Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

High Income single families losing Child benefit

139 replies

ReturnoftheMe · 30/12/2023 15:30

Hi there - I know this has been talked about extensively over the years, but I wondered if anyone has been following the topic and discussions around it in parliament for the future? Are there any changes to come for the next budget?

I am a single mother with no input from my 2 kids father. I live in London work full time and currently cannot afford to put my 2 year old in nursery as fees are too high, and I am not eligible for any help (fees are 2k + a month in my area). Luckily my mother has stepped in, but without her I'd have to claim benefits and not work, or I'd have to dial down my ambitions and go for a part time job which puts me at a disadvantage in my work place.
This year I will gratefully receive a bonus that just about puts me at the point of not being eligible at all for any Child Benefit down to the penny. This really bothers me because all the families I know all receive it still. Some really high earning self employed couples who manage to complete tax returns that keep them eligible and even my own brother, both him and his wife earn 50k and 46k respectively and they still get CB for their two boys.

When is this going to change in order to be fair for single mothers like myself? I cannot afford nursery and I also do not get any child benefit. Something is incredibly wrong here.

Am I being unreasonable to feel as though this is unfair to single mothers?

OP posts:
Whoknowswhatanymore · 30/12/2023 17:48

Similarly though, couples are also at a loss when the high earner just earns over the threshold and the lower earner earns just over £10K for instance, often putting them at a lower salary than a single earner on £65-70K with one extra mouth to feed and clothe; maybe an extra car in the household too for work purposes? Who knows but one thing is for certain, the threshold needs upping significantly as £50K is not that high a salary in real terms.

MumblesParty · 30/12/2023 17:42

Could you ask for your bonus to be split across 2 tax years? Have half in March and half in April?

OhBeAFineGuyKissMe · 30/12/2023 17:34

You don’t need to do it on joint income. Keep couples the same as it currently is (for privacy or whatever). Then you can provide evidence of being single (is the council just a self declaration?) in a similar way to universal credit and then there is a higher allowance.

i don’t see this being a huge administrative burden.

*I would also include where one person can’t work due to caring, they probably will be getting PIP(?) or similar and therefore should have the single person allowance for the other earner. Stay at home by choice is different.

Æthelfled · 30/12/2023 17:34

I'm on £49k, next year if I get any increase in salary I'll be tipped onto the sliding scale. I've worked hard to get to where I am in my career and feel as if I'm being seriously penalised for doing so.

For reference I was an unemployed young single mum on benefits, put myself through university, bought a home and still feel as if I have the same spare money as I did way back then. This isn't a benefits bash it's a dig at how the world and the financial structures of it are all set up for couples, and screw working singletons.

ReturnoftheMe · 30/12/2023 17:34

@Ohnotyoutoo I am going to have to work it out and see whether it make sense to sacrifice the bonus into my pension. Would have been nice to see some of the money though, especially at at time like this.

How would I increase student loan repayments in advance and how does that benefit me?

OP posts:
TrashedSofa · 30/12/2023 17:31

Yanbu. It's an exceptionally foolish system, and I say that as a beneficiary. Our household income is a fair whack higher than yours, but we still get full CB to go along with our two personal allowances. This was always going to happen when the Tories decided to stop it being universal though, and I've never yet seen any evidence that the enforcement costs are less than the saving. Although with inflation and fiscal drag, presumably that will happen at some point.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 30/12/2023 17:28

ChanelNo19EDT · 30/12/2023 17:27

I have sympathy for sahm unmarried mothers in a relationship, in situations where their co hab partner is the high earner and they don't get child benefit. How does that effect their pension? I used to work in the UK and I rang up about it recently and to my surprise, the time I'd been in receipt of children's benefit counted in my pension forecast.

They need to get back to work.

SAHP’s can still be credited toward their pension even if they don’t actually receive Child benefit.

Araminta1003 · 30/12/2023 17:28

It is really unfair and that is why it used to be universal. You are just really unlucky.

The birth rate is low again, I reckon Government will soon be having to offer tax incentives to all parents to have children. In some other jurisdiction you get eg 10000 free tax allowance per child that you have. We need that here.

DrCoconut · 30/12/2023 17:27

@OttilieKnackered definitely. This is discriminatory towards single parents. But having that high an income is a problem many of us would love to have

ChanelNo19EDT · 30/12/2023 17:27

OttilieKnackered · 30/12/2023 15:58

Definitely unfair on single parents.

Don’t have the same sympathy for couples where only one works. That’s a choice and you’re saving a fortune in childcare in the early years.

I have sympathy for sahm unmarried mothers in a relationship, in situations where their co hab partner is the high earner and they don't get child benefit. How does that effect their pension? I used to work in the UK and I rang up about it recently and to my surprise, the time I'd been in receipt of children's benefit counted in my pension forecast.

They need to get back to work.

Ohnotyoutoo · 30/12/2023 17:26

YANBU. I don't understand why two parents earning £99k combined is fine but one parent earning what you do means no CB at all!

Could you:

  • Stick all your bonus into your pension
  • Increase student loan payments till end of the financial year
  • Take bonus but increase pension contributions to the end of the fiscal year?

We had something similar happen this year around tax-free childcare due to an unexpected bonus. Had to send a letter to HMRC & Tax-free Childcare Services but it was sorted in the end.

Kwasi · 30/12/2023 17:23

I have never understood why it's based on a single income rather than a household income.

ReturnoftheMe · 30/12/2023 17:19

@Sd1960 50k is higher than the average salary, but in this instance it is unfairly classed as "High Income" when it is not, in places like London.
@kittensinthekitchen I mean increase the tax threshold for single parents but keep it the same for couples. Perhaps 80k might sound more fair?

@MintJulia it really does not sound as wonderful as people think does it and certainly feels like they stick the knife in the more you try to better your circumstances as a single mother. Better you do keep the health insurance considering your current status. Wishing the best with it. Glad to hear also that you have a home. I have to rent privately as I am not eligible for government assistance of course. My dreams of buying a home one day for me and the children seems so far, far away. My only chance is if one day their father steps in and steps up.
@KateyCuckoo... my son turns 3 in Feb, so he should eligible for 30 hours after that no? Literally cannot wait for that. my mum is 68 and she is really doing everything she can and beyond to be the other parent for my kids. I owe her so so much, and I really do feel incredibly blessed to have her support, so the childcare element for us is hugely important so she can get a break.

Again, I know I am luckier than most so I hate to sound like I am complaining, but I am being penalised for having a high income as a single parent when that is false.

OP posts:
KateyCuckoo · 30/12/2023 17:16

From April your 2 Yr old can get 15 hours of funding, plus use tax free childcare which is 20% paid by the government for the balance. That's quite a lot I'd say!

AnnieRegent · 30/12/2023 17:15

Sd1960 · 30/12/2023 16:00

£65k not a huge income? It’s like a parallel universe on here sometimes.

A parallel universe named "London and the South East".

Ladyj84 · 30/12/2023 17:14

Do what my other half does pays more into the pension to keep it below so we still get child benefit. Your other choice is move to a cheaper area

MintJulia · 30/12/2023 17:14

@safetyfreak I think you're right. It's Tory spite and their bigoted judgement of single mothers.

I am not a single mum through choice, I don't claim benefits or pop a baby out every two years. I have one well behaved and pleasant child, I work full time including all the way through chemo, I'm doing my level best, am a net contributor, have already paid 43 years NI and it feels like they take pleasure in sticking the boot in. 🙁

Blaggingit123 · 30/12/2023 17:13

OP the threshold is based on net income after pension contributions, so take these off your salary to work out if you’re over the threshold.

You have until September to fill out a tax return for the year to April 24 and can then take the option to repay what you owe back through PAYE in the 25/26 tax year so you won’t start repaying it til April 25 if this helps.

You are right it is unfair, worth complaining to your MP over how unfair it is to single parents in areas where £60k is not a high household income, but it won’t change now.

Zanatdy · 30/12/2023 17:12

I lost mine. I live in the south east, can’t even afford enough bedrooms for my son at Uni so I sleep on the sofa bed in the hols. I’m renting a 2 bed flat, on 63k, trust me I’m far from rich

Jeannie88 · 30/12/2023 17:11

I think the idea is if you're earning a certain amount you don't need benefits? We're not very high and have never had child tax credits, assumed it was for anyone, together or single, who earnt under a decent income and needed help to bring up to national average? X

megletthesecond · 30/12/2023 17:11

Yanbu. It's massively unfair. The government won't do anything as it almost exclusively affects women.
All I can suggest is you to max out your pension contributions.

The limit needs to be raised too. IIRC it should be around 60k now. But, as before, it only really affects women so nothing will be done. (I earn peanuts so it will never affect me, I still think it's bang out of order).

TeacherPlease · 30/12/2023 17:10

2024fit · 30/12/2023 15:54

I think it’s completely unfair for you to lose your child benefit and equally unfair for singles who don’t have children who get penalised in tax when they earn above 50K

They really have to change this. I hope this becomes Martin Lewis next campaign.

Some really high earning self employed couples who manage to complete tax returns that keep them eligible and even my own brother, both him and his wife earn 50k and 46k respectively and they still get CB for their two boys.

I feel the issue of slightly above average income couples being dishonest on their tax return is another issue though and it does need more attention, but tbh I’d rather more focus went on the super high earners and big corporations that are dodging tax.

As PP have pointed out there’s a lot wrong with the income tax system generally.

Edited

The effort does go to the super wealthy and large corporations. It’s very difficult for those to avoid tax, despite what the media would have you believe.

56% of the tax gap (c £20bn) is small businesses, so the likes of the self employed.

11% is large business, and 5% is wealthy individuals.

My pet peeve is (not the PP!) those who complain how the wealthy and large international business get to avoid/evade tax, when in reality the bigger problem is most likely to be those who are complaining.

Sd1960 · 30/12/2023 17:09

Have you any idea what the average income is in the UK. It’s not £50k.

safetyfreak · 30/12/2023 17:08

Blame the Tory government.

The tax threshold needs to be higher than 50k, but the Torys are using it as a stealth tax.

hanschristmassolo · 30/12/2023 17:07

But it absolutely penalises single parents like us

Swipe left for the next trending thread