Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I'm definitely being unreasonable! Comparing lives with Australians!

388 replies

teulie · 31/12/2023 20:18

Watched a lot of Love Island Australia and MAFS Australia this year and follow a lot of the people from it now. Seeing all their stories all year and today for NYE, the sunshine, the beaches, the groups of girls all just having the best time being young in such a beautiful country with the best sort of lifestyle and it makes me feel sad!

I'm in my late twenties married with two kids, boring job, normal family life style but I look and think god could I of done that? Could life of been like that?

One of my old friends is currently in Australia so I'm seeing their insta stories all day everyday and it's made the pining worse than ever, I've never even been there and I find myself just wishing I could do life again and be born there Blush

OP posts:
Thread gallery
16
BayCityCoaster · 01/01/2024 17:13

MNers love a bit of New World bashing.

They bang on about the lack of ‘culture’, and in doing so, wipe out entire indigenous cultures. It genuinely does not even occur to them. And I bet most don’t even go to the opera, themselves.

We have a symphony orchestra annual sub, and can walk into town (at least in summer) to see the opera, ballet, theatre, to galleries and museums - if we’re talking Eurocentric culture.

But on top of that we have our hugely prevalent and embraced indigenous culture, as well.

If you went to / lived in Australia and couldn’t find any of these things (assuming you actually, genuinely wanted to find them), that says more about you than it does about Australia.

‘Class’ is the big issue in the UK, and these threads do nothing more or less than prove that.

mathanxiety · 01/01/2024 16:54

@ilovepuppies2019
You haven't seen the threads on America/ Americans then...

mathanxiety · 01/01/2024 16:52

itllbedifferentnextyear · 01/01/2024 07:34

John Patterson on X: "To celebrate Daryl Somers’ hot take on cancel culture yesterday here’s all the edits I’ve done from the Hey Hey archives. Here’s the legend Kamahl being bullied by the Hey Hey gang t.co/Aa3WMeRw54" / X (twitter.com)

Australian TV in the 1980s.

One skit shows him being introduced to the sounds of African drumming and voiceover artist John Blackman, pretending to be from the show’s lighting department, suggesting Kamahl should smile so that the audience could “see him”. He was also hit in the face with white powder while trying to perform, and then told he was now a white man.

A montage of segments, recently circulated on Twitter, showed a joke that Kamahl’s album would “go black” instead of gold or platinum, the singer getting hit in the face with white powder and told “You’re a real white man now”, and a caricature of him sitting in a stew pot with a bone through his nose.

So unlike The Black and White Minstrel Show, which graced British TV screens in the 70s...

Iirc, it ran until 1978, a run of approximately 20 years. It had 16 million regular viewers in its heyday.

Despite some protests over the years, the BBC failed to understand how offensive it was, and it was only canned because by 1978 variety shows in general were less appealing to audiences than they had once been.

Ozgirl75 · 01/01/2024 16:38

I always assume it’s the same people who go to Rome in August and complain about how hot it is, or say Paris is unfriendly.
it’s good that we don’t all like the same things!

ilovepuppies2019 · 01/01/2024 16:31

I can't think of many other counties or cultures in the world where it would be acceptable to use such stereotypical, racist descriptions. A few pages in and Australians (and specifically children in some cases) have described as sexist pigs, having no culture, having no taste, being uneducated, racist and mysoginistict. Replace Australian with the name of almost any other cultural group and this thread would be on fire. It is incredibly bigoted (at best) to decide that an entire country of people meet these descriptors and galling to read people complaining of racism while they deliver such a racist rant. If you would not find it acceptable to classify all people from a particular region / culture / religion in a particular way based on your one holiday or experience then please apply this same respect to Australia.

OP we have a rich and diverse culture and a lovely climate in Australia. There are wonderful strengths to Australia as there are to all areas of the world. Don't believe what you see on Instagram as it's never real life. The grass will always be greener anywhere that a person doesn't have to contend with the struggles of daily life.

BayCityCoaster · 01/01/2024 16:30

SausageCasseroles · 01/01/2024 10:11

I don't think it's an "of course it's better in Australia". We had the chance to emigrate and decided against it. Many people on this thread have lived in Australia. And many people move back to the UK after trying Australia. Just as many Australians emigrate to the UK....

I think "of course Australia is better ffs" is just as blinkered as the "hot/snakes" repsonse. It's a bit like the American belief of growing up convinced your country is where everyone wants to be.

And yes we looked into house prices as we considered moving at one point as family were there!!

And many people move back to the UK after trying Australia. Just as many Australians emigrate to the UK....

This makes it sound like you’re drawing the conclusion that the UK is therefore better.

Likewise, many Australians move back to Australia from the UK. Many Brit’s move to Australia and love it.

Don’t forget that for many, home ties and homesickness play a big role in where people end up.

They try somewhere else, but end up deciding home is preferable - not because their home country is objectively better. But because it’s familiar, it’s where friends and family are, and it’s simply preferable to them.

Small-minded people will whinge about their adopted country, say how much better everything is in their home country, and think they’re the absolute oracle on it all (this thread is littered with such people. Hint: you’re not the oracle, it’s just your opinion).

I lived in the UK for 13 years, and then moved back to my home country. I like both countries, but home won out for me.

Ozgirl75 · 01/01/2024 16:28

Kitkatfiend31 · 01/01/2024 16:10

The education system isn't all that great. Or that many extra curricular activities available compared to here. Life always looks better in the sun and we've had so much rain I think it's easy to forget what we have.

That is utter, utter rubbish I’m afraid. There are SO SO many extra curriculars and the education systems are similar, although Aus does do better in the pisa ratings but I suspect that is because we have a smaller population. Making statements like this makes you look frankly silly as well as misinformed.

mathanxiety · 01/01/2024 16:24

2024IWillBeNurturingMe · 01/01/2024 09:58

More bigotry, a bit like being in the UK 30 years ago

You are joking me right?

I lived and worked in Asia for nearly 2 decades, and I worked for 2 Aussie companies. I made loads of Aussie mates, and I went there 20 times.

The Brits I met whilst working overseas: Where are you from? What school did you go to? Do you know XXXX, their great grandad was a Lord/ Brigadier/ made millions doing XXX. Where are you going on holiday? Depending on your answers, you'll be put in a class box, and then treated accordingly.

The Aussies I met overseas, and in Australia: At first they are a little reserved because they can't tell you apart from the stereotype above, but after they get to know you and realise you are not like that, you are onto a winner. They are super friendly, and they don't give a toss where you are from, what your accent is, or what class you are.

So, please do not come on here and say Aussies are bigots when IME, the most bigoted people I have ever met are English.

Nailed it.

BayCityCoaster · 01/01/2024 16:20

So, @teulie - are you coming back to the thread you started?

Or did you just want to start the first Australia bashing thread of 2024?

Kitkatfiend31 · 01/01/2024 16:10

The education system isn't all that great. Or that many extra curricular activities available compared to here. Life always looks better in the sun and we've had so much rain I think it's easy to forget what we have.

allthevitamins · 01/01/2024 15:59

You do all know that Australia is a really big, diverse place, and that not everyone lives swanky, beachy, outdoorsy lives? There are plenty of impoverished people struggling to live healthy and fulfilling lives in Australia too.

Ever looked into life in the western suburbs of Sydney? Or what life would be like in a large but insular regional centre? Or somewhere a bit more remote? What if your nearest supermarket / pharmacy / cafe was a 40-60 minute drive away? Or your nearest major airport a 4-5 hour drive?

What if you had to catch all your own water or have it tankered in? What if when driving after dark you always risked crashing into kangaroos? What if you're not bright or outdoorsy or well off... and as a young person you get sucked into the very prevalent drug culture?

These things are common in Australia and have a significant detrimental impact on life in comparison to say the wildlife or weather.

Groovy48592747 · 01/01/2024 15:33

I had family emigrate to Aus, within 10 years they'd all come back home.

Parvanati · 01/01/2024 15:19

Amsterdam is lovely, but just for a weekend really I am not sure it would be cool to move there.

raffys · 01/01/2024 15:14

Not entirely sure why the conversation needed to descend to playground oneupmanship. Is it not possible that both counties can be great places to live, they both have amazing scenery and lots to do but they are vastly different. Or is that all just too sensible.

Rocklettre · 01/01/2024 15:14

2024IWillBeNurturingMe · 01/01/2024 12:26

I also love the access to Europe and we go regularly taken teens to Paris / Amsterdam/ Berlin and had a blast.

Hmmm, the Margaret River, Monkey Mia, Denmark Beach, Perth and Fremantle, the Daintree Rainforest, a boat on the barrier reef, a weekend in the Whitsundays…………..or Amsterdam 😂

Are you laughing at the idea of going to Amsterdam? Really? Have you been? An amazing city to visit. Fremantle doesn’t nearly compare, sorry.

Parvanati · 01/01/2024 15:11

My daughter is currently in Australia travelling and this thread makes me feel nervous about it

TheaBrandt · 01/01/2024 15:08

Don’t fancy any of those places thanks never even heard of them - hard to beat Paris and Berlin though!

Mikimoto · 01/01/2024 14:57

2024IWillBeNurturingMe · 01/01/2024 12:26

I also love the access to Europe and we go regularly taken teens to Paris / Amsterdam/ Berlin and had a blast.

Hmmm, the Margaret River, Monkey Mia, Denmark Beach, Perth and Fremantle, the Daintree Rainforest, a boat on the barrier reef, a weekend in the Whitsundays…………..or Amsterdam 😂

Sydney to Freemantle is 4000 kms.
London has around 40 capital cities closer to it than that.
Plus the Arctic.

Boomboom22 · 01/01/2024 13:10

Also the UK has one of the richest natural environments in Europe, not samey like most of eg Spain. Generally the UK and NZ are known for this, hence both countries filming so many Hollywood and other series in thise countries with access to varied locations.

Boomboom22 · 01/01/2024 12:54

Even the left is quite right wing in oz though, their attitudes to migrants if said here would be considered hate speech, certainly far more than Braverman's policy ideas. They go beyond on implementation. Considering the very idea of turning illegal immigrants away is considered far right to most Labour voters in the UK I think oz politics would be considered way too right wing, even for moderate tories. Same with the lockdown response except this time authoritarian.

Scalottia · 01/01/2024 12:54

honeysuckleweeks · 01/01/2024 08:53

Lol. I missed the ugly furniture! WTF? haha. It's probably bloody imported from England.

I laughed at this! Australia has ugly furniture? This comment coming from what I assume is an english person? Ok then.

Codlingmoths · 01/01/2024 12:45

mrsjoyfulprizeforraffiawork · 01/01/2024 12:24

@WhirlpoolRider
Gosh! You remind me of an Australian woman I met years ago when I spent 9 months in Oz (8 years later went back for another couple of months). She said, "It must be awful to live in a country with no trees". Me: "Yes, it must be. Er, why did you say that?" (I was being very polite). Her: "Well, there are no trees in England, are there?". I explained in a kind way that we do have some trees. (As it happens, I am a Londoner, who lives in an outer suburb surrounded on 3 sides by a large ancient forest, readily accessed by public transport to all Londoners. My little road is home to foxes, owls and deer and I once saw a rare native grass snake on the communal lawn of our flats). I was subjected to endless Pom bashing back then, which, clearly, the Pom bashers had no idea felt bullying and unkind to the recipient. It was 1980s, so I hope there is less these days. I remember hitching from rural NSW to Melbourne with my Australian friend, for example, and being picked up by a truck driver. "Where are you girls from?" On hearing I was from London. "A Pom? A Pom?" and immediately he called up his mate in another truck on his radio "Hey, Bill, you'll never believe this, I've got a bloody Pom in my cab". Can't remember next bit but in such Pom-subjected interactions, it was usually "and what do you think of God's own country? I bet you never want to go back, do you? It rains all the time there, doesn't it." . General England bashing would then ensue. I got used to gritting my teeth and pretending to find this light-hearted banter and not really annoying at all. I really hope that it doesn't happen any more now. I would never say anything like this to visitors to the UK. I missed the European culture too. I love the theatre and, working in Sydney, went to anything I could - theatre, opera, concerts at the opera house and often to the art gallery by the botanical gardens but rural Australia then had nothing like this available and spending hours in the pub gets a little tedious. Great bush walking and beautiful scenery though and a lot of kind and friendly people.

I met someone in the uk at work no less and the conversation was like oh you’re an Aussie? Never seen such a bunch of uncultured rednecks as Australians.
me- !! So it happened the other way around in about 2016. I was quite a bit better at my job than he was at his.

KimberleyClark · 01/01/2024 12:34

WhirlpoolRider · 01/01/2024 11:09

I hate to call anyone a liar but really? I’ve lived and travelled the world over and the UK is by far the most tamed place on earth. Mostly mowed grass, concrete and bitumen. The last remains trees are in protective custody.

Everyone has access to a creek in Australia. That’s the norm.

Snowdonia?
The Lake District?
Pembrokeshire coast?
Yorkshire dales?
Scottish highlands?
Hebrides?
Cornwall?
Norfolk Broads?
The Pennines?

2024IWillBeNurturingMe · 01/01/2024 12:26

I also love the access to Europe and we go regularly taken teens to Paris / Amsterdam/ Berlin and had a blast.

Hmmm, the Margaret River, Monkey Mia, Denmark Beach, Perth and Fremantle, the Daintree Rainforest, a boat on the barrier reef, a weekend in the Whitsundays…………..or Amsterdam 😂

mrsjoyfulprizeforraffiawork · 01/01/2024 12:24

@WhirlpoolRider
Gosh! You remind me of an Australian woman I met years ago when I spent 9 months in Oz (8 years later went back for another couple of months). She said, "It must be awful to live in a country with no trees". Me: "Yes, it must be. Er, why did you say that?" (I was being very polite). Her: "Well, there are no trees in England, are there?". I explained in a kind way that we do have some trees. (As it happens, I am a Londoner, who lives in an outer suburb surrounded on 3 sides by a large ancient forest, readily accessed by public transport to all Londoners. My little road is home to foxes, owls and deer and I once saw a rare native grass snake on the communal lawn of our flats). I was subjected to endless Pom bashing back then, which, clearly, the Pom bashers had no idea felt bullying and unkind to the recipient. It was 1980s, so I hope there is less these days. I remember hitching from rural NSW to Melbourne with my Australian friend, for example, and being picked up by a truck driver. "Where are you girls from?" On hearing I was from London. "A Pom? A Pom?" and immediately he called up his mate in another truck on his radio "Hey, Bill, you'll never believe this, I've got a bloody Pom in my cab". Can't remember next bit but in such Pom-subjected interactions, it was usually "and what do you think of God's own country? I bet you never want to go back, do you? It rains all the time there, doesn't it." . General England bashing would then ensue. I got used to gritting my teeth and pretending to find this light-hearted banter and not really annoying at all. I really hope that it doesn't happen any more now. I would never say anything like this to visitors to the UK. I missed the European culture too. I love the theatre and, working in Sydney, went to anything I could - theatre, opera, concerts at the opera house and often to the art gallery by the botanical gardens but rural Australia then had nothing like this available and spending hours in the pub gets a little tedious. Great bush walking and beautiful scenery though and a lot of kind and friendly people.