Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

‘You need to accept that both our mothers are going to move in with us’

359 replies

Wigglytuff123 · 31/12/2023 15:24

Is what DH said to me… instant chills

I do not speak the same language as my MIL, not even a little and I find her very very hard work, truthfully there’s a lot of water under the bridge. She’s just turned 60

now to my own mother fractious history. I was the scapegoated child and sibling golden child (single narcissistic mother, at points she was down right abusvie and cruel) the worm has turned somewhat as sibling has very similar narcissistic tendencies as mother and sticky fingers (Steals despite being mid 30s) and no longer talks to mother as was caught in the act. Mother is 70s

both single, divorced and widowed.

is dh right? Truthfully the thought of either of them living with us fills me with dread

what prompted this conversation was we’re planning a 3rd child and dh was making his case to consider a 5/6 bed house for a move, whereas I don’t think staying in a 4 bed with a garden office sounds too awful.

is he right? I don’t know why but I feel quite resentful to take on a mortgage in a much larger house for them to move in, and if one moves in the other will be pissed the other didn’t, and both together, no way.

at least my mum would be bringing capital, his mum wouldn’t be putting anything into the house

OP posts:
Wigglytuff123 · 03/01/2024 22:59

Justia · 03/01/2024 22:38

@Wigglytuff123

it’s like more recent posters have said people seriously underestimate the cost and the toll of caring, and it is impossible to do and work full time which is something that I need to do for my own retirement as well as the short to medium future

Please will you give this a rest.

Myself and one other relative coordinated the care of three wheelchair bound adults simultaneously. At that time I had a baby, was working and doing a degree.

It would have been easier if they had lived in the same house as driving between and managing multiple households sucked up time.

You outsource the care. You don’t do it yourself. You have to work. End of story.

You can try and find a work around where they are living on site or close by but aren’t considered part of your household to save money..

But even at that if they become so decrepit that they need to move in it will be about 18months max until they either die or need to go into a care home for their own safety.

Seriously you need to stop building this up into an absolute drama because you are so emotionally against it.

Your mothers are going to age, become ill/unfirm and will die. That is a fact.

You need to get practical not emotional. Think about the legalities relative to estate management, power of attorney etc. Think about how you are going to shovel the shit and work out a long term plan.

When they have dementia, cancer, anything serious enough to warrant moving in they have the stuffing knocked out of them and the battle axe is gone there is too much else to deal with. Even if they have just become frail… it’s a lot.

Stop throwing the toys out of the pram and get real about what you need to do. The mess is going to land as your door no matter what you do if there is no other family available.

What are you talking about?

why will it be 18 months before they die? How did you get this figure? My grandmother lived with us for the best part of 10 years, and then passed away in a hospital.

there are numerous other posters who have affirmed how challenging it can be to care for someone. I’ve literally witnessed this. As my grandmother moved in the LA would not provide any care or any support when it became too much.

my point is I don’t really want to live with them at any point, as it is not financially viable. I don’t understand why you seem to think it is? for instance your older suggestion of buying them both a house next door?

OP posts:
Justia · 03/01/2024 22:58

venusandmars · 02/01/2024 15:04

I think some posters underestimate the reality of having elderly parents in their home / an annexe, and some are overly optimistic about the prospect of care provided for or paid for by a local authority.

As my dm (who I loved dearly) became increasingly frail, my ddad needed respite so dm came to stay one week every month. She was an entirely reasonable person, could wash/dress/ feed herself and wouldn't intend to be a bother. However... I was on constant call - helping her turn on the shower, finding dry towels because she sprayed the shower in the wrong dierection, work the microwave, change the channel on the blaringly loud TV, doing laundry, opening bottles of pills, getting medication out of blister packs, reading the small print on things, being available for general chit-chat (endless). I ran my own business from home and it became close to impossible at times.

My cousin built an annexe for her Mum, but ended up as defacto full time carer for a very sick woman with dementia - very much to the detriment of her own young children and her own mental and physical health. Building an annexe for a benign, slightly aging parent seemed like a good idea but no-one could predict the rapid advancement of dementia / violence / incontinence.

Where was social care in these situations? non-existant. Because there was some kind of 'available' family suport, they were pretty low down on extremely pressurised LA budgets and issues with shortages of staff. It took simultaneous medical crises for dm and ddad to get any kind of real help.

In 2022, MIL had a fall while dh was visiting. Because he was in the house at the time, he became her full time carer during weekdays, with SILs doing it at weekends. That was everything - personal care, toiletting, showering, feeding etc. MIL lived 2 hours from our house so dh and I only saw each other at weekends. Again, it was low on social care priorities because dh was there (albeit at breaking point).

I suppose what I'm saying is that even with the best will in the world, the practicalities of caring for elderly parents can't be predicted. Whatever the situation is now, you need to be thinking and planning two steps ahead, and contemplating a whole variety of scenarios.

@venusandmars

I agree with everything you have said 2000%

Especially
Whatever the situation is now, you need to be thinking and planning two steps ahead, and contemplating a whole variety of scenarios.

OP and DH, I feel should as a minimum help her mother sort out her affairs/property and shift her closer (keeping her in her own individual property) because otherwise it’s super difficult when she has issues.

It would make sense to have a bigger property for their family anyway leaving the option open to have space.

Whether that space is used for an ailing relative depends on what the issue is, the availability of social care in the area, finance available and so forth.

The best case scenario is to have them in their own property to be able to access maximum care packages, which you then supplement with your care (some extra personal care, toileting, feeding, shopping, washing etc). It is the fastest way of getting them into a home as they are made a priority over others.

However, if for example they are diagnosed with terminal cancer they may want to move in prior to hospice care, or if they keep having falls but are otherwise alright they may need some support.

The main thing is to have the discussions, work out the legalities by speaking to CAB and a solicitor. Sort OP’s Mum and move to have space for the nuclear family with an eye to having room for the mother/s if needs be in some capacity.

A crystal ball would be great, but in its absence common sense, legal advice and good planning is needed.

Justia · 03/01/2024 22:38

@Wigglytuff123

it’s like more recent posters have said people seriously underestimate the cost and the toll of caring, and it is impossible to do and work full time which is something that I need to do for my own retirement as well as the short to medium future

Please will you give this a rest.

Myself and one other relative coordinated the care of three wheelchair bound adults simultaneously. At that time I had a baby, was working and doing a degree.

It would have been easier if they had lived in the same house as driving between and managing multiple households sucked up time.

You outsource the care. You don’t do it yourself. You have to work. End of story.

You can try and find a work around where they are living on site or close by but aren’t considered part of your household to save money..

But even at that if they become so decrepit that they need to move in it will be about 18months max until they either die or need to go into a care home for their own safety.

Seriously you need to stop building this up into an absolute drama because you are so emotionally against it.

Your mothers are going to age, become ill/unfirm and will die. That is a fact.

You need to get practical not emotional. Think about the legalities relative to estate management, power of attorney etc. Think about how you are going to shovel the shit and work out a long term plan.

When they have dementia, cancer, anything serious enough to warrant moving in they have the stuffing knocked out of them and the battle axe is gone there is too much else to deal with. Even if they have just become frail… it’s a lot.

Stop throwing the toys out of the pram and get real about what you need to do. The mess is going to land as your door no matter what you do if there is no other family available.

inamarina · 03/01/2024 15:35

Olinguita · 02/01/2024 11:25

I just don't think the cultural expectation of multigenerational households works in the economic reality of the UK. It is totally possible to care for and cherish our elders while maintaining separate homes and healthy emotional boundaries. I think culture has to evolve for these reasons:

  1. people live much longer these days and often have more complex health needs such as dementia that often cannot realistically be managed at home. If you merge households then it is very, very difficult and more complex to access care home places or funding for carers to visit at home. I think it's important to be clear-eyed about this. The noble aim of caring for parents at home sometimes just doesn't work in reality
  2. most households need to have two parents earning, and it's not financially viable for one person to take years out of the workforce to care for an elder at home. This would also have implications for their pension and could leave them impoverished in their own old age.
  3. I think we have different ideas these days about what is acceptable in terms of accepting bullying and manipulation from our elders. Whereas previous generations would have just shut up and put up with their parents or PILs meddling in their marriage, dictating what they can or can't do in their own homes, or treating DILs as skivvies, we question it. We also recognise that moving an individual who has toxic and bullying tendencies into our homes might not be a great environment for children to grow up in.

I have an Asian MIL as I have mentioned up thread. She is an exceptionally difficult and high-conflict character and I have told DH before marriage I will never live with her. I will go above and beyond to make sure she is provided for and is not lonely, but having her as a permanent member of our home would trash my marriage and create a very tense environment for DCs. I truly respect how Asian families care for and cherish their elders, but I don't want a chain smoking alcoholic with controlling and bullying tendencies under my roof on a permanent basis, and I no way in hell would I leave the workforce and compromise my own retirement plans to care for her at home when there are other options open to us.

These are all really good points.

inamarina · 03/01/2024 15:29

venusandmars · 02/01/2024 15:04

I think some posters underestimate the reality of having elderly parents in their home / an annexe, and some are overly optimistic about the prospect of care provided for or paid for by a local authority.

As my dm (who I loved dearly) became increasingly frail, my ddad needed respite so dm came to stay one week every month. She was an entirely reasonable person, could wash/dress/ feed herself and wouldn't intend to be a bother. However... I was on constant call - helping her turn on the shower, finding dry towels because she sprayed the shower in the wrong dierection, work the microwave, change the channel on the blaringly loud TV, doing laundry, opening bottles of pills, getting medication out of blister packs, reading the small print on things, being available for general chit-chat (endless). I ran my own business from home and it became close to impossible at times.

My cousin built an annexe for her Mum, but ended up as defacto full time carer for a very sick woman with dementia - very much to the detriment of her own young children and her own mental and physical health. Building an annexe for a benign, slightly aging parent seemed like a good idea but no-one could predict the rapid advancement of dementia / violence / incontinence.

Where was social care in these situations? non-existant. Because there was some kind of 'available' family suport, they were pretty low down on extremely pressurised LA budgets and issues with shortages of staff. It took simultaneous medical crises for dm and ddad to get any kind of real help.

In 2022, MIL had a fall while dh was visiting. Because he was in the house at the time, he became her full time carer during weekdays, with SILs doing it at weekends. That was everything - personal care, toiletting, showering, feeding etc. MIL lived 2 hours from our house so dh and I only saw each other at weekends. Again, it was low on social care priorities because dh was there (albeit at breaking point).

I suppose what I'm saying is that even with the best will in the world, the practicalities of caring for elderly parents can't be predicted. Whatever the situation is now, you need to be thinking and planning two steps ahead, and contemplating a whole variety of scenarios.

I think some posters underestimate the reality of having elderly parents in their home / an annexe, and some are overly optimistic about the prospect of care provided for or paid for by a local authority.

I think so too. While I could imagine my mum or MIL living close to us, I really don’t see myself becoming a full time carer.

In 2022, MIL had a fall while dh was visiting. Because he was in the house at the time, he became her full time carer during weekdays

So just because he was there at the time of her fall he was expected to basically just remain there more or less permanently? That sounds crazy.
What about his job and his own family? How long did he have to do it for?

AndWordsWhen · 02/01/2024 23:42

people live much longer these days and often have more complex health needs such as dementia that often cannot realistically be managed at home. If you merge households then it is very, very difficult and more complex to access care home places or funding for carers to visit at home. I think it's important to be clear-eyed about this. The noble aim of caring for parents at home sometimes just doesn't work in reality

That is the single smartest post I have read on this subject. I'm going to memorise it for future use.

Mary46 · 02/01/2024 15:13

Yes its really hard. My mother is like another child. We do what we can. Your right people dont realise the care involved..

venusandmars · 02/01/2024 15:04

I think some posters underestimate the reality of having elderly parents in their home / an annexe, and some are overly optimistic about the prospect of care provided for or paid for by a local authority.

As my dm (who I loved dearly) became increasingly frail, my ddad needed respite so dm came to stay one week every month. She was an entirely reasonable person, could wash/dress/ feed herself and wouldn't intend to be a bother. However... I was on constant call - helping her turn on the shower, finding dry towels because she sprayed the shower in the wrong dierection, work the microwave, change the channel on the blaringly loud TV, doing laundry, opening bottles of pills, getting medication out of blister packs, reading the small print on things, being available for general chit-chat (endless). I ran my own business from home and it became close to impossible at times.

My cousin built an annexe for her Mum, but ended up as defacto full time carer for a very sick woman with dementia - very much to the detriment of her own young children and her own mental and physical health. Building an annexe for a benign, slightly aging parent seemed like a good idea but no-one could predict the rapid advancement of dementia / violence / incontinence.

Where was social care in these situations? non-existant. Because there was some kind of 'available' family suport, they were pretty low down on extremely pressurised LA budgets and issues with shortages of staff. It took simultaneous medical crises for dm and ddad to get any kind of real help.

In 2022, MIL had a fall while dh was visiting. Because he was in the house at the time, he became her full time carer during weekdays, with SILs doing it at weekends. That was everything - personal care, toiletting, showering, feeding etc. MIL lived 2 hours from our house so dh and I only saw each other at weekends. Again, it was low on social care priorities because dh was there (albeit at breaking point).

I suppose what I'm saying is that even with the best will in the world, the practicalities of caring for elderly parents can't be predicted. Whatever the situation is now, you need to be thinking and planning two steps ahead, and contemplating a whole variety of scenarios.

Wigglytuff123 · 02/01/2024 13:45

Libertyy · 02/01/2024 12:33

Well when she said at least her mum would be bringing capital in, definitely didn’t seem like something someone would say if they were 100% against their own mother moving in

That was in this hypothetical scenario whereby both move in…

in that hypothetical and hellish situation in which we were looking to move both of our mothers in, at least the cost of upsizing (considerably) would be covered in part by my mothers bringing of capital, where as my MIL wouldn’t be bribing a penny to make this move to a mansion with two separate granny annexes possibles

i am opposed to both. I suppose with my mother in moderately more open to her as ‘better the devil you know’

but it’s like more recent posters have said people seriously underestimate the cost and the toll of caring, and it is impossible to do and work full time which is something that I need to do for my own retirement as well as the short to medium future

OP posts:
Wigglytuff123 · 02/01/2024 13:33

diddl · 01/01/2024 11:49

If either or both move in it would surely have to be on Op & her husband's terms wouldn't it?

For example if a separate annexe/flat couldn't be afforded for MIL she either accepts that or doesn't move in?

Who would want to see their son & dil struggle with a bigger mortgage just so that they could move in?

Who would want that… my MIL. She doesn’t give 2 figs about what her son wants as long as she’s happy and get what she wants.

she guilted him out of moving away to uni, out of taking jobs that would’ve required him to move, she doesn’t care as long as she gets her own way.

yes it would absolutely be down to us and if we can afford it (unlikely) but she’d gladly see us in financial ruin if it meant she got her way

OP posts:
Libertyy · 02/01/2024 12:33

Etincelle · 02/01/2024 12:07

It was in the OP's first post!

Well when she said at least her mum would be bringing capital in, definitely didn’t seem like something someone would say if they were 100% against their own mother moving in

CharlotteRumpling · 02/01/2024 12:08

I suppose it helps that my mum is and was a fabulous mum and grandmum. DC adore her. As does DH. She has never asked to live with me, but I think she deserves it. We shall have to see how that goes.

I will be looking for a retirement home for myself though, as I hope to break the cycle of intergenerational living in this generation.

Etincelle · 02/01/2024 12:07

Libertyy · 01/01/2024 13:31

That makes sense now. Then it that case protecting yourself comes first

It was in the OP's first post!

Etincelle · 02/01/2024 12:03

I was the scapegoat and my mum is keen to be a close mother and daughter doing stuff together. She's asked to live with me and come on holiday with us. Nope! You reap what you sow!

CharlotteRumpling · 02/01/2024 11:59

Well, it's why intercultural marriages are often very difficult. Maybe I will come back and post how I am getting on in a few years, once I have moved my DM into my home.

Olinguita · 02/01/2024 11:25

I just don't think the cultural expectation of multigenerational households works in the economic reality of the UK. It is totally possible to care for and cherish our elders while maintaining separate homes and healthy emotional boundaries. I think culture has to evolve for these reasons:

  1. people live much longer these days and often have more complex health needs such as dementia that often cannot realistically be managed at home. If you merge households then it is very, very difficult and more complex to access care home places or funding for carers to visit at home. I think it's important to be clear-eyed about this. The noble aim of caring for parents at home sometimes just doesn't work in reality
  2. most households need to have two parents earning, and it's not financially viable for one person to take years out of the workforce to care for an elder at home. This would also have implications for their pension and could leave them impoverished in their own old age.
  3. I think we have different ideas these days about what is acceptable in terms of accepting bullying and manipulation from our elders. Whereas previous generations would have just shut up and put up with their parents or PILs meddling in their marriage, dictating what they can or can't do in their own homes, or treating DILs as skivvies, we question it. We also recognise that moving an individual who has toxic and bullying tendencies into our homes might not be a great environment for children to grow up in.

I have an Asian MIL as I have mentioned up thread. She is an exceptionally difficult and high-conflict character and I have told DH before marriage I will never live with her. I will go above and beyond to make sure she is provided for and is not lonely, but having her as a permanent member of our home would trash my marriage and create a very tense environment for DCs. I truly respect how Asian families care for and cherish their elders, but I don't want a chain smoking alcoholic with controlling and bullying tendencies under my roof on a permanent basis, and I no way in hell would I leave the workforce and compromise my own retirement plans to care for her at home when there are other options open to us.

inamarina · 01/01/2024 19:58

Staniam · 31/12/2023 18:28

Provide what? The hands-on, day-to-day care? What if the women would rather provide?

I‘m also wondering how people can be expected to provide for others outside their immediate family (wife/husband + kids) if circumstances change, the husband (or the wife) loses their job, the cost of living goes up, etc.
A previous poster mentioned how a Thai wife might expect her Western husband to send money home to her family.
What if he’s not earning enough? I can’t imagine my family abroad expecting regular contributions from my husband.
Same goes for the expectation that parens/ in-laws can move in with their children without contributing financially.
How many people can actually afford that? Especially if they’d have to upsize.
If I could just click my fingers and a lovely little granny flat would magically appear in our garden, I probably wouldn’t even mind my MIL moving in. But I can’t imagine having to buy a bigger house to accommodate someone I’m not even getting on with, because of cultural expectations.

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 01/01/2024 18:43

mylittleprince · 01/01/2024 12:19

I think a lot of people on here are very naive about the reality of caring for older people. Especially if you are working and have children.

I'm with you op. Just keep saying no. Agree to support her living in her own home independently. If she has no capital social services will fund any care she needs when the time comes.

But you forget. Culturally especially on her DH’s side she has to look after the evil old witch.

If she ever did move in with me the old witch wouldn’t like it one bit. Seeing as she’s been nasty in loads of ways including making fun of her DIL when she tries to speak their language (and dialect).

amicissimma · 01/01/2024 15:31

I volunteer with the elderly and I therefore have a crystal ball.

I guarantee you that, regardless of how many assurances you get, how many things 'will be put in place', that you will end up doing the lion's share of the care of an elderly person who lives with you, unless you are quite extraordinarily strong minded and resistant to emotional pressure.

You may get lucky and both remain self-caring until they die, or you may find yourself committed to years of caring for someone with quite intense needs, possibly 24 hours a day, maybe with no respite and no chance to leave the house. Failures in the provision of outside care, no matter how wonderful it seems to be, are very common.

Emotionalsupportviper · 01/01/2024 15:05

Puzzledandpissedoff · 01/01/2024 13:28

I think a lot of people on here are very naive about the reality of caring for older people

I thoroughly agree, mylittleprince - ditto the idea of providing "separate" accommodation

It can all work very well if the seniors are independently minded and value their own space as well as respecting yours ... less well, perhaps, if they lack (or just plain ignore) boundaries, even those they seemed to agree to in advance

Not only a matter of lacking boundaries and ignoring ground rules when it suits.

You could have the best parents and in-laws in the world - totally respectful of our need for family space etc - but they could become very incapacitated physically and/or mentally, and it would be a huge amount of work - especially if you have children or teenagers in the house.

As @mylittleprince says I think a lot of people on here are very naive about the reality of caring for older people. Especially if you are working and have children. There is both a physical and a (massive!) emotional load.

And let's not kid ourselves - the lion's share of that work will fall on the wife.

Libertyy · 01/01/2024 13:31

GrannyAchingsShepherdsHut · 01/01/2024 11:52

@Libertyy it's in the OP

... now to my own mother fractious history. I was the scapegoated child and sibling golden child (single narcissistic mother, at points she was down right abusvie and cruel)...

Edited

That makes sense now. Then it that case protecting yourself comes first

Puzzledandpissedoff · 01/01/2024 13:28

I think a lot of people on here are very naive about the reality of caring for older people

I thoroughly agree, mylittleprince - ditto the idea of providing "separate" accommodation

It can all work very well if the seniors are independently minded and value their own space as well as respecting yours ... less well, perhaps, if they lack (or just plain ignore) boundaries, even those they seemed to agree to in advance

mylittleprince · 01/01/2024 12:19

I think a lot of people on here are very naive about the reality of caring for older people. Especially if you are working and have children.

I'm with you op. Just keep saying no. Agree to support her living in her own home independently. If she has no capital social services will fund any care she needs when the time comes.

nxlee · 01/01/2024 11:54

I've been thinking about this a lot.

OP's MIL isn't the nicest so I understand her view and believe OP is correct.

Just for me personally I'd want my elderly parents to live with me. They looked after me when I was small, and I want to take care of them.

Mum has even said she'd help take care of any kids so me and my partner can both work. She has promised to not become a toxic MIL and to not interfere in my marriage

My gran lives with her eldest son and she helps with the housework etc.

It is very common in the south Asian culture and in many many cases causes mental anguish for the DIL.

From my understanding of islam (I saw the religion being mentioned up thread) that a the life has a right to her own house with her husband and doesn't have to live with her PILs.

GrannyAchingsShepherdsHut · 01/01/2024 11:52

@Libertyy it's in the OP

... now to my own mother fractious history. I was the scapegoated child and sibling golden child (single narcissistic mother, at points she was down right abusvie and cruel)...

Swipe left for the next trending thread