Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to pay service charge at restaurant

86 replies

ThesecondLEM · 31/12/2023 12:19

So we went out last night, had a lovely meal, great service. Pricey, but we knew this. 12.5% discretionary service charge added to bill, which of course we paid happily.

DP prefers to be given the choice to tip, I think it makes it easier.

It then occurred to me that when handing over a tip for good service I'm reasonably confident the staff receive this (hopefully tax free) to boost their wages. I'm wondering if this happens when the service is automatically added as part of the bill. Especially in larger/chain resturants if it just goes into the profits?

I'm not interested in boosting company profits, I'm wanting to say thank you to staff for their hard work. Saying that, might someone who works in a restaurant where tips are extra?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Mirrorballsocial · 01/01/2024 21:00

@NorthernGirlie

Is the chain also a drink? That's absolutely shocking re tips.

LindyLou2020 · 01/01/2024 16:41

I've just "googled" to check that my memory of reading about a service charge issue was correct........
In 2016, famous chef Michel Roux jr., owner of Le Gavroche in London, at first denied, then admitted, that none of his staff received any of the 13% service charge.
This was discovered after it was found he had paid some of/all of (?) his chefs below the minimum wage.
His argument was that the restaurant needed the service charge as part of its revenue.
The article I read doesn't say whether the system was changed or remained the same.

MrsSkylerWhite · 01/01/2024 15:51

OnTheRoll · Yesterday 14:11

ComfortableAtLastTookLongEnough ·Yesterday 14:06

The waiting staff couldn’t do their part of the job without the chef’s, commis’s, KP’s, the meeters and greeters, so I think the one pot system works well, so long as it is not including management, who are generally well paid.

They all already receive their wages, no?

As do waiting staff. Why should the people who do the hard work in the kitchen be overlooked?

BeckyBloomwood3 · 01/01/2024 15:47

HoHoHoliday · 01/01/2024 15:09

I long for the time that we move to being a tip-free society. Just pay people a wage for doing a job and leave it at that. Tipping is such a silly practice.
As for service charge - also silly. If I'm going to eat in a restaurant it should be expected that I am served. That's why I'm willing to pay £20 or so for a main course that would cost a fraction of that price if I made it at home, why I'm paying similar for a bottle of wine I could buy cheaper in a shop. The higher price of what I'm ordering should include the fact that it is served to me and I'm not wandering into the restaurant kitchen to help myself.

The best part is that restaurants which have app ordering still include the service charge. What service??
Our 'nice' local pub has no service charge, is amazing, staff friendly, knowledgeable and always down for a chat I leave a top because I want to. I resent it being an expectation for no apparent reason.

LindyLou2020 · 01/01/2024 15:22

NorthernGirlie · 31/12/2023 14:53

I always ask the staff. Some places they only get it if it's separate.

A student of mine works at a semi chain place in the North East (as in there's a few restaurants of the same name - cheap Italian food if any8ne from up here reads this) and he said they're not allowed to keep any tips. The manager takes them - so I don't tip if we go there.

@NorthernGirlie
That's appalling! Would you be prepared to name and shame them, given that you are anonymous on MN?
This makes me so angry, especially as bar/waiting on staff are often students who may be too afraid to speak up.

HoHoHoliday · 01/01/2024 15:09

I long for the time that we move to being a tip-free society. Just pay people a wage for doing a job and leave it at that. Tipping is such a silly practice.
As for service charge - also silly. If I'm going to eat in a restaurant it should be expected that I am served. That's why I'm willing to pay £20 or so for a main course that would cost a fraction of that price if I made it at home, why I'm paying similar for a bottle of wine I could buy cheaper in a shop. The higher price of what I'm ordering should include the fact that it is served to me and I'm not wandering into the restaurant kitchen to help myself.

iklboo · 01/01/2024 15:04

But genuinely, why worry about it? Presumably you wouldn't go into any other place of work and involve yourself relative pay/benefits at the time, so how are eateries different?

You're overthinking my comment. Service charges in the UK don't equate to relative pay & benefits. That's part of an employment contract agreed & signed by the two parties. Tips are an entirely separate issue & discretionary.

I don't 'involve' myself. Worry is maybe the wrong word. I don't lie awake at night. But I have worked in the area & know that sometimes the split is unfair with the people who have actually done all the hard graft getting significantly less than others who did very little instead of a fair / even split.

Lizzieregina · 01/01/2024 14:52

I’m in the US so tipping wait staff is the norm. MW for tipped employees is $9 per hour (versus $16 for non tipped) where I live. National MW is much lower.

Service charges are generally added for parties of 6 or more.

I always leave a cash tip. And waiters always have to “tip out” the bartender and the bus boy (clears the table) but not the cooks or management. I’ve never heard of any pooling of tips, I’m sure that would never fly here.

Tips are supposed to be declared for tax, there are no “tax free” tips, but of course, cash offers the opportunity for some fudging of numbers.

If you can get a wait job in a high end steak house near me, you could easily make $600-$700 in a shift, so I can see where those people would prefer tipping. In a diner you might make 10% of that and still work very hard.

Personally I’d prefer people to be paid properly, including contributions to a state retirement and proper healthcare, but then businesses say they’d have to raise their prices too much.

BeckyBloomwood3 · 01/01/2024 14:49

Groovy48592747 · 01/01/2024 14:11

I don't mind a service charge, however I have in past not realised and tipped as well.

If a service charge is added, I don't tip as well although if they just leave it to a discretionary tip, I would tip more than what a service charge is. I presume they do this as many people don't tip, or tip poorly?

On recent visits to the US, at least 15-20% is expected now. Even on buffets I've been to, where it always used be advised leave a couple of dollars in buffets, to the servers who bring your drinks.

If revenue isn't enough to cover costs, like any other business restaurants should raise the price of their products. Not add a 'service charge'. Should hairdressers, opticians etc also add a 'service charge'?
Why is not tipping a problem? You're charged a price for the food and drinks. You pay the price. the end. Again, like for any other service.
I'm quite annoyed to see all this taking hold in the UK. It seems to be the norm nowadays even though we have minimum wage here. And eating out is already expensive.
It's duplicitous to display a price then charge extra on top of it.
I always ask for the service charge to be removed.

clara778 · 01/01/2024 14:36

Now that we have minimum wage, I'm getting to the point where I think tipping is unnecessary.
Especially as eating out has become very expensive. My friend and I had one drink each and a small main each last month it was £70. Who wants to pay £8.00 extra?

Restaurants wonder why numbers are down, I was too polite to remove it, but I think I will going forward.

BIossomtoes · 01/01/2024 14:34

We’re generous tippers but we usually do it with the non payer providing a cash tip so we remove the service charge and hand 10% of the bill in cash to the waiter.

Ponoka7 · 01/01/2024 14:26

@Grimchmas , if you were leaving why didn't you question it higher up? I know lots of people who work in different Spoons (Via my DD doing a Chef course etc) and they get their tips.

Ponoka7 · 01/01/2024 14:18

ThesecondLEM · 31/12/2023 14:27

I agree that all members should get tip,I think, I couldbe wrong, that waiting staff get less money?

It depends on their role. My DD did all sorts of catering roles while on her Chef collage course. Some waiting on also do kitchen assistant jobs. The wages are the same. My DD worked in pizza places as well. A bug bare is that only the delivery drivers get tips. In all service charge situations the tips were split. It started when cashless got more popular. Even when working race events the tips were split.

Grimchmas · 01/01/2024 14:17

When I worked for wetherspoons years back we were supposed to get tips but never saw them (roumer was that management was using them to subsidise stock discrepancies)

It would be lovely to think that staff got all of their share of tips by law. Having worked in various services industry positions, I'll believe it when I see it. Until then I'll keep asking staff if they get them, and getting the service charge taken off the bill and tipping cash separately. It's still the most reasonable way to try to ensure tips actually do go to staff.

neilyoungismyhero · 01/01/2024 14:15

On the whole their wages are shit. Most of them only do it for the tips. It's a perk of a low paying bloody thankless job that people often do as a second job to make ends meet.

19lottie82 · 01/01/2024 14:13

JadeSeahorse · 01/01/2024 14:10

Yes and with regards to the “Poor American waiters” only being paid USD2 per hour, if I was a waiter in some of those restaurants, bearing in mind the tip expected is around 20% of the bill total, I would be paying the owners to work there.😒

How much do you reckon those “Poor American waiters” are earning in many restaurants in New York, Orlando, Los Angeles etc. for instance? 🙄Must be quite a hefty sum I reckon. USD100 bill is peanuts in the States in many restaurants. USD20 per table? Nice work if you can get it

True. Bartending and waiting tables can make big money in the states, it’s often considered a career unlike in the UK where the jobs are mainly seen as those for students ect

Groovy48592747 · 01/01/2024 14:11

I don't mind a service charge, however I have in past not realised and tipped as well.

If a service charge is added, I don't tip as well although if they just leave it to a discretionary tip, I would tip more than what a service charge is. I presume they do this as many people don't tip, or tip poorly?

On recent visits to the US, at least 15-20% is expected now. Even on buffets I've been to, where it always used be advised leave a couple of dollars in buffets, to the servers who bring your drinks.

JadeSeahorse · 01/01/2024 14:10

TeacherPlease · 31/12/2023 14:42

When did you last go to America? Last time I went, restaurant prices were definitely comparable and often higher than ours, before you even factor in a tip.

Yes and with regards to the “Poor American waiters” only being paid USD2 per hour, if I was a waiter in some of those restaurants, bearing in mind the tip expected is around 20% of the bill total, I would be paying the owners to work there.😒

How much do you reckon those “Poor American waiters” are earning in many restaurants in New York, Orlando, Los Angeles etc. for instance? 🙄Must be quite a hefty sum I reckon. USD100 bill is peanuts in the States in many restaurants. USD20 per table? Nice work if you can get it

EmmaGrundyForPM · 01/01/2024 14:08

ACynicalDad · 01/01/2024 13:00

Most jobs don’t get tips, I strongly think people should get a reasonable wage and any tips should be at the discretion of the punter for exceptional service and not routinely added to bills.

This.
Many people do jobs at minimum wage without being tipped. Restaurants etc should pay a decent wage (ie above NMW) and tips should be the exception not the norm.

Cookerhood · 01/01/2024 14:03

I used to object to it being added on automatically. DS works in an independent gastropub type place. He prefers it when it is added on to the bill as it's simpler. They add up all the tips & divide by the number of staff then multiply by the hours they have done, or something like that. This means everyone from the chefs to the pot washer get a fair amount. Cash can disappear into people's pockets.

HeraSyndulla · 01/01/2024 14:01

The one thing I did cut back on last year was eating out. Most local independents have closed, the chains are noisy and expensive, and their service is "variable ". I recently waited 45 minutes to be served and then they added 12.5 % and left it open to add your tip. I declined their kind offer on both counts. The food was pretty average too.

Rosiem2808 · 01/01/2024 14:00

I absolutely never pay the charges that are automatically added to the bill. If I have received good service I pay my waiting staff cash to them personally. I never tip for bad service not ever.

caringcarer · 01/01/2024 13:59

My niece worked as a waitress whilst at uni and she shared tips with whoever worked that night. They were all put in a glass jar put on the bar and shared out each night before they went home. She got given £50 by a customer once. She generally got a £70 share after each shift.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 01/01/2024 13:58

It is entirely legal to use the tips as "wage". And not uncommon at all. Some of the largest chains do it

So do many cruise lines Hmm

There was a brouhaha some years ago when P&O tried to claim that all tips were paid to staff, only for it to be disproved and more "clarifications" issued which actually clarified nothing

It's a hot topic among cruisers anyway and some got themselves in a right knot over it, ignoring that they could have just paid up once then forget about it

Mirrorballsocial · 01/01/2024 13:55

OnTheRoll · 31/12/2023 14:11

They all already receive their wages, no?

As do the waiting staff, no?