Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

‘You need to accept that both our mothers are going to move in with us’

359 replies

Wigglytuff123 · 31/12/2023 15:24

Is what DH said to me… instant chills

I do not speak the same language as my MIL, not even a little and I find her very very hard work, truthfully there’s a lot of water under the bridge. She’s just turned 60

now to my own mother fractious history. I was the scapegoated child and sibling golden child (single narcissistic mother, at points she was down right abusvie and cruel) the worm has turned somewhat as sibling has very similar narcissistic tendencies as mother and sticky fingers (Steals despite being mid 30s) and no longer talks to mother as was caught in the act. Mother is 70s

both single, divorced and widowed.

is dh right? Truthfully the thought of either of them living with us fills me with dread

what prompted this conversation was we’re planning a 3rd child and dh was making his case to consider a 5/6 bed house for a move, whereas I don’t think staying in a 4 bed with a garden office sounds too awful.

is he right? I don’t know why but I feel quite resentful to take on a mortgage in a much larger house for them to move in, and if one moves in the other will be pissed the other didn’t, and both together, no way.

at least my mum would be bringing capital, his mum wouldn’t be putting anything into the house

OP posts:
diddl · 31/12/2023 19:53

We can’t tell her we go on holiday because she’ll melt down, we hid we bought our house for a year, we’ve got two weeks in America next year and we’ll be pretending we’ve got a virus apparently

All that on top of her mocking you & your husband thinks that you should tolerate her living with you?

CharlotteRumpling · 31/12/2023 19:46

I wasn't trying to compare the two situations. I am simply fed up of posters with zero knowledge of Asian culture posting " Well tell him to fuck off with his mum". Won't happen.

That said OP, your MIL sounds insane. Mine is difficult sometimes, but she is civil and nice to me.

Justia · 31/12/2023 19:35

Wigglytuff123 · 31/12/2023 19:30

Sorry I’m confused, is there another thread?

my MIL has never worked and refused to, and definitely expects dh to keep her and her husband (but more so dh and her husband left her for another woman and had pretty just treated their house as a bnb to stay in like once a week max for year… not paying for maintenance, just food and bill money) I’m confused if the other things are about my MIL or another thread?

@Wigglytuff123

There is another thread discussing another mother and @CharlotteRumpling was trying to compare your situation to that.. I was pointing out that to do so is absolutely ludicrous.

Justia · 31/12/2023 19:33

@Wigglytuff123 I really wouldn’t worry, by the time your MIL moving into your house becomes an issue she will probably be ticked off for care home anyway.

LA will organise multiple calls to keep her in her own home for as long as possible, and you and DH can add in additional calls during the day…. The point where it becomes a conversation is when you both get sick of having to run over there 4x a day, do her washing separately, 2 sets of grocery shopping etc etc.

When you’re having that conversation and dealing with that situation you have enough to be coping with without - oh no we have to get a bigger house or renovate to build an annex…. In reality she might be dead or moved to a care home before the accomodation is suitable and you have all that stress.

Get the bigger house and then at least in the event things get tough you are prepared. If she is that bad ie dementia/cancer etc her physicality and personality will be different to the difficult person you encounter today (be that mother or mil).

Hopefully neither will ever need that level of care, remain independent and die in their sleep or quickly… but really it is better to be prepared because it is god awful enough if it does happen.

Walmu · 31/12/2023 19:32

Please just talk to your husband and hear what he really means? What stage of life is planning for and then take it from there.

its conversations worth having. It’s easier to plan now when they are well than not.
We have healthy relationships with my mom and MIL, been there for us. We will live together at some point when needed, fortunate enough to be able to do it well financially.

not the case for everyone, so hence the the need for the conversation.

As for the peeps who have said “get ready to divorce”…I cannot begin to imagine what it’s like to be like this, hints emotionally manipulative in their own lives.

Wigglytuff123 · 31/12/2023 19:30

Justia · 31/12/2023 19:20

@CharlotteRumpling

Can I just interject here to point out that said “penniless mother” has

  1. never worked a day in her life
  2. sponged off husbands and then her own mother to survive
  3. never claimed child benefit nor carers allowance to give her credit towards a pension/access to benefits
  4. an inheritance of 5-10k if I remember correctly
  5. more years to work (60) but refuses to

This person is not bereft, not incapable of work but simply wants to sponge of someone else and not take responsibility for their own life. I think it’s reasonable the daughter refer her to citizens advice and encourage her to be independent and handle her own finances.

The two situations are entirely incomparable.

In this instance, the husband is urging the OP to forward plan in terms of their living accomodation for their growing family and for the event that one or other of their mothers becomes ill needing 24/7 care. Usually there is a period of time 18-24months where an elderly person deteriorates in function during which time they will not be accepted for a care home, but need ideally more family support. The recommendation to move the OP’s mother closer is sensible, practical, reasonable and best for all involved avoiding a lot of distress.

So yeah, don’t try and compare a looney situation with a normal situation that pretty much all families face as relatives age.

Sorry I’m confused, is there another thread?

my MIL has never worked and refused to, and definitely expects dh to keep her and her husband (but more so dh and her husband left her for another woman and had pretty just treated their house as a bnb to stay in like once a week max for year… not paying for maintenance, just food and bill money) I’m confused if the other things are about my MIL or another thread?

OP posts:
Wigglytuff123 · 31/12/2023 19:26

CharlotteRumpling · 31/12/2023 19:19

Yes @Wigglytuff123 you are right it can happen that way. But I have many, many highly educated friends who also look after their parents or inlaws in their homes. Really no point in comparing an individualistic culture to a familial one. That family gives as well as takes in my experience. Many of my friends relied on their MILs for childcare.

In your situation you are only 15 minutes away from your MIL so I do not think you are being unreasonable in not agreeing for her to move in. Perhaps your DH is thinking 20 years ahead?

Yes he’s thinking down the road unlikely 20, but 10, but even then for me, there’s a lot of ground for her to make up and as things stand, I just can’t see how. We can’t tell her we go on holiday because she’ll melt down, we hid we bought our house for a year, we’ve got two weeks in America next year and we’ll be pretending we’ve got a virus apparently

OP posts:
Justia · 31/12/2023 19:23

GrannyAchingsShepherdsHut · 31/12/2023 19:07

OP has said her mother is an abusive narcissist, why are any of her needs a problem for OP to solve?

I don't think she's 'sticking her head in the sand' I think she's being clear what her healthy boundaries are in relation to people who have been abusive and / or nasty to her.

@GrannyAchingsShepherdsHut

Because she has benefited from her mother financially and is probably due to inherit a few hundred grand.

If their are no other relatives close it is her responsibility to sort things out.

Justia · 31/12/2023 19:20

CharlotteRumpling · 31/12/2023 19:07

There is this other post on MN where the poster is being urged to leave her penniless homeless unemployed mum to fend for herself.

Would it be OK for me to condemn that culture too? Or is it only ok to be dsmissive of cultures that take care of the elderly at home? Not that I am saying the OP should do it. But the general dismissiveness - oh well S Asian women have no lives- is grating.

@CharlotteRumpling

Can I just interject here to point out that said “penniless mother” has

  1. never worked a day in her life
  2. sponged off husbands and then her own mother to survive
  3. never claimed child benefit nor carers allowance to give her credit towards a pension/access to benefits
  4. an inheritance of 5-10k if I remember correctly
  5. more years to work (60) but refuses to

This person is not bereft, not incapable of work but simply wants to sponge of someone else and not take responsibility for their own life. I think it’s reasonable the daughter refer her to citizens advice and encourage her to be independent and handle her own finances.

The two situations are entirely incomparable.

In this instance, the husband is urging the OP to forward plan in terms of their living accomodation for their growing family and for the event that one or other of their mothers becomes ill needing 24/7 care. Usually there is a period of time 18-24months where an elderly person deteriorates in function during which time they will not be accepted for a care home, but need ideally more family support. The recommendation to move the OP’s mother closer is sensible, practical, reasonable and best for all involved avoiding a lot of distress.

So yeah, don’t try and compare a looney situation with a normal situation that pretty much all families face as relatives age.

OnceUponATimeInChristmasTime · 31/12/2023 19:19

Christ almighty. Absolutely not. My mother in law has started to 'jokingly' drop hints at us having a granny annex for her. It's a firm, unequivocal nope. There are numerous siblings of my other half, all of whom have spare rooms, she is welcome to explore those options. I have been open with my own mom, it's just not on the cards.
I would consider moving somewhere where there was a possibility of a house next door or in the same street. That is my limit.
It is a hard boundary for me.

CharlotteRumpling · 31/12/2023 19:19

Yes @Wigglytuff123 you are right it can happen that way. But I have many, many highly educated friends who also look after their parents or inlaws in their homes. Really no point in comparing an individualistic culture to a familial one. That family gives as well as takes in my experience. Many of my friends relied on their MILs for childcare.

In your situation you are only 15 minutes away from your MIL so I do not think you are being unreasonable in not agreeing for her to move in. Perhaps your DH is thinking 20 years ahead?

Wigglytuff123 · 31/12/2023 19:13

CharlotteRumpling · 31/12/2023 19:07

There is this other post on MN where the poster is being urged to leave her penniless homeless unemployed mum to fend for herself.

Would it be OK for me to condemn that culture too? Or is it only ok to be dsmissive of cultures that take care of the elderly at home? Not that I am saying the OP should do it. But the general dismissiveness - oh well S Asian women have no lives- is grating.

I get what you mean it’s grating but surely you can see in some pockets of the s Asian community it is organised to ensure the woman has no life, no earning potential and limited education to ensure that she is at home and is the carer for the children and the parents. She (in these scenarios) often moves into the parents IL home, so she even in divorce she has nothing

OP posts:
GrannyAchingsShepherdsHut · 31/12/2023 19:07

Justia · 31/12/2023 18:38

I think you need to be realistic that something will need to be done for both of them at some stage and have a workable plan in action.

Your husband has gone to one extreme of moving them both in (though he hasn’t stated when or under what circumstances), you are sticking your head in the sand and refusing to accommodate either of them.

Saying you don’t want the responsibility of your Mum’s two properties sorting out is silly - if she dies you will be facing it and grief at the same time which is a horrible situation and difficult to do at distance too.

Your Mum needs to be closer and her accumulation of stuff sorted while she is still able to do some of it herself. Property should be sold or rented out depending on what is better financially (see point b).
a) Buy a bigger house with a granny annex already built or somewhere that could be converted such as a garage or outbuilding. If you have another child 4 bedrooms is tight as they get older and the additional space will be useful regardless. If your mother comes to live with you and has sold her house, your share of inheritance can pay off the work/additional cost, if she has rented out and her mortgage is paid off then a good chunk of the income can go towards your mortgage.
b) If your mother moves closer but wants to maintain her own property, then you do one of two things - if the two properties elsewhere are more valuable you keep them and rent out, using the income to fund a smaller purchase or rental near you. If they are comparable in value or lesser than the area you are in then you sell up and help Mum buy similar near you. If the latter option, this could release some inheritance for you to make life easier with another child and to move so that you have more room. Again, it will be needed regardless of the mother/mil situation.

With regard to MIL there is no reason to do anything unless she becomes very unwell or unable to cope. She is still working and I don’t think you need to worry about anything until she is about 70, if she doesn’t collapse from a heart attack or develop cancer etc in the meantime.

The main priority is moving your Mum closer because the current situation is not workable in the event she needs help. And sorting out her life and two properties at the point where she needs care or after death will be an absolute ballache - I really cannot emphasise that to you enough, sort it now while she is fit and well, because otherwise it is a very stressful mess.

Second priority is get yourself a bigger house if you can afford it. 5 people in a 4 bed is fine until the kids grow up a bit and then you have their friends all trailing in here there and everywhere. Get the bigger house so you have room for Polly, Joe and Emily coming to stay and space for the grannies if they are in dire need of care.

If it gets to that stage it’s a few years max. Once they need lifted to the loo and so forth they have to go into a home anyway.

OP has said her mother is an abusive narcissist, why are any of her needs a problem for OP to solve?

I don't think she's 'sticking her head in the sand' I think she's being clear what her healthy boundaries are in relation to people who have been abusive and / or nasty to her.

Justia · 31/12/2023 19:07

Wigglytuff123 · 31/12/2023 18:46

this is basically what dh was saying apparently. I’ll be back to the thread in a bit it’s bed time so need to bath the kids

@Wigglytuff123

Speaking as someone who has navigated caring for and sorting out the estates and belongings of several family members, I don’t think your husband is being unreasonable but practically planning ahead for the worst case scenario and ensuring your family has more space as it grows larger too (a granny annex would be useful for an older teen/young adult too).

Whenever an elderly person becomes unwell it is much more demanding and complicated by contrast to caring for children, because they are bigger, have experienced independence and the paperwork involved is monumentally enormous. It’s also harder to get their needs met be it privately or via nhs.

It has a negative impact on the whole family, is hugely disruptive, stressful and traumatic.

Being preemptive and sorting out as much in advance when the waters are calm is the sensible and preferred option. If you have the chance to do so, please do for the sake of your well-being and that of your kids.

CharlotteRumpling · 31/12/2023 19:07

There is this other post on MN where the poster is being urged to leave her penniless homeless unemployed mum to fend for herself.

Would it be OK for me to condemn that culture too? Or is it only ok to be dsmissive of cultures that take care of the elderly at home? Not that I am saying the OP should do it. But the general dismissiveness - oh well S Asian women have no lives- is grating.

Staniam · 31/12/2023 18:52

Wigglytuff123 · 31/12/2023 18:35

Well ‘traditionally’ man would work aka provide money and the woman would raise family and care for his parents etc

Thanks, @Wigglytuff123, for confirming my original point.

Wigglytuff123 · 31/12/2023 18:46

Justia · 31/12/2023 18:38

I think you need to be realistic that something will need to be done for both of them at some stage and have a workable plan in action.

Your husband has gone to one extreme of moving them both in (though he hasn’t stated when or under what circumstances), you are sticking your head in the sand and refusing to accommodate either of them.

Saying you don’t want the responsibility of your Mum’s two properties sorting out is silly - if she dies you will be facing it and grief at the same time which is a horrible situation and difficult to do at distance too.

Your Mum needs to be closer and her accumulation of stuff sorted while she is still able to do some of it herself. Property should be sold or rented out depending on what is better financially (see point b).
a) Buy a bigger house with a granny annex already built or somewhere that could be converted such as a garage or outbuilding. If you have another child 4 bedrooms is tight as they get older and the additional space will be useful regardless. If your mother comes to live with you and has sold her house, your share of inheritance can pay off the work/additional cost, if she has rented out and her mortgage is paid off then a good chunk of the income can go towards your mortgage.
b) If your mother moves closer but wants to maintain her own property, then you do one of two things - if the two properties elsewhere are more valuable you keep them and rent out, using the income to fund a smaller purchase or rental near you. If they are comparable in value or lesser than the area you are in then you sell up and help Mum buy similar near you. If the latter option, this could release some inheritance for you to make life easier with another child and to move so that you have more room. Again, it will be needed regardless of the mother/mil situation.

With regard to MIL there is no reason to do anything unless she becomes very unwell or unable to cope. She is still working and I don’t think you need to worry about anything until she is about 70, if she doesn’t collapse from a heart attack or develop cancer etc in the meantime.

The main priority is moving your Mum closer because the current situation is not workable in the event she needs help. And sorting out her life and two properties at the point where she needs care or after death will be an absolute ballache - I really cannot emphasise that to you enough, sort it now while she is fit and well, because otherwise it is a very stressful mess.

Second priority is get yourself a bigger house if you can afford it. 5 people in a 4 bed is fine until the kids grow up a bit and then you have their friends all trailing in here there and everywhere. Get the bigger house so you have room for Polly, Joe and Emily coming to stay and space for the grannies if they are in dire need of care.

If it gets to that stage it’s a few years max. Once they need lifted to the loo and so forth they have to go into a home anyway.

this is basically what dh was saying apparently. I’ll be back to the thread in a bit it’s bed time so need to bath the kids

OP posts:
Noseybookworm · 31/12/2023 18:42

Just tell him no, that's not going to happen. And keep saying it until he gets it!

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 31/12/2023 18:40

Wigglytuff123 · 31/12/2023 18:33

Would I expect my DIL to live with me, hells no.

if they wanted to whilst saving for a house, sure, maybe but I think it would be awkward living under each others feet but I’d also not mock her and ostracise her at social events, so there’s that

His MIL and family sound awful mocking and ostracising you at social events. No wonder you do not want her living with you.

2mummies1baby · 31/12/2023 18:39

Wigglytuff123 · 31/12/2023 18:23

Please read the updates we’ve had this conversation prior to marriage and then after

Sorry, my fault for not RTFT. Remind him of the conversation you had where you said you would never live with her because of her behaviour towards you. Why is he ignoring that?

Justia · 31/12/2023 18:38

I think you need to be realistic that something will need to be done for both of them at some stage and have a workable plan in action.

Your husband has gone to one extreme of moving them both in (though he hasn’t stated when or under what circumstances), you are sticking your head in the sand and refusing to accommodate either of them.

Saying you don’t want the responsibility of your Mum’s two properties sorting out is silly - if she dies you will be facing it and grief at the same time which is a horrible situation and difficult to do at distance too.

Your Mum needs to be closer and her accumulation of stuff sorted while she is still able to do some of it herself. Property should be sold or rented out depending on what is better financially (see point b).
a) Buy a bigger house with a granny annex already built or somewhere that could be converted such as a garage or outbuilding. If you have another child 4 bedrooms is tight as they get older and the additional space will be useful regardless. If your mother comes to live with you and has sold her house, your share of inheritance can pay off the work/additional cost, if she has rented out and her mortgage is paid off then a good chunk of the income can go towards your mortgage.
b) If your mother moves closer but wants to maintain her own property, then you do one of two things - if the two properties elsewhere are more valuable you keep them and rent out, using the income to fund a smaller purchase or rental near you. If they are comparable in value or lesser than the area you are in then you sell up and help Mum buy similar near you. If the latter option, this could release some inheritance for you to make life easier with another child and to move so that you have more room. Again, it will be needed regardless of the mother/mil situation.

With regard to MIL there is no reason to do anything unless she becomes very unwell or unable to cope. She is still working and I don’t think you need to worry about anything until she is about 70, if she doesn’t collapse from a heart attack or develop cancer etc in the meantime.

The main priority is moving your Mum closer because the current situation is not workable in the event she needs help. And sorting out her life and two properties at the point where she needs care or after death will be an absolute ballache - I really cannot emphasise that to you enough, sort it now while she is fit and well, because otherwise it is a very stressful mess.

Second priority is get yourself a bigger house if you can afford it. 5 people in a 4 bed is fine until the kids grow up a bit and then you have their friends all trailing in here there and everywhere. Get the bigger house so you have room for Polly, Joe and Emily coming to stay and space for the grannies if they are in dire need of care.

If it gets to that stage it’s a few years max. Once they need lifted to the loo and so forth they have to go into a home anyway.

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 31/12/2023 18:37

Wigglytuff123 · 31/12/2023 18:33

Would I expect my DIL to live with me, hells no.

if they wanted to whilst saving for a house, sure, maybe but I think it would be awkward living under each others feet but I’d also not mock her and ostracise her at social events, so there’s that

Apologies, I thought you were South Asian too so would follow culturally when you got a DIL. I think it’s extra complex for you though.

Wigglytuff123 · 31/12/2023 18:35

Staniam · 31/12/2023 18:28

Provide what? The hands-on, day-to-day care? What if the women would rather provide?

Well ‘traditionally’ man would work aka provide money and the woman would raise family and care for his parents etc

OP posts:
Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 31/12/2023 18:35

Emotionalsupportviper · 31/12/2023 17:42

And don't forget t light the blue touch paper . . . 😈

Why couldn’t that happen?!

Actually I knew of a family the sons were at junior school with me and DB. One of the nans of the family got an offer from bus garage being built to buy her house, she bought a big house with her son and his wife and 2 sons and the other nan (the daughter’s DM) also contributed equally. The size of the house meant they both had 2 granny flats on the ground floor and the son/daughter and 2 sons lived on first floor and attic was converted into bedrooms. Fairly big garden too. They all lived happily together until the nans died. White British family. The house was sold a few years ago.

PBandJ111 · 31/12/2023 18:34

I’d rather get divorced