Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

10 year old, 8 year old and a newborn? AIBU?

91 replies

StudyWorries · 01/01/2024 09:16

DH and I already have 2DC and have always wanted a 3rd but life events have meant that we haven’t had one yet. We are 35 and 36yo, if that’s of any relevance.

To give the full picture, we are not home owners as DH is provided accommodation as part of his employment, but we will need to have a home of our own in about 5 years time. We have £30k in savings.

Are we BU to have one more child in these circumstances?

OP posts:
NameChangeAgain23 · 01/01/2024 12:17

I have that age gap. I’ve found it tough in some ways (school run, older kids evening activities, the fact I get very little child free time as often I leave baby to sort older kids etc, plus their bedtime is later, level of housework etc) and in other ways easier. Kids dote on him, beeline to play, cuddle him when they are home. All 3 faces light up when they see him.

cost wise, I’m on month 3 of paying nursery and that’s not much fun! I get a lot of things second hand from vinted so that helps a lot

SkankingWombat · 01/01/2024 12:14

PinkPlantCase · 01/01/2024 10:27

Different POV but I currently have a newborn and a 2.5 yo. Life would be so much easier right now if DS was 8yo and not 2 🙈

For you, but how about for (theoretical) 8yo DS? Would he appreciate having his more grown up activities and days out replaced for ones suitable to the baby/toddler/preschooler? Having established extra curriculars cut back to cover nursery fees? Having to start keeping all his toys up out of the way in case DC2 swallows a small piece or breaks a prized Lego build through heavy handling?

I have a 7 and a 9yo. Nothing could compel me to add a baby into the mix at this point. The life in the trenches of the baby days are long gone, and everything is easier (although well aware this may change again in the teen years!). I have no desire to return to the slog of sleepless nights and nappies, and can't see any enhancement it would add to my current DCs' lives. They would each get significantly fewer resources (time, money, space etc) but without the positive of companionship a similar-aged sibling brings. Also, DD1's hormones are already on the move - negotiating her movement into and through puberty whilst also being chronically sleep deprived with a small human limpet or rampaging toddler to manage would be hell.
The financial aspect makes it all even more crazy IMO. As PPs have pointed out, your bigger family needs a bigger house and then there are the nursery fees. Unless you are expecting a huge promotion in the next year, this alone will leave you significantly worse off. Then, whatever money you have left for DCs now has to be split 3 ways instead of 2. What things do DCs do now that they would be expected to drop to fund their sibling and additional housing needs?

Poorlycatadvicewanted · 01/01/2024 11:41

I have 4 OP and rent. Owning a home is irrelevant. As long as you have a roof over your head. However, there are 18 months to 2 years between each of them. Eldest 10, youngest 4 and now the older 2 are 9 and 10 I couldn't imagine going back to baby days. However, I have 4 already so that plays into it.

I have many friends who have kids with a big age gap and it works for them. If you like the baby stage and happy to do it, then go for it. But it will be difficult, as a pp said activities won't line up age wise. But in a few years your older ones will be teens, and doing more of what they want anyway.

It's all personal choices. What works for one family, won't work for another

OhmygodDont · 01/01/2024 11:39

We are also building in the garden to provide another bedroom and livingroom.

OhmygodDont · 01/01/2024 11:38

At this ages I personally wouldn’t also you already have two sharing one room? I’m going to hazard they are both the same sex, if you have a third and say go from boy boy girl then suddenly the new baby once out of your room gets its own bedroom while the other two are sharing so you will end up with two teens sharing while a toddler gets his/her own room. The older two are highly unlikely to be very keen on the fairness of that.

We have three. 15,12,7 and the gap of things to do with the 7 v 12 and 15 on holidays and trips is something we will have to consider. It was quite a shock actually our first holiday realising just how big of a gap we had. For us the younger two are The same sex so they share a room with a privacy arrangement and luckily the youngest was an amazing sleeper.

I certainly wouldn’t unless some kind of emergency situation be having three to one bedroom especially with a large gap. Imagine a teenager trying to revise with a toddler/very young child.

VladimirVsVolodymyr · 01/01/2024 11:36

Thanks @ShoesoftheWorld that's lovely!

Guavafish1 · 01/01/2024 11:36

go for it

Ormside · 01/01/2024 11:35

I have DC1 aged 28, DC2 19 and DC3 17. They are full siblings, people often assume the older one is a half brother due to the gap. It felt like we completely started again with DC2 (it's easy to forget how exhausting the baby and toddler stage is), and it could be difficult to choose family activities that suited all when they were younger.

If you're prepared for that and your parent friends to also be at different stages in life then go for it. I have no regrets.

I felt at times I almost wished the eldest DC's life away looking to the next stage, rather than enjoying living in the moment. I also didn't appreciate how quickly the loveliest stages passed by, such school nativities, Santa, etc. With DC2&3 I cherished those moment.

Eldest DC says he had a wonderful childhood and we're very close but I do feel guilty at times that his early life taught me how to be a more relaxed parent his much younger siblings. There's no sibling rivalry and the younger two adore and look up to their much older DB. They will both play key parts in his wedding later this year.

FreshWinterMorning · 01/01/2024 11:35

I know the urge to have a third one when you've got two kids is immense (when the youngest one gets to sort of 10 to 12 years old.) I've had it myself (I have 2 girls less than 2 years apart.) I was in my early 40s at the time and I even came off the pill and tried. (DH wanted to too!) It never happened. I was disappointed for a year or two, but I am so glad now. (So is DH.)

I'd have been 43 or 44 when the third one was born. I can't believe I even thought of doing it. This was like, 15 years ago, and I would have had a junior school age child at 50, and a child in their early teens now when I'm knocking the door of 60. It fills me with absolute horrors just thinking about it. Shock

Since 49-50 y.o. (nearly a decade,) me and DH have had an empty nest, as our 2 DDs left home in quick succession, one year after the other and never came back (both went to uni.) We both love our girls dearly, and enjoyed every second of raising them, but that part of our life is done, and I can't imagine why we thought about starting over with another one when they were virtually teenagers, and almost independent.

Having an empty nest at 50 was wonderful. Having a full one for 20 years was wonderful, but having an empty one at 50 and not having to worry about young/school age children anymore is lovely! We now have 2 intelligent, successful, brilliant young women - with their own home - who are now our adult daughters - and our best friends.

I know you're a bit younger but you'll still be in your early 50s, with a child in their early to mid teens. Instead of being early 40s with a child in the early to mid teens. Honestly how much more tired and weary you feel, and how many more health problems you have in your early 50s, compared to early 40s, you can't even imagine.

I see a few people on here thinking having a baby at 41-44ish, and they think it's great idea because they feel really great and healthy and young - but don't underestimate what the menopause does, and how your health can change in that one decade - early 40s to early 50s...

Also, unless you're actually very well off, on six figures, have your home paid for, and have a few hundred thousand pounds put away, don't do it. It's going to be hard enough with two as they grow up - with school, college, university, trying to help them financially. We struggled financially for quite a years, and only came out of struggling properly when they left uni as we are not on massive salaries, just average like most people. Don't put more struggling into the mix. Stick with two children. It's a perfect number of children. (So is one!)

ShoesoftheWorld · 01/01/2024 11:34

VladimirVsVolodymyr · 01/01/2024 10:56

@ShoesoftheWorld I have similar age gaps. Can I ask how their relationship with the youngest progressed through the early teenage years? All good at the moment 😂

Fabulous. She has always been their favourite person. They won't hear a word against her. Any irritations (inevitable from time to time) have been minor and short-lived. Dc1 has decided he doesn't want any children, but I'm really not sure she's the cause Grin

369damnshesfine · 01/01/2024 11:17

margotrose · 01/01/2024 10:59

I wouldn't. Your kids are finally at an age where they're becoming independent - why would you want to go back to the baby days?!

I agree!

Focus on both of your careers and getting a home where your kids can have their pen rooms.

Right now you’re at risk of a baby having to share a room with an 11 and 9 yo, which would not be fair to them.

Focus on the kids you have.

Beautiful3 · 01/01/2024 11:10

No. You don't even own a home. I'd honestly look at buying a flat, to rent out. By the time husband retires, you could move into the flat. Someone I know was a school caretaker, with free accommodation. He was there for years, with little savings. He was let go, and they were suddenly homeless. It's a scary prospect. I'm not saying your husband would be sacked. But he could leave due to ill health or die prematurely. It would be most sensible to buy a small property to rent out, as the value would continue to rise over time. Otherwise you'll struggle to get a mortgage past 50.

margotrose · 01/01/2024 10:59

I wouldn't. Your kids are finally at an age where they're becoming independent - why would you want to go back to the baby days?!

caringcarer · 01/01/2024 10:58

My DC were 10 and 8 1/2 when I had a third DC. Third not planned but very much loved. I didn't find it hard for the first year. The next 2 years were more difficult as I could not find many activities all 3 DC liked except petting zoos. Then when the youngest in school is ok again because older DC are doing their own thing more. Middle DC and youngest both boys and very close now both adults. It helped that they always had their own rooms. It would have been much harder if trying to put a 10 year old in the same room as a toddler.

VladimirVsVolodymyr · 01/01/2024 10:56

@ShoesoftheWorld I have similar age gaps. Can I ask how their relationship with the youngest progressed through the early teenage years? All good at the moment 😂

HMW1906 · 01/01/2024 10:56

Honestly I wouldn’t. My friend has a 8 year age gap not through choice (now 9 and 18m) and she struggles to come up with activities/days out that cover both ages….although she did say the newborn stage was easier as the 8 year old was fairly self sufficient and happy to play on his Xbox while she sorted baby.

Also £30k isn’t a massive amount for a house deposit and having another baby would seriously put a dent in your ability to save more. I’d concentrate on increasing the house deposit so that you can be more financially stable when you need to buy a house in 5 years.

VladimirVsVolodymyr · 01/01/2024 10:50

@CandycaneParcel we are a family of 5 and never had any issues with booking hotel rooms. We used to book family rooms as opposed to double rooms as a family of 4, so continued to do so as a family of 5 even on holidays. But I do get your point about finances. Also I think sometimes having kids so close together (less than 2 years gaps) can be very intense on both kids and parents. Child rearing is intense on its own but having multiple toddlers and babies can magnify it and cause stress between siblings. Just my thoughts 😂

ShoesoftheWorld · 01/01/2024 10:44

I do have to say, as I did touch in in my post, that we wouldn't necessarily have made the same decision had we been in the UK. We're in a European country with subsidised childcare, social insurance systems (so no need to worry about reliance on a funding-starved NHS) and child benefit and student finance systems that actively support, rather than penalizing, 'larger' families.

VladimirVsVolodymyr · 01/01/2024 10:41

@PinkPlantCase congratulations 🥳 I had bang on same L, newborn and 30 month toddler. it is a bit full on but in 6 months, the baby will love the toddler. Is your toddler asking when baby can play? Mine almost drive me demented asking why when can they play together. Hang in there 😅

CandycaneParcel · 01/01/2024 10:39

It would be a no for me.Teens are expensive, really expensive, they are adults at about 12/13 in terms of food consumption, shoes and clothing. Uniform jumpers are £18 each for secondary round here plus all the other branded PE kit items.

University is currently costing me over £5k per year to fund one child. I have a 3 year gap so I have 6 years of the government expecting me to pay £5k per year to top up their maintenance loan. Ds's accommodation is over £7k a year, self catered. He gets minimum loan, it is dependent on the household income.

You woud be catering to very different ages if you go out for the day or go on holiday, I know people are on here saying it works for them but where are the other 3 children families saying it doesn't? I am one of 3, we hated it, everything is geared up for 2 children, hotel rooms, tickets, 2 ganging up on one when there are fights and there wasn't anywhere near the age gap yours have. When your eldest is 18 your youngest would be around your 8 year olds age. Lots to think about especially childcare costs which you are almost out of with an 8 year old.

VladimirVsVolodymyr · 01/01/2024 10:37

We have 3 aged 10, 8, and 2.5. We had 2 with a 30 month gap and always considered a third. We moved house 300km, I changed jobs, we bought a house (a year later), I moved jobs two years later and then covid hit. So there is 5.5 years between my second and third.

They both love their younger sibling. Cons are it is harder in your thirties (we had our two mid to late twenties), your house ends up covered in baby gear again but that doesn't bother me. Also we couldn't use a nanny again as the other two were older and DH worked from home. But childcare now is cheaper compared with paying for two.

Although the pros of a third child outweighs the cons, we were not going to have a third before buying a house and we wouldn't have if we hadn't bought our 4 bed. You will need a higher income for 3 kids to be approved for a mortgage.

Also your kids are almost teens and will be by the time you apply for your mortgage and teens are expensive. So will your wages increase by a good bit in the near future? Our kids were 2 and 4.5 when we bought and had next to no hobbies. Now age 8 and 10 they cost us nearly €400 monthly, no way we could save for a mortgage whilst paying that.

I know that feeling of wanting another but I would say think with your head first, practicalities, have a plan in place and if you want to then do. My friend had twins aged 37 and another just had triplets aged 40 so keep that in mind 😊

Justfinking · 01/01/2024 10:34

I wouldn't, you don't even own your own home. What if all three of your kids want to go to uni? I'd focus on the two you already have.

sandyhappypeople · 01/01/2024 10:32

I think you need to think about the pros and cons very carefully, people answering on here are answering based on their own personal circumstances and that doesn’t necessarily apply to you.

you DO need to think about your financial position, will you be taking on a mortgage in 5 years or renting? Will you be going back to work or SAHM? You also need to consider if one of you is ill, or your baby or children fall ill, can you survive financially?

do either of you have parents that may require additional care in the next 10 years? And adequate family support?

There are so many variables only you really know what’s right, good luck with whatever you decide.

Unwisebutnotillegal · 01/01/2024 10:32

30 k in savings probably won’t cover a house deposit and having 3 kids will affect your affordability, especially if you have childcare expenses. Our mortgage affordability reduced by 35k when we had our second in full time childcare.
In my area 3 bedroom rental are £1,300 so if either of your jobs are insecure then you could find yourself struggling pretty quickly. Please look at your finances as I’m not sure you’re going to be able to do it.

PinkPlantCase · 01/01/2024 10:27

Different POV but I currently have a newborn and a 2.5 yo. Life would be so much easier right now if DS was 8yo and not 2 🙈