Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ricky Gervaise Armageddon yay or nay?

209 replies

pandosadick · 30/12/2023 23:53

I'm stunned and not in a good way. Watched for a bit but found it too offensive. Apparently when he's on stage and making these 'jokes,' he's in character, like an actor playing a role how? He's gervaise doing what he does. Saying what he says… the fact that he regards anyone who disagrees with him as fucking idiots is laughable. His humour isn't nuanced or sophisticated and I'm pretty certain that the live audience who laughed aloud his jokes about disabled children weren't there for the nuances either.

OP posts:
SerendipityJane · 31/12/2023 11:49

I disagree that you can't vivisect the frog.

Since I used that word, I can respond and point out you completely and utterly misread or misunderstood what I said (as per the internet law on the matter).

I did not say you can't do it. Just that if you do (a) not many people are interested and (b) the frog dies.

You can fit wheels to a tomato. But it's time consuming and a waste of time.

Pedants of the word unite !

BillionaireTea · 31/12/2023 11:45

So let's try and parse the joke that has been mentioned here. I disagree that you can't vivisect the frog. Cultural and literary analysis is a thing, a skill which helps us to understand ourselves and the artefacts of our culture. If you're all "ugh, it's just a joke" then you might not want to read this post.
(But also, please know you're living the unexamined life, and are no better than an animal. That was a joke. Or was it?)

RG had a joke setting up the idea of a celebrity; someone a bit like himself but morally bankrupt, self obsessed, self congratulatory. This person would be so self indulgent they would force a "kind gesture" on a child with cancer, come in with inappropriate tone and content, notice things about the person that make them different from "the norm" (i.e. no hair) and point that out with a huge lack of awareness. Gervais acts that person and says what they would have said.

That's a funny premise (and very similar to his excellent and monstrous creation in The Office). Lots of history for this kind of humour, lots of characters where it's funny that we see them saying, with no filter, things that we might think and have to check ourselves (That person is fatter than average, that person has less hair than average, that person is of a different race than me, blah blah).

The humour comes from a presumed emotional "embarrassing hot spot" in our culture. It assumes that we are all secretly thinking "Oh look, the main characteristic of that person is that they are black, or have a visible disability, that is Not Normal, and the majority of us in this room are white and able bodied, which feels Normal. Oh! but I mustn't say that, although it's true- because I might offend or upset them!!" It is very funny watching people struggling not to say inappropriate things that we all also struggle with. So I suspect that is where the humour lies; we have a release of tension laughing at someone who doesn't have the self awareness to hide their embarrassing inner monologue.

But! I don't personally find that a funny or relevant insight when it comes to the issue of "noticing difference". Most of us are streets ahead of that weird embarrassment now (oh no I mustn't mention the wheelchair!) It was on its way out with Basil Fawlty's Don't Mention the War, 50 years ago.

The idea of being "Woke" would genuinely be to think "Ah, interesting, I noticed some minority trait in a person before I noticed other things about them - what does that say about me? I'll just naturally refocus on other things and use it as an internal small reminder that we are all different." No shame, no embarrassment, just a bit of ongoing work we all do every day.

I think the cancer=bald head joke drags us back to an era we have left, where noticing difference for the majority of people was a big shock and suddenly a tedious thing you had to "pretend to not find unusual" - unless you were among friends when you could go back to your jokes about untrustworthy other races, hysterical women, etc.

So the joke allows RG to have his cake and eat it, by giving the audience that illicit thrill of laughing at people different from them while pretending they're not doing. It dog whistles to white, able bodied, "majority" folks who see the new way of ongoing work for diversity as an imposition on their inner monologue.

The people in the audience aren't laughing because children with cancer are bald. They're laughing at the idea of "a man who notices that about children who've had cancer treatment, characterises and simplifies them to their illness, and can't resist saying so". The trouble is, there is no way that character is funny (rather than distasteful) - unless you have a flicker of sharing the mentality (oh mustn't mention the bald head!). Otherwise how do you recognise it and find it funny??

I think folks who are in that place are a bit unevolved and old fashioned and it looks like Gervais is too. Maybe he's sending up people laughing at people who are like the imaginary celebrity. But I've seen no evidence of that in any discussion he has done about his work. And indeed if he is, he is mean spiritedly laughing at his own audience as they aren't in on the joke.

Thanks for coming to my TED talk :)

Jewel1968 · 31/12/2023 11:43

I think I understand what he is trying to do but the jokes for me just weren't that funny. I don't have an issue with edgy jokes (although I don't remember any jokes about vegans and animal rights activists?) but it has to be funny. Some of his earlier stand up was funny but this was flat.

crumblingschools · 31/12/2023 11:36

If anyone says anything offensive in a group context it is fine, but not if it is aimed at a real individual? So RG can use the word retarded in front of an audience and that makes it an inoffensive term, but he wouldn’t direct it an individual

Spaghettieis · 31/12/2023 11:34

I haven’t seen it but I find him a completely insufferable twat in general, who thinks he is much cleverer than he is.

Southislandsea · 31/12/2023 11:33

He's a mind reader too?

Glad you found me funny BTW

Don't like him and what he says.

He's taken nothing from me.

NotBadConsidering · 31/12/2023 11:32

Snowflakecookie1989 · 31/12/2023 11:21

Oh 🤨Ha bloody ha! 🥱🤦‍♀️🙄

It was funny. The context was everything. He even makes the point that by using the word in the show, (but not in real life) will have people frothing about how offensive he is. Congratulations on proving him right.

orchiddottyback · 31/12/2023 11:28

Southislandsea · 31/12/2023 11:17

Excuse me...!
I am bright actually.
And his teeth are vampirish.
My observational humour.
And if he can't take it, he shouldn't dish it.
Tommy Cooper is the way to go!
And Frank Spencer

Yet again you miss the entire point 😂

You diatribe post was nothing more than a personal insult directly to an individual, but also claiming "And if he can't take it, he shouldn't dish it.". Makes your post even more funny because he already predicted some one like you would post something exactly like this on social media and has already replied to you, hahah.

RG has already taken it from you, he has already predicted exactly what some one like you would say.

Southislandsea · 31/12/2023 11:27

Yep
My thoughts exactly.
Still wouldn't go as far as him though.
Who decides where the line is drawn?
Isn't it great we're all having such a laugh on here? Not!
Irony

AlwaysWearSPF · 31/12/2023 11:25

crumblingschools · 31/12/2023 11:01

@AlwaysWearSPF can you always excuse anything offensive by saying it is a joke, even if the person it is said to finds it offensive? I wouldn’t go to a RG show as I know I wouldn’t find it funny.

But I work with schools where there is a huge issue with misogyny amongst the male students, who will excuse it as ‘banter’. Do the female students have to just accept this as the boys are just having a laugh and a joke?

F can you always excuse anything offensive by saying it is a joke, even if the person it is said to finds it offensive? I wouldn’t go to a RG show as I know I wouldn’t find it funny.

But I work with schools where there is a huge issue with misogyny amongst the male students, who will excuse it as ‘banter’. Do the female students have to just accept this as the boys are just having a laugh and a joke?

Can you always excuse anything offensive by saying it's a joke? It's a comedy show which people have paid to go and see. The name says it all really comedy, it's not offensive to me and I have a daughter who has a very serious disability and she found it very funny. She found it quite light and didn't take offence, actually she liked having the break from all the seriousness surrounding her disability. Again all down to taste RG is not for everyone.

Furthermore in regards to your comment on misogyny within the schools that you work in that's something that you may have witnessed again down to prospective on what you find offensive nothing at all to do with comedy.

Snowflakecookie1989 · 31/12/2023 11:24

Imnotadentist · 31/12/2023 11:08

What’s with all the comments about him being fat/ has bad teeth/ I want to pin him down so someone can break his legs?

From posters who claim RG is offensive….

Well if he can rip the piss out of babies with aids or cancer,you know... surely it's ok to rip the pee out of his teeth and man boobs? It's only a joke right? 🙄

Snowflakecookie1989 · 31/12/2023 11:21

NotBadConsidering · 31/12/2023 10:36

As part of a joke.

Oh 🤨Ha bloody ha! 🥱🤦‍♀️🙄

NotBadConsidering · 31/12/2023 11:20

The joke about the disabled child being racist was actually a joke about how there are people in this world who justify abusing people they deem have failed in their purity spiral. It’s ok, in these people’s minds, to shout at a disabled child if that - imaginary- child is racist, misogynist and a homophobe.

Last year a woman who worked for a Labour MP shouted at a man holding a baby, in the face of the baby, that he was “fucking fascist” “raising a child to believe in this filth!”

That’s who RG is mocking. People like that.

Southislandsea · 31/12/2023 11:17

Excuse me...!
I am bright actually.
And his teeth are vampirish.
My observational humour.
And if he can't take it, he shouldn't dish it.
Tommy Cooper is the way to go!
And Frank Spencer

SerendipityJane · 31/12/2023 11:17

I also find Reginald D Hunter very funny, for extreme comparison.

SerendipityJane · 31/12/2023 11:16

Drifting OT, but with a point .... in his latest show, Kevin Bridges makes a perfect analogy of "Twitter being the VAR of jokes these days". You can tell a joke. It crashes the room. And then a 5 second snip ends up in Twitter and it's disallowed.

Imagine if we treated Shakespeare like we did comedians ? Throw away the plot, the narrative, the themes and context. Just look at individual lines. Makes Hamlet a totally different read. And Wuthering Heights descends into an over long advert for double glazing.

Jacfrost · 31/12/2023 11:12

Imnotadentist · 31/12/2023 11:08

What’s with all the comments about him being fat/ has bad teeth/ I want to pin him down so someone can break his legs?

From posters who claim RG is offensive….

They're just not very bright. Nobody has to actively like RG but if they cannot at least understand the point of his act, they're just not very bright.

SerendipityJane · 31/12/2023 11:11

So the joke about the children and what they wanted for Christmas and how they non disabled kid got overlooked was funny. But when he started shouting at the disabled child for being racist etc,

As he points out (to a great whoosh it seems) this kid doesn't exist. They aren't real. You will never meet them. They will never have hope, or dreams, or ambitions. They won't struggle to achieve their potential. They will never fall in love. They will never hold their child.

I won't be so crass as to comment on the hysteria that non existent people can cause at Christmas except to say it does have a dimension in the irony universe.

The well worn adage about analysing humour and frog vivisection still seems to apply.

Imnotadentist · 31/12/2023 11:08

What’s with all the comments about him being fat/ has bad teeth/ I want to pin him down so someone can break his legs?

From posters who claim RG is offensive….

PlasticHeart · 31/12/2023 11:08

AlwaysWearSPF · 31/12/2023 10:53

I knew that was going to be mentioned so predictable..."White middle class man." I could name many great comedians from all backgrounds telling obscene and offensive jokes...yea that's right a joke you know that thing that makes people laugh. Again it's all down to taste and clearly RG is not your cup of tea big deal move on, don't need to get all Will Smith about it.

Exactly, it's the default go to these days. IMAGINE saying such things about a person of any other ethnicity, it's diabolical..OP called RG a "fat white man living in an ivory tower" 😑. RG grew up on a Reading council estate, one of which was the most deprived areas at the time. He did not start to make serious money until his 30s, he has also donated nearly £2 million to animal charities! Wtf have you done OP?

Jacfrost · 31/12/2023 11:07

OP children with cancer aren't the butt of his jokes. YOU are.

Imnotadentist · 31/12/2023 11:06

This was the first RG show I have watched. I thought parts were very funny and other jokes less so. I think what he does is test where your boundaries are. It’s like he starts a joke with something you might find amusing and then ramps it up until you find it too close to the bone. It makes you question what is or isn’t acceptable, which I found quite interesting.
btw So the joke about the children and what they wanted for Christmas and how they non disabled kid got overlooked was funny. But when he started shouting at the disabled child for being racist etc, that felt very uncomfortable to me, which again I think was deliberate as it mimicked a twitter pile on.
It reminded me a bit of Ben Elton early stand up. Some of his jokes got more of a gasp than a laugh from the audience.

NotBadConsidering · 31/12/2023 11:06

crumblingschools · 31/12/2023 10:47

What was the joke @NotBadConsidering?

I could explain it, but without the context and the qualifiers he adds afterwards it will be hard to do it justice. You could, you know, watch it yourself?

orchiddottyback · 31/12/2023 11:05

Pocketfullofdogtreats · 31/12/2023 10:45

Nay. Have only seen a short clip but I don't find him funny at all. I think people have paid such a lot for tickets and travel that they are determined to have a good time and not find fault that they big up something that if they saw it on TV and didn't know the comedian they would switch channels. I remember the old days when there were comedians like Tommy Copper who had me nearly unable to breathe from laughing, because he was clever. Not offensive. All this edgy stuff - no thanks. I like witty and clever.

Your reply made me laugh as some one who has never seen RG live and only watched it as I came across it on Christmas day by accident on Netflix proves your thought process is completely wrong --->"I think people have paid such a lot for tickets and travel that they are determined to have a good time and not find fault that they big up something that if they saw it on TV and didn't know the comedian they would switch channels" .

I pay for Netflix any way watching this was an unexpected bonus thanks, so no i did not have to justify any thing liking it.

I think his entire show just 100% proved a perfect point about the OP and all the other naysayers especially those whom have not watched it and still slating it, as others have already said.

crumblingschools · 31/12/2023 11:01

@AlwaysWearSPF can you always excuse anything offensive by saying it is a joke, even if the person it is said to finds it offensive? I wouldn’t go to a RG show as I know I wouldn’t find it funny.

But I work with schools where there is a huge issue with misogyny amongst the male students, who will excuse it as ‘banter’. Do the female students have to just accept this as the boys are just having a laugh and a joke?

Swipe left for the next trending thread