Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Uncle's reaction to education discussion

282 replies

Krankopi · 31/12/2023 14:53

Family gathering in Southern England over Xmas with extended family and we drove over from West Wales where we've lived for past 18 months. I'm chit chatting to aunt and catching her up on our lives and tell her about plans for DS education.

Our DS turns 3 next year and we're opting to send him to a Welsh-speaking pre-school from September and then if all goes well to Welsh speaking primary school.

The school is very good, recent investment and a few neighbours whose kids go there really rave about it. I studied French at uni and have very open attitude to other language so think it would be great opportunity for DS to be bilingual From young age.

If there were any unforeseen issues and it doesn't work out then there are English speaking primaries and secondaries in area also.

Uncle overheard the conversation and chimed in 'but you're not Welsh!' and 'it's a dead language'. I attempted to explain benefits of bilingualism, fact our area has quite a lot of Welsh speakers and DS will grow up there etc but fell on deaf ears and he really went for it at that point.

He seemed properly offended by the whole thing as if we were somehow betraying our roots (we're English and DS also born in England). It was completely ridiculous. He then proceeded to insult the Welsh, their language before aunt told him to cool it and convo moved on.

His opinion about DS education is irrelevant but thinking back to his reaction has really angered me. It wasn't just that he didn't agree, his blood seemed to really boil. He is a bit of a little Englander type who voted for Brexit so I shouldn't be surprised but I can't understand how someone could take such offense to going to Welsh school in Wales.

The more I think about it, the more I want to say something to him to put him in his place. I find his attitude disgraceful and I'm so close to writing or calling to give him piece of my mind. AIBU? Should I just forget the whole thing?

Maybe making my point another way will work better, like writing next years Xmas card in Welsh.

OP posts:
Smugandproud · 01/01/2024 04:18

My dgs went to welsh nursery from 2 years old and welsh led primary.
He's 11 now and fluent in both English and Welsh.
My dm asked why the school didn't teach a more useful second language.
I told her they do, English, Welsh is his first language.
So many ignorant English people @Krankopi including your uncle. He's a xenophobic knob for sure.

Valeriekat · 01/01/2024 04:01

If you aren't Welsh speaking yourself won't he be at a huge disadvantage?

Hughs · 01/01/2024 02:30

We are non-Welsh speakers living in Wales and sent the DC to English medium schools - mainly because primary schools at that time made such a thing about the importance of parental support that we thought it would be best. (Also the schools were further away, no Welsh medium secondary in our town.) I do wonder sometimes whether it was the right decision and DD in particular has a moan about it occasionally. She wishes she was fluent and that's her project for next summer after A levels. But thinking back, they did get a lot of support at home, especially in early primary and at gcse time. That wouldn't have been possible if they were at WM school, so on balance it was probably the right thing to do. It's a great idea if you have time to become fluent yourself though, so you can be as involved as they need.

I have definitely lost out on opportunities at work because my Welsh isn't good enough.

AndSoFinally · 31/12/2023 20:34

We did exactly this. They picked it up like sponges. The only thing i noticed is that they don't really seem to know when they're speaking Welsh (odd as that sounds). They couldnt translate things until quite late in primary school, despite understanding perfectly, they just didn't seem to realise they were speaking a different language I didn't u fees rand, they were all just "words" they knew.

I sent them to English medium secondary as I wanted to be able to help them more. This was tough because only a few from their class did this, but they soon made new friends.

Several colleagues that went to Welsh secondary and sixth form had said they found the transition to English medium university really quite tough, and wished they'd moved for sixth form or earlier, so I figured this would help with that too.

Definitely no regrets

RandomMess · 31/12/2023 20:09

Utterly bonkers, you live in an area of Wales where Welsh is widely spoken. Welsh government is actively seeking to increase the use of the Welsh language.

Why wouldn't you choose a Welsh medium school.

🤷🏽‍♀️

Vistada · 31/12/2023 19:35

OP - you asked for an opinion, you can't get defensive when you get opinions different to yours.

If you wanted an echo chamber to tell you how right you are and how wrong uncle is, MN is not the place...

DaNiYmaOHyd · 31/12/2023 19:33

Clic | Stori'r Iaith | Elis James (s4c.cymru)
There are English subtitles available

It's fascinating.

DaNiYmaOHyd · 31/12/2023 19:31

@EmporiumHawkins , OP's DC won't be living in a Latin-speaking community.
I don't think there are any Latin-medium primary schools in the UK.

DaNiYmaOHyd · 31/12/2023 19:26

@Mirabai , Never said it was. Speaking Welsh won’t make other languages easier no, unless it’s Cornish or Breton or the Goidelic Celtic languages.

I'm a mother tongue Welsh speaker and was educated in Welsh medium schools.
Being bilingual has certainly helped me learn other languages, including non-european ones.
It's given me a better ear & tongue for different sounds in other languages for a start.

EmporiumHawkins · 31/12/2023 19:22

personally id value latin more as a language

EmporiumHawkins · 31/12/2023 19:21

"He is a bit of a little Englander type who voted for Brexit so I shouldn't be surprised"

when people make sweeping statements like this, its puzzling, i mean how can someone being an englander and brexit suddenly explain all the persons views on different subjects, etc for an accurate perspective on there views then surley thats case by case, not just oh they voted brexit as if that somehow gives full analysis.,

@Krankopi

WillowCraft · 31/12/2023 19:10

Alcyoneus · 31/12/2023 15:52

Your son, your choice. It’s quaint and probably quite a middle class trendy thing right now, but let’s not pretend it’s of any benefit career wise. Welsh isn’t up there with Spanish, Mandarin and Arabic in the list of languages that is going to benefit anyone’s job prospects.

Actually you are entirely wrong. Speaking Welsh is a big advantage for any public sector job in Wales. Presumably the op would like her son to be able to remain in Wales and not have to leave for career reasons. It may not be middle class and trendy but lots of people do like their children and grandchildren to live near them

BeckyBloomwood3 · 31/12/2023 18:28

LondonGrey · 31/12/2023 18:03

The ignorance! and how condescending!
I bet you have never come to wales (don’t bother 🤣)
Just an FYI but the welsh language is extremely important if you want to have a job in wales because guess what we speak welsh (not mandarin) …i can’t get over the stupidity and ignorance

It's shocking how @Alcyoneus and some other posters don't even bother to read the thread.
People growing up in Wales, learning Welsh 'trendy middle class'. LOL.
I admire the Welsh btw for keeping their language going. It's sad to see the decimation of Scots and Gaelic.

Previousreligion · 31/12/2023 18:24

I'm gobsmacked by some of these replies.

I'm also jealous. If there was a foreign speaking nursery and primary school near me I'd definitely send DC to it! I don't even mind what language it was. I wish I had been brought up bilingual! Sadly I've looked and there's nothing like that near me.

LondonGrey · 31/12/2023 18:03

Alcyoneus · 31/12/2023 15:52

Your son, your choice. It’s quaint and probably quite a middle class trendy thing right now, but let’s not pretend it’s of any benefit career wise. Welsh isn’t up there with Spanish, Mandarin and Arabic in the list of languages that is going to benefit anyone’s job prospects.

The ignorance! and how condescending!
I bet you have never come to wales (don’t bother 🤣)
Just an FYI but the welsh language is extremely important if you want to have a job in wales because guess what we speak welsh (not mandarin) …i can’t get over the stupidity and ignorance

Dotcheck · 31/12/2023 18:01

TheaBrandt · 31/12/2023 14:56

Sorry but he has a point. Not sure your son will thank you in the future.

Why? How on earth does it harm anyone to learn an additional language?

JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · 31/12/2023 17:59

I think it's a fantastic opportunity for your son. I have a family member who learned a Celtic language and was poo-pooed by many. They now have a fantastic very highly paid job as a translator. Your uncle is an idiot. But you know that.

Mariposistaa · 31/12/2023 17:56

Please once your son is old and verbally fluent enough teach him to address his uncle exclusively in Welsh.
Your idea sounds great. Just make sure that when he is a teenager that he gets used to writing formally and academically in English as well as Welsh. My friend took all her GCSEs and A Levels in Welsh and while she was fluent in English too, struggled with formal essays at uni.

Melonandfalafel · 31/12/2023 17:54

@1offnamechange and @OneMoreTime23

I was trying to be helpful.
My child was excluded at infant school and it continues to impact her.
I therefore think everyone should think very carefully about the decisions they make, and I’m not going to just agree with the OP.
FWIW I think the treatment of languages in the English system is really disappointing.
Anyway I’m going to celebrate NY now.

Curioushorse · 31/12/2023 17:54

Being bilingual helps you access more languages. It helps develop pattern recognition, understanding of language and grammatical structures, and improves cognitive flexibility- so it would make it easier to learn other languages.

I am currently sitting here with three people who were taught in a Welsh medium school and have all gone on to work in jobs which require languages. Other languages. One of them is a translator- she translates two other languages into English (NOT Welsh).

Your uncle, and some of the people on this thread, is confidently spouting rubbish.

Moonflower12 · 31/12/2023 17:51

To all the people wondering if the child will be left out at play dates etc, as the family are in West Wales, Welsh will be most children's FIRST language. I think in Ceredigion it's the first language of 70% of the population and rising.

And it's not only spoken in Wales. It's also spoken in Patagonia.

ChristmasFluff · 31/12/2023 17:51

It's brilliant he will be learning Welsh, and I believe it's important for people to learn Welsh if they live here (I am learning). It's certainly not a dead language here in the north, and many, many jobs require basic Welsh.

Immersion is an excellent way to learn at a young age, and your son is so young he will learn to speak without an accent too - amazing gift to give him!

SapphireOpal · 31/12/2023 17:48

ImCamembertTheBigCheese · 31/12/2023 17:43

Lives in Wales now. Just a thought ...

But it's not like there's a handy French speaking school round the corner. It's send him to an English speaking school and have him only know one language, or the Welsh medium one where he'll get to know an additional one.

Who knows what language may be useful to him in future but having learnt one that MAY be useful can't be a bad thing.

1offnamechange · 31/12/2023 17:47

Melonandfalafel · 31/12/2023 17:38

I’d only proceed only after full research and understanding of:

  1. Where you plan to live over the long term
  2. The ability to realistically help your child with homework and projects in the long term
  3. Whether your child be seen as an ‘outsider’ when play dates etc come up
  4. Going to school events / parents’ evenings - will these be in Welsh? Will grandparents feel comfortable watching a Welsh speaking play? You may not think this is a big thing but being excluded as a parent or child can have repercussions, particularly surrounding anxiety.
My view would be to ask another parent who has been there for their opinion on the education, and whether it has been valuable. Being bilingual is a great asset but there will be alternatives, if you don’t think the best course of action.

I think you owe it to your child to do research from BOTH sides and avoid calling those who have different viewpoints: ‘Little Englanders’, or Brexit supporters.

why would you assume that OP hasn't already done all of these things? If nothing else she will have almost definitely spent more time looking into it than the uncle.
But yes nice 'Nadolig Llawen' card to him next year 🐲