Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Children and Dogs in first class on trains

858 replies

CQaire · 31/12/2023 02:28

Today I was travelling from Carlisle to London on the train to spend New Year with my sister, just me and my 20 year old daughter. We decided to go first class thinking it would be more relaxing and we'd enjoy a little tipple etc.
At the next stop on from us a family with 4 children and a dog got on and were in first class too. Mum, a baby (maybe 1 or so) and twin toddlers at a table for 4, dad and maybe a 5 year old or so at the table for 2 across from them and a spaniel dog.
They were all very chatty to the point earphones didn't help, the dog was barking, dad seemed useless mum seemed to be juggling all the kids + dog herself. Baby was crying etc. This was a 3 hour journey. The kids barely touched any food or had anything to drink so I'm not sure if you pay for under 5s in first class but if you do it can't have been worth it.
DD agreed that it was odd to travel with a dog and kids in first class, especially when there is a standard premium option on these trains which is the same carriage type as first class without the food.
AIBU to think dogs and small children don't belong in first class on a train? (Or plane or anywhere else for that matter).

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 31/12/2023 21:33

CatMadam · 31/12/2023 21:30

Some are, some aren’t. But, once again, people don’t tend to be allergic to or afraid of children. That is my point.

I can take an antihistamine against dog fur. No one has yet figured out how to stop men from harassing lone women travellers. It's not dogs that I fear on the train.

Emotionalsupportviper · 31/12/2023 21:33

BIossomtoes · 31/12/2023 18:25

Someone will probably invoke Godwin’s law in a minute.

Hitler's dog, Blondi, doubtless travelled with him on his private train, so invoking Godwin's law would be appropriate.

Mademetoxic · 31/12/2023 21:33

CatMadam · 31/12/2023 21:30

Some are, some aren’t. But, once again, people don’t tend to be allergic to or afraid of children. That is my point.

Surely if you are allergic to a dog you would not purposely go and stand/sit next to one if you saw one on a train.

Goldbar · 31/12/2023 21:31

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 31/12/2023 20:47

Ok. That’s meaningless if you mean you love your cat more than people you don’t know or who are not close, like colleagues, the postman etc.

If you say you love your cat more than most members of your family or close friends, your statement has meaning but is a bit, um, peculiar.

It's an interesting question, isn't it?

As a previous cat owner, if I had to choose between my cat or a sibling getting squashed by a car, I'd clearly save the sibling.

If the cat and an uncle/aunt, I'd reluctantly save the uncle/aunt. I don't see any of them very often so tbh I'd probably have missed the cat more than them but I do have some family feeling and am mildly fond of them.

I'd really struggle when it came to an acquaintance or even a complete stranger. Logically (and perhaps selfishly), I should save the cat whose absence in my life would be more keenly felt (and indeed was keenly felt when the end came). But much as I might have loved my cat more than most humans, I still couldn't have prioritised him OVER humans. Because ultimately he was just a cat. So I like to think, if faced with the choice, I would have chosen to save someone's child, parent, brother, sister or partner over my cat. Because humans come first.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 31/12/2023 21:31

Mademetoxic · 31/12/2023 21:22

Do you think a great number of kids are well behaved? I don't think so.

I'm far more bothered about the badly-behaved adult men! I've never yet had a child nor a dog offer to sodomise me, yet my last sexual harassment incident whilst travelling by train involved multiple men of the same group expressing a desire to do threatening me with exactly that.

CatMadam · 31/12/2023 21:30

Mademetoxic · 31/12/2023 21:22

Do you think a great number of kids are well behaved? I don't think so.

Some are, some aren’t. But, once again, people don’t tend to be allergic to or afraid of children. That is my point.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 31/12/2023 21:26

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 31/12/2023 20:53

I don’t think you know what ‘logical fallacy’ means.

The rest is sophistry, except for the civil rights part, which is so obvious as to go without saying.

The logical fallacy was the bit you were quoting. I unhelpfully didn't make that clear and even less helpfully addressed that at the end of my post but listed it first in my opening sentence.

The people saying "pets are family therefore Rover has a right to go on the train" are committing a non sequitur. If two brothers travel by train and one gets booted off for misbehaviour, he can't demand readmission on the grounds that ejecting him splits up his family travel group, and he's human with a civil right to be allowed to travel until he does something wrong. Family members do not have a right to travel together that trumps all other concerns. It therefore does not follow (non sequitur) that "Rover is family" grants Rover an absolute right to be on the train. Is that clearer?

None of that undermines what I said about dogs being highly valued and often loved more than humans. Rover is family in the minds and hearts of hundreds of thousands of people, but the rail company don't have to consider that fact. However, rail companies have chosen to consider that fact because dog owners pay money to travel by train.

Mademetoxic · 31/12/2023 21:23

Cmonluv · 31/12/2023 21:13

Really? How dangerous is a kid being a bit bouncy in a train carriage?

Are you that daft to realise that a train carriage is not the place for kids to be a 'bit bouncy' when there are other people around in a small proximity?!

Mademetoxic · 31/12/2023 21:22

CatMadam · 31/12/2023 20:53

My comment wasn’t about not liking to see things. It was about people being afraid of or allergic to dogs. Unfortunately, a great number of dogs are not well behaved.

Do you think a great number of kids are well behaved? I don't think so.

Cmonluv · 31/12/2023 21:21

LaurieStrode · 31/12/2023 18:54

Oh, here we go with all the old "my children will be your doctor" tripe. That's so worn out, and hun, on a planet teeming with 8 billion humans, most of them young, no one "needs" anyone's particular offspring. There is no projected shortage of human beings, unfortunately. Woe to the other species on this poor planet.

If you think the only people your kids are bothering are "sour faced old crones" (nice hypocritical ageism, btw, from someone clamoring against age-related criticism of children's behaviour) you are quite mistaken.

While there may not be a shortage of human beings there are a disproportionate number of older humans, out of working age, who require a great deal of social and health care.

Your whole rant on benefits, does that mean parents like myself and my husband who are not entitled to any benefits due to income level are allowed to let our kids run rampant? If it's just as a tax payer that you're offended I'm glad to know my children can do as they please.

You are coming across as an entitled, right wing, idiot frankly

Cmonluv · 31/12/2023 21:13

XenoBitch · 31/12/2023 18:06

No kids should be running around and burning off energy on public transport. It is fucking dangerous.

Really? How dangerous is a kid being a bit bouncy in a train carriage?

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 31/12/2023 20:53

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 31/12/2023 20:32

I detect a logical fallacy and a failure to understand how much dogs are embedded into human society here.

Dogs are intelligent, loyal, and loving and are used by the military, the police, and disabled people because of these qualities. Humans trust minesweeper dogs with their lives. There are many humans unworthy of that trust, even if they had the nose to sniff out explosives. Love is only stable and solid when it is built on trust. "Stable and solid" aren't the words I really want but my autistic alexithymia doesn't let me find the right words.

It's therefore reasonable for humans to value highly dogs who show these same qualities of loyalty and intelligence. It's reasonable for humans to love these highly trustworthy dogs as much as or more than most other humans. It's reasonable for humans to consider these dogs that they love and trust to be family.

What is not reasonable is for anyone to demand that a dog gets human civil rights.

"Not part of the family" isn't a reason to bar dogs from the train. "Not human" isn't a reason either (a bicycle isn't human but trains carry those), but "them being there harms (some) humans" might be a reason.

I don’t think you know what ‘logical fallacy’ means.

The rest is sophistry, except for the civil rights part, which is so obvious as to go without saying.

CatMadam · 31/12/2023 20:53

Mademetoxic · 31/12/2023 17:54

I don't like to see little humans with their fingers up their noses in public places. I don't like seeing kids touching everything with their sticky fingers when I'm out shopping.

I don't like seeing adults/teenagers/children drop litter & are loud obnoxious.

What I do like to see is well behaved adults. Well behaved children. Well behaved dogs.

My comment wasn’t about not liking to see things. It was about people being afraid of or allergic to dogs. Unfortunately, a great number of dogs are not well behaved.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 31/12/2023 20:47

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 31/12/2023 20:34

Sorry for my lack of clarity. I love DCat more than most humans.

Ok. That’s meaningless if you mean you love your cat more than people you don’t know or who are not close, like colleagues, the postman etc.

If you say you love your cat more than most members of your family or close friends, your statement has meaning but is a bit, um, peculiar.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 31/12/2023 20:34

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 31/12/2023 20:23

What do you mean by “…considerably more loved than most humans”?

That you love your cat more than you love most humans, or that you love your cat more than most humans love other humans?

Sorry for my lack of clarity. I love DCat more than most humans.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 31/12/2023 20:32

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 31/12/2023 17:10

Er, I think the point is that some of us are saying that should change. To which one response has been that pet dogs are “family members”. As if a ban would split up families.

It’s that justification I find so odd. And frankly unsettling. They’re not people, they’re dogs.

I detect a logical fallacy and a failure to understand how much dogs are embedded into human society here.

Dogs are intelligent, loyal, and loving and are used by the military, the police, and disabled people because of these qualities. Humans trust minesweeper dogs with their lives. There are many humans unworthy of that trust, even if they had the nose to sniff out explosives. Love is only stable and solid when it is built on trust. "Stable and solid" aren't the words I really want but my autistic alexithymia doesn't let me find the right words.

It's therefore reasonable for humans to value highly dogs who show these same qualities of loyalty and intelligence. It's reasonable for humans to love these highly trustworthy dogs as much as or more than most other humans. It's reasonable for humans to consider these dogs that they love and trust to be family.

What is not reasonable is for anyone to demand that a dog gets human civil rights.

"Not part of the family" isn't a reason to bar dogs from the train. "Not human" isn't a reason either (a bicycle isn't human but trains carry those), but "them being there harms (some) humans" might be a reason.

JustanotherMNSlapperTwat · 31/12/2023 20:32

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 31/12/2023 20:23

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 31/12/2023 19:58

DCat is more important to me and considerably more loved than most humans. Some of the posters on this thread are reminding me why that is.

What do you mean by “…considerably more loved than most humans”?

That you love your cat more than you love most humans, or that you love your cat more than most humans love other humans?

sunglassesonthetable · 31/12/2023 20:08

Just out of interest, how did you persuade your toddler(s) to demonstrate dignity and social graces, or did it not matter as you only travelled second class?

I'd bet dog biscuits that Laurie is a man. And def the type who never took a toddler with him on a train.

But Happy New Year everyone. Have a good one.

sunglassesonthetable · 31/12/2023 20:05

*Eh? I don't know if you're a woman. You don't know if I'm a woman. There is no mention of women in my posts.

How odd some folk are.*

You were fibbing about going to do stuff with Real people weren't you. 😉

Thehandinthedark · 31/12/2023 20:04

JustanotherMNSlapperTwat · 31/12/2023 19:42

Ah yes implying women are emotional if they disagree with you, so refreshingly mysoginistic

Eh? I don't know if you're a woman. You don't know if I'm a woman. There is no mention of women in my posts.

How odd some folk are.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 31/12/2023 19:58

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 31/12/2023 15:57

There’s the problem, right there.

Dogs aren’t pets any longer, they’re family members, like the kids, grandparents and Aunty Linda.

🙄

DCat is more important to me and considerably more loved than most humans. Some of the posters on this thread are reminding me why that is.

NalafromtheLionKing · 31/12/2023 19:49

LaurieStrode · 31/12/2023 19:07

Where did I say it should be linked to a financial penalty? Should it have to, to prod people into doing the right thing? That's sad.

You said “You’re expected to consider others in return for what you get” (i.e. taxpayer funded financial “largess”). This suggests that, if families do not keep their side of the bargain by being quiet in settings such as first class train carriages, then they should not have the benefit of that largess and should therefore suffer financial penalties.

Just out of interest, how did you persuade your toddler(s) to demonstrate dignity and social graces, or did it not matter as you only travelled second class?

category12 · 31/12/2023 19:44

Sugarfree23 · 31/12/2023 19:33

Seriously did she not have a private carriage? Can't imagine HMQ in a public train first class or council class!

She had her own train. 😂Charlie boy still uses it.

Of course she could take her dogs on. 😂

JustanotherMNSlapperTwat · 31/12/2023 19:42

Thehandinthedark · 31/12/2023 19:23

I don't need to suck anything up, thanks. (What charming parlance.)

Crying babies are awful. It is possible to move into the vestibule area with them to soothe them.

What about the barking dog?

Anyway. Arguing with angry randoms on the internet is a bit 2006, so I'm off to do nice things in the real world with actual people. Enjoy your evening shouting at people you don't know. Watch that blood pressure.

Ah yes implying women are emotional if they disagree with you, so refreshingly mysoginistic