Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

OP posts:
Deathbyfluffy · 01/01/2024 12:56

peakygold · 01/01/2024 10:47

I know quite a few people who top up their benefits by buying stuff at jumble sales and then selling it on for a few quid. Tax has already been paid on pre-loved goods, so I cannot fathom why there should be a "tax implication". Also, online sellers pay the platform for the ability to sell, and the platform pays taxes. Greedy, greedy Tories.

With all due respect, you need to learn how taxation works - and this isn’t a Tory policy.
It’s how taxation has worked since it was created; tax can be levied multiple times during a product’s lifespan.

EatMyHead · 01/01/2024 12:52

Somatosensational · 01/01/2024 10:16

How are they going to determine what the original price was?

If you're a business buying and selling things then you need to keep records of what you paid for them, along with all other expenses. The difference between that and what you gain from selling them is your taxable profit.

HMRC can't just come along one day and decide that a SINGLE TRANSACTION is taxable. The transaction is either a being made by a business (in the widest sense, including sole traders) or an individual. HMRC deciding that the transaction is taxable is part and parcel of deciding that that person is actually running a business, in which case ALL their similar transactions become taxable as well, and they have to do all the usual bookkeeping of a business in connection with this.

The point being that there is no possible reason why HMRC would want to do this for a bunch of transactions that are, overall, going to make a humungous loss. They would just be massively increasing their own work while not gaining any tax receipts and in many cases giving people opportunities to reduce their overall tax.

Cornflakelover · 01/01/2024 12:45

On EU platforms Occasional sellers who sell less than 30 item or less than 2000 euros won’t be reported as a seller
but I don’t know if that applies to the uk as well

Cornflakelover · 01/01/2024 12:43

It’s a new law
followed on from the new law in the Eu called DAC7 . If you search that you will understand what it means

its already in place in the EU has been since Jan 2023 - loads of people on digital platforms in the EU are kicking off because they have only been told recently that they have to supply tax ref numbers / or National insurance equivalent and home address and if they don’t supply the details they can’t use the platform until they hand it over and they

its for people who sell on digital platforms
sales of goods
Fixed property
personal services
transport ( so Uber and similar )

The uk has just started the same for platforms like eBay Amazon Etsy Uber eats deliveroo fiver basically any uk based that has sellers on it
The platform have to collect info on sellers on the platform on how much they have earned via selling on the platform and report this back to HMRC in Jan. 2025

it starts today - runs till Dec 24 and details are sent to HMRC in Jan 2025

if a seller won’t give their details which are
address
NI number or tax ref
then the seller is blocked from using the platform till they hand it over and they can withhold any money that is owed

The overall plan is that eventually all digital platforms report earnings to tax department of wherever the seller is based so eventually EU platforms will report to the UK and likewise

So someone who is using AirnB to advertise a property in Spain and lives in say the USA
airb ( Spain ) will report how much the person has made in total via the platform to the american tax authorities.

I recently read a post where an american guy had a property in Spain and asked if the person renting it would go off platform to pay for it as if he was to go via the platform the platform will report that as a booking even though he is based in the USA

zingally · 01/01/2024 12:34

My parents made an absolute killing on Ebay, back in the very early 00s, when Ebay was pretty new.
They were selling books to Americans, on niche hobbies. Doesn't sound like an instant money-maker. But it earnt enough for 4 of us to have a very high-end 2-week touring holiday to western Canada, and then some.

Hoardasurass · 01/01/2024 12:22

SmellyKat10 · 01/01/2024 11:12

Meh. If it’s a business then fair enough.

ive always wondered why they don’t tax lottery wins and other windfalls like that though. Surely if you win £25 million on the lottery you should pay something..?

You pay the tax as part of the cost of the ticket, ie your taxed on the bet not the winnings. Whilst this may seem counter intuitive it actually earns the government more tax than just taxing the winnings, due to all the fees, charity donations and wages which comes out of the ticket price (along with the tax bill) before the remainder is allocated for winnings, whereas when you tax the bet you get the tax on the whole cost of the bet (which the lottery is) before all deductions.

ElderMillenials · 01/01/2024 12:14

I can't see it actually happening in an inconvenient way, the same way hmrc aren't going after the million/billionaire tax avoiders. It's a scare headline and empty threat.

Maybe somewhere like Etsy with the hundreds of shops selling cricut crafts will start to see sellers asked to self asses. I imagine a lot aren't declaring. But at the same time most probably aren't making that much.

The actual businesses avoiding tax on larger earnings aren't online, and will be cash payments.

Deathbyathousandcats · 01/01/2024 12:05

lol, not gonna happen.
HMRC couldn’t monitor a car boot sale in their own car park. They haven’t the staff, the skills, or the inclination.

LamePanda · 01/01/2024 12:05

@EatMyHead I asked this question upthread! I’m self-employed with a completely different area from ‘retail’. I regularly sell clothes the kids have grown out of, or things I’ve impulse bought but not needed, etc. I do spend recklessly and then have to get rid of the clutter regularly, as I get overwhelmed by having too much stuff. (Thanks ADHD.) My items always sell for less than paid for originally.
if HMRC want to come after my eBay/vinted selling, more than happy to offset those losses against the sizeable chunk of my income I pay through SA!

JaceLancs · 01/01/2024 12:04

I used to sell on eBay regularly and probably turned over £2-3k a year - but they were all mine and DC clothing shoes, toys, handbags etc, jewellery id got bored with - I always buy secondhand and aim to get back about what I’d spent in first place
I get bored easily especially with clothing
A few years ago I dieted away 6 stone and sold off all my bigger clothing

Somatosensational · 01/01/2024 11:59

@MandyMotherOfBrian exactly. I won’t be handing my NI number over either.

OP posts:
MandyMotherOfBrian · 01/01/2024 11:54

No issue with paying any tax that is due. I only sell my own belongings but it’s second hand clothes that sell for less than they were purchased. Won’t attract tax even it goes over £1,000.00 Pa. But I do have an issue handing over my NI number to eBay. Who already have my name and DOB and other identifying information. What guarantee is there from eBay that data is safe. As soon as they ask for a NI number, I’ll stop using them, and as pp said, boot sale.

LlynTegid · 01/01/2024 11:47

HMRC chasing tax avoiders. About time. Just don't stop at those selling on EBay and other selling sites, take on companies and places alleged to be money laundering such as vape shops.

Zwicky · 01/01/2024 11:46

If you bulk buy a fuck ton of stuff and resell it in online selling platforms then you are running a business and should pay appropriate taxes the same as everyone else. I know 2 people who sell loads online. One buys new items from discount retailers like home bargains and sells on eBay for small profits. It’s mainly pet supplies but some DIY and “home” things too. She doesn’t make much but she is a benefit claimant and I’m not sure where the line should be drawn with that. It’s not like she’s seen a bargain and thought “I could resell that for £5 more” and having a fiver - she’s doing it over and over and generating a small but consistent income. Is it ok if it’s £5 a month? What about £100 a month? What if she made £1000 a month? Is it fair that someone working in a part time job for £1000 a month pays more tax and is entitled to less government support than someone generating a £1000 a month income from selling online? I don’t think it is.

My other friend who sells massive amounts is a fashion queen. She buys loads from vinted but also buys loads new and sells it fairly quickly. Lots of her clothes she keeps only for a few weeks - lots is bought for a purpose and sold after one wear. She must has a higher turnover than my dog treat selling friend but will have a net loss as she buys lots new and sells used. She has a professional job and isn’t a benefit claimant. On paper her vinted income is probably many £1000s a year, but so is her vinted spending. HMRC could spend 3 seconds looking at her credit card spending in asos, Zara, JL, Boden etc and see that she just is a woman who updates her wardrobe with vigour.

I’ve had a huge declutter this year and sold about £2000 worth of stuff on vinted and eBay and marketplace. The most expensive thing was £250 - for something that retails at about £1200 new. Lots of kitchen appliances I don’t use sold at about 20-30% of their new value - LOADS of kids clothes - some quite smart “designer” adults clothes that were bought for special occasions. I’ve “lost” £1000s despite the occasional gain of selling something for a small amount more than I paid for it on vinted myself. If HMRC want to tax me on declutterring (they don’t) then I would process it all through DHs limited company and probably reduced his tax burden by more than I actually sold the stuff for.

When does the “little guy” online retailer spill over into “massive capitalist Tory”? Does it depend on the goods for sale? The mark-up? The turnover? The social class of the seller? If Michelle Mone sold her shit PPE on eBay would she be the persecuted underclass if she was asked to declare profits?

TeaGinandFags · 01/01/2024 11:39

Somatosensational · 01/01/2024 10:16

How are they going to determine what the original price was?

Ebay differentiates between used and new items.

I'd wager that HMRC are looking for undeclared businesses rather than ordinary people shifting surplus stuff.

Surely, I can't be the only person to notice a preponderance of businesses on what was supposed to be a site for individuals?

tescocreditcard · 01/01/2024 11:36

They are also going to be using information supplied by Airbnb so make sure people have declared that income.

They have employed an additional 40 full time new members of staff to deal with this. 40. At any one time, half of them will be on leave/off sick/in a meeting/in training.

I can't see how it can be done to be honest and I wouldn't spend a second worrying about it. In fact, I'm not gonna declare my Airbnb business. I'll risk it. Highly, highly unlikely to be found out.

maddiemookins16mum · 01/01/2024 11:35

HMRC can barely cope with their normal workload, weeks for UTRs to be issued, months for P87 claims to be paid out, they even closed their SA line for weeks back in the summer to focus on their horrendous backlog. I doubt they’ll redeploy staff to check on someone selling a bundle of 0-9 months girls clothes.

SmellyKat10 · 01/01/2024 11:32

hellojelly · 01/01/2024 11:20

Because the way the UK tax system works is that for all gains you potentially have allowances you can offset. To tax the lottery you'd have to allow people to offset any gambling losses they'd made too. You would, however, be substantially taxed on the interest you'd make on winning £25 million.

Thank you! That has always bugged me!

hellojelly · 01/01/2024 11:27

EatMyHead · 01/01/2024 11:25

Thanks! I'd always wondered about this too but that makes complete sense.

I'm an accountant and this was one of the first questions I asked my first boss when training, so I understand the curiosity 😂

wronginalltherightways · 01/01/2024 11:26

redhatwhitebeard · 01/01/2024 10:17

Hilarious that the government spend money monitoring this, but are quite happy to not chase after their mates who they gave billions dollars PPE contracts to and didn't deliver, or the billions that was fraudulently claimed in furlough payments etc! One rule for the average Joe and another rule for those multi millionaires who like to tax dodge!

100%

PIck on the little guys trying to scrape a living, protect their wealthy friends and themselves.

EatMyHead · 01/01/2024 11:25

hellojelly · 01/01/2024 11:20

Because the way the UK tax system works is that for all gains you potentially have allowances you can offset. To tax the lottery you'd have to allow people to offset any gambling losses they'd made too. You would, however, be substantially taxed on the interest you'd make on winning £25 million.

Thanks! I'd always wondered about this too but that makes complete sense.

EatMyHead · 01/01/2024 11:23

Actually regarding my last post, it would be even worse than that from HMRC's point of view. If casual selling of household items were suddenly called "business", then a lot of people who DO have self employed businesses could integrate both "businesses" for tax purposes and make a lower paper profit or even a loss. It would be a massive own goal on HMRC's part.

hellojelly · 01/01/2024 11:20

SmellyKat10 · 01/01/2024 11:12

Meh. If it’s a business then fair enough.

ive always wondered why they don’t tax lottery wins and other windfalls like that though. Surely if you win £25 million on the lottery you should pay something..?

Because the way the UK tax system works is that for all gains you potentially have allowances you can offset. To tax the lottery you'd have to allow people to offset any gambling losses they'd made too. You would, however, be substantially taxed on the interest you'd make on winning £25 million.

SaturdayGiraffe · 01/01/2024 11:16

Just don’t run a business and claim it’s personal?

Meanwhile on our high street there’s a hairdresser who insists on cash or bank transfer (to Croatia) and a nail bar and two take aways cash only.

20 American Candy shops on Oxford St, a vape shop every 50m, empty barbershops by the dozen.

TBH if selling platforms want to operate here then I have no issue with HRMC forcing them to provide information. These platforms avoid paying UK tax at every opportunity (especially Airbnb), do the bare minimum of customer service, and reap vast rewards from users. Let them do some legwork.

EatMyHead · 01/01/2024 11:15

They've been talking about this for years and years. I can't see how it will work without people getting caught in the crossfire who shouldn't be. They say they're looking for people receiving more than £1000 a year, but that could easily be someone selling their personal possessions.

It's possible that someone could have a turnover of £1000+ in a year from selling personal possessions, but that wouldn't mean there would be a tax liability. In the vast majority of those cases the possessions would be sold at a loss, simply because second hand goods are cheaper than new. So if HMRC did insist on them making a tax return there would be no tax to pay anyway.

And if HMRC did view such activities as a "business", the income and expenditure would be cumulative for the whole year: ie, if you sell ten items and for some reason one of them makes a profit, it would still be offset by the losses made on all the others.

So the very worst that being "caught in the crossfire" would mean is an increase in bureaucracy. In practice however, I very much doubt HMRC would use this to get people registered as businesses who really aren't. HMRC hate unhelpful bureaucracy as much as anyone, particularly when it costs them in man hours and overhead to process without actually bringing in any more tax receipts. There's no reason they would want to get a whole load more people submitting SE tax returns and then paying nothing.