Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Children and Dogs in first class on trains

858 replies

CQaire · 31/12/2023 02:28

Today I was travelling from Carlisle to London on the train to spend New Year with my sister, just me and my 20 year old daughter. We decided to go first class thinking it would be more relaxing and we'd enjoy a little tipple etc.
At the next stop on from us a family with 4 children and a dog got on and were in first class too. Mum, a baby (maybe 1 or so) and twin toddlers at a table for 4, dad and maybe a 5 year old or so at the table for 2 across from them and a spaniel dog.
They were all very chatty to the point earphones didn't help, the dog was barking, dad seemed useless mum seemed to be juggling all the kids + dog herself. Baby was crying etc. This was a 3 hour journey. The kids barely touched any food or had anything to drink so I'm not sure if you pay for under 5s in first class but if you do it can't have been worth it.
DD agreed that it was odd to travel with a dog and kids in first class, especially when there is a standard premium option on these trains which is the same carriage type as first class without the food.
AIBU to think dogs and small children don't belong in first class on a train? (Or plane or anywhere else for that matter).

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
DonnaBanana · 31/12/2023 12:39

To be fair I do understand how you might want your journey to be comfortable and in peace, most people would! You’re not going to guarantee that on public transport ever. So you have to get used to it, not travel, or get a proper private form of transportation like a car or limo.

dinmin · 31/12/2023 12:42

Haven’t RTFT but YABVU. A family being chatty is the same anywhere - first class isn’t a quiet carriage.

Dogs are allowed on public transport and it’s more considerate of the owners to fork out for first class where there is more likely to physically be space than to try to squeeze them into standard where they’re likely to be on top of people.

TulipCat · 31/12/2023 12:45

quisensoucie · 31/12/2023 07:58

@TulipCat Oh, yes and they were so safe for sole female travellers! I mean, why on earth did they phase them out? Wokeness gorn mad...
Dear god

Good grief, calm down , I just said I enjoyed the nostalgia of something that doesn't exist any more. Did I suggest reintroducing them? Don't think I did...

Rosecoffeecup · 31/12/2023 12:46

YANBU, I would absolutely hate that.

Emotionalsupportviper · 31/12/2023 12:46

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 31/12/2023 09:21

Then don’t keep a dog.

It’s a dog owner’s choice. They have to change their daily lives around a dog anyway - training, walking, feeding, vet care etc. So they should think about travelling with a dog too.

Roll on a ban.

You could equally argue that if you don't like sharing public transport with others you don't want to be near, then don't use public transport.

(What do you suggest people do with their children?)

Dog owners HAVE thought about travelling with a dog. They know they can use public transport.

Beezknees · 31/12/2023 12:54

PaperSheet · 31/12/2023 12:17

I'm autistic and really struggle with many things in social/ public situations. I am also aware I need to tolerate many situations but it does not make it any easier for me unfortunately. Unpredictable things and noise are the worst which unfortunately children and dogs do more of. Drunk people I also don't like.
I spent years living in a flat and was nearly driven crazy by neighbour noise. It wasn't unreasonable neighbour noise. But my brain cannot cope with it. I used to have to go out daily and sit in parks even in winter and when in the house wear earplugs with noise cancelling headphones over the top. I saved up and moved to a cheap area in order to buy a detached house.
When flying/ trains I try and book quiet carriages or sometimes yes first/ business class to at least minimise/reduce chances of these situations. I also carry my headphones everywhere I go.
I obviously understand that I cannot completely avoid these situations so I do tolerate them when they happen.
But I would always happily pay extra to avoid these things where possible. I don't see why that's unreasonable to want a child free/quiet/drunk free carriage for people who are happy to pay for it. Like someone said earlier maybe that could be used to reduce fares for other people.

I think the main issue is though that it's not being around children/dogs that's the problem. It's the badly behaved ones.
I was sitting on a train recently where the kid behind was banging the tray table up and down. Dad kept saying stop it but didn't actually do anything to stop it and kid ignored him. I moved and dad called me a bitch as I walked off.
On a quiet carriage once a mother played a cartoon loudly on an iPad for her child. When challenged (not by me) she said her child had autism so could not cope with the noise of general carriages and also couldn't wear headphones so we all had to accept it. Much arguing ensued. I moved.
I was at a dog friendly restaurant (didn't actually know it was dog friendly on entering and I don't really care anyway though as long as I'm not disturbed) and half way through the meal a big husky dog on a long lead wandered over and started trying to eat off my friends plate. She had to get up and lift her plate in the air. When asking the owners to call their dog back she was called names. We left and didn't pay.

So while I do all the things I can to tolerate things I struggle with, other people just seem to often do as they wish and pretty much just think fuck everyone else. I wouldn't blame someone for a baby crying. It's one of those things. I put my headphones and remind myself that it's no one's fault and it's part of life I need to tolerate. But tolerating a dog eating my food or a child banging my chair constantly to me is not right.

Most trains DO have quiet carriages that you can book. First class is not a designated quiet carriage though.

Emotionalsupportviper · 31/12/2023 12:55

Moglet4 · 31/12/2023 11:21

Well no, because you’re human and they’re not. A separate carriage would be a reasonable compromise I think. That way, people can still travel with their pets but it’s not negatively affecting anyone else’s health, physical or mental.

You have autonomy, dogs don't. They have to remain where their owners settle them.

Emotionalsupportviper · 31/12/2023 12:57

TulipCat · 31/12/2023 12:45

Good grief, calm down , I just said I enjoyed the nostalgia of something that doesn't exist any more. Did I suggest reintroducing them? Don't think I did...

There used to be "women only" carriages at one time. Nowadays, of course, they'd all be full of blokes in bad wigs and short skirts.

Beezknees · 31/12/2023 12:58

Sugarfree23 · 31/12/2023 12:02

That only works if the train is quiet with lots of empty seats. If a family are travelling together and have reserved seats why should they have to move?

It should be like the old smoking / nonsmoking carriages people should be able to book pets free.

Same argument applies for the dog owner, why should they have to move if they've reserved a seat?

Pet free carriages would be a good idea but they don't currently exist so people need to put up with it for now when they choose to travel on public transport I'm afraid.

IGotItFromAgnes · 31/12/2023 13:00

Beezknees · 31/12/2023 12:54

Most trains DO have quiet carriages that you can book. First class is not a designated quiet carriage though.

Most quiet carriages aren’t actually quiet. Full of entitled wankers making phone calls, usually, who don’t respond well to people pointing out it’s a quiet carriage. Or, as per the PP’s experience, parents who think that playing tablets without headphones in a quiet carriage is fine because of reasons- no consideration that others may have booked the quiet carriage because they need quiet…

I won’t book them any more. It winds me up too much when people don’t obey the quiet carriage rules 😂

Dwappy · 31/12/2023 13:00

Beezknees · 31/12/2023 12:54

Most trains DO have quiet carriages that you can book. First class is not a designated quiet carriage though.

Quiet carriages do not ban children, pets or speaking. You are not meant to use phones or technology that makes a noise.
As pointed out above, I have experienced a mother and child playing an iPad loudly in a quiet carriage. When challenged stated that her child was autistic and could not cope in the general carriages and people should be kind to her autistic daughter etc and not complain. I left during the argument.
I also know that first class does not guarantee quiet. But it's often less likely to happen. No carriage is guaranteed quiet even ones called quiet. I can only do what I can to minimise the chances of disruption and manage my condition to the best of my ability.

Moglet4 · 31/12/2023 13:12

Emotionalsupportviper · 31/12/2023 12:55

You have autonomy, dogs don't. They have to remain where their owners settle them.

So they can just as easily remain in a separate carriage in a carrier, where their owner settles them 🙄. Or, as one poster said, in her country they have a separate carriage for pets and owners- even better!

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 31/12/2023 13:14

Emotionalsupportviper · 31/12/2023 12:46

You could equally argue that if you don't like sharing public transport with others you don't want to be near, then don't use public transport.

(What do you suggest people do with their children?)

Dog owners HAVE thought about travelling with a dog. They know they can use public transport.

Edited

You could argue that. But it would be a bit pointless. Public transport - and most other places, except for vets and grooming parlours - are made for people, not pets.

Children? I’ve already said that we should be more accepting and tolerant of children generally, not just on trains. (Always interesting, though, that some dog owners - not you - turn out to be the biggest child-haters.)

And, sure, dog owners now can take their pet dogs on trains, more’s the pity. I was talking about a choice to have a pet dog if a ban is introduced. It’s ‘shouldn’t be able to’, not ‘can’t’.

gratefulforcousins · 31/12/2023 13:16

I'd love a carriage full of dogs rather than horrible stuck up humans.

BIossomtoes · 31/12/2023 13:16

Moglet4 · 31/12/2023 13:12

So they can just as easily remain in a separate carriage in a carrier, where their owner settles them 🙄. Or, as one poster said, in her country they have a separate carriage for pets and owners- even better!

Where would you get a carrier for anything bigger than a Jack Russell? And why would anyone lug a carrier round with them when their well behaved dog a) doesn’t need one and b) has never been in one? The idiocy of people who know nothing about dogs is breathtaking.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 31/12/2023 13:21

Moglet4 · 31/12/2023 13:12

So they can just as easily remain in a separate carriage in a carrier, where their owner settles them 🙄. Or, as one poster said, in her country they have a separate carriage for pets and owners- even better!

For longer journeys, dog-friendly carriages with dogs not allowed in other carriages would be a reasonable adjustment for allergy sufferers without barring dogs from the train. I maintain that pet allergy sufferers can't expect the whole world to be deallergened for them, it's simply not practical.

Berlinlover · 31/12/2023 13:21

YANBU I would be furious.

Allfur · 31/12/2023 13:29

Whatstheuse - we need fewer people travelling by car, not more

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 31/12/2023 13:30

BIossomtoes · 31/12/2023 13:16

Where would you get a carrier for anything bigger than a Jack Russell? And why would anyone lug a carrier round with them when their well behaved dog a) doesn’t need one and b) has never been in one? The idiocy of people who know nothing about dogs is breathtaking.

You’re coming from a view that pet dogs should be allowed on trains, just because.

Fair enough. But also fair enough that many people would like pet dogs kept away from public spaces, particularly confined spaces.

If reasonable compromises don’t work then a total ban would be in order. It’s got nothing to do with knowledge of dogs. Most people have no need or wish to know about dogs.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 31/12/2023 13:32

Allfur · 31/12/2023 13:29

Whatstheuse - we need fewer people travelling by car, not more

Yes, but not on public transport with pet dogs.

Wateroverwine · 31/12/2023 13:32

Dogs barking and children crying or talking loudly on a train is anti social to me. I would be mad too

Moglet4 · 31/12/2023 13:33

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 31/12/2023 13:21

For longer journeys, dog-friendly carriages with dogs not allowed in other carriages would be a reasonable adjustment for allergy sufferers without barring dogs from the train. I maintain that pet allergy sufferers can't expect the whole world to be deallergened for them, it's simply not practical.

I agree but it isn’t just allergy sufferers. Dogs are a little different from other animals in that lots of people are petrified of them and many of them do encroach on people’s personal space (I’m thinking crotches here and bouncing)! Obviously, other dogs are perfectly well behaved and don’t do this. Just trying to think of a solution that works for everyone, dog lovers and dog haters alike

IGotItFromAgnes · 31/12/2023 13:38

@moglet4 Dog-free carriages for the allergy sufferers or dog phobic and any dog behaving in an antisocial manner or approaching others unsolicited to be kicked off with its owner at the next station?

Can’t think why anyone would object to that unless they have poorly-trained dogs.

ArcaneWireless · 31/12/2023 13:41

Aye. Me too.

I commute by train.

I’d much rather travel in a carriage full of dogs than with people yelling into phones, watching tablets/tik tok/etc without earphones, folk full of the drink being sick or shouting, swearing in front of young kids (and I can be a sweary Mary - just not in public) and being horrible to other passengers.

I have an effect on crying babies. My face seems to puzzle them into a bemused silence.

This seems to be just another frothy thread which is a shame as there are decent arguments for dog friendly/kid free/quiet carriages etc.

It is just up here, a lot of the trains are two carriages only. It just wouldn’t work.

Flivequacle · 31/12/2023 13:42

OP just discovered that paying for first class does not necessarily deliver the desired experience.