Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

High Income single families losing Child benefit

139 replies

ReturnoftheMe · 30/12/2023 15:30

Hi there - I know this has been talked about extensively over the years, but I wondered if anyone has been following the topic and discussions around it in parliament for the future? Are there any changes to come for the next budget?

I am a single mother with no input from my 2 kids father. I live in London work full time and currently cannot afford to put my 2 year old in nursery as fees are too high, and I am not eligible for any help (fees are 2k + a month in my area). Luckily my mother has stepped in, but without her I'd have to claim benefits and not work, or I'd have to dial down my ambitions and go for a part time job which puts me at a disadvantage in my work place.
This year I will gratefully receive a bonus that just about puts me at the point of not being eligible at all for any Child Benefit down to the penny. This really bothers me because all the families I know all receive it still. Some really high earning self employed couples who manage to complete tax returns that keep them eligible and even my own brother, both him and his wife earn 50k and 46k respectively and they still get CB for their two boys.

When is this going to change in order to be fair for single mothers like myself? I cannot afford nursery and I also do not get any child benefit. Something is incredibly wrong here.

Am I being unreasonable to feel as though this is unfair to single mothers?

OP posts:
Alittlenonsensenowandthen · 30/12/2023 19:58

I'm sure I'm repeating what others have said but here's my thoughts.
I have no issue with a cap on the benefit but it should be done on total household income. Seems incredibly unfair that my neighbours bring in nearly 99k and keep theirs and we don't because my husband is on a decent salary.
I also think it's unfair that twins don't hoth get classed as first babies but thats a separate issue!

Pippippipi · 30/12/2023 19:55

I think what some posters are not recognising is that this was a universal payment for everyone before the tories introduced the limits in 2013!

Also the government were quite happy to assess my entitlement to tax credits on a household income so there is a clear disparity here.

Along with fiscal drag, this is seriously making me consider dropping some hours at work even though I really need to be earning more.

MrsDooDaa · 30/12/2023 19:46

I don't understand why they can't add a box on the self assessment form to select that you are a single adult person household and then your threshold is higher.

That's not more expensive to admisinister. It's self assessment. Am I missing something?

DragonFly98 · 30/12/2023 19:41

You do realise you will get 15 free hours in September and 30 after Easter plus tax free childcare.

TrashedSofa · 30/12/2023 19:28

SutWytTi · 30/12/2023 19:26

Totally agree it is divide and conquer, and I opposed it too for this reason.

The chip chip chip away of the welfare state puts all but the very wealthy at risk.

Agreed. As someone on the left and a supporter of the welfare state, I cringe when I see people trot out tropes about how posters discussing these issues should think themselves lucky they're not poor, or similar. Utterly idiotic.

SutWytTi · 30/12/2023 19:26

ZeroFucksGivenToday · 30/12/2023 19:20

I have been raging about this for years. It's a fully divide and conquer policy. I recall raising it at the time on here as completely unfair and had a range of responses similar to you about count yourself lucky etc. if you earn that much you shouldn't need it.
Fine, but now the government are coming after those lower earners too and decimating the safety net they will want us to all stand up and be counted, but when we asked their for help they said no, so I'll take my salary that they think is huge and completely leave them all to it. And that is exactly what the government wanted. A split of people who may have banded together and now won't.

Id look at what you can do, maybe deferring some bonus to next year may help, I've lost all mine now, but I am very lucky as my DD is 50/50 with me and my ex and he was allowed to claim it once I couldn't.

Totally agree it is divide and conquer, and I opposed it too for this reason.

The chip chip chip away of the welfare state puts all but the very wealthy at risk.

SutWytTi · 30/12/2023 19:25

Circe7 · 30/12/2023 19:14

@SutWytTi
But HMRC already have to assess individual income to assess whether you are over the £60k threshold (and for tax purposes in general). If you simply doubled the thresholds for single parent families and asked for proof of entitlement to the single person council tax reduction (for example) I don’t see that it would be much more complex than the current system. You can log on to your personal tax account and HMRC will tell you in almost real time what they think your taxable income is.

Assessing household income would be a bit more complex and I think there’s less of an argument for (say) a SAHM and someone earning £70k being entitled to child benefit because the SAHM could generally work if they wanted to and having a SAHM generally saves on childcare etc. Being from a single parent family does (in general) negatively affect children - and I say that as a single parent myself- probably because single parents are time and money poor so resources are stretched thinner and sometimes due to trauma related to breakdown of the relationship with the child’s other parent or not seeing that parent etc. The benefits system could specifically address that disadvantage given that child benefit is supposed to benefit children but it’s doing the opposite.

You create a new admin task of verifyng eligibility. You create a new type of fraud that has to be investigated. You create a new change of circs that has to be administered.

It is a lot to administer, really, which costs a lot.

ZeroFucksGivenToday · 30/12/2023 19:20

I have been raging about this for years. It's a fully divide and conquer policy. I recall raising it at the time on here as completely unfair and had a range of responses similar to you about count yourself lucky etc. if you earn that much you shouldn't need it.
Fine, but now the government are coming after those lower earners too and decimating the safety net they will want us to all stand up and be counted, but when we asked their for help they said no, so I'll take my salary that they think is huge and completely leave them all to it. And that is exactly what the government wanted. A split of people who may have banded together and now won't.

Id look at what you can do, maybe deferring some bonus to next year may help, I've lost all mine now, but I am very lucky as my DD is 50/50 with me and my ex and he was allowed to claim it once I couldn't.

Circe7 · 30/12/2023 19:14

@SutWytTi
But HMRC already have to assess individual income to assess whether you are over the £60k threshold (and for tax purposes in general). If you simply doubled the thresholds for single parent families and asked for proof of entitlement to the single person council tax reduction (for example) I don’t see that it would be much more complex than the current system. You can log on to your personal tax account and HMRC will tell you in almost real time what they think your taxable income is.

Assessing household income would be a bit more complex and I think there’s less of an argument for (say) a SAHM and someone earning £70k being entitled to child benefit because the SAHM could generally work if they wanted to and having a SAHM generally saves on childcare etc. Being from a single parent family does (in general) negatively affect children - and I say that as a single parent myself- probably because single parents are time and money poor so resources are stretched thinner and sometimes due to trauma related to breakdown of the relationship with the child’s other parent or not seeing that parent etc. The benefits system could specifically address that disadvantage given that child benefit is supposed to benefit children but it’s doing the opposite.

Coolblur · 30/12/2023 19:06

OttilieKnackered · 30/12/2023 15:58

Definitely unfair on single parents.

Don’t have the same sympathy for couples where only one works. That’s a choice and you’re saving a fortune in childcare in the early years.

Not always. Sometimes it's due to ill health and childcare is still needed

OttilieKnackered · 30/12/2023 18:56

@BettyBakesCakes obviously there will be some exceptions.

I hope you get some kind of benefits at least to help (carer’s allowance, PIP etc.) I know they don’t replace a salary though.

caringcarer · 30/12/2023 18:47

The thing you can.do.is Chanel an extra £5k into your pension then you could claim some CB. It's up to you to manage.

SutWytTi · 30/12/2023 18:46

OhBeAFineGuyKissMe · 30/12/2023 18:40

I’m arguing that they don’t need to. Just declare (with some proof if required) that you are single (same as for council tax) and then you individually have a higher limit.

That's complicated and expensive to administer.

The CTax discount is quite simple as it is not income related.

SutWytTi · 30/12/2023 18:44

Sd1960 · 30/12/2023 17:56

It might not be a huge salary in your estimation, but a huge percentage of the population live on half that, if they are lucky.

The fact others are paid a salary that is too low, doesn't mean a salary that is adequate should be badged as great riches. The UK is a low pay economy sadly, we have had such a long period of wage freezes that those at the bottom are genuinely underpaid, those in the middle are about adequate and obviously anyone at the top is doing OK. Whereas what we want to see is those at the bottom paid enough, and the rest do better than that.

OhBeAFineGuyKissMe · 30/12/2023 18:40

Blumarine · 30/12/2023 18:37

They need to know how much you earn in order to administrate child benefit. HMRC already has records of how much individuals earn. But they don’t have records of combined household income. What they’re saying is that it would be too much hassle to collect this information.

I’m arguing that they don’t need to. Just declare (with some proof if required) that you are single (same as for council tax) and then you individually have a higher limit.

Blumarine · 30/12/2023 18:37

OhBeAFineGuyKissMe · 30/12/2023 18:36

I find the tax argument odd as it is a benefit not a tax. And other benefits do take into account if you are single and council TAX has a single person discount.

So, don’t do it as a joint income but as a single parent extra!!!!

They need to know how much you earn in order to administrate child benefit. HMRC already has records of how much individuals earn. But they don’t have records of combined household income. What they’re saying is that it would be too much hassle to collect this information.

OhBeAFineGuyKissMe · 30/12/2023 18:36

I find the tax argument odd as it is a benefit not a tax. And other benefits do take into account if you are single and council TAX has a single person discount.

So, don’t do it as a joint income but as a single parent extra!!!!

mewkins · 30/12/2023 18:30

MintJulia · 30/12/2023 17:14

@safetyfreak I think you're right. It's Tory spite and their bigoted judgement of single mothers.

I am not a single mum through choice, I don't claim benefits or pop a baby out every two years. I have one well behaved and pleasant child, I work full time including all the way through chemo, I'm doing my level best, am a net contributor, have already paid 43 years NI and it feels like they take pleasure in sticking the boot in. 🙁

You've hit the nail on the head.

KateyCuckoo · 30/12/2023 18:11

Yes if he's 3 next term then he'll get 30 hours after Easter.

This is decent no?

Spirallingdownwards · 30/12/2023 18:03

One way to get you extra income would be to claim child maintenance from the father. It should be more than the child benefit and non taxable.

Ohnotyoutoo · 30/12/2023 17:59

ReturnoftheMe · 30/12/2023 17:34

@Ohnotyoutoo I am going to have to work it out and see whether it make sense to sacrifice the bonus into my pension. Would have been nice to see some of the money though, especially at at time like this.

How would I increase student loan repayments in advance and how does that benefit me?

I had thought that as student loans come out before your salary has been paid then your gross salary might be lower if you increased payments. Not sure how it works or if it's possible a lot all.

Unfortunately you'll have to take a hit somewhere along the line if you want to be under the threshold again. Increase pension payments, or some sort of other salary sacrifice-type deal.

It's rubbish though. Such a bum deal that it's all or nothing.

Sd1960 · 30/12/2023 17:56

It might not be a huge salary in your estimation, but a huge percentage of the population live on half that, if they are lucky.

Failedinlife · 30/12/2023 17:56

It’s hugely unfair and discriminatory to lone parents.

The only reason why more of a fuss has not been made about this is because the vast majority of lone parents are on low incomes so the number of lone parents affected by this is relatively small.

But that does not make it right.

Blumarine · 30/12/2023 17:56

Parliament debated this on 18th Dec and they decided to keep the system as it is. They said “CB is calculated on an individual rather than a household basis, in line with other tax policy. Basing CB on household income would require all of the 7.7 million households currently registered for Child Benefit to regularly report income data, for HMRC to verify household income and ensure compliance with the charge. This would complicate the process”

So basically they can’t be arsed to calculate household income, which means some families miss out.

ReturnoftheMe · 30/12/2023 17:53

@MumblesParty had not thought of that.. might be worth looking into.
@Æthelfled well done to you for achieving so much on your own. I too put myself through Uni to better my earnings and I am not seeing much difference at the end of each month. I think perhaps my expectations were too high and I didn't for see things like this.

@OhBeAFineGuyKissMe I don't see it as a huge administration burden either, but I have just looked on the petition site and seen the ministers response to the petition on December 18th, and it looks like nothing will change... I will just have to keep doing better to increase my earnings to the point where it it stops feeling so unfair.

Government response:

"The HICBC is calculated on an individual rather than a household basis, in line with other tax policy. Basing the HICBC on household income would require all of the 7.7 million households currently registered for Child Benefit to regularly report income data, for HMRC to verify household income and ensure compliance with the charge. This would complicate the process for the majority of Child Benefit claimants who are not liable to the HICBC. The Government therefore considers that the current approach remains proportionate, as it only requires a proportion of individuals to complete a Self Assessment tax return, whilst leaving the majority of claimants unaffected... As with all other tax policy, the Government will keep the HICBC under review. Improvements to the HICBC have been announced as part of the Government's commitment to a simpler and fairer tax system. On 28 April, the Government announced that steps will be taken to allow parents to receive a National Insurance credit retrospectively. This will ensure that parents who were eligible to claim Child Benefit but who chose not to are able to protect their future State Pension entitlement, reaffirming the Government's commitment to supporting all parents.
Similarly, on 18 July, the Government announced that steps will be taken to enable employed individuals to pay HICBC through their tax code, without the need to register for Self Assessment. This will make the process of paying HICBC easier for individuals who become liable for the charge.

HM Treasury"

In a nut shell, they don't give a shit, single mums earning £50k should shut up, count themselves lucky and nothing will be done.

OP posts: