Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Children and Dogs in first class on trains

858 replies

CQaire · 31/12/2023 02:28

Today I was travelling from Carlisle to London on the train to spend New Year with my sister, just me and my 20 year old daughter. We decided to go first class thinking it would be more relaxing and we'd enjoy a little tipple etc.
At the next stop on from us a family with 4 children and a dog got on and were in first class too. Mum, a baby (maybe 1 or so) and twin toddlers at a table for 4, dad and maybe a 5 year old or so at the table for 2 across from them and a spaniel dog.
They were all very chatty to the point earphones didn't help, the dog was barking, dad seemed useless mum seemed to be juggling all the kids + dog herself. Baby was crying etc. This was a 3 hour journey. The kids barely touched any food or had anything to drink so I'm not sure if you pay for under 5s in first class but if you do it can't have been worth it.
DD agreed that it was odd to travel with a dog and kids in first class, especially when there is a standard premium option on these trains which is the same carriage type as first class without the food.
AIBU to think dogs and small children don't belong in first class on a train? (Or plane or anywhere else for that matter).

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
EarlGreywithLemon · 31/12/2023 04:52

Seriously? Children are people, and are just as entitled to be in first class on trains, planes, and indeed any other forms of transport. They are not lepers, inconveniences, or dirty secrets to be kept behind closed doors.

The segregationist attitude some people have towards children never ceases to infuriate me. They’d never get away with it if was about other age categories or about sex or skin colour - and rightly so. Keep out older people for example? Thought not!!

pizzaHeart · 31/12/2023 04:56

R4D4 · 31/12/2023 02:46

Children are people. Of course they can travel first class.

Animals should not be on public transport at all.

This^

Sassysmom · 31/12/2023 05:07

Unclear why people have an issue with having dogs on a train. They are required to be well behaved so the guard or conductor would deal with any issues if they were not. As a general matter I've found dogs on trains to be absolutely perfect journey companions: they go to sleep. They have no luggage. They don't talk on phones, or listen to loud music. And, of course, for many people those dogs are service animals and need to be with them.

Remember too that the train is public transport: it is an inclusive travel system - and there are many people who for many reasons do not have access to private transport but do have to get from A to B with their pets.

Moreover: if you are travelling and you see a person or family who are having a difficult day, or struggling with their little ones or their pet, instead of shooting them dirty looks why not ask if you can be of any help? The unwillingness of many people in the UK to be community minded and take a helpful rather than antagonistic viewpoint is quite striking.

R4D4 · 31/12/2023 05:18

Dog are unhygienic, unpredictable, some are dangerous, many people are scared or them having suffered trauma from dog attacks and lots of people are allergic to them and being in close proximity to one - or even in the carriage after one had been present previously - would make them unwell. Bringing a dog onto public transport is highly antisocial unless the dog is a guide dog and therefore the requirement for it outweighs the inconvenience and unpleasantness for other transport users.

110APiccadilly · 31/12/2023 05:19

R4D4 · 31/12/2023 03:25

Although I do agree that trains were far more pleasant when they had separate compartments for 6-8 people. Perhaps we should be demanding train companies provide better trains again rather than packing people in like rats in a sack with first class barely distinguisable from the basic carriages.

When we travelled on a historic train with compartments once on holiday, my mum mentioned that as a teen she was told to avoid compartments if possible. Too easy to get trapped in one by a man. I don't know whether that's why they were got rid of, but there is a safety risk to them, particularly for women and girls.

MintJulia · 31/12/2023 05:20

Yabvu And absurd. Why wouldn't a family travel in first class?

As for chatting, that is normal human behaviour for a family. Chatting to children, pointing things out in the scenery is the best way to get them through the journey. You talked to your daughter.

Why should you have the right to spoil their enjoyment of their journey?

The thing about public transport is it is public! If you are so disdainful of other passengers, I suggest you drive.

YoureRockingTheBoat · 31/12/2023 05:21

I’m very interested in that premium economy option you mention - which operator does that? Would suit me very well.

SutWytTi · 31/12/2023 05:22

R4D4 · 31/12/2023 04:11

Compartment trains were sexual assault traps for lone women.

With modern technology that doesn't need to be the case. Different sized compartments could be made available (as they are on overnight trains) that are pre-bookable and have locking doors if somebody is alone and feel vulnerable.

Technology can't prevent assault, and obviously installing locks is unsafe.

I also like those types of carriage when on heritage railways with family, but they are not safe for proper public transport when alone at 10pm on busy routes.

Cmonluv · 31/12/2023 05:23

jillgreen · 31/12/2023 03:01

I'm going to be the minority opinion and say YANBU. Some people book first class as a special treat like you did and it's not cheap to do so. Others do it so they can get work done in peace. If you know you're going to be disruptive (small kids, dogs, big groups of chatty mates) then I think it's a bit crap to book into first class when there are normal carriages nextdoor.

Why is 1 persons treat or another's work plans more important than the wellbeing of a young family who have chosen first class for comfort reasons, likelihood of having a seat together and lack of drunks?

Isn't their money as good as that of op or some very important person planning to do work?

2024i · 31/12/2023 05:26

Can’t lie, I find people who drink alcohol on trains to be equally undesirable. You’re all as bad as each other in terms of shitty passengers

Cmonluv · 31/12/2023 05:27

R4D4 · 31/12/2023 05:18

Dog are unhygienic, unpredictable, some are dangerous, many people are scared or them having suffered trauma from dog attacks and lots of people are allergic to them and being in close proximity to one - or even in the carriage after one had been present previously - would make them unwell. Bringing a dog onto public transport is highly antisocial unless the dog is a guide dog and therefore the requirement for it outweighs the inconvenience and unpleasantness for other transport users.

So families who have pets, which is a perfectly ordinary thing for people to do, shouldn't be able to transport their pets with them if they don't drive?

Shouldn't be able to take them to the vet, to take them to visit family? Shouldn't be able to take their pet on holiday with them?

The government are meant to be invested in moving people away from such routine car use but you want to remove public transport options from a large cohort of the public?

Because some ok me MAY have trauma from prevoouydog notes? Do we remove men because some of us may have trauma from sexual assault? Do we removed those over 65 because soany of us have childhood trauma from them beating us as kids?

What nonsense

SutWytTi · 31/12/2023 05:27

MilanHilton · 31/12/2023 04:17

I take my two on the first class train whenever we travel. You cannot reserve a seat/ purchase tickets for under 5s so we usually pay more for first class for hopefully spare seats and food and drinks brought to us. Oh I also breastfeed in my first class train seat as well, does that offend you too?

You can purchase a seat for an under 5, you just don't have to.
But if you buy a regular child seat (5-15) then a child of 3 can sit in it. Just book the number of seats you will use. With a family railcard kids' tickets are usually pretty cheap.

Sassysmom · 31/12/2023 05:28

Well we've identified the person here who hates dogs. Fortunately the railway companies in the UK completely disagree with you.

Sassysmom · 31/12/2023 05:37

Cmonluv · 31/12/2023 05:27

So families who have pets, which is a perfectly ordinary thing for people to do, shouldn't be able to transport their pets with them if they don't drive?

Shouldn't be able to take them to the vet, to take them to visit family? Shouldn't be able to take their pet on holiday with them?

The government are meant to be invested in moving people away from such routine car use but you want to remove public transport options from a large cohort of the public?

Because some ok me MAY have trauma from prevoouydog notes? Do we remove men because some of us may have trauma from sexual assault? Do we removed those over 65 because soany of us have childhood trauma from them beating us as kids?

What nonsense

Absolutely agree with this assessment of the nonsense of a blanket ban of dogs on trains. The bizarre trauma logic of the person who hates dogs is ridiculous: dogs on trains are required to be under control of their owner at all times. Someone who is scared of dogs to the extent that they can't be in any kind of proximity to any dog should seek out trauma therapy, not cause hundreds of thousands of perfectly delightful dog owners and their dogs to be banned from the railway network.

I also entirely agree with your comparison to sexual assault/domestic violence: I would be far far far more concerned about sitting in a train carriage with men in it - especially drunk ones - by myself later in the evening than I ever would feel about sitting in a train carriage containing a dog.

VelvetandLace · 31/12/2023 05:40

I consider people who drink alcohol and become loud on trains far more inconsiderate than children or dogs.

Thementalloadisreal · 31/12/2023 05:40

Society: children should know how to behave on public transport / in restaurants / other areas of society

Parents: bring their children on public transport / to restaurants / other areas of society

Society: no, not like that

LizHoney · 31/12/2023 05:48

Can we all just pause for a moment and think of that poor mum, a horde of tinies who didn't eat so will have been ravenous, plus dog, plus shit husband, on a long journey like that. My heart goes out to her, what a bloody nightmare.

Syndulla · 31/12/2023 05:49

Could you not afford to drive OP?

brainworms · 31/12/2023 05:51

lmao

You utter snob.

ConciseQueen · 31/12/2023 05:53

NumberTheory · 31/12/2023 03:36

This is basically the idea that you should be able to buy your way out of the need to be tolerant.

It’s not so much snobby as very entitled.

This. YABU.

It is bizarre that you or anyone else buying a first class ticket thought that guaranteed a certain sort of passenger. It doesn’t guarantee anything other than bigger seats.

R4D4 · 31/12/2023 05:55

So families who have pets, which is a perfectly ordinary thing for people to do, shouldn't be able to transport their pets with them if they don't drive?

Shouldn't be able to take them to the vet, to take them to visit family? Shouldn't be able to take their pet on holiday with them?

It's perfectly ordinary to have pets. It's not appropriate to inflict them on others for the reasons stated above. These types of practicalities should be factored in before committing to buying a pet. Who would take a sick animal on a train to a vet? That would be very distressing for the animal too, I would imagine. And there is no requirement to take a pet with you on holiday.

R4D4 · 31/12/2023 05:56

Thementalloadisreal · 31/12/2023 05:40

Society: children should know how to behave on public transport / in restaurants / other areas of society

Parents: bring their children on public transport / to restaurants / other areas of society

Society: no, not like that

Precisely! Cognitive dissonance of the highest order.

ChillysWaterBottle · 31/12/2023 05:57

YABU.

Auliza · 31/12/2023 05:59

YABU OP. Why should a family not be in First Class if they have paid for the privilege just like you?
Maybe you ruined your own journey by being so consumed in what they were doing. You even know how much the children ate? Just mind your own and get on with it.

Boggles me how people choose public transport and expect it to be quiet, book the quiet coach if that’s what you’re looking for.

The dog is a different matter, I don’t understand why pets are allowed on public transport. I’m very much a dog lover too.

Sassysmom · 31/12/2023 06:01

R4D4 · 31/12/2023 05:55

So families who have pets, which is a perfectly ordinary thing for people to do, shouldn't be able to transport their pets with them if they don't drive?

Shouldn't be able to take them to the vet, to take them to visit family? Shouldn't be able to take their pet on holiday with them?

It's perfectly ordinary to have pets. It's not appropriate to inflict them on others for the reasons stated above. These types of practicalities should be factored in before committing to buying a pet. Who would take a sick animal on a train to a vet? That would be very distressing for the animal too, I would imagine. And there is no requirement to take a pet with you on holiday.

You clearly haven't owned a dog or pet. Or been reliant on public transport.
Dog's don't just got to the vet when they are sick. They go for preventative medication (vaccinations, routine health checks etc). Most dogs have no trouble whatsoever going on a train. My dog loves it - she curls up at my feet and falls asleep.
As for your statement that a dog doesn't have to accompany a family on holiday: for many people their dogs are part of the family.

It's peculiar that you have such an unpleasant view of dogs/pets. I have never seen an animal misbehave on a train or cause any trouble at all - indeed the majority of the time they make people smile. I have seen plenty of grown adults acting terribly offensively and aggressively though - by your logic we should ban many men from trains.