Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

10 year old, 8 year old and a newborn? AIBU?

91 replies

StudyWorries · 01/01/2024 09:16

DH and I already have 2DC and have always wanted a 3rd but life events have meant that we haven’t had one yet. We are 35 and 36yo, if that’s of any relevance.

To give the full picture, we are not home owners as DH is provided accommodation as part of his employment, but we will need to have a home of our own in about 5 years time. We have £30k in savings.

Are we BU to have one more child in these circumstances?

OP posts:
Whinge · 01/01/2024 10:24

I hadn’t considered that they would need to stop sharing? I shared a room throughout my teen years.

They might be happy to share at 8 + 10 but it could be a very different story when you have a 10 and 12 year old. As they get older most children prefer their own space to study, hang out with friends and relax without being bothered by a sibling.

SlightlygrumpyBettyswaitress · 01/01/2024 10:22

My 2 eldest were 10 and 13 when we had our 3rd.
Absolute delight. Oldest 2 doted on her.
But we are now mid fifties with a school age child.

MyDogsPaws · 01/01/2024 10:20

@StudyWorries when I was a teen my options were share a room
or sleep in a cupboard and I chose the cupboard 😂 I think my kids would do the same if they had the option!
I guess it depends on the kids but I have a 13 yo and an 8yo sharing and the 13 yo really struggles not having her own space especially if she wants to have friends over.

tralalalalalalalal · 01/01/2024 10:19

The age gap is fine! I had my youngest sister born when I was 14 and I loved helping to look after her. Now she's the last one at home and I'm sure my parents love that they haven't got an empty nest just yet.

StudyWorries · 01/01/2024 10:17

Really grateful for all of the different perspectives so far. I suppose my biggest concern is not owning a home and whether our financial situation is secure enough.

OP posts:
StudyWorries · 01/01/2024 10:16

Our children already share a room. I hadn’t considered that they would need to stop sharing? I shared a room throughout my teen years.

We also already have a large car, so no issues on that front.

OP posts:
MyDogsPaws · 01/01/2024 10:08

I had an accidental no 3 and to be honest it’s made housing a complete nightmare, once you have to start looking for 4 bed houses it’s a lot more expensive and harder to find anything suitable so that is something you should take into consideration if your hoping to buy a house in the near future. At the moment i’m resigned ti having 2 kids share but it’s causing so much drama and stress!

Mummyoflittledragon · 01/01/2024 10:05

Teens are expensive. There are no free activities for teens. Clothes, food, school stuff etc. This all adds up. If you want to buy your own home, I’d think seriously about your priorities as you may end up having to make a choice.

Nevermind31 · 01/01/2024 10:02

I am 11 years older than my youngest sibling (4 years older than middle one).
Adored them as a baby (apart from when they woke everyone up at night with their crying), found them annoying as a toddler, embarrassed when I was a teenager and we had to do toddler outings/ had friends round but needed to be quiet because of nap time. little relationship once I got to older teens/ moved away to uni.
now (40s/30s) we have a great relationship, and of course wouldn’t want to miss them.
Personally I would not want to go back to the baby years, life is just getting easier. Holidays are relaxing again…
Then there is the financial aspect… can you afford £1500 a month in nursery fees? Buy a house big enough for all? Or will oldest have to share so baby can have own room?

Wetweatherandmud · 01/01/2024 09:58

I had this exact age gap and it worked brilliantly. I wasn't in a great financial situation and was a single parent, but it was fine. The older children really helped with the little one and it was the easiest baby experience I had.

They are really close and best friends, travelling together and in touch every day. The age gap hasn't mattered at all.

I was 36. I'm so happy that I had my third and have adorable grandchildren too!

OakTree16 · 01/01/2024 09:58

I have an 11yo, 8yo and 3yo, so still a reasonable age gap. I have found the change from 2 to 3 children really challenging. It’s hard to find things to do that entertain them all due to their ages. However the two older boys are excellent big brothers to their little sister. The biggest problem I have is dealing with the constant arguing and bickering between the older two boys and then trying to also entertain a 3yo little girl.

AndThatWasNY · 01/01/2024 09:55

Just to warn you the older ones are about to become expensive. Teens are like paying for adults (they eat more than us, they wear adult sizes etc

ShoesoftheWorld · 01/01/2024 09:54

BiffandChip1 · 01/01/2024 09:43

We have 3, 2 boys 4 and 2, and baby is 4m. All works fine because age gaps are very close (18m and 2y1m) but I'd not want to do it with a big gap. 3 is full on because you don't have 3 hands 🤣

I suppose this shows how 'horses for courses' this is - having had two close together, I didn't feel I could have managed a third with a similar gap. Dd did come along a couple of years later than we'd hoped due to miscarriages, but we'd still have been looking at a 5- or 6-year gap minimum. The gap we had actually worked out very well because once dd was a toddler the older two were old enough to go off and (for example) look round a museum or see a film by themselves for a bit while we did something small child-friendly and met up with them later.

PumpkinPie2016 · 01/01/2024 09:53

I personally wouldn't.

Firstly, my son is 10 (I only have 1 child) and the gap between him and a baby/toddler is huge. At 8 and 10, your children are at a lovely stage - more independent, able to do more and I would think, similar things, no nappies/weaning/lugging prams etc. I think adding a baby into the mix would make things very difficult. Your current children will want to do very different things to a baby and that could be hard to manage.

It's also important to consider how the current children would feel/be impacted by the arrival of another baby. It would be quite a big upheaval at this stage.

Financially, if you have a 3rd, you're likely to need a larger car, need to buy baby stuff again and then, when buying a house, you will really need 4 bedrooms, whereas currently, 3 would be fine. In 5 years, your older two will be teens and even if they are the same sex, they will be at a stage of needing privacy and space for homework etc. So sharing isn't really going to be an option and neither will want to share with a child of a maximum age of 4.

Ultimately, only you and your husband can decide but personally, I would stick to the 2 you have.

CanImakethisbetter · 01/01/2024 09:52

crumblingschools · 01/01/2024 09:46

Remember you have the expense of teenagers to come just as you will be looking for accommodation. Also if any of your DC go to university you need to factor costs of that too

This is a really good point. People often don’t think about the cost as they get older and university.

I have 6 years between mine, I only have 2. One in university. It’s not cheap.

Op might already have an expensive time of it with 2 in uni at once. By then, a larger mortgage for a larger house. And extra child at home.

It’s definitely something to consider. Not just finances for the next 5 years.

Kurokurosuke · 01/01/2024 09:52

We had a 12 yo and 10 yo when we had our third (at ages 37 and 40). It has been wonderful. I am so much more relaxed and the dynamics are much better than expected. Oh course all the normal worries (money, life logistics l) are there, but for us it was a great decision.

SEG152 · 01/01/2024 09:51

This question can’t be answered by anyone but you and your partner. Everyone has their own individual feelings and opinions on the size and time line of their family. If you really want another baby and feel this longing won’t go away then go for it. Only you know the answer to this.

Whinge · 01/01/2024 09:49

mamacorn1 · 01/01/2024 09:46

I was the third child in this scenario. My sisters are 8 and 10 years older than me. I was effectively raised as an only child and my two older sisters always resented the fact that I came along - none of us are close.
please think about the dynamics of your family will change, because there is a real knock on effect to the older ones.

This is also a good point and worth thinking about. It's also been my experience that many of those who have a baby after a big age gap often end up having another, so 3 becomes 4, as they worry about the youngest feeling like an only child. Then you have 2 sets of children at different stages of their life and are stretched too much to meet the needs of either group.

crumblingschools · 01/01/2024 09:46

Remember you have the expense of teenagers to come just as you will be looking for accommodation. Also if any of your DC go to university you need to factor costs of that too

mamacorn1 · 01/01/2024 09:46

I was the third child in this scenario. My sisters are 8 and 10 years older than me. I was effectively raised as an only child and my two older sisters always resented the fact that I came along - none of us are close.
please think about the dynamics of your family will change, because there is a real knock on effect to the older ones.

ShoesoftheWorld · 01/01/2024 09:45

I had exactly the gap in your OP and it's been great, but, perhaps crucially, we don"t live in the UK with the horrific cost of childcare and we were happy to adapt holidays etc to the situation rather than expecting to be able to do the standard '2adults, 2 dc' things. We also didn't have a bedroom for a few years so the dc could have a room each. They are 18, 16 and 8 now and the older two have always adored their little sister. We often do stuff separately (one parent takes older two to gig, other parent takes dd to children's concert) but still do a lot together as a family - museums, long country walks, beaches, cooking and eating.

Mariposistaa · 01/01/2024 09:45

YABU in the sense you have 2 lovely children at lovely ages where you can enjoy them, go on fun days out and holidays, play games as a family, not juggle bedtimes and pushchairs etc. And you have more money and time to give them. Another child would ruin all that.

BiffandChip1 · 01/01/2024 09:43

We have 3, 2 boys 4 and 2, and baby is 4m. All works fine because age gaps are very close (18m and 2y1m) but I'd not want to do it with a big gap. 3 is full on because you don't have 3 hands 🤣

PPTorPDF · 01/01/2024 09:40

YourNameGoesHere · 01/01/2024 09:23

Personally I think you'd be bonkers to go back to the baby days when you've got two children who are getting to an age where they will allow you more independence again but if you both want one then that's your choice.

This. My sister and a few of my friends did this and now struggle in school holidays to do days out that are suitable for both toddlers and teenagers. It's usually the older ones that miss out doing what they want to do and end up sitting at soft play type place every day.

Neodymium · 01/01/2024 09:40

I wouldn’t, the baby will miss out because older siblings won’t want to do the same things as the teenagers. I have 3, 14 12 and 10 and it’s hard finding a middle ground for things all the kids will enjoy. I have a friend who had kids 5 and 6 and then a baby and the baby (who is now 20) was left out her whole life as they did things the older 2 liked and not her. She didn’t go to parks or playgrounds or anything much and was kind of made to grow up quickly