Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we're about to see an influx of XL Bully attacks after a rehoming free for all?

513 replies

SeattleSpacePlane · 31/12/2023 17:03

So I know the ban is about to come in. Plenty for it, many against it. Not trying to start a debate about that!

Yesterday someone on my FB shared a post from a woman who was offering to rehome an XL to save it before the ban came in. Someone commented with a group for rehoming XLs before it's too late and banned and I clicked on it for a look.

I was absolutely gobsmacked by the posts on the group. Hundreds of posts going back weeks of XLs needing new homes (I suppose expected) - but a VERY high and panicked volume of posts over the past few days, as the ban approaches.

Lots of pictures of dogs with !!URGENT!! rehoming requests. From people asking on behalf of their friend, because their HA just told them XLs are banned under their tenancy, for the XL they just found abandoned behind Tesco, because they bred an XL litter this year and a buyer has just dumped an 8 month old pup back with them. Lots of reasons. Incredibly sad for the dogs, none of this is of their making.

But it's the reaponses. Comments and comments from people offering to rehome an XL to save them. Highlights were 'willing to take one but must be good with children as I have a 5 year old'. 'I wish I could have both but I'm in a flat so one is my limit, please contact me'. 'I have an XL already who is brilliant with the kids, happy to add another poor baby to our pack'.

Dogs are currently being panic-rehomed all over the Country. People are offering their services to transport the XL from Devon to the family in Yorkshire who've agreed to take it. No home checks, no behavioural checks of the dogs, people aren't even meeting the dog they're agreeing to home. Lots and LOTS being shipped to Scotland in particular where there's no ban.

It's truly frightening the amount of people with young dc agreeing to blindly rehome an XL to save them. I wouldn't rehome a bloody Yorkie without meeting the dog first never mind an XL!

This is going to end in tragedy, surely?

AIBU to think the ban on privately rehoming them should have been immediate at point of announcement to prevent this madness? And also that, sadly, we're likely to be reading several tragic stories in the coming weeks about one of these panic-rehomed dogs turning?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
CoatOfArms · 02/01/2024 11:30

I think the Scottish government took advice from the animal charities on the XL legislation and they were told it wasn't the breed etc. and also that the dangerous dogs act was completely unpoliced. Whether that's sensible or not at least they took advice.

Did they bollocks. They did what they always do, look at what England/Wales are doing and choose the opposite. If course if you go to a "Bullies are Marvellous" charity they are going to say it's not the breed. Meanwhile, back in the real world...

Also anyone with half a brain could predict that the hard of thinking are going to import their animals to us up here. Your other mistake is thinking the Scottish government give a shit about anyone in Scotland who is not a paid up SNP member.

ismu · 02/01/2024 11:22

I think the Scottish government took advice from the animal charities on the XL legislation and they were told it wasn't the breed etc. and also that the dangerous dogs act was completely unpoliced. Whether that's sensible or not at least they took advice.
Unlike King Rishi who decided that an instant ban would work.
It's a shitshow of course because anyone could see that these dogs are bred and owned by people who either are gangsters or like to think they are. There's also a serious amount of dog fighting that goes on.
It's part of a whole culture that prides itself on being hard and the attacks are part of the thrill.
So the next favourable dog breed is just waiting to be adopted by these people.
Unfortunately Scotland has a good fair share of these idiots and plenty more seemingly intelligent people who buy brachiocephalic breeds, adopt mental street dogs from the Med and let their beloved fur babies off lead to maul fields of sheep. None of that has been dealt with in any meaningful way by any government in Scotland.
My dog was attacked by an off lead bedlington terrier and fortunately I was able to pick the dog up by its harness and move it. Fortunately as he's a beagle it put him neither up nor down and he still screams like a knob to meet and greet every dog he sees
I'd hate to even begin to drag off a Bully.

SomeCatFromJapan · 02/01/2024 10:27

That is absolutely horrible. I've made clear I'm not keen on the breed and I don't think humane euthanasia is the worst thing that can happen to an animal in contrast to an uncertain future, but deliberately causing suffering is a whole other matter.

Megifer · 02/01/2024 10:19

An XL bully has been found in an alleyway in London with its head fractured, legs tied together, ear cut off and legs burned. Initial reports suggest it escaped from someone's garden when the fence blew down in the wind, so seems very possible a member of the public has done this.

Article easy to find. Warning the images are very upsetting.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 02/01/2024 10:14

ArtisticMeeg · 02/01/2024 09:49

Do vets have the highest suicide rate of all professions? Have you got a link to that? I acknowledge it is one of the highest. But dentists and doctors have high rates as well. And dentists definitely aren't killing anyone. I thought the suicide levels for any medical profession was high due to stress levels. Whether that's for people or animals. Most likely from having to deal with the public and make decisions that could be wrong etc and cause them to be sued potentially.

I had a quick Google and it seems to confirm what you say. The professions generally have higher than average rates of suicide, no doubt because of the general stresses.

I very much doubt that putting pets down is the main cause, or probably even a major cause, of stress in vets. Money and dealing with the unforgiving and unreasonable public are much more likely to be behind that. And it’s not hard to see how difficult some pet owners must be, judging by the many threads about cats and dogs on MN and some of the crazy attitudes of owners.

Threemusketeers80 · 02/01/2024 10:10

I'm a dog lover, I have three myself. But I've got non status breed who are placid and calm in nature.

I however do agree with the restrictions, I've seen people out walking these dogs with little training being dragged around, having to dig their heels in and use their body weight to try and control them. Most are acquired to breed from and sell on to people who want that "look".

It's sad they will be PTS that aspect I don't particularly agree with. But yes they should have a licence, be neutered, and wear a muzzle. At least then they can't rip people to shreds anymore.

ArtisticMeeg · 02/01/2024 09:49

CornishPorsche · 02/01/2024 09:02

Vets have the highest suicide rate of all professions. No one becomes a vet because they want to put animals down, especially not in bulk quantities. It's an emotive part of their job. I'm guessing you aren't upset if your pet is put to sleep?

Do vets have the highest suicide rate of all professions? Have you got a link to that? I acknowledge it is one of the highest. But dentists and doctors have high rates as well. And dentists definitely aren't killing anyone. I thought the suicide levels for any medical profession was high due to stress levels. Whether that's for people or animals. Most likely from having to deal with the public and make decisions that could be wrong etc and cause them to be sued potentially.

Megifer · 02/01/2024 09:25

"As someone in the profession said earlier today to us “I keep the syringes filled, game on” and they were from Manchester. 148 were euthanised between 27th and 30th December at that one practice"

I'll take "shit that didn't happen so much it unhappened things that did happen" for £250 please.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 02/01/2024 09:25

CornishPorsche · 02/01/2024 09:02

Vets have the highest suicide rate of all professions. No one becomes a vet because they want to put animals down, especially not in bulk quantities. It's an emotive part of their job. I'm guessing you aren't upset if your pet is put to sleep?

I would never keep a pet alive if it were ill or elderly and had a poor life. Keeping pets alive for the sake of it is cruel IMO. I’ve had pets put down when they were old and in a bad way.

I used to work with a vet’s wife who said her husband used to tell her of many owners who would spend anything and subject a cat or a dog to anything, to keep it going, however much he might counsel them against it. Paid for a lot of foreign holidays for them, apparently.

I’ve never had to have a healthy pet PTS. But if the law required it I would do it. And that would be my pet, not the vet’s pet. To a stranger it would be just another dog.

As for suicide among vets, that’s truly terrible (as it is for any suicide). But I imagine there are many reasons for that, including the pressures of dealing with obsessive and unreasonable owners, as I said upthread.

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 02/01/2024 09:24

Give this job to the Royal Air Force then, not vets.

CornishPorsche · 02/01/2024 09:02

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 01/01/2024 22:57

Why a toll on vets’ mental health? Vets would just be despatching dogs. If a vet becomes traumatised by putting down animals they shouldn’t be a vet.

I don’t believe any vets would suffer in that way anyway. They’re not A&E doctors.

Vets have the highest suicide rate of all professions. No one becomes a vet because they want to put animals down, especially not in bulk quantities. It's an emotive part of their job. I'm guessing you aren't upset if your pet is put to sleep?

Patchworksack · 02/01/2024 05:36

You are correct @SeattleSpacePlane that the irresponsible last minute rehoming is likely to lead to an increase in attacks. There has been no increase in resources allocated to deal with the consequences of the ban for the dog wardens or police dog liaison officers - both already under resourced services. I think it remains to be seen how/if the ban is policed and we need a few high profile prosecutions with the unlimited fine/6 month prison sentence actually being applied before it will be taken seriously. It’s likely that as with pre-existing dog law the law abiding responsible owners will comply and there will be very little consequence for the folk that don’t unless a serious attack happens.

NeighbourhoodWatchPotholeDivision · 02/01/2024 04:08

You have to ask though why are they willingly taking their “fur babies” who wouldn’t hurt a fly to be PTS? Or why are they sending them to Scotland instead of doing the responsible thing of having the animal castrated, registered or muzzled?

Yes. I can see that training even the most laidback adult dog to accept wearing a muzzle must be a dreary grind. But neutering and microchipping is just normal pet ownership of cats and dogs. I'm not sympathetic to anyone who'd rather put the animal down.

You don't even need to step a foot outside your home to get third-party insurance and the exemption certificate! They can both be done online! If you're trying to rehome your pet on facebook, you've got net access, haven't you?

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 02/01/2024 01:11

XenoBitch · 01/01/2024 23:12

Vets become vets because they love animals and want to help them. They do not see PTS as "dispatching" dogs at all. Every animal that they see is a beloved pet. Many vets know and love their patients and journeys, and cry when that journey ends.
Do you honestly think that vets are just autonomous robots who inject stuff into animals to kill them, and go about their day after?

Are you aware of the high suicide rate in the vet profession?

I’d lay good money that a fair amount of the stress on vets is from the demands and behaviour of obsessive and unpleasant owners.

oakleaffy · 02/01/2024 00:31

BellaAndDave · 01/01/2024 23:41

It’s par the the course of the SNP though. They want independence and refuse to be governed by Westminster - they’re making a point aren’t they as usual to the detriment of everyone else.

I’ve posted about this before on here. Our beloved lab was attacked by an XL Bully. It ripped my dog to bits and I will never forget that attack. We’d heard about them but we’d never met one. The thing came from nowhere and no amount of battering it, kicking it, lifting its back legs up, booting its ribs, smacking it with a fence post or kicking its balls stopped the attack. My DH managed to drag it (and my dog because it wouldn’t let go) into a small river and he drowned it. He was literally lying on top of the thing to keep it under the water…. I have absolutely no shame that he drowned that thing. My dog never survived, the internal injuries were fatal. I really don’t think anyone understands the viciousness of these dogs, the power in their jaws or seeing how happy they are when attacking. We had the police out who filed a report of a dangerous dog. The bastard owner fucked back off the England and surprise surprise gave a fake address.

The Scottish government need to get their finger out as most of these dogs being rehomed up here are dangerous. Let’s face it, if you truly loved your dog you’d muzzle it, have it castrated and get exemption papers wouldn’t you? You wouldn’t just rehome a dog to Scotland for no reason.

I remember your very traumatising post about the vicious attack by an XL Bully on your innocent dog.

These things get a kick out of attacking other animals- Dogs, horses, cats, sheep- they get literally ''turned on'' by the act of mauling.

They are an absolute menace, and unstoppable as you say, unless one has a .45 and several rounds.

The average puny owner drawn to this type of dog doesn't have a hope in hell of controlling it should it decide to attack.

A foolish so called 'Trainer' of these things took an interviewer out with him, but the XL was focussed on other dogs and absolutely not listening to him, and his elderly foster carer neighbour had one as well ''as the foster kids can be rough with it'' ''I pacifically {sic} got the dog so she can be rough with it''

Absolutely insane.

American XL Bully ban: Can they be trained to behave? | Times Reports

A man has died after suffering serious injuries while protecting his puppy from a larger dog, believed to be an XL bully.The victim has been named locally as...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=blwFCsHTGdU&t=308s

Boomboom22 · 02/01/2024 00:29

That's fantastic, let's hope those kinds of numbers are replicated everywhere.

BellaAndDave · 02/01/2024 00:23

XenoBitch · 01/01/2024 23:49

Really?
You think vets/nurses just see XLs as "beasts"?
A happy and healthy dog is not the sort of animal they are content to PTS. They can actually refuse (and they do... some surrenders to rescue centres are from vets refusing to PTS... some even adopt the animal themselves).

But I know you from other threads. You hate dogs.

You’d be surprised at how many vets and veterinary staff view these dogs as “abominations” of animals. It doesn’t matter if it’s happy and healthy it’s the risk it poses. As someone in the profession said earlier today to us “I keep the syringes filled, game on” and they were from Manchester. 148 were euthanised between 27th and 30th December at that one practice. 148 less chances of attacks imo. You have to ask though why are they willingly taking their “fur babies” who wouldn’t hurt a fly to be PTS? Or why are they sending them to Scotland instead of doing the responsible thing of having the animal castrated, registered or muzzled?

XenoBitch · 01/01/2024 23:56

winewine · 01/01/2024 23:24

@XenoBitch
I would say vets would be more traumatised trying to help the cats and dogs that have been victims of XL bully attacks.

There is a difference between treating an injured animal and PTS a healthy one.

XenoBitch · 01/01/2024 23:49

Boomboom22 · 01/01/2024 23:20

Any vet who cares about animals in general would be quite happy to pts these beasts, they are a danger to other animals and to humans. It is extremely doubtful these will take a toll on their mh, also they only pts animals where it is best to as a general rule so don't find it upsetting when the alternative is suffering.

Really?
You think vets/nurses just see XLs as "beasts"?
A happy and healthy dog is not the sort of animal they are content to PTS. They can actually refuse (and they do... some surrenders to rescue centres are from vets refusing to PTS... some even adopt the animal themselves).

But I know you from other threads. You hate dogs.

BellaAndDave · 01/01/2024 23:41

Cosmosforbreakfast · 01/01/2024 21:43

Humza better get his head out of his ass now and bring in a ban on those savage dogs before a child is ripped to shreds. Letting the country become a dumping ground for those savage dogs is just ridiculous. Just another example of the SNPs complete disregard for the safety of Scottish people.

It’s par the the course of the SNP though. They want independence and refuse to be governed by Westminster - they’re making a point aren’t they as usual to the detriment of everyone else.

I’ve posted about this before on here. Our beloved lab was attacked by an XL Bully. It ripped my dog to bits and I will never forget that attack. We’d heard about them but we’d never met one. The thing came from nowhere and no amount of battering it, kicking it, lifting its back legs up, booting its ribs, smacking it with a fence post or kicking its balls stopped the attack. My DH managed to drag it (and my dog because it wouldn’t let go) into a small river and he drowned it. He was literally lying on top of the thing to keep it under the water…. I have absolutely no shame that he drowned that thing. My dog never survived, the internal injuries were fatal. I really don’t think anyone understands the viciousness of these dogs, the power in their jaws or seeing how happy they are when attacking. We had the police out who filed a report of a dangerous dog. The bastard owner fucked back off the England and surprise surprise gave a fake address.

The Scottish government need to get their finger out as most of these dogs being rehomed up here are dangerous. Let’s face it, if you truly loved your dog you’d muzzle it, have it castrated and get exemption papers wouldn’t you? You wouldn’t just rehome a dog to Scotland for no reason.

winewine · 01/01/2024 23:24

@XenoBitch
I would say vets would be more traumatised trying to help the cats and dogs that have been victims of XL bully attacks.

Boomboom22 · 01/01/2024 23:20

Any vet who cares about animals in general would be quite happy to pts these beasts, they are a danger to other animals and to humans. It is extremely doubtful these will take a toll on their mh, also they only pts animals where it is best to as a general rule so don't find it upsetting when the alternative is suffering.

Teder · 01/01/2024 23:14

Missingmyusername · 01/01/2024 21:15

The hysteria on this thread is something else. Here’s a snippet from sky news…

Asked if the ban will work, Dr John Tulloch's answer was simple: "No."
He is a vet and epidemiologist, also at the University of Liverpool, who researches dog-related injuries and deaths.
In the last 20 years, the number of adults needing hospital treatment after a dog bite has tripled, his research has found. The increase in dog-related injuries predates the appearance of XL bullies to the UK; the crossbreed arrived in about 2014.
"If I genuinely thought the increase over the last 20 years was all due to one dog breed, I would happily say, yeah, we shouldn't be allowing people to have this breed," he said. "But I don't believe that is the case."

This isn’t hysteria. Incidentally, a very misogynistic word to use on a predominantly female site. I think this thread has been quite fair and measured.

People have been pointing out that many XL bully owners - who proclaim to love their dogs - have shown very limited actual care and would rather dump them. Too much effort to follow the law but not too much effort to whine about it on social media. 🤷🏻‍♀️
Just goes to show they don’t have the dog for the right reasons and that the ban is needed because too many people cannot be trusted to own an XL without legal restrictions.

If my (tiny dog) breed was banned or there were legal restrictions, you best believe I’d be going above and beyond to keep my dog and adhere to the law. The difference is, my dog is beloved family pet and I made a commitment. Too many people see XL bullies purely as status symbols and they’ve ruined it for everyone else (the dogs and the sensible owners).

XenoBitch · 01/01/2024 23:12

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 01/01/2024 22:57

Why a toll on vets’ mental health? Vets would just be despatching dogs. If a vet becomes traumatised by putting down animals they shouldn’t be a vet.

I don’t believe any vets would suffer in that way anyway. They’re not A&E doctors.

Vets become vets because they love animals and want to help them. They do not see PTS as "dispatching" dogs at all. Every animal that they see is a beloved pet. Many vets know and love their patients and journeys, and cry when that journey ends.
Do you honestly think that vets are just autonomous robots who inject stuff into animals to kill them, and go about their day after?

Are you aware of the high suicide rate in the vet profession?

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 01/01/2024 22:57

XenoBitch · 01/01/2024 21:53

I think it is incredibly sad, and it is the dogs who are paying the price.
Responsible owners will have already been doing muzzle training and getting the right paperwork sorted. If someone loves their dog, they will do what they need to to keep them. Obviously people losing their dogs because of tenancy agreements is something unavoidable.
I have only seen a handful of XL bullys where I live, and they have all been well behaved (and might I add, not with the stereotypical owner that gets peddled on here).
I feel for the vets in this... having to PTS healthy dogs. It must be having a huge toll on their mental health.

Why a toll on vets’ mental health? Vets would just be despatching dogs. If a vet becomes traumatised by putting down animals they shouldn’t be a vet.

I don’t believe any vets would suffer in that way anyway. They’re not A&E doctors.