Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I'm definitely being unreasonable! Comparing lives with Australians!

388 replies

teulie · 31/12/2023 20:18

Watched a lot of Love Island Australia and MAFS Australia this year and follow a lot of the people from it now. Seeing all their stories all year and today for NYE, the sunshine, the beaches, the groups of girls all just having the best time being young in such a beautiful country with the best sort of lifestyle and it makes me feel sad!

I'm in my late twenties married with two kids, boring job, normal family life style but I look and think god could I of done that? Could life of been like that?

One of my old friends is currently in Australia so I'm seeing their insta stories all day everyday and it's made the pining worse than ever, I've never even been there and I find myself just wishing I could do life again and be born there Blush

OP posts:
Thread gallery
16
ImustLearn2Cook · 01/01/2024 05:27

Most of us Australians are from more diverse heritage than British. We really should stop blaming England for the oppression and racism and mistreatment of indigenous Australians.

ImustLearn2Cook · 01/01/2024 05:21

@Catsmere 😆I know right.

Catsmere · 01/01/2024 05:11

IamMini · 01/01/2024 00:47

@ShitChristamasPresents

I don’t feel the same about NZ - yes, it’s also limited in terms of being so far away from other countries and their influences, but the Māori heritage and language is respected in a completely different way. Children learn Māori alongside English at school. There is an innate respect for Māori history and people. I have heard so many people say incredibly derogatory things about Aboriginal people and heritage in Aus. Mind blowing my awful things. Often.

Essentially, Australians are just a couple of generations away from being purely British themselves, so you are really suggesting this about your own people. Until 20 or 30 years or so ago, Australians considered themselves to be British. Additionally, any racial tension you heard is an issue the British created in the first place, so criticism from a British perspective is odd.

In the 90s and 2000s? Nonsense. I was born in 1963 and the idea of Britain being "home" or us being British was well and truly dead by the time I was a kid.

Catsmere · 01/01/2024 05:06

The city centre is quite small but the city itself extends for miles and miles. No use to non drivers like us.

Eh? Melbourne born and bred here, I never needed a car when I lived there, even when I was in the outermost suburbs that were almost in Gippsland. Train services, trams in the inner-middle suburbs, and buses. I didn't need to learn to drive till I moved to a country town in my fifties.

Nofilteritwonthelp · 01/01/2024 05:02

wandawaves · 01/01/2024 05:01

Woohoo another Australia bashing thread, how original!

Anyway, I'll let you all get back to your "BuT tHeReS nO CuLtUrE aNd ItS 40 DeGrEeS" 🙄

Yesterday there was one about South East Asians ... but no racism to see here ... 🤔

CuriousGeorge80 · 01/01/2024 05:02

(I should say I absolutely love Australia and come here every year - I just think the GC in their summer is hard work!)

wandawaves · 01/01/2024 05:01

Woohoo another Australia bashing thread, how original!

Anyway, I'll let you all get back to your "BuT tHeReS nO CuLtUrE aNd ItS 40 DeGrEeS" 🙄

CuriousGeorge80 · 01/01/2024 05:00

Well I’m on the Gold Coast for Christmas and New Year. We had a five day power cut from Christmas Day evening and then such huge storms last night that there has been another power cut and flooding. People have died. I’m being bitten all the time. There have been some nice bits too (beach etc) but god I don’t know how anybody can live like this.

LargeSquareRock · 01/01/2024 04:55

Ah the Little Englanders are out in force I see, as they shiver in their little grey boxes with a tiny square courtyard garden that they take their dog out to four times a day to shit and piss on, dreaming of their annual Majorca piss up via Ryanair.

Meanwhile, diverse, multicultural, beautiful, imperfect Australia with the oldest living cultures on Earth just gets on with living.

IamMini · 01/01/2024 04:49

@ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming

Didn't take long did it? The usual rubbish is being trotted out ad nauseum.

When I was very young I thought the whinging stereotype was awful - soon changed my mind about that!

And what appears on MAFS isn't really representative of normality at all.

A friend of mine said after a business trip to England, "It's grey, drab, oppressive, there are people everywhere and the houses are miles of cookie-cutter monotony. The museums are great, though." I don't judge England based on that statement, though, and would still like to go there.

MaitlandGirl · 01/01/2024 04:40

To give you an idea - in the past month :

we've been on evacuation warning for a local bushfire that destroyed houses, buildings and businesses (no lives lost thankfully)

we've had multiple hailstorms that left my car badly dented, my daughter's car with a cracked windscreen, the neighbours solar panels badly damaged and my son with concussion (he got hit by a golf ball sized hailstone)

we've had 9 thunderstorms with 3 lightning strikes on the estate

and temperatures in excess of 40C

Food prices have increased by around 30% in the past 18mths, electricity is almost 50% higher than last year and interest rate rises have seen people paying an additional $1200 a month on a $500,000 mortgage since the beginning of this year. On our estate a home and land package pre covid was less than the current cost of the same sized block of land today - prices have more than doubled.

While living here has been good for my family and has meant we've missed out on a lot of the problems in the UK (covid deaths for instance were massively lower) it's not the miracle solution so many people seem to think it is.

Racism is rife, socially we're at least 15 years behind the rest of the developed world and everything is so damn expensive. We still have 2 adult children (26 & 28) living at home because they can't afford to move out and if we're honest we can't afford for them to move out.

Australia's a great place for a holiday but not to live.

IamMini · 01/01/2024 04:30

@SmugglersHaunt

So the racial tension can’t be solved by Australians? Your argument seems to be that it was ‘created by the British’, but your country is seemingly incapable of changing it. It’s not a stunning endorsement

It absolutely can, but that isn't something that is resolved in the space of a generation.

Helar · 01/01/2024 03:21

Why not plan a holiday over there and see if it matches up to the dream? If you really did love it, you could look into getting a visa. And if it wasn’t so great and you were glad to get home then it would stop the pining.

SmugglersHaunt · 01/01/2024 03:18

IamMini · 01/01/2024 00:47

@ShitChristamasPresents

I don’t feel the same about NZ - yes, it’s also limited in terms of being so far away from other countries and their influences, but the Māori heritage and language is respected in a completely different way. Children learn Māori alongside English at school. There is an innate respect for Māori history and people. I have heard so many people say incredibly derogatory things about Aboriginal people and heritage in Aus. Mind blowing my awful things. Often.

Essentially, Australians are just a couple of generations away from being purely British themselves, so you are really suggesting this about your own people. Until 20 or 30 years or so ago, Australians considered themselves to be British. Additionally, any racial tension you heard is an issue the British created in the first place, so criticism from a British perspective is odd.

So the racial tension can’t be solved by Australians? Your argument seems to be that it was ‘created by the British’, but your country is seemingly incapable of changing it. It’s not a stunning endorsement

SmugglersHaunt · 01/01/2024 03:14

Saggypants · 31/12/2023 23:52

I don’t feel the same about NZ - yes, it’s also limited in terms of being so far away from other countries and their influences, but the Māori heritage and language is respected in a completely different way. Children learn Māori alongside English at school. There is an innate respect for Māori history and people.

A lot of that is tied to the way they were colonised by the British. There was a war in NZ, the Maori were better equppied for such and the country as it is today was founded by treaty. (That's not to say there weren't atrocities, but the Maori were recognised as owners of the land from the get go.)

Good and decent Australians want better race relations and to undo the harm caused by British invasion, though they may disgree on how best to do it. I feel more progress should have been made in ~120 years but the systems of power and influence established by the British are well entrenched and it's slow going. To be lectured about it by the (I assume) British themselves is grating, to say the least.

So all the blame for racism in Australia comes down to the British and their influence from 120 years ago? The only conclusions to draw from such an argument are either:
a) Australia is inept at managing its own affairs, even given the 120 years it’s had to do so
or
b) is not changed because that’s how Australians like things

TimeFlysWhenYoureHavingRum · 01/01/2024 03:13

Instagram is not a real picture of people's lives. Get off social media.

ImustLearn2Cook · 01/01/2024 02:52

ShitChristamasPresents · 31/12/2023 23:14

@Reader1303 But aboriginal culture is largely ignored or white washed by much of Australia. That’s rather the point I’m making. The ancient history of the country is not something that’s well represented.

You are very right in this statement. This might be interesting reading of how we allowed a mining company to destroy an ancient aboriginal site that had very important historical significance and of course a very important sacred significance and connection with the First Nations people.

When I was younger I used to defend my country vehemently against the allegations that Australia has a lack of culture. As I have gotten older I unfortunately see the sad truth in that allegation.

I hope that we could one day see it as constructive criticism and feel motivated to improve, rather than being outraged and offended while digging our heels in deeper.

https://www.australiangeographic.com.au/topics/history-culture/2020/05/an-ancient-aboriginal-site-was-blasted-away-by-a-mining-company-heres-why-that-was-allowed/

An ancient Aboriginal site was blasted away by a mining company. Here’s why that was allowed

The history of large developments destroying Indigenous heritage sites is, tragically, long.

https://www.australiangeographic.com.au/topics/history-culture/2020/05/an-ancient-aboriginal-site-was-blasted-away-by-a-mining-company-heres-why-that-was-allowed/

mathanxiety · 01/01/2024 02:39

Comparison is the thief of joy, OP.

whirlyhead · 01/01/2024 02:07

How about finding some different TV programmes to watch! I lived in NZ for years and really liked it but it has its problems, just like England, as does Australia. Being so remote is good in some ways. Cant say I’ve noticed people being more bigoted and sexist in Australia than England though.

coxesorangepippin · 01/01/2024 02:07

Yes it's hot

Yes you could get bitten by a snake/spider/ jellyfish

Yes housing is expensive

But you could also have access to amazing weather, outdoor living, amazing work life balance, fabulous healthcare.

I lived there for a year and did not see one spider/snake etc.

What do you do for work? Could you be eligible for Australia?

Passingthethyme · 01/01/2024 01:56

This is why I waited until I was older and 'partied' out before I had children, but the bonus for you is that when yours are grown you'll still be young enough to do things whereas I'll probably need a walking stick. Pros and Cons. Weather is definitely better though, a million times more so than the UK, no denying that. Be happy with your lot, boring is better than drama.

xyz111 · 01/01/2024 01:50

When I've watched MAFS, I was always surprised how small their houses were, considering the size of the country!!

Cricketbelle · 01/01/2024 01:42

I’ve never been to Australia but it looks awesome to me 🤷‍♀️

I really miss watching Wanted Down Under…. People wanting to emigrate to Aus/NZ having never even visited!

I’ve noticed on MAFS that they all seem to live in nice houses/apartments,the standard of property seems higher.

The lack of sun here in the winter does get me down a bit which is also why it’s appealing.

Premfove · 01/01/2024 01:23

It's a great place and you absolutely could have had that lifestyle - I did when I lived there for a while at your age. It was a dream, like a three year holiday really and a decade on I still get wistful over the place 😩. However, I chose to move home to have DC and be close to family and you chose (I assume!) to have DC young instead OP, so unfortunately that ship has sailed for you, but on the plus side you will probably have lots of free time to do as you please when your DC are grown up as you will hopefully still be fit and young enough to enjoy life so you can go travelling more then.

Tangled123 · 01/01/2024 01:21

I loved Christmas/New Years in Australia. It did feel a bit weird without Christmas lights, but I don’t enjoy the Christmas holidays in Ireland that much due to the bad weather. Going to the beach was great.
I spent a month in Perth and then the rest of the year in Melbourne and our flat must have had central heating because I don’t remember ever being cold inside (our flat in Auckland on the other hand only had single glazed windows so was very drafty in Winter).
I never saw any snakes or spiders etc in Perth, Melbourne, Adelaide, Sydney, Darwin or Alice Springs. They were all over the rural areas in between though. Frogs in the toilets and everything.

I agree with everyone who mentioned racism. They don’t want much immigration in Australia now so everything is set up to be as difficult as possible for immigrants. It’s the main reason I wouldn’t go back (I can’t without a visa anyway even though I was born there). I would have loved to have grown up there though, I would have had so many more opportunities compared to the crappy area I grew up in in NI.

New Zealand is great for a holiday, but a year there was enough IMO. I wouldn’t want to live there again, it’s a bit boring after you’ve done the tourist stuff if you don’t have family there.

Swipe left for the next trending thread