Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to pay service charge at restaurant

86 replies

ThesecondLEM · 31/12/2023 12:19

So we went out last night, had a lovely meal, great service. Pricey, but we knew this. 12.5% discretionary service charge added to bill, which of course we paid happily.

DP prefers to be given the choice to tip, I think it makes it easier.

It then occurred to me that when handing over a tip for good service I'm reasonably confident the staff receive this (hopefully tax free) to boost their wages. I'm wondering if this happens when the service is automatically added as part of the bill. Especially in larger/chain resturants if it just goes into the profits?

I'm not interested in boosting company profits, I'm wanting to say thank you to staff for their hard work. Saying that, might someone who works in a restaurant where tips are extra?

OP posts:
Runningandtired · 01/01/2024 12:08

Also, to add. I overheard one of our young waitresses tell a customer they don't receive tips.... this was a lie. As per my PP. She did get pulled up on it. As the customer took pity on her and put a tenner in her hand and closed it like she was helping her out. In my opinion that's basically theft. She lied. I pulled her up on it. She was embarrassed. I only let her stay as she promised not to do it again and she gave the £10 back to the customer before they left. Customer thanked her for her honesty and let her keep it anyway.

So just because a server says they don't get the tips, doesn't mean it's true. Some places are bad and don't give it. But I think in this case, staff have to vote with their feet and leave. There are good employers out there.

Runningandtired · 01/01/2024 11:54

Me and dh run and own 3 restaurants.

All cash tips go in a pot and divided. Someone is responsible and they divide it equally. We don't get involved. Any tips/service charge on card is taxed and deducted and then we have a tips tronc holder and they distribute it after we take the tax off.

It's fair. However, I don't think half of the people who use restaurants understand the costs and how little a restaurant actually makes.

Our staff are all paid well above minimum wage plus tips. They earn more than us most months. So our lowest wage we pay is £14 an hour. We spend in one restaurant about £6000 a week in wages after tax and national insurance is deducted. Rent sare high, business rates need to be paid, stock is very expensive, alcohol has duties included in prices etc, gas and electric is extortionate. Things regularly break down and need repairs etc. And then if you saw our VAT bills. You would have a heart attack.

But we have definitley seen this change in attitude from serving staff where they think they should receive tips tax free, because the US do this. But in the UK there is a minimum wage and we pay over this and we still have staff complain they don't receive as many tips.

All I know is, it's bloody hard managing people and they expect tips even when they have done the bare minimum.

We try to be a fair employers and we are flexible when it comes to child care, shift changes, we help out where possible. For example someone is moving, we will help move their things as we have a van. If they need a lift, we will do it etc etc

Not all hospitality managers and owners are the work of the devil.not paying their staff.

Meant to add. There's not a huge profit on hospitality, so it's not owners being greedy. We have had our restaurants for about 8 years.

We are also independents, not chains. Not sure if that's relevant or not.

Katemax82 · 01/01/2024 11:42

If service charge is added you don't need to tip extra

Usernamen · 01/01/2024 03:44

RichPetunia · 01/01/2024 02:53

I like the added service charge. Makes everything easier 🤩.

Agreed. I also think if it wasn’t automatically added, most people in the UK wouldn’t tip.

BrokenWing · 01/01/2024 03:14

Brefugee · 31/12/2023 12:22

i always ask for a service charge to be removed. I check with the staff that they get the tips, and usually also ask how they are split.

If there is indication that not paying cash tips ends up with management, i pay my (service free) bill with my card and hand the cash tip to the waiter.

Your investigations are probably a waste of time as they will be told all tips need to be pooled anyway if given in cash and it risks the young persons job if they are tempted to keep it and get caught out. It also causes issues between the team of staff if they believe one of their colleagues are pocketing what should be shared tips.

Whereever ds has worked tips are pooled and shared/paid monthly (pro rata to hours worked) between all front and back of house staff and his employer takes care of the tax requirements for them through paye and saves them having to report to hmrc personally.

It is very naive to think front of house waiting staff just walk away with pockets full of tenners at the end of a shift.

HamBone · 01/01/2024 03:06

Kwasi · 31/12/2023 13:07

Why should the staff receive tax-free income? It's not like it's America where servers are paid a dollar an hour.

@Kwasi Recently, things have got weird in the US re. tipping. Wages aren’t as low as they used be- DD (18) is paid $13/hr in her first restaurant job, she knows ppl making $17/hr. But the expected tip has gone up to min. 20%, even 25% is suggested. It used to be 15%, 20% for excellent service. I’m not sure why it’s changed recently.

RichPetunia · 01/01/2024 02:53

I like the added service charge. Makes everything easier 🤩.

Lookingforbiscoff · 01/01/2024 02:53

It seems the Uk just keeps taking the worst parts of US culture and ramming it in to this society even when it doesn’t make sense. I get why they have tips in America and it’s still problematic especially when you read the history of tipping and how the tipping system adversely affects minorities etc, but it’s absolutely ridiculous to expect them over here.

A bit off topic but everywhere I go now I see a box for tips or an option for tips on the card machine…even for places where it’s just counter service.

This is UK employers answer to the problem of not increasing wages for over a decade.

spanishviola · 01/01/2024 02:45

Nonewclothes2024 · 01/01/2024 02:33

Exactly

I agree. When did this become fairly standard?

Nonewclothes2024 · 01/01/2024 02:33

MiIIieee · 31/12/2023 12:23

I dont think it should be on the bill at all. We pay it like, but it shouldn't be on there. It should be a personal choice to tip.

Exactly

Brefugee · 31/12/2023 17:57

OnTheRoll · 31/12/2023 14:11

They all already receive their wages, no?

as do the waiters.
The places i have been to that do this give the wait staff a bit more of it proportionally, but the chef the pan bash guy and the bar staff all get a share

LaughingCat · 31/12/2023 15:16

I’ve worked in lots of places and they’re all different. Cash tips are always preferred because you keep the tips for the tables you run minus a small proportion to kitchen or drinks dispense - there’s nothing worse than being good both at your job and with people, but getting an equal share of the card tips with Anna, who’s forgetful, slow and rude, and brought feck all tips in herself. Obviously (to anyone working at HMRC), I have always declared my cash tips throughout my working life in order to pay my tax on them, as automatically happens with my card tips. Pinkie promise.

I hate auto-service charges. I’m a generous tipper if the service was good. Let me choose how much I want to give. My DH is of the mind that you give a tip every time as his nan always told him that you’ve no clue what is going on in that wait staff’s life, so not to judge them on their behaviour that day. But equally doesn’t like to be told how much he should give on the assumption that you will tip.

Sone places I’ve worked have included the card tips in my weekly payslip, some have included them ‘after tills have been balanced’ to make up any shortfalls, some places have only allowed me to keep cash tips and not card, one place said I was not allowed to keep cash or card tips, and insisted on a full body search before and after my shift to make sure. I, obviously, never went back after that shift (which was at a cafe for a freaking science museum).

The only way to know your server’s going to get the tips for sure is to leave cash on the table or check with them, personally.

ScottishDora · 31/12/2023 15:11

I work at resort that adds a service charge and its dividend between all staff in the resort, including back of house staff, like finance and maintenance but the food and beverage staff get a bigger share.

NorthernGirlie · 31/12/2023 14:53

I always ask the staff. Some places they only get it if it's separate.

A student of mine works at a semi chain place in the North East (as in there's a few restaurants of the same name - cheap Italian food if any8ne from up here reads this) and he said they're not allowed to keep any tips. The manager takes them - so I don't tip if we go there.

Agapornis · 31/12/2023 14:50

Ask the person serving you, it's the only way of knowing for sure. I've been doing this for years because it varies greatly. In some places they got to keep cash tips but not card ('add gratuity' Hmm). Just because the law changes doesn't mean restaurants will adhere to it. I've worked in a shop with a cash tip jar that was never shared with staff.

HappiestSleeping · 31/12/2023 14:49

Kwasi · 31/12/2023 13:07

Why should the staff receive tax-free income? It's not like it's America where servers are paid a dollar an hour.

They don't. It doesn't matter whether the tip is payed by card or cash, the recipient still should pay tax on it (at least, that is the situation in the UK. Whether they declare it is a different question). I think the OP was more asking about whether the establishment keep it, or some of it vs it going entirely to the serving staff (less whatever tax they have to pay on it, per above).

jackstini · 31/12/2023 14:42

I do tend to ask the server what happens to tips and am pleased the law is changing to make sure any tips given do go to the staff, not just kept by the restaurant

Dd works in an independent restaurant and all tips (cash or credit card on bill) go into one pot and get divided up between staff each week pro-rata depending on hours worked
They get it in cash in the same envelope as their weekly pay slip

TeacherPlease · 31/12/2023 14:42

LordBummenbachsMagnificentBalls · 31/12/2023 14:02

I really do object to the service charge automatically being added to the bill lately, it means you have to make a point of asking for it to be removed and dictates how much is expected.

the point of the standard 10% charge is based on an American system of food being cheaper because the tips subsidise the cost of labour, but food prices in restaurants aren’t similar costs in the UK. Expecting customers to also pay a percentage to servers is not comparable if we are also paying higher costs for food

When did you last go to America? Last time I went, restaurant prices were definitely comparable and often higher than ours, before you even factor in a tip.

Ladybughello · 31/12/2023 14:37

Just ask the waiter/waitress whether the £ goes to them or not. In my experience they always appreciate the question. And definitely don’t use it as an excuse not to tip if the service was good!

WellThisIsFun1 · 31/12/2023 14:30

Service charges must get distributed to the team via their wages, which of course is taxed.

Companies can't just keep it for themselves

ThesecondLEM · 31/12/2023 14:27

I agree that all members should get tip,I think, I couldbe wrong, that waiting staff get less money?

OP posts:
Britpopbaby · 31/12/2023 14:27

I thought you had to be notified before hand that a service charge was to be added and that is what has guided me in terms of tipping. I had a meal ruined because I made a point of this and the subsequent discussion around this situation between the waitresses and the manager right next to me spoilt the meal that I had ordered.

OnTheRoll · 31/12/2023 14:11

ComfortableAtLastTookLongEnough · 31/12/2023 14:06

The waiting staff couldn’t do their part of the job without the chef’s, commis’s, KP’s, the meeters and greeters, so I think the one pot system works well, so long as it is not including management, who are generally well paid.

They all already receive their wages, no?

ComfortableAtLastTookLongEnough · 31/12/2023 14:06

The waiting staff couldn’t do their part of the job without the chef’s, commis’s, KP’s, the meeters and greeters, so I think the one pot system works well, so long as it is not including management, who are generally well paid.

BeckyBloomwood3 · 31/12/2023 14:06

Starzinsky · 31/12/2023 12:52

I think it's mixed bag as to whether it goes to the company or staff currently. There is a new law coming into force in 2024 which means all service charges have to be given to staff. I do absolutely hate added service charges and I don't really understand how it has become more common when we now pay higher meals prices to cover increases in minimum wage, pension etc which further inflates the service charge. I would rather pay sightly higher prices and know that staff are getting a fair basic wage. I hate it being a set % too as often my family buy the most expensive thing on the menu so often the amount charged seems excessive for the actual amount of service received.

What a waste of legislative effort. They should've just banned service charges instead. I say that as a former hospitality industry employee.