Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be selfish and not reveal my past?

109 replies

TinaTurner1980 · 01/01/2024 10:33

Name changed for obvious reasons…

Ive been married to DH for 15 years and have 2 DC. He comes from a really lovely family who I now proudly call my own and we really get on. It makes me so proud that I have given my children something I never truly felt growing up - love, safety and stability and I owe that to them.

I didn’t have the best of childhoods, my mum was a single parent and took drugs. She’s clean now but it meant that as a child my house was chaotic and unsafe. Things happened in my childhood that shaped me and by 20 I ended up partying all the time and eventually addicted to drugs myself.

It was a really rough time when I did things I wasn’t proud of but I came through, got clean, went back to uni and built a good career in a sector helping people like me. I met DH who knows all about my past, managed to buy a nice house ( something I never even dreamed I’d be able to do) and had kids.

Anyway, so me and SIL get on REALLY well. She’s a great aunty to my kids and I’ve grown to really care about her. She’s been really unlucky in love so unfortunately hasn’t had any kids but has been talking about this amazing man she’s dating for a couple of months and how she thinks he’s the one etc.

Yesterday she brought him to our NY party to meet us and when I saw him I had to run and hide in the bathroom. I knew him quite well when I was younger, he was a dealer and someone everyone was quite scared of on my estate growing up. He either didn’t recognise me or pretended not to and it has been over 20 years…

Now I don’t really know what to do and haven’t slept all night…DH knows about my past but not every detail and my in-laws don’t know any of it. They’re not from a background like mine, I doubt they’ll understand and this man knows things about me that might make them hate me.
So…

YABU - to not tell her. She deserves to know even though he might tell her and the rest of your in-laws all about your past. Even if you lose everything it’s not fair on her to keep it a secret.

YANBU - He might have changed like you, it was 20 years ago, she’s an adult and it’s not worth the risk.

OP posts:
Kwam31 · 01/01/2024 14:43

It's double standards if you're terrified of your past coming out but everyone's saying tell SIL about this guys past. So protect your secrets but blow his life up?
You've turned your life around in the twenty years so likely he's done the same.
I'd keep your mouth shut, leave the past behind.

lastchristmas80 · 01/01/2024 14:14

Another vote for sharing with your DH and seeing if can collectively find the best approach- after all it’s his sister involved?

AcrossthePond55 · 01/01/2024 14:01

@TinaTurner1980

It's a hard one. But just as you wish to conceal your past from DH's family & your children because you aren't that person now, maybe it's the same with him.

Did you share your past with your DH right away or did you keep your secrets until you knew him better? If so, shouldn't this man be given the same opportunity?

I agree with talking to your DH. But I think I'd be tempted to take a 'watch and wait' position for a bit. Maybe DH or you could 'sound out' your SiL about what she may know about him or what he's said about his past. 'Innocent' questions about a new bf aren't unusual so it shouldn't raise any suspicions.

Icedlatteplease · 01/01/2024 13:55

Perhaps suggest she does a Claires (or is it sarahs) law request. Given you work in the area I would say you recognise the names but aren't sure if it's the same person.

Either way if he has history this safeguards your sil

Frangipanyoul8r · 01/01/2024 13:50

There’s nothing to say this relationship is going to last. If she’s thinking of marrying him and having kids with him she may want to know, otherwise stay well out of it.

Itsbritneybitch22 · 01/01/2024 13:49

Ok the advice you said was a good idea is an awful idea, you would be lying and he can just say actually since she’s brought it up this is how it really was and list all the things that you did do?

No judgment at all from me but did you do sexual things for him to get drugs? Or prostitution to pay for drugs too because something in one of your posts made me think there’s more to just the taking drugs element, especially as your husband knows about your drug history.

I know it’s embarrassing and you don’t want to deal with it or your children to find out and I think that if you’re honest that is your main concern? I think honestly I would leave it unless it comes up and you’ve built a life with your husband he won’t leave you over things from 20 years ago.

I do find it interesting that 2 children from a well to do family have gotten into relationships with people that are from totally different ways of life but maybe their pasts aren’t all so Rosie as you think? It’s not always poor people that end up on very hard drugs.

MeMySonAnd1 · 01/01/2024 13:41

I would just mention to DH, so he knows and is prepared to deal with the situation if his sister comes to tell him that her boyfriend used to deal drugs to you.

magnitude100 · 01/01/2024 13:34

I don’t think you should say anything . It’s not your right to gossip about his past .
How would you feel if he did that about you

This.

Fidgety31 · 01/01/2024 13:32

I don’t think you should say anything . It’s not your right to gossip about his past .
How would you feel if he did that about you ?

it’s not your relationship so you should keep out of it . You risk alienating your sister in law if she sees you as interfering in her relationship.

Everyone has a past and everyone has the capability to change . It’s not up to you to decide who should know what about his past .

DNLove · 01/01/2024 13:23

Maybe he's sat at home wondering if he should tell SIL that he knows you and about your past. Maybe he's been honest about his past with her already and you'll look like a trouble maker of you go in too quickly. I'd let it to play out a bit, tell DH you know him but looks like he's turned life around like you have. Don't say anything yet. If you get a chance in future at a family event, just say to him in a friendly way "aren't you a blast from the past" to show you know him and hold no shame. Then you'll get a sense of his personality now.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 01/01/2024 13:20

First of all, ruddy well done for the way you've turned your life round and built a much better one Flowers

As for your SIL's relationship, I suppose you could say that you know of him and his activities rather than having been involved in them yourself, but overall - and as PPs have said - you may be better off telling your DH and leaving it up to his judgement

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 01/01/2024 13:20

lemmein · 01/01/2024 12:55

My BIL went to prison for dealing and has been to the US over the last few years; though I know he had to jump through a lot of hoops and it wasn't just a case of buying a ticket and packing his case!

He was sent to prison for about 5 years, 25 years ago. He's never been in trouble since and now runs his own business and has a family.

OP, I'd probably just say something like 'oh god, I remember him, I thought he looked familiar - he was a wrong'un back in the day, what's he like now?' and see where it goes from there. He could've turned his life around like you - maybe google him to see if any recent convictions come up.

You've done amazing to get to where you are now; don't be ashamed of your past, you've overcome it, it's something to be proud of!

It depends if they declare it on their ESTA or not and what it was.

I knew a stupid man who was a drug dealer over here, got arrested and did spent a short time in jail (not just for dealing). He went to Vegas, did something stupid involving drink I think, they looked into his background (he’d got into a fight but hurt the other man more) and he winded up in jail, for a period of 6 months, with a fine, he got fired from his job over here once they knew! His wife had encouraged him to lie on his ESTA as it was “in the past”.

Most petty criminals I know (I’ve known some) I’ve got no idea what they do now. One is my ex best friend’s older brother, a nasty piece of work, who when her DM got ill and died recently was arrested as he threatened his sister who’d been caring for their mum, he certainly hasn’t changed one bit.

ActDottie · 01/01/2024 13:19

TestingTestingWonTooFree · 01/01/2024 10:36

Can you confide in your DH? He may have a better idea of how to approach it.

This I think first thing is to tell your DH and see what he thinks.

sunights · 01/01/2024 13:16

YANBU - you wouldn't want him to "out" you, so why on earth would you do this to him?

Pinkdelight3 · 01/01/2024 13:14

Your DH can refer to your mum taking drugs if you feel comfortable about it, not you.

Hmm, feels very double-standardsy - tell SIL about his drugs past, but don't mention OP drugs past. Quite dramatic to imagine attacks and car crashes based on who he was decades ago. Definitely talk to DH but hangfire on the rest unless there really are hints of things in the present and then you can talk about that in the present anyway, no need to open this closet of skeletons. If he's dealing or using now, then that's the issue, not what he did in his youth.

LlynTegid · 01/01/2024 13:08

If there is any hint that he is still taking drugs or a dealer, or was in recent years, then your SIL needs to know. You would not want her to go through the pain of him being attacked or something happening to her house, or a car crash, for example.

Best I think via DH. Your DH can refer to your mum taking drugs if you feel comfortable about it, not you.

magnitude100 · 01/01/2024 13:03

369damnshesfine · 01/01/2024 13:02

You obviously come from a privileged background then.

You shouldn’t judge OP or this man for the choices they made due to their background.

Who says I did?

Icelandic9 · 01/01/2024 13:02

I wouldn't say anything yet personally

369damnshesfine · 01/01/2024 13:02

magnitude100 · 01/01/2024 12:28

If someone has never needed to resort to crime then they come from a very privileged background.

Wtf?

You obviously come from a privileged background then.

You shouldn’t judge OP or this man for the choices they made due to their background.

lemmein · 01/01/2024 12:55

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 01/01/2024 12:16

For me. Yes he might’ve changed but you don’t know. If he has convictions eg for stealing then this could mean an impact on SIL eg entering another country like USA in the future.

But yes discuss with DH.

A few people I’ve known and socialised with in the past, we went clubbing did drugs. We’re all grown up now. The odd person did deal drugs. We don’t see each other now so it wouldn’t bother us.

My BIL went to prison for dealing and has been to the US over the last few years; though I know he had to jump through a lot of hoops and it wasn't just a case of buying a ticket and packing his case!

He was sent to prison for about 5 years, 25 years ago. He's never been in trouble since and now runs his own business and has a family.

OP, I'd probably just say something like 'oh god, I remember him, I thought he looked familiar - he was a wrong'un back in the day, what's he like now?' and see where it goes from there. He could've turned his life around like you - maybe google him to see if any recent convictions come up.

You've done amazing to get to where you are now; don't be ashamed of your past, you've overcome it, it's something to be proud of!

Nonimai · 01/01/2024 12:52

I am going against the tide here, but I wouldn’t say anything for now. You have changed. He might have changed. He might have done a stint in prison and completely turnedhis life around for all you know . Stay quiet, be kind, and learn more about him and the current situation.

StockpotSoup · 01/01/2024 12:49

Or send the SIL an anonymous letter revealing all about him, then you don't need to come into it.

This is a very bad idea. At best, all it does is worry the SIL, with nothing to back up the assertions and the accompanying upset of a “poison pen” letter (which is what it could seem like). At worst, SIL tells her boyfriend, who actually has recognised OP and knows very well the letter will have come from her, and shares absolutely everything she would prefer stayed buried.

zingally · 01/01/2024 12:47

A similar thing happened to me, but it turned out to be a case of mistaken identity.

I went round for dinner at my best friends house, and her DH was there. He's a lovely man, and someone I've known for 20 years. Not a bad, or mean bone in his body. I'll call him "Bill".

I took a couple of photos, and put them up on FB when I got home.

About an hour later I got a panicked sounding FB messenger alert from a girl, "Mel", who I went to primary school with. Basically asking who Bill was, and asking if his name was "Ted"? And if he was Ted, I should get away from him hard and fast. She'd had a short relationship with Ted in her early 20s, and he was an abusive, violent drug addict. She said she was very worried, and if I need any further information, she was happy to talk.

I was able to reassure he that it wasn't "Ted", but the sweet and loving husband of my best friend, "Bill". A man I'd known since my late teens.

She came back to me, relieved, but shocked at home physically alike they looked.

I was, and still am, very grateful to Mel for reaching out to protect me. As it happened, there was no danger. But she was prepared to open a really vulnerable part of herself to help another woman who was, she thought, in danger. It's women protecting women.

In your case, I'd definitely raise it.

Fullofxmascbeer · 01/01/2024 12:43

I wouldn’t make a big thing if it.

I’d just say to her that he didn’t have the best childhood like you, that he had a reputation when you knew of him, but that you assume he’s changed. But that you hope he’s been honest with her and if he hasn’t then she needs to take her time falling for him.

You don’t need to go into too much detail, just that you think dealing drugs were involved but obviously 20 years have passed and he’s unlikely to be that same person now.

MorganKitten · 01/01/2024 12:34

You stopped taking drugs and straightened up right? Why wouldn’t he be ale to do the same? Like you said it’s been 20 years.

Swipe left for the next trending thread