Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Christmas card - Is the normal? Cute or Cringe

105 replies

EveeH · 31/12/2023 20:48

Just been taking down the Christmas cards we received this year (albeit not many). One of them I must not have looked at properly the first time as I've no realised that it's a bit different from what I'm used to and thought maybe the ultra middle class that is Mumsnet might be able to tell me if this is normal as I like it and might do it myself next year.

The card design on the front was drawn by the family who sent its children (age 1-5 so you can imagine it wasn't a work of art) and printed on. On the left hand side was a family picture, giving very the royals Christmas picture vibe, then the right hand side was a big paragraph outlining all of the events the family had that year include kids starting school and what have you. On the back was a little note saying they were donating £2.50 per card sent to a specific charity.
The card was sent by DHs manager, they are well off, big six bed detached house in Kew, ski trips and private schools for all the kids. I think you get the type.
I'm as common as muck so just wondering is this normal in any circle? Is it cute or cringey? We are expecting our first child in the new year so I'm thinking this might be a nice tradition to start but not sure?

AIBU to think this is quite cute and wonder if it's normal?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
catotangent · 01/01/2024 17:57

Cringe, bragging, virtue signalling, but more importantly comedy gold. In all an excellent example of a round robin.

JellyfishandShells · 01/01/2024 17:41

I’ve had these from American friends - not surprised it’s made its way over here.

I used to get a quite over the top round robin Xmas newsletter from an old flatmate which was tone deaf in terms of boasting, but she was like that in real life and I knew it was insecurity then and she was lovely in other ways so it didn’t bother me.

BCBird · 01/01/2024 17:35

Can't be doing with the round robin Christmas update , who cares?

BusyMum47 · 01/01/2024 17:33

The picture & drawing....meh.
The braggy bollocks about their wonderful year....very naff indeed.

Snowdogsmitten · 01/01/2024 16:50

I got quite a few like that. Lots with family updates in them, not so many made by the children. All from quite wealthy or known families. I think it’s a habit of certain people. I couldn’t bring myself to send out anything like that.

hellsBells246 · 01/01/2024 15:59

I think it's nice. It keeps people up to date with all the family's events if you don't talk to them regularly. It's only when it gets to 'Tarquin got 11 A stars at GCSE' that it gets tedious...

Fizbosshoes · 01/01/2024 14:48

I've never received or heard of that format of card but we get the occassinal round Robin letter with pics.
When we were kids/teens we had a round Robin Christmas letter from friends of my parents (who we had never met) with bragging news about their children. There was a section on each child - what grade music they were, how great their exams results were etc, we used to joke if we noticed some years they were scraping the barrel to find something newsworthy about each child!
I guess in those days (80s/90s) it was a bit like a forerunner of social media. I'm sure all the things were noteworthy to close friends and family, but my parents were not close friends and we (me and siblings) had never even met the people!

NeedToChangeName · 01/01/2024 14:38

A photo and short note of what family are doing is OK

Telling people you are donating £2.50 per card to charity is weird and braggy

PuffyShirt · 01/01/2024 14:31

When our kids were small and round robins were rife, we’d all bring ours to our regular new year’s gathering and read them aloud to the group. Most boastful and pretentious would win!

LadyEloise1 · 01/01/2024 14:25

Dorriethelittlewitch · 31/12/2023 21:03

We send cards with our children's art on them because the school does it as a fundraiser every year. I've had a few raised eyebrows over the years from people who assumed I'd send something "classier" but since I have them...may as well send them.

We did it too when the children were younger.

I once got one of those Christmas letters of all the family achievements throughout the year, along with a card from a friend from school days.
I thought she'd lost the run of herself altogether. 😂
She's Irish but was living in the US.
I think she only did it the once. No doubt her siblings ( and her dh's siblings ) put her straight. 😀

Doyouthinktheyknow · 01/01/2024 12:56

I think it’s cringey, just send a fucking card and donate to charity without telling everyone.

I think the modern version of the round robin letter is the facebook year round up that seemed everywhere yesterday! They weren’t interesting to anyone else either!

And no one ever says, yes I had a had a really crap year!

I am a miserable grump and I did have a shit year😩

guineverehadgreeneyes · 01/01/2024 12:48

Some years ago, I was keeping an eye on a neighbour's house while they were away over Christmas and New Year, which included taking their post into the kitchen. On their family notice board was pinned a Christmas round robin, which I could not help but read.

Simon had just written off the BMJ but luckily they still had the Range Rover...little Calypso was already on cello grade 6...and so it went on, and on and on. It was so much like a parody round robin that I wasn't sure to begin with whether it was a joke or not.

BrightGreenMoonBuggy · 01/01/2024 09:54

The kids having a drawing on the front is cute. Lots of primary schools do this, after all. Most people like cute little snowmen etc drawn by children. But the family photo and pre-printed details of their year’s highlights really does give me strong smug vibes. It’s the narcissism, isn’t it? Christmas isn’t about them. Send family a photo of your kids and updates on news in an email or a letter etc, but don’t put it on a Christmas card to give to everyone on your list as if you’re expecting them to be delighted and interested.

27Mankinis · 01/01/2024 09:36

I have an old work colleague who sends round robins every year. I usually enjoy them and it triggers me to send her an e-mail to say hi.

This year though it was filled with a very great deal of medical detail about the health problems of her elderly relatives which I thought was a bit intrusive. I last worked with her more than 20 years ago so if she is sending them to me she is probably sending them to a very great deal of people.

theduchessofspork · 01/01/2024 09:33

It’s fine IMO (and I am a bit of a miserable cow) - most round robins have disappeared with social media (hurrah) but if they don’t use it - as long as it’s short, factual rather than braggy and ideally with a bit of humour - then can’t see an issue

If you do use SM and everyone already knows what’s going on with you then do it without the round robin

Oohmontydon · 01/01/2024 09:29

I always find family photo Christmas cards odd. Why on earth would you want someone else's family/children on display? Presumably if you wanted a photo of them, you'd have one up already? They still go up though because I tell myself they've taken the time to send one etc...

HottestEverRecordedTemperature · 01/01/2024 09:26

phoenixbiscuits · 31/12/2023 20:59

It's a bit crass to be rubbing people's faces in it if they can't afford these things. Family and people of a similar lifestyle, not to my taste but whatever. But sending it to your staff who can't afford these things... Nope. The handmade, photo of family and £2.50 per card, all good. Showing off how you can afford fancy shit, no thanks 😂

yeah that's what I think.

I get a cringey round robin every year from friends of DHs who inherited literally millions at 40 and retired. Their kids are in super posh boarding schools and high achievers and the parents now spend their time yachting and skiing around the world and send us all that news. Plus including one year the gem that the wife had won £900 on a scratch card.

Just fuck off.

It's hard to believe people can be that self absorbed but they walk among us.

boobot1 · 01/01/2024 09:26

I think its weird you all think your friends and family having acheivements is braggy. Surely you should be happy for them. Strange people. I don't send any cards myself but dont mind receiving them. Never occurred to me it was braggy. I dont know anyone in real life who thinks like the people on here. Its interesting, if a little sad.

guineverehadgreeneyes · 01/01/2024 09:20

We now send and receive very few Christmas cards but have received cards in the past with kids artwork on them which were sold through their schools - I don't mind these (though I expect some families find them expensive and under pressure to buy them).

What I cannot stand are the "round robins".

We had some neighbours we knew well who moved to another village and started sending out two or three A4 page updates every Christmas. We'd get to hear about A's news and B's news and news about the four elderly grandparents (whom we had met several times), and the daughter and her family's news and the son and his family's news (once their kids were both married) and their several holidays a year. The year they included an update on the progress of Great Aunt Agatha's leg ulcer (a woman whom we had never met nor even heard of) I stopped reading them.

At no point was there a personal note added at the end, like: We were very sorry to hear you lost your dad or How are you all doing now (when they knew we were living with long-term health problems) - it was always all about them.

SpongeBob2022 · 01/01/2024 08:42

My personal opinion is that the kid's artwork is fine. Most schools round here engage in this. I bought some the first year DS did it but haven't done since.

The photo and letter are cringy and a bit tone deaf IMO. The only time I'd see this as acceptable is if someone has emigrated or something and it's a once a year 'keeping in touch' type thing.

Breakingpoint1961 · 01/01/2024 08:03

Every year my cousin sends me a card with pics of him/wife/daughter on it. Then the achievements of said daughter (who is now 18). They are in a very good financial position, and daughter has had a very privileged upbringing.

I am a very private person, don't 'show off' any achievements by myself/DC. I find it so utterly braggy/flash and incredibly cringeworthy. I'm not jealous, I just prefer humble and modest folk, who don't need to tell the world about what they have, financially or academically.

These 'round robins' are tiresome at the very least🙄

BitOutOfPractice · 01/01/2024 05:51

It’s very normal. But not to my taste. Don’t do it op.

adultsizedogbed · 01/01/2024 05:44

My cousin does this , with a letter of a round up of their year .

Literally no one cares !

I put it in the recycling .very cringey for me !

fishfingersandtoes · 01/01/2024 05:16

I suppose it's the equivalent of what lots of people do year round on FB & insta?

Happyhappyday · 01/01/2024 05:13

The family pictures + the kids drawing something is very normal in our “circle”, lots of people do the family updates, I tend not to because it’s hard for it not to be boasty. Our circle is mainly well off, ski vacation, big house, private school people though so maybe it’s just us. We in fact just spent New Year’s Eve discussing exactly that, private schools and ski holidays in a large 6 bedroom house 😂. I guess we are just cringey all around.