed to buy a nice house ( something I never even dreamed I’d be able to do) and had kids.

Anyway, so me and SIL get on REALLY well. She’s a great aunty to my kids and I’ve grown to really care about her. She’s been really unlucky in love so unfortunately hasn’t had any kids but has been talking about this amazing man she’s dating for a couple of months and how she thinks he’s the one etc.

Yesterday she brought him to our NY party to meet us and when I saw him I had to run and hide in the bathroom. I knew him quite well when I was younger, he was a dealer and someone everyone was quite scared of on my estate growing up. He either didn’t recognise me or pretended not to and it has been over 20 years…

Now I don’t really know what to do and haven’t slept all night…DH knows about my past but not every detail and my in-laws don’t know any of it. They’re not from a background like mine, I doubt they’ll understand and this man knows things about me that might make them hate me.
So…

YABU - to not tell her. She deserves to know even though he might tell her and the rest of your in-laws all about your past. Even if you lose everything it’s not fair on her to keep it a secret.

YANBU - He might have changed like you, it was 20 years ago, she’s an adult and it’s not worth the risk.

OP posts:
zigzag716746zigzag · 01/01/2024 12:33

OP I think @Pinkdelight3 makes some really good points here …OP's panicked response is really more about her own issues with her past, the shame and the side of her that she feels she's laid to rest but not so peacefully - maybe she needs some safe space to talk it through with a counsellor and work on healthily reconciling the girl she was with the woman, wife, mother and in-law who she is now, rather than seeing them as separate worlds that could collide.

Ohtobetwentytwo · 01/01/2024 12:32

Say nothing. She wont dump him on your word. If he abuses her and she stays, she would have anyway.

magnitude100 · 01/01/2024 12:30

I agree with @Pinkdelight3

magnitude100 · 01/01/2024 12:28

If someone has never needed to resort to crime then they come from a very privileged background.

Wtf?

Pinkdelight3 · 01/01/2024 12:27

if they guy had really changed and done the work, then he wouldn't have the slightest hesitation being open about it. He would have honesty and transparency as core values, and wouldn't contemplate secrecy or deception.

I don't agree with this. OP has not told many people about her past and isn't at all open about it and has good reason to have made that decision. Likewise this guy doesn't have to go around telling everyone he was a dealer 20 years ago. That doesn't make him deceptive. Maybe he'll tell SIL if the relationship gets serious like OP's did with her DH, but that still doesn't mean SIL would tell OP, in the same way OP hasn't told her ILs about her past. It's long in the past and really none of OP's business unless any other red flags arise with this guy.

Absolutely would not be sending any anonymous notes either. I feel like OP's panicked response is really more about her own issues with her past, the shame and the side of her that she feels she's laid to rest but not so peacefully - maybe she needs some safe space to talk it through with a counsellor and work on healthily reconciling the girl she was with the woman, wife, mother and in-law who she is now, rather than seeing them as separate worlds that could collide.

zigzag716746zigzag · 01/01/2024 12:27

For me it depends on what you mean by people having been scared of him. Is he/was he violent? I am guessing yes. And yes people do change and turn their lives around, but it’s also true that sometimes hard-man violent drug dealers end up in that occupation because they are already violent and it gives them power.

Genuinely, how would you feel about your kids being looked after by him alone, if he ends up being their uncle?

I would also advise that you are probably overestimating how much your extended family would be shocked or care that much about your past. For you it is front and centre and something you feel ashamed of and inferior because of. For them it would be a bit of a surprise. An “oh, really?” moment and move on. They have know you for years. They know who you are. What you did as a teenager is not as important to them as who you are now.

pickledandpuzzled · 01/01/2024 12:25

Please don’t tell everyone! Just DH, and he can tell his sister. If he has done as you have, he shouldn’t be outed any more than you should be.

He may have been honest with Sis.

369damnshesfine · 01/01/2024 12:21

I wouldn’t judge anyone for stuff they did 20 years ago (unless it rape or something).

He sounds like a pretty normal lad who found a way to make money but has now got out of that life and has his head screwed.

We all sometimes do things to cope in difficult times.

If someone has never needed to resort to crime then they come from a very privileged background.

magnitude100 · 01/01/2024 12:18

TinaTurner1980 · 01/01/2024 12:07

Honestly, thank you so much for all the supportive posts. So glad I found mumsnet! ❤️

His SM seems to check out. Says he works for a recruitment company like SIL said. He’s got a LinkedIn and I can’t find anything obviously dodgy but I will definitely tell DH tonight.

Edited

If you checked out his Linkedin he will know this..but I’m sure you knew this.

You have nothing to be ashamed of btw, be proud of yourself because you deserve it.

OrlandointheWilderness · 01/01/2024 12:16

Just don't say anything! You've changed your life, maybe he has too?! You have no idea if she is aware, but it's not really your business.

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 01/01/2024 12:16

For me. Yes he might’ve changed but you don’t know. If he has convictions eg for stealing then this could mean an impact on SIL eg entering another country like USA in the future.

But yes discuss with DH.

A few people I’ve known and socialised with in the past, we went clubbing did drugs. We’re all grown up now. The odd person did deal drugs. We don’t see each other now so it wouldn’t bother us.

Staniam · 01/01/2024 12:12

Look, if they guy had really changed and done the work, then he wouldn't have the slightest hesitation being open about it. He would have honesty and transparency as core values, and wouldn't contemplate secrecy or deception.

Discuss this with your DH. You might also ask the bloke himself if he intends to disclose his past to your sil.

TinaTurner1980 · 01/01/2024 12:07

Honestly, thank you so much for all the supportive posts. So glad I found mumsnet! ❤️

His SM seems to check out. Says he works for a recruitment company like SIL said. He’s got a LinkedIn and I can’t find anything obviously dodgy but I will definitely tell DH tonight.

OP posts:
Drinkinggreentea · 01/01/2024 12:03

You need to tell everyone now because he WILL tell people about you anyway. There's no way if they're super serious that this won't come out and you'll look very shady and deceitful at that point. It's better to control the narrative and also to protect your sister in law. You don't have to go into detail about your past and it's really none of their business anyway but you do need to say that you're shocked and worried and why.

Bex5490 · 01/01/2024 12:02

pickledandpuzzled · 01/01/2024 11:46

Reframe your past. You overcame tremendous disadvantages to achieve a stable, sober present and you worked hard for it.

I would consider asking DP what he thinks as well. That is your prime responsibility, and he needs to be involved in your decisions. He may not what his family to know your past- and that’s ok.
He may be able to tell his sister that you have a history you have worked hard to escape, and want to help her avoid becoming someone else with a shitty ex!

Absolutely this.

I think you have to tell DH as honesty is something you currently have and you definitely don’t want to lose.

You have nothing to be ashamed or embarrassed of. In your first post you attribute your children’s stability and positive upbringing to DH’s family but it is in fact you who created that life for them out of more challenging circumstances than they could possibly understand.

If I found this out about a relative it would make me love them more for their strength not hate them for a life or upbringing I could never understand.

Talk to DH and let him handle it with his sister. ❤️

JingleSnowmanTree · 01/01/2024 11:59

Is he using his real name now? Was he then?

How much time did you spend with him last night?

you had a crap start in life, you were young when you took drugs & when you were with your Ex. Yes you did some awful things (steal & cover for your ex etc) but you were young & vulnerable. You stopped all that, now you need to stop feeling guilty about it!

what could he tell your DH that he doesn't know? I'd definitely get in there first. I'd also do some searching online to see if there's anything recent there.

talk to DH first, but be clear that you're going to talk your SIL, you owe her that.

upwardsonwards · 01/01/2024 11:52

You have to tell your DH. If it turns out the guy is the same as ever, if he ever pulls you aside, he may feel he has sway over you. Don’t give him that power. Speak to your DH now. He can decide what to do re his sister.

ElFupacabra · 01/01/2024 11:46

Also, if you were a smackhead he probably doesn’t recognise you after all this time. You’ll look older but also a lot different as you’re clean and healthy now.

pickledandpuzzled · 01/01/2024 11:46

Reframe your past. You overcame tremendous disadvantages to achieve a stable, sober present and you worked hard for it.

I would consider asking DP what he thinks as well. That is your prime responsibility, and he needs to be involved in your decisions. He may not what his family to know your past- and that’s ok.
He may be able to tell his sister that you have a history you have worked hard to escape, and want to help her avoid becoming someone else with a shitty ex!

FurballFrenzy · 01/01/2024 11:45

This is a tricky one, because in your situation I’d probably want to warn her too, but I think you need to ponder the fact that you feel it’s your right to hide some of your history from your family, but you also feel he doesn’t have the same right to keep his past to himself.

Also, for all you know he’s come clean about everything in his past to her and she’s just keeping it to herself, in the same way your DP has.

Like I said, if it was my SIL or sister I’d likely still want to tell her out of concern he hasn’t changed but morally I think I’d find myself a bit of a hypocrite, especially if one of your worries is that he will spill details of your past.

ElFupacabra · 01/01/2024 11:45

Are you sure SIL doesn’t already know about his dodgy past? People keep mentioning her safety but if OP has changed then he could have too!

If your in laws won’t understand she won’t want his past gossiped about and spread around either so I don’t think, even if he did mention it to SIL it would go any further as she wouldn’t want her parents to know his background.

shiningstar2 · 01/01/2024 11:39

And if he hasn't recognised you ou your secret is still safe even after you've told sil. Just need to say you have evidence, have heard ....

shiningstar2 · 01/01/2024 11:37

I would watch and wait op. You only saw him for the first time last night after a gap of twenty years. He may be like you and have changed. His relationship with sil might fizzle out. Could you try to find out more about him before you move on this? If he's still dealing ext no question ..your sil should be told straight away. If he's changed ...well you can give him the same chance you've had. If he was a dealer you would have been one amongst many so he may not recognise you. If he's changed he want to out you and be outed himself. If he hasn't you tell sil and he's out of everybody's lives. 💐

MayThe4th · 01/01/2024 11:36

I think there are certain things about the past which you don’t have the right to leave there, and IMO having been a dealer of hard drugs is one of them.

It doesn’t matter whether he’s turned his life around, the fact is she has a right to know who he is so she can make an informed decision.

Having taken and been addicted to drugs is one thing, tbh as someone’s partner I would want to know that but wouldn’t feel it necessary for anyone else to know, but these things happen, people do it, people get past it, but dealing drugs is on a whole other level and most people wouldn’t want to be involved with someone with that kind of past, not least because of the likely contacts they have and the risk that even having turned around someone with that kind of background would pose to them and potential children.

SIL absolutely has the right to know.

crostini · 01/01/2024 11:32

It's been 20 years so I'd give him the benefit of the doubt and wouldn't say anything to SIl, other than mention that you vaguely know him as you used to be local.
That way you won't look like you've pretended you don't know him.

It's highly unlikely that he's got any deep recollection or stories about you. I wouldn't worry about him.

Swipe left for the next trending thread