Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I'm definitely being unreasonable! Comparing lives with Australians!

388 replies

teulie · 31/12/2023 20:18

Watched a lot of Love Island Australia and MAFS Australia this year and follow a lot of the people from it now. Seeing all their stories all year and today for NYE, the sunshine, the beaches, the groups of girls all just having the best time being young in such a beautiful country with the best sort of lifestyle and it makes me feel sad!

I'm in my late twenties married with two kids, boring job, normal family life style but I look and think god could I of done that? Could life of been like that?

One of my old friends is currently in Australia so I'm seeing their insta stories all day everyday and it's made the pining worse than ever, I've never even been there and I find myself just wishing I could do life again and be born there Blush

OP posts:
Thread gallery
16
Moosegrass · 01/01/2024 11:45

@WhirlpoolRider
the majority of the country is countryside. Rural areas make up 90% of the land mass in England! You’ll find it’s lots of towns and villages connected by countryside. All easily accessible, millions of trails and paths. There’s a new coastal path that goes around the entire of England’s coast. It a small country so you’re never far from some beautiful scenery. Rambling, trail running cycling etc are all huge here.
I'd suggest following some Instagram accounts to get an idea of the countryside, countryfile, natural England, national trust, woodland trust, rspb are some I can think of of the top of my head (if you are actually interested!!)

Rocklettre · 01/01/2024 11:17

WhirlpoolRider · 01/01/2024 11:09

I hate to call anyone a liar but really? I’ve lived and travelled the world over and the UK is by far the most tamed place on earth. Mostly mowed grass, concrete and bitumen. The last remains trees are in protective custody.

Everyone has access to a creek in Australia. That’s the norm.

Yes of course! You’re so wrong I don’t even know where to begin. Did you just go to a city and not leave? Quite mind blowing really

WhirlpoolRider · 01/01/2024 11:09

Rocklettre · 01/01/2024 10:49

In the UK, unless you are in the top 10% your life won’t be great. Your housing and access to nature will be very limited, if either of those are of value to you. Access to Europe is a huge plus of course if you’re able to research and plan a trip but I found that these occasional trips didn’t offset the everyday drudgery of heading off to work in rain and cold. The reality is that most will go to Ibiza and so on, which is worse than most easy trips from Australia. With that said, London pips Sydney and Melbourne if you prefer and can afford it.

again just not true. We’re no where near the top 10% earners and have a much better life in the uk than we did in Australia. Something Australians clearly can’t understand. Sydney has more rain days than where I live now…. I work flexibly, from home, compared to my almost 2 hour commute to work in aus. Had to drive everywhere in Australia too and couldn’t afford to be near the beach. Yet we walk everywhere here, have a great community, live 10 min walk to a beautiful little beach, have a river and countryside within 5 minute walk. And I’m sure people have wonderful lives in Australia too, but ‘stating’ you can’t have a good life unless you’re top 10% is mad, and saying access to nature is limited in the uk is insane! We have some of the most accessible countryside in the world!

I hate to call anyone a liar but really? I’ve lived and travelled the world over and the UK is by far the most tamed place on earth. Mostly mowed grass, concrete and bitumen. The last remains trees are in protective custody.

Everyone has access to a creek in Australia. That’s the norm.

Fraaahnces · 01/01/2024 11:04

@tennesseewhiskey1 - I’m so sorry about that. We’re not all racist idiots, I promise. A lot of Aussies do the negging thing and can’t hack it when you get offended, as well… 🤦🏼‍♀️ The only place I have experienced racism was the Netherlands, and while it was awful, I now consider it a very good life lesson.

tennesseewhiskey1 · 01/01/2024 10:51

I’m almost 40 and Australia is the ONLY place where I experienced racism. Shame really.

Ratfan24 · 01/01/2024 10:51

My relatives emigrated to Australia and have the most amazing lifestyle, granted they moved there over 20 years ago and had good jobs to go to so it would be harder today, but they were able to buy a plot of land in a beautiful rural location and build a house. They have take full advantage of the weather to spend a lot of time outdoors in nature and playing various sports which they love. Plus they have travelled extensively and really enjoyed the scenery and fascinating natural history as well as the food and wine which can be very good. It wouldn't work for everyone, but I don't like some of the intolerance we have seen on this thread.

Rocklettre · 01/01/2024 10:49

In the UK, unless you are in the top 10% your life won’t be great. Your housing and access to nature will be very limited, if either of those are of value to you. Access to Europe is a huge plus of course if you’re able to research and plan a trip but I found that these occasional trips didn’t offset the everyday drudgery of heading off to work in rain and cold. The reality is that most will go to Ibiza and so on, which is worse than most easy trips from Australia. With that said, London pips Sydney and Melbourne if you prefer and can afford it.

again just not true. We’re no where near the top 10% earners and have a much better life in the uk than we did in Australia. Something Australians clearly can’t understand. Sydney has more rain days than where I live now…. I work flexibly, from home, compared to my almost 2 hour commute to work in aus. Had to drive everywhere in Australia too and couldn’t afford to be near the beach. Yet we walk everywhere here, have a great community, live 10 min walk to a beautiful little beach, have a river and countryside within 5 minute walk. And I’m sure people have wonderful lives in Australia too, but ‘stating’ you can’t have a good life unless you’re top 10% is mad, and saying access to nature is limited in the uk is insane! We have some of the most accessible countryside in the world!

Chubbywubba · 01/01/2024 10:49

Seriously - you make your heaven or hell wherever you are. No-where could you live a life of dreams, carefree and dancing on air. It’s a fantasy. You could move to Australia. But you’d still have your responsibilities to attend to - your family, your work, earning enough to pay your bills, feed the family.

Like many things, the reality is often very very different to the idea. I’ve not been to Australia so I can’t comment but I agree it looks lovely.

However, my point is that you can’t escape the realities of your existence and your circumstance - people generally run from things not to things

Picklemeyellow · 01/01/2024 10:49

SpiderBait · 01/01/2024 10:38

OP please ignore all the tourists, UK hermits and fantasists that populate this thread. I’ve lived across Australia and the UK. Here’s the straight dope.

You can have a good life in Australia if you’re a higherish earner - say top 25%. You’ll live in a good suburb close to the city with great amenities, culture, healthcare and so on. You’ll have ample time and money for pretty impressive beach holidays and some simple but stunning inland adventures. Conversely, if you’re not ambitious but kind of skilled and don’t care about the big city lifestyle of museums and books (plumber etc), you can have a pretty idyllic small town costal life. 40 degree days and bushfires and rare despite what you might see here. I say that access to Asia preferable to Europe.

In the UK, unless you are in the top 10% your life won’t be great. Your housing and access to nature will be very limited, if either of those are of value to you. Access to Europe is a huge plus of course if you’re able to research and plan a trip but I found that these occasional trips didn’t offset the everyday drudgery of heading off to work in rain and cold. The reality is that most will go to Ibiza and so on, which is worse than most easy trips from Australia. With that said, London pips Sydney and Melbourne if you prefer and can afford it.

So you are implying people with careers in plumbing etc aren’t skilled or interested in culture and just want to live quiet lives by the sea!
And how do you come to the conclusion that 90% of the earners in the UK won’t be living ‘great’ lives.
Jeez talk about living in a bubble

Shadowsindarkplaces · 01/01/2024 10:39

A number of my family went to Australia in the 60s/70s. One in particular posts racist memes about immigration. The irony seems to escape her. She blocked me after she posted a 'Australia for Australians' meme and I asked when she's coming home..😂

Codlingmoths · 01/01/2024 10:39

itllbedifferentnextyear · 01/01/2024 07:24

Australia could get rid of the monarchy if they wanted. I wonder why they don't?

They could also have voted YES on the Constitution to recognise the First Peoples of Australia by establishing a body called the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Voice.

Umm. You were perfectly clear on why we haven’t got rid of the monarchy. Because we are backwards and racist. The voice referendum was a huge disappointment, I guess it was like Brexit in the uk- a big protest vote due to people really feeling the cost of living crisis. Except Brexit was years before the current inflationary pressures so I guess it was just a big protest vote. We were living in the uk at the time.

SpiderBait · 01/01/2024 10:38

Rocklettre · 01/01/2024 10:18

But definitely lives a gloomy boring existence in the UK. Literally getting up each day and going through the motions and cannot bear to think a better life exists somewhere else and so must be negative about better places in justification.

Of course Australia is a better place to live FFs! The reasons people give on this thread and all others like it are ridiculous nonsense

This is the attitude I found of so many aussies! Can’t fathom that lots of people don’t want to live in Australia/ have a better life not in Australia. I have an amazing life in the uk and I’m sorry if you can’t get your head around that.

OP please ignore all the tourists, UK hermits and fantasists that populate this thread. I’ve lived across Australia and the UK. Here’s the straight dope.

You can have a good life in Australia if you’re a higherish earner - say top 25%. You’ll live in a good suburb close to the city with great amenities, culture, healthcare and so on. You’ll have ample time and money for pretty impressive beach holidays and some simple but stunning inland adventures. Conversely, if you’re not ambitious but kind of skilled and don’t care about the big city lifestyle of museums and books (plumber etc), you can have a pretty idyllic small town costal life. 40 degree days and bushfires and rare despite what you might see here. I say that access to Asia preferable to Europe.

In the UK, unless you are in the top 10% your life won’t be great. Your housing and access to nature will be very limited, if either of those are of value to you. Access to Europe is a huge plus of course if you’re able to research and plan a trip but I found that these occasional trips didn’t offset the everyday drudgery of heading off to work in rain and cold. The reality is that most will go to Ibiza and so on, which is worse than most easy trips from Australia. With that said, London pips Sydney and Melbourne if you prefer and can afford it.

TheaBrandt · 01/01/2024 10:33

I also love the access to Europe and we go regularly taken teens to Paris / Amsterdam/ Berlin and had a blast. Think Australia would be too remote for me.

TheaBrandt · 01/01/2024 10:31

Op sounds like a candidate for wanted down under! Loved that program wish they would bring it back.

Never been but love sun and beaches so the lifestyle looks amazing to me. But I love my family our jobs not transferable without huge effort and enjoy the “feel” of the history of England so guess it will have to be Australia in another life! A family member moved from NZ to Australia then back to NZ as it was too hot and her kids couldn’t cope with the heat.

Cookiecrumblepie · 01/01/2024 10:31

Main difference is in Australia you can become whoever you want. In England there is an ancient and ingrained class system that will not change. The gap between rich and poor is wider in England but there is also more access to Europe. Nowhere is perfect.

tralalalalalalalal · 01/01/2024 10:30

Life on Instagram always looks great

Georgie743 · 01/01/2024 10:26

Saggypants · 31/12/2023 21:52

Did you forget the oldest living culture in the world? Or is white peoples' culture the only one that matters?

While calling other people racist! I get you're just trying to make the OP feel better but... honestly.

Thank you!! When people say there's no culture, what they mean is no European style culture. And in the same breath, Australia is more racist?! Wow.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 01/01/2024 10:23

Friends of ours just outside Perth recently had to leave their home for 48 hours because a bush fire came incredibly close.
They’ve been there for over 30 years (big house, extensive grounds) and this was the first time a bush fire has been a real threat.

We’ve visited Oz twice (not recently) and both times there’s been severe drought in the areas we visited (mostly Melbourne and the E coast area). The effects of climate change would really put me off.

anothernamechangeagainsndagain · 01/01/2024 10:22

It's very very expensive from the moans of my friend's dc - stayed living at home for university, working now in a professional job but can't afford a flat share even. He has applied to transfer to Britain - I have warned him Bristol isn't cheap but he reckons it's about 1/3 rent of where they live and pay is 2/3 ... definitely better off here in uk (he's a dual national)

EasternStandard · 01/01/2024 10:20

SausageCasseroles · 01/01/2024 10:11

I don't think it's an "of course it's better in Australia". We had the chance to emigrate and decided against it. Many people on this thread have lived in Australia. And many people move back to the UK after trying Australia. Just as many Australians emigrate to the UK....

I think "of course Australia is better ffs" is just as blinkered as the "hot/snakes" repsonse. It's a bit like the American belief of growing up convinced your country is where everyone wants to be.

And yes we looked into house prices as we considered moving at one point as family were there!!

Yes this is my take. You can have great, bad or middling experiences in both countries

It doesn’t need to be everyone has to prefer one over the other anyway. Both countries are obviously attractive for many who choose them. People will like different things, that’s good though we don’t all need to be the same

honeysuckleweeks · 01/01/2024 10:19

quisensoucie · 01/01/2024 10:10

@honeysuckleweeks Oh god, yes, me again.
What assumptions have you made about my background and ethnicity?

Probably not as many as you've made about Australia. Night. I'm off to bed. It's late for me at after 9pm on new years day!. Don't forget to watch that show. "Stuff the British Stole" ABC TV. Eye-opening.

Rocklettre · 01/01/2024 10:18

But definitely lives a gloomy boring existence in the UK. Literally getting up each day and going through the motions and cannot bear to think a better life exists somewhere else and so must be negative about better places in justification.

Of course Australia is a better place to live FFs! The reasons people give on this thread and all others like it are ridiculous nonsense

This is the attitude I found of so many aussies! Can’t fathom that lots of people don’t want to live in Australia/ have a better life not in Australia. I have an amazing life in the uk and I’m sorry if you can’t get your head around that.

Throwhandsupintheair · 01/01/2024 10:18

As a mixed raced born Brit who’s been to Australia several times, I do raise my eyebrows when Brits claim Australia is more racist.

Outside cities, parts of the UK can be unwelcoming to foreigners and non-white people. The country which had Brexit as well as people like Suella Braverman spouting the most odious rhetoric, isn’t in a position to call Australia racist.

UK often does racism more covertly but there is still plenty of racism, as you will see from Daily Mail comments.

SausageCasseroles · 01/01/2024 10:11

I don't think it's an "of course it's better in Australia". We had the chance to emigrate and decided against it. Many people on this thread have lived in Australia. And many people move back to the UK after trying Australia. Just as many Australians emigrate to the UK....

I think "of course Australia is better ffs" is just as blinkered as the "hot/snakes" repsonse. It's a bit like the American belief of growing up convinced your country is where everyone wants to be.

And yes we looked into house prices as we considered moving at one point as family were there!!

quisensoucie · 01/01/2024 10:10

@honeysuckleweeks Oh god, yes, me again.
What assumptions have you made about my background and ethnicity?