Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Uncle's reaction to education discussion

282 replies

Krankopi · 31/12/2023 14:53

Family gathering in Southern England over Xmas with extended family and we drove over from West Wales where we've lived for past 18 months. I'm chit chatting to aunt and catching her up on our lives and tell her about plans for DS education.

Our DS turns 3 next year and we're opting to send him to a Welsh-speaking pre-school from September and then if all goes well to Welsh speaking primary school.

The school is very good, recent investment and a few neighbours whose kids go there really rave about it. I studied French at uni and have very open attitude to other language so think it would be great opportunity for DS to be bilingual From young age.

If there were any unforeseen issues and it doesn't work out then there are English speaking primaries and secondaries in area also.

Uncle overheard the conversation and chimed in 'but you're not Welsh!' and 'it's a dead language'. I attempted to explain benefits of bilingualism, fact our area has quite a lot of Welsh speakers and DS will grow up there etc but fell on deaf ears and he really went for it at that point.

He seemed properly offended by the whole thing as if we were somehow betraying our roots (we're English and DS also born in England). It was completely ridiculous. He then proceeded to insult the Welsh, their language before aunt told him to cool it and convo moved on.

His opinion about DS education is irrelevant but thinking back to his reaction has really angered me. It wasn't just that he didn't agree, his blood seemed to really boil. He is a bit of a little Englander type who voted for Brexit so I shouldn't be surprised but I can't understand how someone could take such offense to going to Welsh school in Wales.

The more I think about it, the more I want to say something to him to put him in his place. I find his attitude disgraceful and I'm so close to writing or calling to give him piece of my mind. AIBU? Should I just forget the whole thing?

Maybe making my point another way will work better, like writing next years Xmas card in Welsh.

OP posts:
Melonandfalafel · 31/12/2023 17:46

@Nineteendays
I’m sure that will be helpful for the OP and others making decisions.

OneMoreTime23 · 31/12/2023 17:45
  1. Whether your child be seen as an ‘outsider’ when play dates etc come up

🙄

Moonflower12 · 31/12/2023 17:44

If your son decides to stay in Wales as an adult, a lot of jobs require Welsh speaking as an essential especially in education and healthcare.

I think you've made an excellent decision to help him.

And he can win at hide and seek/sardines because his cousins can't hoodwink by speaking in Welsh and making plans-still bitter 48 years later.

( My mum made the choice to send me to the English Medium school) I'm still upset.

ImCamembertTheBigCheese · 31/12/2023 17:43

namechange55465 · 31/12/2023 15:16

I mean, Welsh seems like quite a useful choice for somebody who lives IN WALES tbh...

Lives in Wales now. Just a thought ...

easylikeasundaymorn · 31/12/2023 17:42

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 31/12/2023 15:00

What downsides? Nobody is suggesting that DS ONLY speaks Welsh! He'll presumably speak English at home and be completely bilingual. Welsh qualifications are valid anywhere - he's not going to be massively disadvantaged. And don't the Welsh still get free Uni education?

The welsh have never had free uni education, or not for any longer than the english had it (i.e. before tuition fees were introduced). When I started in the mid 2000s you had a reduction if you were welsh and stayed in wales for uni but that ended ages ago too.

Strangely people don't seem to apply the 'a minority language not spoken anywhere else' argument to other small european countries - nobody suggests than someone living in Malta or Iceland shouldn't bother learning the native language and 'just speak english' yet more people speak welsh than either of those. It's very normal for welsh primary schools to have parents who don't speak it/are learning and schools are set up to help with this - if children from non-welsh speaking families aren't taught it then how are move people ever going to learn it? Or should it just die out?

Babyblackbear78 · 31/12/2023 17:42

I‘M welsh and live in wales. My children attended English medium schools. I wish they were bilingual to help in the job market as so many occupations now call for the welsh language.

Nineteendays · 31/12/2023 17:41

Melonandfalafel · 31/12/2023 17:38

I’d only proceed only after full research and understanding of:

  1. Where you plan to live over the long term
  2. The ability to realistically help your child with homework and projects in the long term
  3. Whether your child be seen as an ‘outsider’ when play dates etc come up
  4. Going to school events / parents’ evenings - will these be in Welsh? Will grandparents feel comfortable watching a Welsh speaking play? You may not think this is a big thing but being excluded as a parent or child can have repercussions, particularly surrounding anxiety.
My view would be to ask another parent who has been there for their opinion on the education, and whether it has been valuable. Being bilingual is a great asset but there will be alternatives, if you don’t think the best course of action.

I think you owe it to your child to do research from BOTH sides and avoid calling those who have different viewpoints: ‘Little Englanders’, or Brexit supporters.

  1. it won’t make a difference where they choose to live in the long term. Their English levels will be as good as anyone else’s
  2. it can be tricky to help with homework but schools will often send it home bilingually and fully support parents in helping their child.
  3. why would they be an outsider for play dates? They can speak English
  4. parents evenings are in the language of the parents choosing. Mine are always in English as are reports. I don’t fully understand every word of school plays And nor does my mum but it makes no difference to us, we love to watch them on stage
Melonandfalafel · 31/12/2023 17:38

I’d only proceed only after full research and understanding of:

  1. Where you plan to live over the long term
  2. The ability to realistically help your child with homework and projects in the long term
  3. Whether your child be seen as an ‘outsider’ when play dates etc come up
  4. Going to school events / parents’ evenings - will these be in Welsh? Will grandparents feel comfortable watching a Welsh speaking play? You may not think this is a big thing but being excluded as a parent or child can have repercussions, particularly surrounding anxiety.
My view would be to ask another parent who has been there for their opinion on the education, and whether it has been valuable. Being bilingual is a great asset but there will be alternatives, if you don’t think the best course of action.

I think you owe it to your child to do research from BOTH sides and avoid calling those who have different viewpoints: ‘Little Englanders’, or Brexit supporters.

Nineteendays · 31/12/2023 17:38

I think a lot of people don’t realise that just because the education is in the medium of Welsh, English is still taught and children will reach the same levels as children in English medium schools- they will do the English GCSEs just like the English schools etc

my children are in welsh education. Daughter is in year 3 and just started English lessons. (She’s first language English, all the kids are fluent English). In one term, she’s now on stage 9 English reading books and should be working at the same level as her English medium peers by the end of year 4.

son is in year 7. He is working at the expected level for all his subjects including English. If he chose to go to the local English medium high school instead of welsh, he would be exactly where he needs to be just fluent in another language too. i imagine he will go to an English medium college or sixth form in the future, it won’t be a problem.

you’re not taking anything away from your kids giving them a welsh medium education OP. You’re giving them an extra string to their bow by giving them full fluency in another language in addition to English.

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 31/12/2023 17:37

DinoDays · 31/12/2023 15:04

Blimey! This thread is a real eye opener!

Despite being an old fucker I didn't really believe the English were narrow minded racists. But hey this thread proves otherwise!

Why on Earth would it be an odd decision to live in Wales and speak Welsh! What the actual fuck! He's not only going to be able to speak Welsh! He'll be speaking English at home!

My flabber is gasted at some of these posters. Genuinely!

Your son will definitely thank you later!

I agree - I didn't realise how many small-minded xenophobes there were on MN!

Your uncle is an idiot, OP, but you're best off ignoring him. Don't give him headspace.

therealcookiemonster · 31/12/2023 17:37

don't think anything is to be gained from further engaging with your uncle regarding your DS's education. I would leave it

I do think its brilliant to send him to a Welsh speaking primary though! it's so important to preserve these less spoken languages. otherwise, before you know it - they die out.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 31/12/2023 17:32

Good on you, OP. I'd love to learn Welsh! Some depressing and infuriating replies though. Some English people are unfortunately very ignorant about language-learning, far too blinkered by the dominance of English, and incapable of realising that there is inherent value in learning another language, whatever that language is.

Mirabai · 31/12/2023 17:31

theduchessofspork · 31/12/2023 17:02

@Mirabai

There’s plenty of evidence knowing more than one language helps you pick up others, whether they are in the same group or not. Part of this will be confidence, but it is also neurological.

One example from Tokyo University below but there are many

Now, stop being a dick and go and have a nice NYE

studyfinds.org/more-languages-easier-for-brain/

Do people read the links they post on this thread?

This tiny study of 49 people actually indicated that multilinguals picked up a new language faster than bilinguals. Multilinguals showed one side of their brain activated, while bilinguals used both sides.

Mirabai · 31/12/2023 17:24

Simonjt · 31/12/2023 17:01

If you look at research done in the area you’ll see it isn’t a generalisation, but backed up by a wide range of studies.

It is a generalisation as it is not true of everyone. Research in the area, as in most subjects, contains differing perspectives, contradictory or inconclusive evidence, and varying conclusions.

Nor am I arguing it’s not a plus to be bilingual - I’m all for it - but personally I’d want my second language to be more broadly useful then Welsh, much though I am fond of Wales.

MrsWinkly · 31/12/2023 17:21

It's not a dead language. My Dad was from Ceredigion, Welsh was his primary language. He spoke English equally well. The next 2 generations of my family in Wales are the same. I can only swear, recite a nursery rhyme about 2 rats on 2 potatoes, and use very basic words, having grown up in England.
I think it's wonderful that the Welsh language is alive and kicking. It's an advantage in all sorts of ways, not a millstone!
It doesn't exclude the possibility of learning other languages as well - makes it easier I think. My Dad could speak French and Italian too.
No advice on how you deal with it, but your uncle sounds a bit ignorant OP!

BeckyBloomwood3 · 31/12/2023 17:16

Mirabai · 31/12/2023 17:09

There’s certainly plenty of evidence that starting a language very young is much more likely to end in mastery than starting later. Same can be true of music and sport. However kids in bilingual schools can struggle in ways that are not being acknowledged on this thread. If they do not have a particular facility for languages it can make school much more of a challenge than a monolingual one.

The OP's son is young. If there's an issue it will be easy to spot and fix, say by moving him to an English language school.
I'd have concerns for an older child, but not one who hasn't even started school yet.

TripleDaisySummer · 31/12/2023 17:15

It's pretty usual thing to do in Wales.

We moved later - primary years - and to more English speaking border area so our kids went into English Medium schools. They still had to sit GCSE Welsh as second language - so if he does move to English medium later on it's still a huge benefit later anyway.

FIL attitude towards welsh language has been negative and hardened over time we've been here as well no fucking clue why.

Welshphoenix · 31/12/2023 17:14

Boomboom22 · 31/12/2023 15:15

Hmm. The problem is English is globally the language of business then French so are you setting him up to only live in Wales rather than a more global language? Because of the Americans of course, when I was young it was not expected for English to still be the language of business tbh.

He will be at least bi lingual so will be able to speak English as well may be even French if he wants to work there

Horrace · 31/12/2023 17:11

I live in Wales. Born in Wales. Don't speak or understand Welsh. English only.
Nothing wrong with your uncle voting to leave the EU or for having a different opinion to you.
Just leave him to his opinion and you to yours. Not worth falling out over.
It will blow over.
I have very strong views over the Welsh language but I wouldn't want to fall out with family and friends over it.
Just seems silly.
Not everyone has to think the same as you.

PinkMimosa · 31/12/2023 17:11

I think what you're doing is pretty much normal, especially for west Wales.

All he has done is show his own ignorance in lots of subjects including Wales, the Welsh language, education and language acquisition.

Definitely carry on with your plan and try to limit how much you tell him about your life in the future.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 31/12/2023 17:11

53 % of Welsh voted for Brexit.

‘According to the 2021 census, the Welsh-speaking population of Wales aged three or older was 538,300 (17.8%) and nearly three quarters of the population in Wales said they had no Welsh language skills. Other estimates suggest that 889,700 people (29.2%) aged three or older in Wales could speak Welsh in June 2023.’

SleepingStandingUp · 31/12/2023 17:09

Neriah · 31/12/2023 15:28

Because English people think the whole world should communicate in a language they understand, which means they don't have to be arsed learning any others. They always have.

Yes. Every single English person to ever have existed. Including OP. And the English people agreeing with OP. We're all lying and hate anyone who doesn't speak English 🤔. You sound as ridiculous as the ignorant uncle

Mirabai · 31/12/2023 17:09

titchy · 31/12/2023 16:57

I’m good at languages but some people aren’t, and sticking them in a bilingual school doesn’t change that.

It does though, particularly if they start from early primary, and there's oodles of evidence that shows that.

There’s certainly plenty of evidence that starting a language very young is much more likely to end in mastery than starting later. Same can be true of music and sport. However kids in bilingual schools can struggle in ways that are not being acknowledged on this thread. If they do not have a particular facility for languages it can make school much more of a challenge than a monolingual one.

CarterBeatsTheDevil · 31/12/2023 17:08

Love this, OP. Not sure how you can get much more authentically British than learning Welsh, which (edit!) comes from the language that was spoken across Britain before the Anglo-Saxons turned up. Your uncle is a tit. Admittedly I am a massive language nerd, but I would do exactly the same if I lived in Wales.