Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to pay service charge at restaurant

86 replies

ThesecondLEM · 31/12/2023 12:19

So we went out last night, had a lovely meal, great service. Pricey, but we knew this. 12.5% discretionary service charge added to bill, which of course we paid happily.

DP prefers to be given the choice to tip, I think it makes it easier.

It then occurred to me that when handing over a tip for good service I'm reasonably confident the staff receive this (hopefully tax free) to boost their wages. I'm wondering if this happens when the service is automatically added as part of the bill. Especially in larger/chain resturants if it just goes into the profits?

I'm not interested in boosting company profits, I'm wanting to say thank you to staff for their hard work. Saying that, might someone who works in a restaurant where tips are extra?

OP posts:
UglyModernWindows · 01/01/2024 13:53

Automatic service charge is not a new thing. When I worked in the catering in London in late 90’s to early noughties, it was fairly common then. And it was 12.5% even back then.

I worked at a well known landmark restaurant for few years and they had the tronc system. We got paid a basic annual salary, which was above minimum wage and then a percentage of the service charge based on your experience & job title (which were graded). I of course don’t know if the restaurant kept a percentage to themselves but for what it’s worth, I felt we were quite well paid within the industry.

shivawn · 01/01/2024 13:41

When I did waitressing and bartending work (over 10 years ago in my late teens/early 20's) we all kept our own tips and I'm pretty sure no one declared them, I definitely didn't. It wasn't like we got much anyway, mostly coins back then but it was always nice.

shivawn · 01/01/2024 13:37

I've only ever seen service charge added for large groups at restaurants around here and I eat out quite a lot. Usually it's just my husband and I and there's almost never a service charge for a table of 2. We tip in cash if we want to. Before Covid I always always tipped no matter what but after lockdowns I noticed a massive drop in service at the same time as prices started going up, so now I'm much more discerning.

Neriah · 01/01/2024 13:34

Kwasi · 31/12/2023 13:07

Why should the staff receive tax-free income? It's not like it's America where servers are paid a dollar an hour.

Why do you assume that tips are tax free? They aren't. All income should be declared. Whatever your job is.

And a wide range of employers take the tips / service charge, and if they don't keep them, they use them as part of the wage thereby reducing what the employer actually pays to below the minimum wage. It is entirely legal to use the tips as "wage". And not uncommon at all. Some of the largest chains do it.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 01/01/2024 13:32

iklboo · 01/01/2024 13:24

One thing that worries me with 'all tips go to staff' is the ratio of the split.

But genuinely, why worry about it? Presumably you wouldn't go into any other place of work and involve yourself relative pay/benefits at the time, so how are eateries different?

Runningandtired · 01/01/2024 13:29

Oh and added to my post up thread. We only add a service charge for tables of 10+ and we are more than happy to remove if asked

I had posted further up thread as we own restaurants.

But this is the guidance sent to us by our accountant.https://www.litrg.org.uk/latest-news/news/220720-how-tips-are-taxed

PotterHead1985 · 01/01/2024 13:28

I can understand the service charge on larger parties thing. Amount of work of a larger table can be a lot to handle at times. But service charge on a single person's bill or the like, sod off.

iklboo · 01/01/2024 13:24

One thing that worries me with 'all tips go to staff' is the ratio of the split.

Groovee · 01/01/2024 13:20

My Ds works for Toby Carvery. He shares cash tips with any colleague who may have covered the table at one point. Any tips paid by card get paid in his wages. All tips on Christmas Day were shared amongst all staff before they finished their shift.

I know a local place charge a service charge and all staff on that shift get a share of it from kitchen staff to front of house staff.

Doublerainbow23 · 01/01/2024 13:19

I haven't come across it being added automatically, but would remove it if it was. I sometimes leave a cash tip, sometimes not, depends on if the service was genuinely great or not. Buy I'd never leave more than 10%. If it was average why would I give the staff a ti, they've literally just done theornjob? They're paid at least minimum wage. If they don't like the salary get a different job. Same as anyone.

Winnading · 01/01/2024 13:17

caringcarer · 01/01/2024 12:57

I think that's fair. They all do their bit. One preps veg, someone else usually cooks it, bar staff pours drinks, someone else carries it to the table. Why should the person carrying it to the table get a tip and not those prepping veg or cooking the meal? I think sharing the tips is a much fairer way.

I agree it's fair in principle.

However who is looking after the cash tips? How do you know they are not skimming?
How is it worked out.

Many (very many) years ago I did 6 weeks as a silver service waitress. Over the Christmas period. All tips were handed in to be split with all staff. My share after a month of 2 shifts a day, 7 days a week was £3. 45.
I'm almost certain the manager was skimming hundreds first. So who do you trust with the cash tips?

After the first month, I kept my own tips. For those 2 weeks I made easy 200 a week. Got caught keeping my own tips, and was sacked.

NorthernGirlie · 01/01/2024 13:16

Yup. Assume they're all the same but I only know about the 1 they work in!

Puzzledandpissedoff · 01/01/2024 13:12

What I object to is when service charges are added to bills, it really annoys me because it puts you in a difficult position if you weren’t going to tip/can’t really afford a tip

As said I'll willingly pay either a service charge or a tip, but the one which winds me up is when they put on a charge AND leave a space for a tip as well ... they've got to be joking

About the place where you tipped then found an added service charge though - surely that was announced on the menu?
Because if it wasn't you'd have been fully entitled to have it removed

LlynTegid · 01/01/2024 13:11

Tips should be in cash, I would never expect anything else to get to the staff who have performed an excellent service.

I think you should ask for it to be removed, explain it is a point of principle to you (so not about the person who served you), and then leave any tip in cash if you feel it deserves it.

Æthelfled · 01/01/2024 13:07

I've noticed where there is a service charge added the service is appalling. I always ask for it to be removed.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 01/01/2024 13:05

There is a new law coming into force in 2024 which means all service charges have to be given to staff

These kind of things always make me smile, realising that the decent places will go on handing it to the staff anyway and the no-so-decent will find some way round it

Personally I'll either tip or pay a service charge unless it's terrible; just let me know what's required and I'll happily do it. What I won't do however is get involved with the inevitable stories about getting stiffed in the hope of a bigger tip ... I don't interfere with the employment of others, so if you have a problem with management take it up with them yourself

ACynicalDad · 01/01/2024 13:00

Most jobs don’t get tips, I strongly think people should get a reasonable wage and any tips should be at the discretion of the punter for exceptional service and not routinely added to bills.

CoatOfArms · 01/01/2024 13:00

DD works in a restaurant. Tips are all split between staff, both those tips left as cash on the table or those added to a credit card bill or added as a service charge. Tips are split between waiting staff, bar staff and kitchen staff, depending on how many hours tehy have worked that week.

feynmanfan · 01/01/2024 12:57

I can answer that for The Ivy (chain ones). I know a young student who works there in holidays. Staff DO NOT get the service charge. They are also made to hand over cash tips. They might get some of the cash ones. But they NEVER get the included service money.

caringcarer · 01/01/2024 12:57

honeyandfizz · 31/12/2023 13:25

DS works in a restaurant and is not allowed to keep any cash tips that are given to him they have to go in the tip jar. All of the gratuity is divided between all the workers - bars staff, kitchen staff etc. Can't help think it is a bit of a fiddle though.

I think that's fair. They all do their bit. One preps veg, someone else usually cooks it, bar staff pours drinks, someone else carries it to the table. Why should the person carrying it to the table get a tip and not those prepping veg or cooking the meal? I think sharing the tips is a much fairer way.

Mammyloveswine · 01/01/2024 12:47

NorthernGirlie · 31/12/2023 14:53

I always ask the staff. Some places they only get it if it's separate.

A student of mine works at a semi chain place in the North East (as in there's a few restaurants of the same name - cheap Italian food if any8ne from up here reads this) and he said they're not allowed to keep any tips. The manager takes them - so I don't tip if we go there.

Sambucas?! That doesn't surprise me tbh!

Georgieporgie29 · 01/01/2024 12:33

I always tip when using restaurants. I tend to go about 10% but round it up. What I object to is when service charges are added to bills, it really annoys me because it puts you in a difficult position if you weren’t going to tip/can’t really afford a tip. Eating out is a treat to some and they shouldn’t be expected to top up people’s wages.

We ate somewhere last year, the food was delicious, the service was slow but they were busy so fair enough. As a consequence I had to leave whilst we were waiting for the bill as I had to drop my daughter off and due to the slow service time was tight. DH told me that he had left a generous tip as the food was delicious, when I looked at the receipt they had also added a service charge, so we had in effect paid twice. We haven’t been back to this place because we were so annoyed that they did that and didn’t even tell us and let us tip twice.

orchiddottyback · 01/01/2024 12:30

HelpMeGetThrough · 31/12/2023 13:16

I get this in hotels when travelling for work, bill comes out with it added. I get it removed, as the company won't reimburse that on my expenses.

Same with me and I'm away from home a lot, so every restaurant or hotel that adds it I request its removed virtually never an issue. To be honest I do it now when I go out on my own time too now.

rookiemere · 01/01/2024 12:19

I object to the moving of the goalposts from 10% to 12.5%.

Restaurant prices have increased a lot more than our salaries have over the past few years, and the service hasn't noticeably improved so what is the extra 2.5% meant to be for ?

SkySecret · 01/01/2024 12:15

I don’t like the whole tipping and service charge culture. It’s just a job like any other, cashiers at a supermarket don’t get tipped, so why should a bartender? UK laws mean that waiting staff aren’t getting a “poor deal” compared to others.

All costs for overheads, including staff, should be on the menu price. I then decide if I want to eat there and agree to pay the advertised price. Just like any other service.

I’ve asked for service to be removed before, most notably at a large chain hotel in London, I was there for a course with work and we got lunch in the restaurant. I ordered a lamb burger, which came on its own, no chips or sides etc, and cost £13. They added a service charge to the bill 😂
sorry, but you’re not telling me that £13 for a piece of bread and a bit of meat isn’t covering your staffs wages. (This was also pre-cost of living crisis). It was already extortion, I’m not handing over even more just because someone walked it over to my table 🙄