Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Uncle's reaction to education discussion

282 replies

Krankopi · 31/12/2023 14:53

Family gathering in Southern England over Xmas with extended family and we drove over from West Wales where we've lived for past 18 months. I'm chit chatting to aunt and catching her up on our lives and tell her about plans for DS education.

Our DS turns 3 next year and we're opting to send him to a Welsh-speaking pre-school from September and then if all goes well to Welsh speaking primary school.

The school is very good, recent investment and a few neighbours whose kids go there really rave about it. I studied French at uni and have very open attitude to other language so think it would be great opportunity for DS to be bilingual From young age.

If there were any unforeseen issues and it doesn't work out then there are English speaking primaries and secondaries in area also.

Uncle overheard the conversation and chimed in 'but you're not Welsh!' and 'it's a dead language'. I attempted to explain benefits of bilingualism, fact our area has quite a lot of Welsh speakers and DS will grow up there etc but fell on deaf ears and he really went for it at that point.

He seemed properly offended by the whole thing as if we were somehow betraying our roots (we're English and DS also born in England). It was completely ridiculous. He then proceeded to insult the Welsh, their language before aunt told him to cool it and convo moved on.

His opinion about DS education is irrelevant but thinking back to his reaction has really angered me. It wasn't just that he didn't agree, his blood seemed to really boil. He is a bit of a little Englander type who voted for Brexit so I shouldn't be surprised but I can't understand how someone could take such offense to going to Welsh school in Wales.

The more I think about it, the more I want to say something to him to put him in his place. I find his attitude disgraceful and I'm so close to writing or calling to give him piece of my mind. AIBU? Should I just forget the whole thing?

Maybe making my point another way will work better, like writing next years Xmas card in Welsh.

OP posts:
Simonjt · 31/12/2023 17:07

MumblesParty · 31/12/2023 17:01

Does your son speak welsh already? Because if not, and if you don’t plan to teach him before he starts school, then it seems harsh to send him to a school where he won’t understand a word being said to him.

I didn’t speak any English when I started school in the UK (technically a lie, I had been taught fuck off by a neighbour) it was fine, I was fluent within the year to the standards of British children of the same age. My son spoke very little English when he started nursery, again, not an issue at all, although he did sometimes pretend not to understand when asked not to do something! Our two year old doesn’t speak English, she’ll start learning it formally at school, which where we live now will start when shes six.

AllAroundMyCat · 31/12/2023 17:07

I have spent many years working with children who have English as an additional language and who either had both parents or one parent who spoke a different language.

I'd like to reassure you that these children were generally very bright indeed and would overtake their English peers as , being bilingual is an exceptional brain training exercise in itself.

They might seem a bit slow at first due to understanding and needing to translate but soon become very proficient at it and suddenly fly.

Good on you OP. And Welsh is a superb language to be proficient in... let's be honest, if you live there then it's best to learn to speak it.
Detractors are just being narrow minded.
( I also speak as a bilingual.)

SleepingStandingUp · 31/12/2023 17:07

Boomboom22 · 31/12/2023 15:15

Hmm. The problem is English is globally the language of business then French so are you setting him up to only live in Wales rather than a more global language? Because of the Americans of course, when I was young it was not expected for English to still be the language of business tbh.

You know op speaks English right? She's not forbidding him from speaking English or from learning French when he's older? No one is saying kids in Wales should be socially isolated from non Welsh speakers less their brain be tainted with other languages

NcSlt · 31/12/2023 17:05

Bilingualism in any languages does help with learning additional languages, they don’t have to be related (see eg https://www.earth.com/news/bilingual-children-learn-faster/), makes sense if you think about it as a bilingual child has an earlier understanding that words and grammar can be different in different languages. It also probably helps with some early cognitive skills, including developing theory of mind, which then also obviously impacts on social skills. And, as someone said, it protects against dementia in later life (if you use both languages regularly). Obviously Welsh is a useful and culturally rich language, but all of that would be true even if it wasn’t, Klingon would have the same benefits!

edit - but no I personally wouldn’t bother going back to argue it out with the uncle!

Bilingual children learn new languages faster than others

A new study reveals an advantage for children who grow up bilingual, as their brains are more capable of learning additional languages.

https://www.earth.com/news/bilingual-children-learn-faster/

Welshphoenix · 31/12/2023 17:04

TheaBrandt · 31/12/2023 14:56

Sorry but he has a point. Not sure your son will thank you in the future.

No he does not have a point , the school will be well funded and having Welsh will benefit him in the future. I would have had the discussion there and then with him .

SleepingStandingUp · 31/12/2023 17:04

MacLaine · 31/12/2023 15:08

There are definite benefits to being bilingual from a young age, though I’m not sure Welsh is the most useful choice.

You don't think speaking Wales in Wales is useful? Or is Les useful than say French or Chinese?

mumonthehill · 31/12/2023 17:03

It does greatly sadden me these threads especially as learning 2 languages is never a bad thing. Remember for many children in wales, English is their second language so they are naturally learning in the language of their home. Also that formal learning in Wales starts much later than in England and is much more a Scandinavian model with early years based on play which mumsnet always seem to like. It is not difficult to support dc as schools support parents.

OneMoreTime23 · 31/12/2023 17:03

MumblesParty · 31/12/2023 17:01

Does your son speak welsh already? Because if not, and if you don’t plan to teach him before he starts school, then it seems harsh to send him to a school where he won’t understand a word being said to him.

This is the most common scenario in Welsh medium
Primary schools. It’s not an issue at all.

theduchessofspork · 31/12/2023 17:02

Whiskerson · 31/12/2023 16:52

Oh, I see, this is what you are like. You are obviously much too clever and sophisticated for me to trouble with pedestrian questions. Have a nice NYE.

@Mirabai

There’s plenty of evidence knowing more than one language helps you pick up others, whether they are in the same group or not. Part of this will be confidence, but it is also neurological.

One example from Tokyo University below but there are many

Now, stop being a dick and go and have a nice NYE

studyfinds.org/more-languages-easier-for-brain/

MumblesParty · 31/12/2023 17:01

Does your son speak welsh already? Because if not, and if you don’t plan to teach him before he starts school, then it seems harsh to send him to a school where he won’t understand a word being said to him.

Simonjt · 31/12/2023 17:01

Mirabai · 31/12/2023 16:59

No, that’s a broad generalisation true for some people not others.

Some bilingual people never manage to master any language other than the ones they grew up speaking despite trying. Some monoglots can go from 0 to fluent in another language in a couple of years.

You can see patterns of facility in general populations - some immigrants never fully master the language of a country despite arriving as children; others learn it very quickly; some forget their original language others retain both.

Muscial training from a young age can greatly aid language learning - developing the ear and the memory.

If you look at research done in the area you’ll see it isn’t a generalisation, but backed up by a wide range of studies.

Poblano · 31/12/2023 17:00

Mirabai · 31/12/2023 16:44

What you’re saying is you have a facility for languages thus your kids picked up French and German easily too. I’m good at languages but some people aren’t, and sticking them in a bilingual school doesn’t change that.

No, what I'm saying is that my DC's school looked at the large amount of research into bilingualism and how an already bilingual child will generally find it easier to pick up additional languages, and decided to provide opportunities for their pupils based on that. Whether or not my own DC had a natural aptitude for languages had no bearing on the school's decision - there were a lot more pupils than just them!

Mirabai · 31/12/2023 16:59

Simonjt · 31/12/2023 16:45

You’re incorrect, being bilingual makes learning any language easier, compared to a monoglot of the same age trying to learn the same new language. My husband speaks two related languages, Swedish and English, he is equally fluent in both. As his brain already had the ability to manipulate the same concept in two different languages ans structures, it meant learning Urdu was easier for him than a monoglot learning Urdu. The frontal areas of the cortex are more able to work frequently with high levels of concentration before tiring, where as the basal ganglia becomes more efficient to the point that multitasking is easier and make it easier for language competition which means the brain is more flexible and more able to cope with varying words and concepts for the same thing/item.

No, that’s a broad generalisation true for some people not others.

Some bilingual people never manage to master any language other than the ones they grew up speaking despite trying. Some monoglots can go from 0 to fluent in another language in a couple of years.

You can see patterns of facility in general populations - some immigrants never fully master the language of a country despite arriving as children; others learn it very quickly; some forget their original language others retain both.

Muscial training from a young age can greatly aid language learning - developing the ear and the memory.

titchy · 31/12/2023 16:57

I’m good at languages but some people aren’t, and sticking them in a bilingual school doesn’t change that.

It does though, particularly if they start from early primary, and there's oodles of evidence that shows that.

WelshWondergirl · 31/12/2023 16:56

It's a HUGE advantage to a Welsh person to be bilingual in Welsh and English - I sincerely regret that I never learned growing up. So many jobs in public and creative sectors either require Welsh or give preference to Welsh speakers. If there's any chance of your kids staying in Wales into adulthood then you'd be doing them a disservice by not giving them a chance to acquire Welsh in childhood.

And in your area of Wales in particular, they may find themselves locked out of a lot of local teen social life and some of the best schools if they cannot speak Welsh.

Having spent much of my life in England I don't think that most English people simply understand how alive Welsh language and culture is in many parts of Wales. Some of the responses to this thread do seem to confirm this.

theduchessofspork · 31/12/2023 16:54

Ignore him, he’s an idiot.

But if you have to see him again haul out all the research about languages being great for the brain, and knowing two languages making it much easier to learn more.

JustACountryMusicGirlInCowboyBoots · 31/12/2023 16:52

I'm learning Welsh now. Just fancied it after watching Hidden and Hinterland. I lived in North Wales and Anglesey for 4 years but didn't bother learning Welsh then. I regret that now. I did pick up a fair amount of vocab though and I'm loving learning Welsh now. I only use Duolingo but it's fun and I've found it quite easy so far. Compared to Ukrainian anyway!! Good for you in learning Welsh OP!

As far as schools go, I'm not sure. I'd be worried about helping with homework would be difficult. That's the only thing I can think of though. Being bilingual will be an advantage and if his friends are Welsh speaking then even more so. As long as the school is good and he is happy there then I see no issue. Tell your uncle peidiwch siarad cach!

Whiskerson · 31/12/2023 16:52

Mirabai · 31/12/2023 16:47

Well you tried in a rather pedestrian way, but it was bollocks as per my post.

Oh, I see, this is what you are like. You are obviously much too clever and sophisticated for me to trouble with pedestrian questions. Have a nice NYE.

pointythings · 31/12/2023 16:52

@Krankopi I'm Dutch. When I was 10, my dad was given the opportunity for a year's secondment to a UK university so off we went. Dsis and I spent a year in a British school. We came back fully bilingual and we both now live in the UK - if you were to hear us speak, you would not know that we weren't British.

In addition I also speak fluent German and French - I have a language brain and the Dutch school system supports this. I learned the latter two languages at secondary age, so there is no issue with your son starting Welsh at primary school.

Lastly, being multilingual has been shown to bring many benefits - not least delaying the progress of dementia in later life. My father, also bilingual, lost his language due to Parkinson's dementia - but he held onto language for longer than he would otherwise have done because there was a period when, if Dutch would not come, he could switch to English and express himself.

Your uncle is ignorant, as are many people on this thread.

Whiskerson · 31/12/2023 16:50

I’m good at languages but some people aren’t, and sticking them in a bilingual school doesn’t change that.

@Mirabai do you have any evidence for this? Competence at any skill is a mixture of nature and nurture. That's like saying there's no point giving a child piano lessons (for example) because if they're naturally musical they will probably just pick up the guitar when they're older. Obviously there's no point making a completely tone-deaf child miserable with piano lessons for years, but broadly speaking I'd err on the side of giving children opportunities, especially for skills that are easiest acquired young.

IsThePopeCatholic · 31/12/2023 16:49

The more languages the better, as long as the child is NT. Otherwise, they may struggle. I’ve heard that Welsh medium schools are very popular with English incomers and the middle classes.

mamacorn1 · 31/12/2023 16:47

Your child, your choice. Uncle should butt out.

Mirabai · 31/12/2023 16:47

Whiskerson · 31/12/2023 16:42

I mean, I literally explained that in my post. I also told you that more information is freely available should you be interested in a perspective outside of your own assumptions. Or are you a specialist in this field making an educated argument? It sounds like you are just talking off the top of your head.

Well you tried in a rather pedestrian way, but it was bollocks as per my post.

Simonjt · 31/12/2023 16:45

Mirabai · 31/12/2023 16:33

Not particularly. Being bilingual in another language makes learning closely related languages much easier to learn. But not if the language has no relation.

Welsh wouldn’t have helped with any of the languages I speak as it’s not related to any of them. Just as speaking 3 Romance languages didn’t help with German at all.

You might just as well say learning stuff at school makes learning other stuff easier.

You’re incorrect, being bilingual makes learning any language easier, compared to a monoglot of the same age trying to learn the same new language. My husband speaks two related languages, Swedish and English, he is equally fluent in both. As his brain already had the ability to manipulate the same concept in two different languages ans structures, it meant learning Urdu was easier for him than a monoglot learning Urdu. The frontal areas of the cortex are more able to work frequently with high levels of concentration before tiring, where as the basal ganglia becomes more efficient to the point that multitasking is easier and make it easier for language competition which means the brain is more flexible and more able to cope with varying words and concepts for the same thing/item.

Poblano · 31/12/2023 16:45

Ayuda · 31/12/2023 16:19

Learning Welsh is brillant. Great idea. But think a completely Welsh school is limiting.

In what way is it limiting?

My DC were educated entirely through Welsh. One DS is now studying for a degree at an English RG university - learning through Welsh at school didn't make him incapable of also studying through English. DD has just applied to university - again all in England (LSE, Bath, Warwick, York and Exeter).

I can't think of a single way in which a Welsh medium education has been limiting.

Swipe left for the next trending thread