Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we're about to see an influx of XL Bully attacks after a rehoming free for all?

513 replies

SeattleSpacePlane · 31/12/2023 17:03

So I know the ban is about to come in. Plenty for it, many against it. Not trying to start a debate about that!

Yesterday someone on my FB shared a post from a woman who was offering to rehome an XL to save it before the ban came in. Someone commented with a group for rehoming XLs before it's too late and banned and I clicked on it for a look.

I was absolutely gobsmacked by the posts on the group. Hundreds of posts going back weeks of XLs needing new homes (I suppose expected) - but a VERY high and panicked volume of posts over the past few days, as the ban approaches.

Lots of pictures of dogs with !!URGENT!! rehoming requests. From people asking on behalf of their friend, because their HA just told them XLs are banned under their tenancy, for the XL they just found abandoned behind Tesco, because they bred an XL litter this year and a buyer has just dumped an 8 month old pup back with them. Lots of reasons. Incredibly sad for the dogs, none of this is of their making.

But it's the reaponses. Comments and comments from people offering to rehome an XL to save them. Highlights were 'willing to take one but must be good with children as I have a 5 year old'. 'I wish I could have both but I'm in a flat so one is my limit, please contact me'. 'I have an XL already who is brilliant with the kids, happy to add another poor baby to our pack'.

Dogs are currently being panic-rehomed all over the Country. People are offering their services to transport the XL from Devon to the family in Yorkshire who've agreed to take it. No home checks, no behavioural checks of the dogs, people aren't even meeting the dog they're agreeing to home. Lots and LOTS being shipped to Scotland in particular where there's no ban.

It's truly frightening the amount of people with young dc agreeing to blindly rehome an XL to save them. I wouldn't rehome a bloody Yorkie without meeting the dog first never mind an XL!

This is going to end in tragedy, surely?

AIBU to think the ban on privately rehoming them should have been immediate at point of announcement to prevent this madness? And also that, sadly, we're likely to be reading several tragic stories in the coming weeks about one of these panic-rehomed dogs turning?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
Hmindr68 · 05/01/2024 12:22

I just wanted to respond to a poster who said most attacks happen inside the home. Attached are the ONS figures released Nov 2023 which show that in the last 5 years, in the case of fatal attacks that has only been true in one year.
In 2023, of the sixteen people killed by dogs, only 5 were in the home.

To think we're about to see an influx of XL Bully attacks after a rehoming free for all?
WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 05/01/2024 11:48

ntmdino · 05/01/2024 11:30

I'm not being pig-headed. The point is that these are short term measures that actually do nothing, because it's an eternal game of whack-a-mole on the end result when the actual problem is caused much, much earlier in the process.

You're so blinkered that you're actively avoiding looking at the stats overall, just focusing on 2020+ to satisfy your confirmation bias.

Putting all of that aside...are you really saying that constantly being reactive and banning breed after breed after there have been attacks is better than pre-empting their existence by actually getting a grip on breeding, and preventing those dogs from being bred in the first place?

Your solution requires people to die and be injured before anything is done. Mine prevents the possibility of that ever happening except in very exceptional circumstances, and results in increased canine quality of life overall and results in fewer dogs (and thus vastly reduced need for rescues), and allows for the control of dangerous genetic lines in all breeds (yes, even the cuddly labrador can be dangerous when uncontrollably bred), and makes it impossible to crossbreed to skirt the law.

As SomeCat has said, the ideal would be both, plus a hefty licence fee plus automatic lifetime bans for owners of dangerously out of control dogs, dogs causing injury to people or other pets etc.

But even if these measures were put in place, a ban on the most dangerous breeds would still be right. And if we can’t have it all at once, bans are the most urgent.

ntmdino · 05/01/2024 11:48

SomeCatFromJapan · 05/01/2024 11:34

Really they should be doing both. Belt and braces.

Well, BSL wouldn't be necessary if breeding was properly regulated and controlled.

The truth is that BSL is cheap and easy to implement and grabs headlines, but breeding regulation is much harder (and requires actual knowledge of the subject, which politicians lack). It's a hand-wave solution that just puts off the problem until the next electoral term, and it always was.

Consider this: in the year prior to the DDA being enacted, 3% of hospital presentations and deaths were due to pitbulls, which was the breed-du-jour of the sensationalist press and the primary reason for the law's entry into the statutes. In fact, 24% were by German Shepherds and 18% by mongrels (which can't be covered by BSL) - believe it or not, the breeds mentioned in the DDA combined accounted for just 5%. Labradors and collies were also massively more likely to result in hospitalisation or death than any of the breeds outlawed by the DDA.

So...what was the DDA for, then? It completely ignored 42% of all attacks (the two biggest "breeds"), and was designed specifically to have almost no effect on the numbers by focusing on those breeds.

SomeCatFromJapan · 05/01/2024 11:34

Really they should be doing both. Belt and braces.

ntmdino · 05/01/2024 11:30

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 05/01/2024 11:02

You know perfectly well that bull breeds (and Rottweilers and Cane Corsos) are massively the most likely to kill people. It’s all there on the internet. If you look at the wiki list for UK fatal dog attacks from 2020 you’ll see the XL Bully again and again. And it doesn’t take Einstein to work out that non-fatal attacks by these breeds will be worse than other breeds.

You are just parroting the line about replacement breeds and crosses, i.e. that some other dangerous dog type will emerge after a ban. So what? Ban those too.

Why are you being so pig-headed about sensible public safety measures?

I'm not being pig-headed. The point is that these are short term measures that actually do nothing, because it's an eternal game of whack-a-mole on the end result when the actual problem is caused much, much earlier in the process.

You're so blinkered that you're actively avoiding looking at the stats overall, just focusing on 2020+ to satisfy your confirmation bias.

Putting all of that aside...are you really saying that constantly being reactive and banning breed after breed after there have been attacks is better than pre-empting their existence by actually getting a grip on breeding, and preventing those dogs from being bred in the first place?

Your solution requires people to die and be injured before anything is done. Mine prevents the possibility of that ever happening except in very exceptional circumstances, and results in increased canine quality of life overall and results in fewer dogs (and thus vastly reduced need for rescues), and allows for the control of dangerous genetic lines in all breeds (yes, even the cuddly labrador can be dangerous when uncontrollably bred), and makes it impossible to crossbreed to skirt the law.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 05/01/2024 11:02

ntmdino · 05/01/2024 10:18

It's made zero difference to the number of hospital presentations or deaths related to dog bites.

That's the point. It hasn't helped one bit in the last 25 years, no matter how much you keep saying it has. That's what you find if you look at the statistics and the studies, rather than the drooling Daily Mail headlines.

It's not about "deaths and terrible attacks per breed", it's about "deaths and terrible attacks across all breeds". Or do you somehow think a death or hospitalisation only counts if the dog involved happens to be of a specific set of breeds you don't like?

It's nothing to do with defending "massive, vicious dogs" and everything to do with the actual real-world results of failed legislation that, for some reason, everyone wants to hang their hat on.

Edited

You know perfectly well that bull breeds (and Rottweilers and Cane Corsos) are massively the most likely to kill people. It’s all there on the internet. If you look at the wiki list for UK fatal dog attacks from 2020 you’ll see the XL Bully again and again. And it doesn’t take Einstein to work out that non-fatal attacks by these breeds will be worse than other breeds.

You are just parroting the line about replacement breeds and crosses, i.e. that some other dangerous dog type will emerge after a ban. So what? Ban those too.

Why are you being so pig-headed about sensible public safety measures?

MadWifeInTheAttic · 05/01/2024 10:59

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

NeverStopTwinkling · 05/01/2024 10:25

I'm in Scotland and worried sick to be honest. I absolutely hate this breed and their stupid owners, and don't make any apology for that. I'll teach my children to avoid them, I'll avoid them as best I can.

I'm writing to my MSP today, I can't think of what else to do.

ntmdino · 05/01/2024 10:18

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 05/01/2024 07:22

I’m not missing anything. Banning breeds isn’t about the number of bites. It’s about the numbers of deaths and terrible attacks per breed.

How many times do defenders of massive, vicious dogs need to have this said to them? FFS

It's made zero difference to the number of hospital presentations or deaths related to dog bites.

That's the point. It hasn't helped one bit in the last 25 years, no matter how much you keep saying it has. That's what you find if you look at the statistics and the studies, rather than the drooling Daily Mail headlines.

It's not about "deaths and terrible attacks per breed", it's about "deaths and terrible attacks across all breeds". Or do you somehow think a death or hospitalisation only counts if the dog involved happens to be of a specific set of breeds you don't like?

It's nothing to do with defending "massive, vicious dogs" and everything to do with the actual real-world results of failed legislation that, for some reason, everyone wants to hang their hat on.

SerafinasGoose · 05/01/2024 09:23

MadWifeInTheAttic · 05/01/2024 09:10

It's like talking to Alf Garnett on here some days.

You're suggesting 'breedism' is akin to dog-discrimination? Systemic prejudice, perhaps? How about a touch of racism?

Good Lord. With this reasoning, lovers of these dogs don't exactly do themselves any favours.

Tatumm · 05/01/2024 09:16

I’m sure there are good owners but I struggle to understand the psychology of wanting to own a breed with a better chance than most of hurting people. Especially mums with kids at home. Do owners live in intimidating neighbourhoods or live alone and get them for protection?

MadWifeInTheAttic · 05/01/2024 09:10

It's like talking to Alf Garnett on here some days.

Cosmosforbreakfast · 05/01/2024 09:04

Anyone sparing a thought for the good XL bully owners?

I have no thoughts to spare for drug dealers and scumbags, they're the only kind of people who want these killer dogs. No one in their right mind would have one of these savages anywhere near them. I'll keep my thoughts for the victims of XL Bully attacks.

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 05/01/2024 07:44

A few people have mentioned that dog fighters will love xl bullies. I think they prefer the smaller more agile dogs like pit bulls.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 05/01/2024 07:22

ntmdino · 05/01/2024 06:16

No, you're spectacularly missing the point. There has been no reduction in bite incidents at all in the 25 years since BSL was introduced - in fact, apart from one year (2000), it's gone up faster than the dog population has every single year.

That's why it's evident that BSL doesn't work and that other measures are required to actually solve the problem rather than just make it look like they're solving the problem to get votes.

I’m not missing anything. Banning breeds isn’t about the number of bites. It’s about the numbers of deaths and terrible attacks per breed.

How many times do defenders of massive, vicious dogs need to have this said to them? FFS

LaLoba · 05/01/2024 06:59

whatsitcalledwhen · 04/01/2024 22:59

It baffles me that people who claim to be responsible dog owners and dog lovers believe that an owner could physically overpower an adult XL bully in attack mode.

Sensible owners who truly respect dogs would do research enough to know that isn't possible, and as a consequence choose one of the many other thousands of breeds of dog as a pet. Especially if they have children in the home. Then they aren't just foolish, they're failing to safeguard their children.

Any dog can turn due to things like brain tumours. Completely out of their control, just a terrible bit of bad luck. Which is why choosing a dog that can do so much damage and not be overpowered if they do lose control, is so irresponsible.

My Jack Russell had fits towards the end of her life in which she viciously attacked her beloved older collie ‘brother’, it was how we found out she had a brain tumour.
She was in a terrier red mist when it happened, would lash out at anyone in her way and was fully in attack mode - in several weeks of this before diagnosis I was able to restrain her and protect my other dog without any physical harm to myself.

Multiple fully grown men at a time have been unable to stop an XL bully attack. I don’t know why anyone who knows anything about dogs would want them in their home.

I’ve also noticed that none of the people I know who were reposting pleas from rescues to rehome these dogs in December actually wanted to live with one themselves either. By definition I’d say an XL bully owner is at best, a misguided fool and whichever way you look at it, not competent with dogs.

ntmdino · 05/01/2024 06:16

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 04/01/2024 22:07

Some people on here say all the time that breed bans haven’t worked at all. I find that strange. It’s obviously untrue as pitbulls, Tosas etc are neither seen nor are reported as attacking people.

If the argument is that other breeds replace the banned ones the law should simply extend to ban further breeds. If the legislators don’t hang around a ban can be in operation in a few months. If we reach a point where large dogs have to banned, or maybe subject to muzzling in public, by reference to weight/height/jaw strength etc so be it.

No, you're spectacularly missing the point. There has been no reduction in bite incidents at all in the 25 years since BSL was introduced - in fact, apart from one year (2000), it's gone up faster than the dog population has every single year.

That's why it's evident that BSL doesn't work and that other measures are required to actually solve the problem rather than just make it look like they're solving the problem to get votes.

oakleaffy · 04/01/2024 23:22

MadWifeInTheAttic · 04/01/2024 22:19

Muzzle training takes time with many dogs. My own dog won't. I doubt you'd like a metal cage attached to your face. But the good bully owners are now going through this to comply with this foolish law, which (as PP pointed out) wouldn't have prevented many of these attacks which seem to have taken place in private homes rather than public spaces.

As @SomeCatFromJapan says, Lurchers, Greyhounds and Whippets often wear Muzzles and no one makes such a fuss over it as 'XL' owners do..

It really doesn't take long to get a correctly fitted muzzle, and a dog will associate their muzzle with fun things like running with their mates , lure coursing and just being out and about.

Whippets,wear them lure coursing as they can get excited and might nip at each other when they catch the lure {a bunch of plastic straps} .

This is a sensible owner on a Lurcher forum.

''I muzzle , mainly because he cant stand any of the others being faster than him and will bite them as they go past. He is a greyhound x deerhound type. Unfortunatley this bad habit has resulted in several visits to the vets with the others for stitching and stapling. Easier to put a muzzle on him and stop the whole thing.

He loves the frisbee he has had since a baby, but cannot play well with the others, so sometimes I let him play on his own in the park as a special treat.

It's a shame because he loves the others to chase him but it tends to go sour, and I don't want anymore vet's bills!''

We too had a dog that had to be muzzled for a short time and he was absolutely fine with it.
Others use muzzles to stop them scavenging and getting ill.

Getting a well fitted one is crucial for comfort {and safety of others}

There are a couple of large heavy dogs locally that were ordered to wear a muzzle by a Court, and they too are fine.

whatsitcalledwhen · 04/01/2024 22:59

It baffles me that people who claim to be responsible dog owners and dog lovers believe that an owner could physically overpower an adult XL bully in attack mode.

Sensible owners who truly respect dogs would do research enough to know that isn't possible, and as a consequence choose one of the many other thousands of breeds of dog as a pet. Especially if they have children in the home. Then they aren't just foolish, they're failing to safeguard their children.

Any dog can turn due to things like brain tumours. Completely out of their control, just a terrible bit of bad luck. Which is why choosing a dog that can do so much damage and not be overpowered if they do lose control, is so irresponsible.

StarDolphins · 04/01/2024 22:55

Dog fighters will snap them up.

Yet more misery for these innocent, failed dogs.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 04/01/2024 22:54

MadWifeInTheAttic · 04/01/2024 22:50

That's horrendous.

No, it’s not.

whatsitcalledwhen · 04/01/2024 22:51

@MadWifeInTheAttic

She has absolutely no problems controlling her dog. She has owned large dogs before, including other types of bulldog.

If she has an XL bully and he / she went into attack mode for any reason (fear / misguidedly defending her / brain tumour etc etc) then she absolutely could not 'control' her dog.

It doesn't matter how much experience someone has with dogs, if a dog the size of an adult XL bully goes into attack mode, they cannot be overpowered.

It is not just 'daily mail headlines', the police report after a recent attack confirmed that the dog attacking someone was hit with a hammer in an effort to stop it, but that didn't work. The dog had to be tasered. You're honestly telling me that if Mimi went into attack mode, her owner, your gentle female friend, could physically overpower her?

You can't believe that's true? No sensible dog owner would believe that.

MadWifeInTheAttic · 04/01/2024 22:50

That's horrendous.

XenoBitch · 04/01/2024 22:46

Bladwdoda · 04/01/2024 22:36

Honestly disgusted at the amount of owners who has just chosen to give up their dog rather than stick to the new restrictions. Speaks volumes about them.

I agree op it’s shocking the amount of people willing to take an own known dog, let alone one this size, into their home on a whim, without any proper prep or checks.

Madness

Someone on this thread is a vet nurse, and said they had to PTS one dog as the owner was homeless so could not apply for an exemption.
Not everyone is feckless and can't be bothered. Some can't exempt their dogs. People in social housing are also finding that they can't either.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 04/01/2024 22:43

MadWifeInTheAttic · 04/01/2024 22:27

She has absolutely no problems controlling her dog. She has owned large dogs before, including other types of bulldog. I am attached to my own particular type of herding dog-- a notoriously gentle one, but I wouldn't become less attached if Daily Mail headline writers and vote-hunting Tory MPs decided to set their sights on them, to win over their witless audiences. So long as you lot have something to hate and fear, they're happy.

Righty, you think the awful attacks and deaths are either untrue or just don’t matter. And people’s views about XL Bullies are all straight out of the Mail. Got it.