Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we're about to see an influx of XL Bully attacks after a rehoming free for all?

513 replies

SeattleSpacePlane · 31/12/2023 17:03

So I know the ban is about to come in. Plenty for it, many against it. Not trying to start a debate about that!

Yesterday someone on my FB shared a post from a woman who was offering to rehome an XL to save it before the ban came in. Someone commented with a group for rehoming XLs before it's too late and banned and I clicked on it for a look.

I was absolutely gobsmacked by the posts on the group. Hundreds of posts going back weeks of XLs needing new homes (I suppose expected) - but a VERY high and panicked volume of posts over the past few days, as the ban approaches.

Lots of pictures of dogs with !!URGENT!! rehoming requests. From people asking on behalf of their friend, because their HA just told them XLs are banned under their tenancy, for the XL they just found abandoned behind Tesco, because they bred an XL litter this year and a buyer has just dumped an 8 month old pup back with them. Lots of reasons. Incredibly sad for the dogs, none of this is of their making.

But it's the reaponses. Comments and comments from people offering to rehome an XL to save them. Highlights were 'willing to take one but must be good with children as I have a 5 year old'. 'I wish I could have both but I'm in a flat so one is my limit, please contact me'. 'I have an XL already who is brilliant with the kids, happy to add another poor baby to our pack'.

Dogs are currently being panic-rehomed all over the Country. People are offering their services to transport the XL from Devon to the family in Yorkshire who've agreed to take it. No home checks, no behavioural checks of the dogs, people aren't even meeting the dog they're agreeing to home. Lots and LOTS being shipped to Scotland in particular where there's no ban.

It's truly frightening the amount of people with young dc agreeing to blindly rehome an XL to save them. I wouldn't rehome a bloody Yorkie without meeting the dog first never mind an XL!

This is going to end in tragedy, surely?

AIBU to think the ban on privately rehoming them should have been immediate at point of announcement to prevent this madness? And also that, sadly, we're likely to be reading several tragic stories in the coming weeks about one of these panic-rehomed dogs turning?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
Missingmyusername · 04/01/2024 13:36

@whatsitcalledwhen Have you read the whole thread? I’ve stayed what I think many, many times.

I’ve walked them, I’ve walked them with my 7 year old. I’ve volunteered at a rescue and I’ve donated money and time to helping the staff pay for neutering/spaying, paying for three behaviourists to temperament test and transferring their last few bullies to Scotland before the ban. I am not a vet and I’m not a professional, I can only give an opinion.

I’d rather be in a room with any of the dogs you mention than some of the posters on this thread. How’s that for an answer.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 04/01/2024 11:09

To be fair to Dr Tulloch - having searched out the Sky News article - he wasn’t really saying what the pp suggested. His point of view is more complex. I don’t agree with him, but it’s not as straightforwardly misguided as it looks. Broadly, he thinks other things should be done as well.

AlienBabi · 04/01/2024 11:08

When I was in A&E not long again a young teenage boy came in with his dad, his arm ripped to shreds by their dog. When asked if it was the dog’s first attack - “no he’s attacked him before but he’s usually such a loving caring dog”! Couldn’t believe the idiocy!
TikTok has had lots of XL bully lives recently too, trying to rehome litters of pups quickly. I block each one.

whatsitcalledwhen · 04/01/2024 10:58

Missingmyusername · 04/01/2024 06:36

@StaunchMomma Not my opinion love, it’s a vet’s. I cut and paste it from sky news. You’ve given me your baseless opinion though. Clearly you know better- 🤔

If you cut and paste it, what are your own thoughts on it?

Can you see how saying "most dogs who bit people during (insert time period here) aren't XL bullies" doesn't negate the statement that "most dogs who killed during (insert time period here) are XL bullies"?

It isn't the biting that has brought about the ban. It's the deaths.

Any dog can bite. A chihuahua can bite. A spaniel can bite. But would you rather be in a room with an angry chihuahua, spaniel or XL bully?

wetotter · 04/01/2024 09:59

KC rules also say that the dam must be over 1 year old before first mating, and under 8 years old at last whelping, plus if a bitch has had 2 Csecs then no puppies from subsequent litters can be registered.

It should stop excessive breeding per bitch, but with the rising demand and good prices for doodle-poos it probably hasn't (nothing to stop the bitch having registered pedigree litters, then un-regulated unregistered cross-breed litters)

Missingmyusername · 04/01/2024 06:36

@StaunchMomma Not my opinion love, it’s a vet’s. I cut and paste it from sky news. You’ve given me your baseless opinion though. Clearly you know better- 🤔

NeighbourhoodWatchPotholeDivision · 03/01/2024 22:40

Yep. Pregnancy, birth and lactation are all tremendously demanding physiological stages/events, and she has to have adequate recovery time in between each one. Same for cats, too, not that people selling kittens on FB care.

I think I've read before that the Kennel Club has a rule that dogs can only be registered as pedigrees if they come from a bitch's first four litters during her life time. That's a rule to discourage people from repeatedly breeding from the same mother.

KarenNotAKaren · 03/01/2024 22:30

Isn’t it very unhealthy for bitches to have lots of litters?

My SIL has a Collie rescued from a puppy farm, this Collie was the resident ‘mum’ and I can’t remember how many litters she had in about years but it was obscene. One litter was by her son and the puppies were all deformed and died after the birth, because clearly the sick owners didn’t bother to keep an eye on the poor thing. She was a terrified little thing and extremely nervous. Evil fuckers.

XenoBitch · 03/01/2024 22:27

NeighbourhoodWatchPotholeDivision · 03/01/2024 22:21

I absolutely despise people like this who anthropomorphise their pets just as far as is financially/emotionally convenient.

If dogs were truly capable of consciously wanting to have the opportunity to be a "mummy", they would never get over it when the puppies disappeared to go to a buyer eight weeks after birth. Or in the case of a lot of these irresponsible morons, six weeks later.

Funny how he pretends it will impact his dog to never have puppies, when he'd laugh you out of the house if you said it would affect her to have them disappear. Because it's all about the money he'd get from selling the puppies!

Yep, dogs don't pine to be mums. I knew someone who forced her bitch to have puppies and she rejected the whole litter.

My mum lives near an estate that has lots of XL bullys. She knows of one lady who took one on and had to sign a "breeding contract"... in that she by taking the bitch on, she was agreeing to breed 3 litters from her. And this was after the ban was announced.

I am not against XL bullys, as I believe the problem is at the human end of the lead.... but stuff like this is just fucked up and shows how much some people do not appreciate the gift that is dogs.

NeighbourhoodWatchPotholeDivision · 03/01/2024 22:21

KarenNotAKaren · 03/01/2024 19:17

This May out me but fuck it.

A family member has put a big OTT post on Facebook about how their XL Bully has this week been ‘deprived the opportunity of being a mummy, she’d have made a great mum’.

He got this dog from a backyard breeder BTW. SO tempted to comment that when dogs are treated by backyard breeders so badly that ‘being a mummy’ is not an enriching experience for a dog. In fact I think it’s horrific in many ways to rip puppies from their mums, and even more so when you don’t have a fucking clue how to breed responsibly.

To me this Family member thought when they paid £2000 for their shitbull that they’d make a nice profit breeding and now they’re super annoyed that they can’t

I absolutely despise people like this who anthropomorphise their pets just as far as is financially/emotionally convenient.

If dogs were truly capable of consciously wanting to have the opportunity to be a "mummy", they would never get over it when the puppies disappeared to go to a buyer eight weeks after birth. Or in the case of a lot of these irresponsible morons, six weeks later.

Funny how he pretends it will impact his dog to never have puppies, when he'd laugh you out of the house if you said it would affect her to have them disappear. Because it's all about the money he'd get from selling the puppies!

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 03/01/2024 22:10

What else would you call a holding facility for animals waiting to die? Though unlike those humans on death row these dogs haven't actually committed a crime.

I find that truly distasteful.

The rest I can’t be bothered with. I just don’t care about the fate of XL Bullies (or any dog listed by the DDA) so long as they are muzzled in public, can’t reproduce or, otherwise, are destroyed.

WiddlinDiddlin · 03/01/2024 21:34

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 03/01/2024 21:15

i very much doubt the temporary injunction will amount to much.

As for the rest, I neither know nor care. As far as I’m concerned they could employ slaughtermen and use bolt guns.

Why should we dance around about the fates of these appalling dogs? This is much closer to a cull of rabid dogs than the unwelcome destruction of an ailing pet.

Why do you say “doggy death row”? Is that some sort of comparison with men and women waiting for execution? Really?

What else would you call a holding facility for animals waiting to die? Though unlike those humans on death row these dogs haven't actually committed a crime.

Slaughtermen/women are trained to slaughter various species. None of which at this time are dogs. I am not sure captive bolt is even considered humane for dogs - there was huge uproar when the RSPCA used that method years ago on a bunch of German Shepherds in a hoarding situation, and when that bloke in the North East was killing ex racing greyhounds that way. A free bullet is dangerous (to humans!!) and only used on dogs in extreme situations where the benefit out weighs the risk.

You'd also put the humans involved at risk from those who are breeding/selling XL Bullies and want to continue doing so. They may be a small % of the population, but theres enough of them to do some serious damage to such a facility and the people unfortunate enough to have to work there.

But again, as I say - such facilities do not exist. You'd propose what, building them? Or forcing existing kennels businesses to do this? I can't imagine they'd be particularly happy to be associated with it...

Its all moot anyway - the government has I think caused all dog rescues to potentially become these dog killing pens. It's that or some of them turn into XL bully sanctuaries which isn't really a viable solution and will lead to hoarding and neglect situations (few people continue to support sanctuaries full of unrehomable large, unattractive and non-cute animals... money dries up, standards slip and so on)...

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 03/01/2024 21:23

StaunchMomma · 03/01/2024 21:16

This is playing with stats to suit your opinion.

OF COURSE there are a lot more dog BITES from dogs that are not XLB's - There are a lot more dogs that aren't XLs than are!

The point is, if a spaniel goes for you, you might have a nasty puncture wound. If an XL turns on you, YOU'RE DEAD!

They are simply too big and too powerful to be controlled by owners and it's just not OK to keep allowing them to kill people or other animals.

Yes, I thought Dr Tulloch’s comment was profoundly stupid when it was posted. (Assuming the quote hasn’t misrepresented him.)

StaunchMomma · 03/01/2024 21:16

Missingmyusername · 01/01/2024 21:15

The hysteria on this thread is something else. Here’s a snippet from sky news…

Asked if the ban will work, Dr John Tulloch's answer was simple: "No."
He is a vet and epidemiologist, also at the University of Liverpool, who researches dog-related injuries and deaths.
In the last 20 years, the number of adults needing hospital treatment after a dog bite has tripled, his research has found. The increase in dog-related injuries predates the appearance of XL bullies to the UK; the crossbreed arrived in about 2014.
"If I genuinely thought the increase over the last 20 years was all due to one dog breed, I would happily say, yeah, we shouldn't be allowing people to have this breed," he said. "But I don't believe that is the case."

This is playing with stats to suit your opinion.

OF COURSE there are a lot more dog BITES from dogs that are not XLB's - There are a lot more dogs that aren't XLs than are!

The point is, if a spaniel goes for you, you might have a nasty puncture wound. If an XL turns on you, YOU'RE DEAD!

They are simply too big and too powerful to be controlled by owners and it's just not OK to keep allowing them to kill people or other animals.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 03/01/2024 21:15

WiddlinDiddlin · 03/01/2024 20:59

A drop off scheme?

Where?
Run by whom?
Overseen by whom?

Not by vets, they wouldn't want to be involved in that unless forced to do so.

So by non-veterinary and likely therefore not suitably experienced people, trained by who?

What facility, presumably all over England and Wales - where are such facilities? We don't have local dog slaughterhouses in each town, and each would need significant capacity in case lots turned up at once, what if theres more than can be killed in a day, so a holding facility, a doggy death row. Where would you find that?

And of course if not vets then how exactly are these lay people to euthanise dogs, guns? captive bolt? Does that sound safe or humane?

Why would this government bother when they can let rescues mop up the mess then tell them with next to no notice that they cannot rehome dogs taken in after X date (not sure if thats now the case but it was a few days ago)... and force them to euthanise instead!

Oh wait, thats what they did... and failed to foresee rescues finding a way to fight it with an injunction and rehome dogs elsewhere.

i very much doubt the temporary injunction will amount to much.

As for the rest, I neither know nor care. As far as I’m concerned they could employ slaughtermen and use bolt guns.

Why should we dance around about the fates of these appalling dogs? This is much closer to a cull of rabid dogs than the unwelcome destruction of an ailing pet.

Why do you say “doggy death row”? Is that some sort of comparison with men and women waiting for execution? Really?

funinthesun19 · 03/01/2024 21:10

'willing to take one but must be good with children as I have a 5 year old'

🤦🏼‍♀️🤦🏼‍♀️🤦🏼‍♀️🤦🏼‍♀️🤦🏼‍♀️

Might be “good with kids” at its current house, but might rip your 5 year old’s face off you fucking idiot 😡.

(To the idiot who OP spotted on Facebook and anyone else who has said the same)

XenoBitch · 03/01/2024 21:09

KarenNotAKaren · 03/01/2024 20:52

I can most definitely tell the difference between a Staffy and a XL Bully and it’s more than a difference in size.

And some people think anything with 'bull' in the name will be under the ban too.
On another thread, one poster said that bull x lurchers will be banned. Totally untrue.

oakleaffy · 03/01/2024 21:00

KarenNotAKaren · 03/01/2024 20:52

I can most definitely tell the difference between a Staffy and a XL Bully and it’s more than a difference in size.

Totally!💯
It’s shape as well and proportions.
A girl locally had a red nosed Pit puppy she said was a “ Staffie “
It was only later she admitted she was a Pit
I didn’t report her as she was very careful with the dog- I made sure to call my dog away when the Pit was playing with her ball.
Haven’t seen her in ages so maybe they moved.

WiddlinDiddlin · 03/01/2024 20:59

A drop off scheme?

Where?
Run by whom?
Overseen by whom?

Not by vets, they wouldn't want to be involved in that unless forced to do so.

So by non-veterinary and likely therefore not suitably experienced people, trained by who?

What facility, presumably all over England and Wales - where are such facilities? We don't have local dog slaughterhouses in each town, and each would need significant capacity in case lots turned up at once, what if theres more than can be killed in a day, so a holding facility, a doggy death row. Where would you find that?

And of course if not vets then how exactly are these lay people to euthanise dogs, guns? captive bolt? Does that sound safe or humane?

Why would this government bother when they can let rescues mop up the mess then tell them with next to no notice that they cannot rehome dogs taken in after X date (not sure if thats now the case but it was a few days ago)... and force them to euthanise instead!

Oh wait, thats what they did... and failed to foresee rescues finding a way to fight it with an injunction and rehome dogs elsewhere.

Missingmyusername · 03/01/2024 20:57

@SerafinasGoose If people really, truly cared for the humans who lost their lives they would go after the breeders- stop it at the source. They’d lobby the government. They’d contact their M.P, Tweet Rishi. They would not stop until every breeder was held accountable. Every breeder was fined, licensed, made to jump through every damn hoop.

@Boomboom22 you sound borderline hysterical. If the dog is muzzled, on lead and licensed you are wasting police time. If I were you I’d be more worried about what is coming next, who knows you may end on the receiving end.

Abbimae · 03/01/2024 20:53

They need putting down. People have bred these dogs for one reason- to be defensive and cause harm.

KarenNotAKaren · 03/01/2024 20:52

I can most definitely tell the difference between a Staffy and a XL Bully and it’s more than a difference in size.

oakleaffy · 03/01/2024 20:49

VegeBurgers · 03/01/2024 20:35

I have already had some shitty stares from people when walking my staffie (she’s beautiful of course but not a pedigree so maybe doesn’t look quite like a proper staffie).
Shes harmless and obviously legally doesn’t need to be muzzled. I respect people may be scared so I keep a distance from them if they seem to be.

My friend’s rescue one isn’t purebred either- but the Staffie face is SO different to that of an XL Bully
A pitbull face is different again to a Staffie.

The eye shape as well.
Pits and XLB s have much smaller , deeper set eyes than a Staffie and different width across jaw and body is like a 🦛
hippo.

XL’s - once you have seen them in person there is no confusing the type of one is used to “ Looking” at dogs conformation.

VegeBurgers · 03/01/2024 20:38

Boomboom22 · 03/01/2024 18:59

Everyone should report anything that looks vaguely like an xl bully or bully type as much as possible. Anywhere you see them, with addresses and car reg if possible.

This is so important. No blind eyes.

No please don’t. If you aren’t sure don’t waste their time when they could be enforcing the rules to a dog owner who is really risking the public.

VegeBurgers · 03/01/2024 20:35

I have already had some shitty stares from people when walking my staffie (she’s beautiful of course but not a pedigree so maybe doesn’t look quite like a proper staffie).
Shes harmless and obviously legally doesn’t need to be muzzled. I respect people may be scared so I keep a distance from them if they seem to be.

Swipe left for the next trending thread