Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

High Income single families losing Child benefit

139 replies

ReturnoftheMe · 30/12/2023 15:30

Hi there - I know this has been talked about extensively over the years, but I wondered if anyone has been following the topic and discussions around it in parliament for the future? Are there any changes to come for the next budget?

I am a single mother with no input from my 2 kids father. I live in London work full time and currently cannot afford to put my 2 year old in nursery as fees are too high, and I am not eligible for any help (fees are 2k + a month in my area). Luckily my mother has stepped in, but without her I'd have to claim benefits and not work, or I'd have to dial down my ambitions and go for a part time job which puts me at a disadvantage in my work place.
This year I will gratefully receive a bonus that just about puts me at the point of not being eligible at all for any Child Benefit down to the penny. This really bothers me because all the families I know all receive it still. Some really high earning self employed couples who manage to complete tax returns that keep them eligible and even my own brother, both him and his wife earn 50k and 46k respectively and they still get CB for their two boys.

When is this going to change in order to be fair for single mothers like myself? I cannot afford nursery and I also do not get any child benefit. Something is incredibly wrong here.

Am I being unreasonable to feel as though this is unfair to single mothers?

OP posts:
kittensinthekitchen · 30/12/2023 17:06

ReturnoftheMe · 30/12/2023 16:53

@Catterbat I earn £55K..the bonus put me over... it is more about how it makes it so unfair for single parents when couples earning far more than I do combined still qualify for Child Benefit. On this bases, the threshold should be increased. £55K is not a huge deal of money when supporting two children solely on one income, at least where I am from it is not. £60k isn't much different either once you consider the higher tax bracket.

I wouldn't expect something like this to be so purposely over looked in the UK.

Why increase the threshold for single parents, if the issue is that it's unfair to penalise single parents? Why not reduce the overall threshold to the same level, so those in couples don't get a 'bonus', and make it a household threshold instead?

edit I do agree it should be raised in line with inflation, though.

MintJulia · 30/12/2023 17:06

I've lost all of mine this year. I've just hit £60k although £5k of that is health insurance benefit. And I daren't cancel that because I'm recovering from breast cancer, and anything could change in a moment.

So I actually have an income of £55k, have lost child benefit, am being taxed as if I earn £60k, have to pay 40% on the health insurance that I can't be sure whether I will use or not. And obviously the mortgage is up.

I have to repay R&C £1100 next month. Things are getting tight. 🙁 And before anyone says it, I know we are luckier than most. We have a house. I am grateful for that.

ReturnoftheMe · 30/12/2023 17:06

@Ottersfortea do you think it is worth it with me earning £55K + if I get a bonus next year similar to this year? I am just hoping the policy makers will adjust what is classed as High Income. Surely £50k isn't the same value with inflation as it was 10 years ago?

As a side note, I spoke to a friend today who lives in Milan, her and her partner collectively out earn me by almost 100,000euro and they pay only 400euro fees PER YEAR for their son's nursery, so I think hearing that (although happy for them) has made look at my own situation and has left me feeling sorry for myself I guess. I feel like such a loser for not being ale to afford childcare, people are always asking me why my son isn't in nursery and I let them know I can't afford it. To which they look bemused because they expect all single parents get help, but most people have no idea.

I will have to speak to my MP to see if there is any forecast to having things change.

OP posts:
HamstersAreMyLife · 30/12/2023 17:06

Yes it's a stupid system. We are a 1 income household earning just over the full repayment threshold. We still get it for NI benefits and just repay with my tax return but it eats me up every year when I know families who earn just below threshold due to part time work so they get to keep it but have higher family income. I did go part time for a while so we became eligible but I've now increased to full time as kids older.

hanschristmassolo · 30/12/2023 17:06

Yes it's grossly unfair and the fact it hasn't changed in 13 years - had it risen with inflation the limit would be £65k

I read somewhere though that they had to do it this way so that each person maintains some privacy over income in a marriage/relationship - if it was done on a joint income then you'd have to tell each other what your salary is - this way the person earning over the threshold does the self assessment - without ever knowing what the other person earns

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 30/12/2023 17:04

Just meed to figure out if I can force child maintenance on him while he lives in a European country.

@ReturnoftheMe Have a look at the REMO countries list for that

https://www.gov.uk/child-maintenance-if-one-parent-lives-abroad/other-partner-lives-abroad

Child maintenance if a parent lives abroad

What to do if you need to get child maintenance and one of the parents lives abroad.

https://www.gov.uk/child-maintenance-if-one-parent-lives-abroad/other-partner-lives-abroad

ilovesooty · 30/12/2023 17:03

Circe7 · 30/12/2023 16:58

@Catterbat
£60k as a single income is equivalent to two people each earning £26k. On £60k you take home approx £3,750 before pension contributions and student loan. With £2k childcare expense you’re left with £1,750 less student loan etc. Liveable maybe but hardly a high income.

Meanwhile 2 parents each on £50k would be bringing home £6,300 ish between them and be entitled to child benefit.

It not always feasible to reduce taxable income by making higher pension contributions because it reduces the money you have available now and sometimes money now is more valuable than money when you retire.

I don’t think it would be that difficult to administer a system whereby they doubled the threshold for single parents. They operate a council tax reduction for single adult households already.

If you base that thought on council tax reductions, there's only a 25% discount for single households.

Circe7 · 30/12/2023 16:58

@Catterbat
£60k as a single income is equivalent to two people each earning £26k. On £60k you take home approx £3,750 before pension contributions and student loan. With £2k childcare expense you’re left with £1,750 less student loan etc. Liveable maybe but hardly a high income.

Meanwhile 2 parents each on £50k would be bringing home £6,300 ish between them and be entitled to child benefit.

It not always feasible to reduce taxable income by making higher pension contributions because it reduces the money you have available now and sometimes money now is more valuable than money when you retire.

I don’t think it would be that difficult to administer a system whereby they doubled the threshold for single parents. They operate a council tax reduction for single adult households already.

44PumpLane · 30/12/2023 16:55

OP, do you have any deductions from salary like health insurance, pension, life insurance etc already?

DO NOT stop your CB!!! You can't get it back, but what you can do is make sure that you have the extra cash put into a pension so that across the tax year you earn a taxable income of £50k on the dot so you keep 100% of your CB.

Far better that and have extra in your pension.

ReturnoftheMe · 30/12/2023 16:53

@Catterbat I earn £55K..the bonus put me over... it is more about how it makes it so unfair for single parents when couples earning far more than I do combined still qualify for Child Benefit. On this bases, the threshold should be increased. £55K is not a huge deal of money when supporting two children solely on one income, at least where I am from it is not. £60k isn't much different either once you consider the higher tax bracket.

I wouldn't expect something like this to be so purposely over looked in the UK.

OP posts:
BettyBakesCakes · 30/12/2023 16:52

OttilieKnackered · 30/12/2023 15:58

Definitely unfair on single parents.

Don’t have the same sympathy for couples where only one works. That’s a choice and you’re saving a fortune in childcare in the early years.

Not everyone has a choice. Id love to work more but I'm also a carer.

Ottersfortea · 30/12/2023 16:45

Do you pay into a work pension? Is it taken as salary sacrifice? Or from your gross or net pay?
If you call your pension provider you may be able to pay extra as a bank transfer from your bank account.
You pay it from your Net pay. The pension provider claims the 20% from the gov (I assume you are in England) and you will fill in a tax return and get the extra 20% back.

Or your payroll may be able to add you entire bonus into your pension from your gross salary.

Your Normal contributions may take your pay under 50k for the year.

I agree it sucks and I wrote to my mp/the gov to complain when it was first introduced as I felt the band would never be increased and eventually many ‘normal’ jobs would be paying back child benefit.

Catterbat · 30/12/2023 16:41

You earn £60k so you don’t need it. The threshold is far too high and the money would be better diverted towards those that do.

CantFindTheBeat · 30/12/2023 16:36

Icelandic9 · 30/12/2023 15:54

It does seem unfair, but it's such a piddly amount of money anyway that I don't really understand why anyone would bodge their tax returns just to receive it

How do you mean, @Icelandic9 ?

ReturnoftheMe · 30/12/2023 16:25

@Sd1960 £65 is not huge at all, especially on 1 single income for a family with two children and one being nursery age.

@ANightmareBeforeChristmas exactly, there is that point too. It boggles my mind how these points are being discussed but yet overlooked year in year out.

@arethereanyleftatall their father lives out of the country and has been off employment due to depression, so, no chance of that changing anytime soon, and even if it did, he has categorically told me he wouldn't be contributing to nursery but may help out to some degree if he can. Just meed to figure out if I can force child maintenance on him while he lives in a European country.

OP posts:
ReturnoftheMe · 30/12/2023 16:21

@PlaidCushionProductions , @ThinWomansBrain @Theoneandonlyjrae I can increase pension contributions yes, but as @Doggymummar mentions, maybe I need the help of an accountant perhaps to tell me what the best way around it is. I do not know how much to divert for it to make it worth the hassle My salary is £55k, and I pay about £200 each month towards my student loan which is quite a hefty repayment. My bonus put me at £60k on the dot, so it means I will have to pay every penny back. I was not expecting this bonus amount, otherwise I would have saved money aside. Instead I have accessed my online account and opted to stop receiving CB all together for now, rather than having to pay it all back.

CB is not a huge amount to those who pointed it out, but I think it is just the unfairness of it and the fact they call it "high income charge"... I am not saying £50K is a low salary, but for a single income with two families in London, it is not by any means a huge amount. I barely scrape by each month and I think going into the new year, it has really got me down. I should feel grateful that I earn "decently", but the fact that I can't afford nursery and I have CB taken away just feels like a sting and majors me fee disadvantaged. I wouldn't want it taken away from any other families but perhaps for the government to bring the "high income" amount up in line with inflation. It should be nearer 70K and it should be adjusted for single income households.

OP posts:
WithACatLikeTread · 30/12/2023 16:09

Icelandic9 · 30/12/2023 15:54

It does seem unfair, but it's such a piddly amount of money anyway that I don't really understand why anyone would bodge their tax returns just to receive it

Lucky for you eh.

wronginalltherightways · 30/12/2023 16:04

It's been unfair since the changes were brought in, because it allowed couples who made just under £100k combined to keep child benefit, but it meant single parents or one-income families who earned over the threshhold of £50k lose it.

We lost it. Made it really hard for me to work normal hours, so dialed back.

Sd1960 · 30/12/2023 16:00

£65k not a huge income? It’s like a parallel universe on here sometimes.

OttilieKnackered · 30/12/2023 15:58

Definitely unfair on single parents.

Don’t have the same sympathy for couples where only one works. That’s a choice and you’re saving a fortune in childcare in the early years.

ActDottie · 30/12/2023 15:55

ThinWomansBrain · 30/12/2023 15:43

can you discuss with you employer and ask for your bonus to be paid into your pension?

This it sounds like only a small amount would need to be paid into your pension.

The child benefit thing is unfair that couples on £49k each get it but a single mum on £51k doesn’t it’s mad!

KombuchaKalling · 30/12/2023 15:55

Sorry just realised it cut off the original post which said increase pension contributions!

ToDoListAddict · 30/12/2023 15:55

Some companies have a scheme where you can deposit bonuses directly into your pension (tax free). Could this be an option?

KombuchaKalling · 30/12/2023 15:54

PlaidCushionProductions · 30/12/2023 15:53

This ^

I also think this is the best way round it

Icelandic9 · 30/12/2023 15:54

It does seem unfair, but it's such a piddly amount of money anyway that I don't really understand why anyone would bodge their tax returns just to receive it